Benito Romano
[email protected]
+1-646-541-2223
Benito Romano
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP
350 5th Avenue
Suite 6903
New York, NY 10118
May 5, 2021
Märten Ross
Deputy Secretary-General
Financial Policy & External Relations
Republic of Estonia - Ministry of Finance
Dear Mr. Ross:
You requested additional information in your May 3, 2021 letter about witness interviews. First, in response to your question, we
have not shared any details of any witness interview with the U.S. authorities or with the authorities in Estonia. We generally
described to the U.S. authorities that we were conducting interviews and would provide relevant information at such time as it was
developed by us as investigators. The interviews were not recorded, and we had not yet reached a point in our work where we
were ready to share any information with the U.S. authorities. When our work was stopped, we also were still in the stage of
developing an understanding of what witnesses could offer, and we had not completed this work.
As for your request about who was interviewed, we found that many of the people we spoke to expressed concern about retaliation
from the Estonian government and other institutions if they cooperated with our inquiry. The witnesses often pointed to issues
such as the mysterious death of a former bank executive, which the witnesses still believe has not been adequately explained. For
these reasons, the witnesses asked us to keep their identity secret.
Corroborating the fear that the witnesses expressed, we experienced a situation during our work where one of the banks under
investigation learned the identity of people we were trying to interview. This bank then interfered with our ability to conduct
interviews, and threatened former employees in an effort to stop them from speaking to us. The Ministry of Finance wrote a letter
to the executives of this bank about the situation.
The condition of maintaining the secrecy of witness identity was accepted and embraced by the Ministry of Finance. Indeed, as
we performed our work, the Ministry of Finance directed that we should not mention the names of specific persons we interviewed
as we provided updates on our work. The Ministry did not want there to be even the suggestion that they would take any action to
harm or benefit the witnesses. The Ministry thought this was a proper solution to avoid even a hint of any improper influence.
This is a long explanation for our position that we will not provide the names of persons interviewed as per the Ministry of Finance
direction during the project and the pledge we made to the individual witnesses.
In closing, FSS expects payment from the Ministry of Finance within a week as our invoices are well past due and we have complied
with all of your requests.
Sincerely,
Benito Romano
Partner
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP
2550 M St NW, First Floor
Washington, DC 20037
February 18, 2021
Keit Pentus-Rosimannus
Minister of Finance
Republic of Estonia
Dear Minister Pentus-Rosimannus:
We were drafting this letter when your memorandum of today arrived. We wrote three prior
communications (attached) this week to you and to Prime Minister Kallas, asking to meet and
to brief you both on the engagement which we have undertaken for the Estonian Ministry of
Finance (MOF), having been hired by former Minister Martin Helme. You did not respond to
the issues we raised. Additionally, we submitted a detailed response (attached) on Tuesday to
your MOF colleague, Mr. Martin Ross, which he asked us to provide regarding a “review” of
the contract. Again, you engaged in no discussion of these issues.
Your lack of support for this engagement, and the refusal to meet or even to discuss this
matter with us, has severely undermined the goal of the engagement, which was to make
Estonia and your Ministry eligible to share in fines which the United States law enforcement
authorities may obtain from the Scandinavian banks who used your Estonian branches for
massive money-laundering schemes. Also, the public undermining of our work by the new
Government and party leaders, and your direction to “stop” our work at a time when we were
actively interviewing relevant witnesses who have not yet been contacted by the FSA and
PGO, has greatly harmed the progress we have heretofore made. This deliberate delay and
interference with our work caused a loss of momentum which is highly damaging to the
project.
For these reasons and as further explained below, you are hereby notified that FSS is
proactively withdrawing from this engagement and discharging the Ministry of Finance as its
client, effective Friday, February 19, 2021.
We also have reviewed several recent public statements by Prime Minister Kallas concerning
our work for the Ministry of Finance. Prime Minister Kallas appears to misunderstand the
nature of our work and the U.S. law concerning the ways the people of Estonia can obtain
important remedies for any misconduct by the Scandinavian banks. Our repeated requests for
an in-person meeting in Tallinn with the Prime Minister to discuss these issues have gone
unanswered. As a highly-respected and internationally engaged professional firm, we cannot
work effectively when you, the Prime Minister, Government and political party deliberately
undermine our work.
Ending our work risks leaving the people of Estonia with no redress against the Scandinavian
banks and with no part of any fine that may be imposed by the U.S. authorities. Lacking
international investigative skills and contacts, the Estonian prosecutors are reviewing only
cases against individuals and not of the banks themselves. During our investigation,
attempts were made by one bank to interfere with the investigation, plainly showing that the
Page 2
bank was nervous concerning the review. Ending our work will leave the people of Estonia
with no remedy for the Scandinavian banks failures in preventing money laundering. The
idea of using a judicial attaché to perform this important work is weak and ineffectual.
Since our engagement, we have worked productively to uncover previously unknown
testimony in Estonia concerning the money laundering activity of the Scandinavian
banks. We have established important communication lines with the U.S. prosecutors
reviewing the cases and promised to share our factual findings with the prosecutors. Ending
our work now signals a lack of interest by the Estonian government in pursuing the massive
money laundering schemes by the Scandinavian banks. It will appear that Estonia has
ceased to be interested in uncovering the facts, and confirming the Prime Minister’s
recently reported public comments that suggest Estonia is no longer pursuing financial
redress for this money laundering.
Three major U.S. law firms competed openly for this engagement because this work
presented an important opportunity to help the people of Estonia. We understand that our bid
was the most competitive and creative of the three firms. We were fairly selected. Our work
to date has been beneficial to Estonia and conducted under the established budget, as we set
forth in prior communications to you.
But Estonian politicians in the new government appear unconcerned by the facts or the
benefit to the Estonian people. Instead, these politicians appear intent on protecting the
Scandinavian banks from paying stiff fines and facing the consequences of their
actions. Ironically, it was the Prime Minister’s party which led the government during the
massive money-laundering scheme which is being investigated by US authorities.
FSS cannot continue to work with such an uncooperative and uncommitted group. We
therefore withdraw and will present a demand for payment of the value of our work and other
significant losses caused by defamatory, irresponsible and unsupported statements by
members of your Government and political party.
We saw great potential in this project for the people of Estonia. We also saw the project as
part of the effort to ensure that Estonia is seen as a leading and transparent financial center for
future generations. We regret that the new Government does not share this vision.
Respectfully,
—————————- ———————————-
Freeh Sporkin Sullivan Louis J. Freeh, Consultant
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL
ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION
MEMORANDUM
TO: Keit Pentus-Rosimannus
Minister of Finance
CC: Kaja Kallas
Prime Minister of Estonia
Märten Ross
Deputy Secretary-General for Financial Policy and External Relations
FROM: Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP
DATE: February 16, 2021
SUBJECT: Work Status on Client Agreement with Ministry of Finance
This memorandum provides an update of work performed by Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan,
LLP (“FSS”), during our engagement with the Ministry of Finance of Estonia, as
requested in the memorandum from Märten Ross of February 10, 2021.
In sum, our work to date is substantially below the approved budget and has made
important progress to producing the significant cooperation with U.S. authorities that
will justify sharing a portion of any fine imposed against the Scandinavian banks. Our
work is focused solely on corporate accountability of the banks, not any individual
liability. Our work is without any conflict to cases by the Estonian authorities.
We have suggested an in-person meeting in Tallinn to further discuss the points raised
in this memorandum and the strategy that will best serve our shared goal of obtaining
the best result for the people of Estonia. In the meantime, in response to your specific
questions, please see our answers below.
1. List of U.S. Law Enforcement and Regulatory Agencies.
Consistent with our mandate in Phase I of the Client Agreement, we established contacts
with all law enforcement authorities in the United States with open investigations of the
Scandinavian banks, including the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”), the U.S. Securities
& Exchange Commission (“SEC”) and the New York Department of Financial Services
(“NYDFS”). We also have been in contact with the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s
representative in the Baltics states, John Bivona.
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL Minister Pentus-Rosimannus
ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION February 16, 2021
Page 2
The investigation for the DOJ is being conducted by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the
Southern District of New York (“SDNY”) and by the Money Laundering and Asset
Recovery Section (“MLARS”) in DOJ’s Criminal Division. One of our lawyers formerly
was the chief prosecutor in SDNY, while another of our lawyers formerly worked at
MLARS. We also previously worked closely with the lead MLARS attorney assigned to
the investigation on a prior monitorship.
With each agency, we have explained our work for Estonia, explained that we would be
coordinating the sharing of information to help in the development of cases, and asked if
any of the agencies had any particular issues in Estonia needing attention. We explained
that we had entered confidentiality agreements with the Finantsinspektsioon (“FSA”)
and the Prosecutor General’s Office (“PGO”).
We advised each agency of our Phase II work plan to interview former employees of the
Scandinavian banks. We advised that many of the employees have told us that they
have not been interviewed by the legal counsel for the banks. We also advised that
some employees have provided us internal documents from the banks, which we have
analyzed and which we maintain in a secure file room. We have promised updates to
each agency of our progress in developing potential witness testimony.
We have facilitated information requests from the U.S. authorities. For example, we
explained that the FSA has various on-site inspection data that may be of value to the
open investigations. We explained that FSA will provide this data to the U.S. authorities.
We followed this verbal offer with a written letter to the authorities describing the
information available from the FSA and the procedure for requesting the evidence. We
understand that NYDFS has requested the information from FSA.
2. Brief Overview of Co-Operation with Estonian Investigators
In connection with the Phase I mandate, we have had several meetings with the Ministry
of Finance, the FSA, the PGO, and the Financial Intelligence Unit (“FIU”) of the Estonian
Police and Border Guard Board. We have meet with other Estonian government officials
and appeared before the Parliament.
In our meetings, we discussed the nature of the cooperation that we would build with
the U.S. authorities and received information on the background of open and closed
investigations in Estonia. We also received information about information sharing
requests from Estonia to the United States that are pending. We explained the types of
“significant” and “essential” evidence and “innovative steps” that could merit an
equitable share of any fine that may be imposed. We further discussed the types of
evidence that would be of value to U.S. authorities, given the legal framework and
history of other anti-money laundering enforcement actions. We provided an analysis
of prior enforcement actions highlighting the key areas of evidence required.
We have read recent statements in the Estonian papers suggesting that Estonia only will
obtain a portion of any fine against the Scandinavian banks if Estonia is considered a
“victim” of the money laundering. This is incorrect and misreads the incentive that US
authorities created to encourage cooperation in investigations by other nations. The
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL Minister Pentus-Rosimannus
ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION February 16, 2021
Page 3
policies of the DOJ and SEC make clear that such active cooperation can be recognized
and rewarded with part of any fine or forfeiture. This policy provides a strong
incentive for countries to provide meaningful cooperation, which is the primary goal of
our engagement.
From our meetings with PGO, we understand that the PGO is reviewing cases involving
individual culpability of former bank employees for alleged money laundering. We
have explained that the focus of U.S. authorities is upon corporate culpability of the
Scandinavian banks under the Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”). Given U.S. jurisdictional laws,
it is unlikely that any individual from Estonia would be charged in any U.S. prosecution.
We have agreed to work with the PGO to make sure that no conflict develops in the
scope of our work.
From our meetings with FSA, we understand that FSA has records for each of the
Scandinavian banks relating to FSA procedures to review and remediate potential
violations of the various administrative statutes directed to the integrity of operations
at financial institutions in Estonia. In this review process, the FSA conducts its
evaluation and issues a precept with any findings, which is then subject to a challenge
by the regulated entity. In addition to the precepts, there additionally are on-site
inspections and corresponding dialogues which did not always end with the precept,
but which track the process by which a financial institutions addresses deficiencies.
The information gathered in the FSA proceedings may be of particular interest to the
U.S. authorities. We have been working with the U.S. authorities to facilitate the sharing
of the FSA data. We understand that the NYDFS has made such a request relating to
Swedbank and SEB. We continue to work with the other agencies to aid in their
understanding of this available material.
3. Overview of Investigative Actions
During our Phase I work, we first focused upon how Estonia can be best positioned to
advocate for a share of any penalty the U.S. authorities impose on the Scandinavian
banks. We provided an analysis of the criteria that U.S. authorities use to determine if
equitable sharing of a criminal fine with another government is merited. We have
described the “significant” and “essential” evidence and “innovative steps” that are
expected under federal policies to justify equitable sharing with other nations. We also
provided research on the primary theory of liability under U.S. law, the BSA, as well as
an analysis of common factors in significant enforcement actions with financial
institutions under the BSA. We also have reviewed the internal investigation reports
issued for Danske Bank and Swedbank and made a study of these reports consistent
with the prior enforcement actions.
Given this research, we have focused upon identifying witnesses in Estonia with
relevant knowledge of the activities at the Scandinavian banks. This strategy serves
several purposes:
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL Minister Pentus-Rosimannus
ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION February 16, 2021
Page 4
- First, this strategy provides a unique and innovative way for Estonia to
assist in the U.S. investigations. Such testimony is not available otherwise to
the U.S. authorities, and they are not able to come to Estonia to perform this
work for themselves. If successful, such assistance would give Estonia a strong
argument for a share of any penalty. This work is the type of “innovative steps”
described in federal policy on equitable sharing.
- Second, pursuing a corporate liability theory provides a potentially important
remedy for the Estonian people against the Scandinavian banks for their
organizational failures and mismanagement of significant money laundering
risks.
- Third, this theory makes clear that Estonia takes a serious position against
money laundering and will take important steps to preserve the integrity of its
banking system. This position is best advanced by holding corporations
responsible for lapses in their compliance environment, so other companies will
make needed changes and take appropriate safeguards.
- Fourth, many of the people we have interviewed have never spoken to counsel
for the Scandinavian banks or any law enforcement authorities. We are
exploring fresh and important facts with people who were at the very forefront
of the activity at the banks.
- Finally, supporting potential corporate liability is distinct from the cases that
the PGO is pursuing against individuals, so there is no overlap or conflict with
the PGO and our work. Indeed, the work is complementary. Our work and the
PGO’s work can both proceed at the same time.
We have identified approximately 70 witnesses who are former Scandinavian bank
employees who worked in (a) the compliance function; (b) the AML function; or (c)
bank management. We have developed a prioritization of the witnesses on the master
list based upon role and function. We have begun interviewing these prioritized
witnesses and have met approximately 10 witnesses. Our first meetings generally focus
on developing a rapport with the witnesses so that they are comfortable providing
honest and frank testimony. We also address any witness concerns. For example, many
people have expressed fear of retaliation if they agree to cooperate with our work.
Many have expressed fears of leaks to the press from government sources. Our
following meetings go deeper into the recollections of the witnesses. We also ask the
witnesses if they have documents from their work that they can share with us.
The process takes time and is made more difficult by the pandemic which requires us to
meet by video with the witnesses. We have adopted well to the situation and have
found ways to develop witness trust and confidence despite the lack of physical
presence. As the pandemic improves, we hope to add a mix of interviews where we are
physically present with the witnesses. We ultimately will build to preserving the
interviews in a formal matter, either through a sworn deposition or through a video
tape of the witness. This material then can be provided to the U.S. authorities.
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL Minister Pentus-Rosimannus
ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION February 16, 2021
Page 5
Most witnesses we have interviewed have stated that they were not previously
interviewed by the lawyers working for the Scandinavian banks or by any authorities.
We therefore are in the unique position of being able to deliver fresh and important
evidence to the U.S. authorities, unfiltered by the Scandinavian banks and their lawyers.
This is an important opportunity that has great relevance to whether the U.S. authorities
will share any fines imposed on the Scandinavian banks.
Some witnesses agreed to meet with us, only to change their mind at the last moment.
We later discovered that lawyers connected with Swedbank apparently discouraged
these individuals from appearing for these interviews. We have informed Swedbank
that we will advise the U.S. authorities about this interference should it continue.
We will provide a master witness list in a password-protected file. The password will
be sent by a separate email message. We ask that all steps be taken to maintain the
confidentiality of this list, both to protect the witnesses from any intimidation or
retaliation and to minimize interference from the Scandinavian banks. We ask that the
witness list only be accessed by those with a need to know this information.
We ask witnesses for the names of others who may have relevant information, so the list
remains a work in progress as we seek additional corroboration of our findings.
We also have reviewed an RFP seeking a representative in Washington for the PGO to
aid cooperation between the U.S. and Estonia. The position is a good idea in general
terms, but the planned position will not satisfy the expectations of the U.S. authorities to
justify equitable sharing and will not continue the important work we have been able to
perform in Estonia to gather material evidence. Reaching out to U.S. authorities without
tangible evidence to offer will not advance the specific interests of Estonia in the cases
against the Scandinavian banks.
4. Initial Assessment of Expected Timeframe of Phase II
We are currently in Phase II of our work, which will be the most important phase for
providing the type of cooperation expected by U.S. authorities to engage in equitable
sharing. Based on direction from the Ministry of Finance, we paused our interviews
and witness meetings during the government transition. We hope this work can resume
soon. We also would plan to contact the U.S. authorities to advise on the status of our
work and to ask for any update that can be provided.
The timeframe of the work depends on at least three variables. The first variable is the
level of cooperation we receive from witnesses in Estonia. Under the best circumstance,
we will continue to develop witnesses and receive useful and relevant evidence. We can
memorialize the witness testimony and then present this testimony to the U.S.
authorities. The second variable is the work pace of the U.S. authorities. We are still
assessing the progress and understanding the additional proof the authorities may still
need. The third variable is the complications of the pandemic to the work being
performed. For example, the investigative grand juries investigating potential criminal
offenses are working on a significantly reduced schedule. Many U.S. regulators continue
to conduct their work from remote locations. These factors delay the resolution.
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL Minister Pentus-Rosimannus
ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION February 16, 2021
Page 6
Given these factors, we suggest a work plan and budget to continue the interviews over
the next six months. We can then assess the interviews conducted and the ability to
present Estonia’s position to the U.S. authorities.
While there is work remaining in Phase II, it is important to note that we are
substantially below our planned budget. We expect that we can perform our future
work at a rate significantly below the budgeted amount of $2,277,966 for Phase II.
For example, through January 31, 2021, we have used less than 20 percent of the Phase
II budget, with total billing of $404,090. We expect that we can perform the remaining
Phase II work at a cost substantially less than had been budgeted. We similarly
performed our work in Phase I well below the approved project budget. The details of
our prior work have been provided in our monthly billing.
5. Remaining Work to Deliver the Objectives of the Client Agreement.
From witnesses interviewed to date, we are hearing important information or relevance
to the compliance tone set by the Scandinavian banks. We are developing the
confidence of the witnesses, who are opening to discussion of key issues, such as the
involvement and knowledge of bank “headquarters” in the decision making on business
development and the implementation of appropriate anti-money laundering controls.
For example, witnesses have discussed the close control exercised by “headquarter”
staff on key compliance and legal functions at one of the banks. Witnesses also have
discussed the lack of investment in important systems that would be critical in
providing information to prevent money laundering. We also have heard of
“headquarter” involvement in branch business development, including setting
aggressive customer initiation goals. W further have heard that audit findings and FSA
findings were not aggressively addressed and remediated.
All of these factors have been cited by U.S. authorities in prior enforcement actions
against other financial institutions. Our objective is to develop these themes further, to
prepare a presentation for the U.S. authorities of the witness testimony available on
these points. We also need to develop detail and depth of these points. We will
preserve the interviews, either through a sworn deposition or through a video tape of
the witness. We will prepare the materials for the U.S. authorities.
6. Conclusion
The work authorized in the Client Agreement is important to the people of Estonia.
Continuing the progress that we have begun likely is the only path to sharing in any
penalty imposed by U.S. authorities on the Scandinavian banks, thus providing the
people of Estonia with redress against the Scandinavian banks’ organizational failures
and mismanagement of significant risks. Continuing the progress further sends an
important signal that Estonia takes seriously the integrity of its financial system and
that the system will operate free from criminal activity. We have strong relationships
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL Minister Pentus-Rosimannus
ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION February 16, 2021
Page 7
with the U.S. authorities, including key decision makers in the new administration. All
of these factors are important to Estonia.
We look forward to meeting with you and discussing this important project further. We
also look forward to restarting our work so as to bring relief to the people of Estonia.
Greg Paw <
[email protected]>
Media Report Re Estonia-FSS Engagement
1 message
Louis Freeh <
[email protected]> Tue, Feb 16, 2021 at 11:19 AM
To:
[email protected]
Cc: "Hon. Keit Pentus-Rosimannus Minister Of Finance (1/21)" <
[email protected]>, Greg Paw
<
[email protected]>, FSS <
[email protected]>, Walt Donaldson FSS*
<
[email protected]>, Sean Freeh <
[email protected]>, Terry Burke Burke
<
[email protected]>, Olavi-Jüri Luik <
[email protected]>, Üllar Talviste
<
[email protected]>, Ragnar Meitern <
[email protected]>
Dear Madame Prime Minister
Good afternoon.
I received today the below media inquiry which asked me to comment on your reported public remarks about Danske
Bank.
Although I don’t intend to make any comment at this time (and have not done so recently), the inquiry shows that
Bloomberg has clearly misconstrued your remarks to mean that Estonia is “no longer looking to lobby the US to take a
share of any Danske Bank fine.” Of course, this is a very counterproductive report for the relevant US authorities to hear,
and completely contradicts what we have been representing to the US for the last year.
This is another reason why you and Minister Pentus-Rosimannus should immediately clarify that the FSS engagement
remains in full force, and Estonia is expecting to share in the proceeds of any US fines, forfeitures, etc., imposed on
Nordic banks for their Russian Federation-based money-laundering activities (MLA) in Estonia.
We have NOT been ‘lobbying’ US authorities and claiming that Estonia is a ‘victim’ of Russia-based MLA in your financial
institutions and Nordic bank branches.
Rather we have been working with your MOF, FSA and PGO in a well-established legal framework wherein the US DOJ
and SEC recognize and reward foreign cooperation in such high-level MLA prosecutions in the US.
Our cooperation has taken the form of obtaining evidence and identifying relevant witnesses in Estonia, which our former
US colleagues are not able to do themselves. Our work is also distinct from what the PGO is doing in terms of any
separate Estonian investigations.
For all these reasons, and to avoid media reports of your comments from confusing US authorities and thereby
preventing Estonia from rightfully sharing in US prosecution proceeds, we urge you to confirm publicly that the FSS
engagement will remain in full force with the same intended goals.
Also, in order to give you and the MOF a better understanding of exactly what we’re doing and how the FSS engagement
benefits your Government and Estonian citizens, I propose that we travel to Tallinn next week to meet and to brief you on
what has been accomplished so far, and how the engagement should advance. We are available any day next week
convenient to you.
Very respectfully
Louie Freeh
“ From: James Thomas <james.thomas@globalinves ga onsreview.com>
Sent: Tuesday, February 16, 2021 5:14:39 AM
To: Freeh, Louis <
[email protected]>
Subject: Media enquiry: Estonia Danske Bank fine
Dear Louis,
I hope you are well.
I'm a reporter for GIR and was reading this Bloomberg ar cle sta ng that Estonia is no longer
looking to lobby the US to take a share of any Danske Bank fine. https://www.bloomberg.
com/news/articles/2021-02-16/estonia-to-stop-lobbying-u-s-for-share-of-potential-
danske-fine
I was just wondering if the Estonian government has told you why it has decided this and if you
are able to share this with me.
Please let me know if you need any more informa on.
Kind regards,
James Thomas”
***** E-mail confidentiality notice *****
Law Business Research is the trading name of Law Business Research Ltd and its subsidiaries.
This message is intended for the addressee only. It is private and confidential. If you have received this message in error, please
notify
[email protected] and remove it from your system.
Law Business Research Ltd. Registered company in England & Wales. No. 03281866. Registered Office address: Meridian House, 34-35
Farringdon Street, London, EC4A 4HL
Sent from my iPhone
On Feb 15, 2021, at 2:40 PM, Louis Freeh <
[email protected]> wrote:
Dear Prime Minister Kallas
Good evening and please pardon this interruption. However, given the importance of the legal
engagement Freeh Sporkin Sullivan (FSS) is now conducting for Estonia, I wanted to write
directly to you in addition to Minister Pentus-Rosimannus (please see attached).
First of all, congratulations on your becoming Prime Minister and we rely greatly on the long
friendship and alliance between Estonia and the United States, which will only be deepened
by President Biden, whom I have known for thirty years. I was very honored to visit Tallinn
shortly after the Soviet occupation and will always remember the strong bond of democracy
and freedom which makes our countries strong partners against the forces of totalitarianism.
As set forth in greater detail to Minister Pentus-Rosimannus, I respectfully urge you to
continue with this FSS engagement, by which we serve you and Estonia, and where we are
positioned to maximize the best possible financial return for the Estonian people. After many
months, and due to the great respect and credibility we enjoy with the US Department of
Justice (DOJ) and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)-which will only be enhanced
with the new Administration and Attorney General with whom we have worked closely in the
past-Estonia’s cooperation with the relevant US law enforcement authorities has been
strengthened. We are actively obtaining relevant evidence in Estonia, identifying important
witnesses and liaising with US authorities on a regular and productive basis. Such a
relationship will not be easily reconstructed with ‘new’ lawyers, and terminating the agreement
without cause will be very counterproductive for Estonia in our view, as it will send a confusing
and negative message from your Government.
Also, as a highly-regarded attorney, you can certainly appreciate the fact that I have been the
target of very defamatory statements and false allegations, particularly from one of your
Party’s deputy chairpersons, who appears to be a bit deranged. We have carefully catalogued
these false and reckless comments and they are actionable both in US and EU courts,
particularly in the context of an arbitrary contract termination. More importantly, this very
insidious campaign to undermine our work and my reputation has only served to harm
Estonia and the goals we have been pursuing for Estonians. Indeed, I was disappointed to
read that when a reporter (Mottus-Leppik) referred to me in a highly defamatory manner (eg.,
‘Kremlin’s lawyer,’ ‘Satan’s lawyer’) in your interview last week, you did nothing to correct this
falsehood. I would hope that you will do so at the earliest opportunity.
We have performed this work well under budget and with dedication and care (while you
stated publicly that I have personally received €500k, the fact is that FSS, which is using 8
people to to this work, has been paid as follows: Phase 1-$413,183.29 out of the approved
$797,288 budget; Phase 2-$404,090 out of the approved $2,277,966 budget), and drastically
under the approved budget.
Finally, we agree that Estonia has been the ‘victim’ of the Nordic banks’ Russian-based
money-laundering schemes which the US law enforcement authorities are now criminally
investigating. However, being such a victim is totally consistent with Estonia working
cooperatively and directly with US authorities to recoup its fair share of any fines, forfeitures
and financial penalties that may be imposed by a US prosecution. The policies of the DOJ
and SEC make clear that such active cooperation can be recognized and rewarded with part
of any fine or forfeiture. This policy is a strong incentive for countries to provide meaningful
cooperation, which is the primary goal of our engagement.
We have asked to meet with the Minister of Finance to discuss this engagement before it is
prematurely and unfairly cancelled. We of course make the same request to you.
Very respectfully,
Louie Freeh
202 215-8321
Sent from my iPad
Begin forwarded message:
From: Louis Freeh <
[email protected]>
Date: February 10, 2021 at 12:29:25 PM EST
To:
[email protected]
Subject: Estonia-FSS Engagement
Dear Minister Pentus-Rosimannus
Good afternoon and congratulations once again on your
appointment as Minister of Finance and the formation of a new
Government. On my first visit to Tallinn I recall meeting with then
President Lennart Meri, who while an accomplished artist, was
very proud of the democratic manner in which the new post-
Soviet government was operating.
I understand how busy you and the Ministry must be as you take
over the important responsibilities of Estonia’s finances. Here in
the US, our new Administration is similarly busy in the same
manner. Our President, a friend and Delaware neighbor for 30
years, nevertheless found time to attend Sunday Mass in our
Wilmington, Delaware Parish this past Sunday.
We have been very honored to be engaged by Estonia to work as
liaison your ‘bridge‘ with the USA authorities (eg., the US
Department of Justice (DOJ), the US Securities and Exchange
Commission, New York State Financial Services) in connection
with the massive money-laundering schemes which the Baltic
banks perpetuated through their Estonian branches.
The single and simple goal of this engagement is to demonstrate
the outstanding cooperation of Estonia to the USA law
enforcement authorities now actively pursuing these criminal
cases. It is our hope and expectation that as a result of such
demonstrated cooperation, Estonia will be eligible to share in the
financial fines, forfeitures and other remedies imposed by US
authorities. As you know, such financial remedies are not
available under Estonia law.
We have made excellent progress in establishing high level
connections for Estonia and your Ministry with the relevant US
authorities. Given our prior service with those agencies
(especially DOJ) and our good reputation and credibility, the
prosecutors and regulators have welcomed our role and tasked
us with continuing to work with the FSA and PGO to provide
evidence that is critical for a successful US prosecution.
Indeed, we know that under the new Biden Administration, US
interest and focus on the systemic (especially Russian Federation
based) money-laundering seen in the current case will
dramatically increase. The new Attorney General nominee, Judge
Merrick Garland, with whom I closely worked while FBI director,
will bring to the Justice Department even more interest in these
cases and likely be briefed on the Estonian case soon after his
confirmation.
While we understand that my appointment was unfortunately part
of a larger political discussion in Estonia (and I assure you I am
not an ‘agent of the Kremlin’), it would be very disadvantageous
to Estonia to terminate what is now a very successful
undertaking.
Regardless of who appointed me, you as Minister will be the
beneficiary of our success. Having spent many years in
government circles in Washington, DC, I believe that our abrupt
termination at this point will send confusing and counter-
productive messages to the USA authorities, who are relying on
Estonia’s continued cooperation in this high-profile and important
case.
So I request that you maintain our engagement and allow this
very productive undertaking to continue along the agreed course.
In order to properly introduce myself and our planned course of
action (including introducing you in person to your counterparts in
Wash, DC when feasible), I ask that you meet with me as soon as
possible in Tallinn. I am ready and willing to make the trip when
convenient for you and your colleagues.
I appreciate you considering this note and request, and look
forward to meeting with you.
Respectfully,
Louie Freeh
202 215-8321
Sent from my iPhone
Saatja: Walter Donaldson <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 31.03.2021 21:29
Adressaat: Riina Virkus <
[email protected]>; Märten Ross <
[email protected]>; RAM Info
<
[email protected]>
Koopia: Benito Romano <
[email protected]>; Louis Freeh
<
[email protected]>; Greg Paw <
[email protected]>
Teema: Attorney Client Communication / Attorney Work Product Privileged and Confidential
Manused: Republic of Estonia Invoice 01.01 thourgh 01.31.2021[Corrected Copy].pdf; Republic
of Estonia Invoice 02.01 thourgh 02.19.2021 [Corrected Copy].pdf
RE: Updated Invoices for January & February
Dear Mr. Ross,
Attached you will find Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP invoices for January and February that were
originally sent to you on February 9th and February 23rd respectively. These invoices have been adjusted
in accordance with your requested in your letter of March 11, 2021.
Additionally, consistent with our obligations under the rules regulating American lawyers, we have
gathered the documents responsive to your letter of March 11, 2021. The responsive documents are
stored in an electronic file site. We will share a link to the file site and a one-time password to access
the responsive documents. Please confirm the email that you want us to send the information to in
order to access this site and files. A separate email will be sent to the address you advise, then
confirmed prior to receiving the password.
Regards,
Walter
Attorney Client Communication / Attorney Work Product Privileged and Confidential
Walter B. Donaldson II, CFE, CFCI, CFSSP
Chief Operating Officer
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP
3711 Kennett Pike, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807
D +1 (302) 824-7533
M +1 (302) 588-2795
[email protected]
FreehSporkinSullivan.com | LinkedIn
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: THIS EMAIL, INCLUDING ANY ATTACHMENT(S),
IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE PERSON OR ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS
ADDRESSED AND MAY CONTAIN CONFIDENTIAL
AND/OR PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY/CLIENT WORK PRODUCT COMMUNICATIONS
AS WELL AS OTHER CONFIDENTIAL, PROPRIETARY OR SECRET INFORMATION. IF
YOU ARE NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT, PLEASE DO NOT READ THIS EMAIL
OR DISSEMINATE IT TO ANYONE. PLEASE NOTIFY THE SENDER IMMEDIATELY
BY REPLYING TO THIS MESSAGE OR BY CALLING +1 (302) 824-7533 (WE ACCEPT
COLLECT CALLS), AND THEN DELETE THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE AND ANY COPIES
OF IT FROM YOUR COMPUTER SYSTEM. ANY
USE, DISSEMINATION, DISTRIBUTION, OR REPRODUCTION OF THIS MESSAGE
AND/OR ANY ATTACHMENTS BY UNINTENDED RECIPIENTS IS STRICTLY
PROHIBITED AND MAY BE UNLAWFUL. THANK YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION.
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 02.07.2021 17:12
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Request for information
Saatja: Walter Donaldson <>Kuupäev: 1. juuli 2021 17:23Teema: Fwd:
Request for informationSaaja: Marju Lepmets <>,Märten Ross <>,Keit
Pentus-Rosimannus <>Koopia: Benito Romano <>,"Bescript, Patricia" <>,Greg
Paw <>
Dear Ms. Pentus-Rosimannus:We have reviewed your letter of June 22, 2021,
concerning delivery of materials that became known to FSS during our
representation of the Ministry of Finance of Estonia. As you are aware,
we already have provided extensive documentation of our work.While we do
not agree with the characterization of the materials we have provided
that is contained in your letter, we nonetheless will provide you with
the names of persons interviewed by FSS during our representation as well
as the notes from these interviews. In return, we expect to be paid all
amounts due to FSS. We will deliver the names and the written interview
notes under separate cover. We previously provided all documentary
information provided bht ye witnesses in our proir
transmissions.Regards,Walter Donaldson
---------- Forwarded message ---------From: <>Date: Tue, Jun 22, 2021 at
1:37 AMSubject: Request for informationTo: Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLP
<>, Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLP <>, AlixPartners <>
Tere! Teile on Rahandusministeeriumi poolt edastatud dokument. Pealkiri:
Request for information Registreerimise kuupäev: 22.06.2021
Registreerimise number: 3.2-12/2527-6. NB! Dokumendile on kehtestatud
juurdepääsupiirang alates 07.06.2021 kuni 07.06.2026, vastavalt AvTS § 35
lg .
Tel. (372) 611 3558e-mail:
P Säästa loodust ja ära prindi seda e-kirja!
________________________________
Käesolev e-kiri võib sisaldada asutusesiseseks kasutamiseks tunnistatud
teavet. This e-mail may contain information which is classified for
official use.
--
Walter B. Donaldson IIChief Operating OfficerFreeh Sporkin & Sullivan,
LLP3711 Kennett Pike, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807D +1 (302) 824-7533
M +1 (302) 588-2795FreehSporkinSullivan.com
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 30.08.2021 11:48
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Request for information
From: Walter Donaldson <> Sent: Sunday, August 22, 2021 5:41 PMTo: Marju
Lepmets <>Cc: Greg Paw <>; Keit Pentus-Rosimannus <>; Märten Ross
<>Subject: Re: Request for information
Dear Marju,
As you requested below, the last only remaining documents that Freeh
Sporkin & Sullivan LLP (FSS) have to provide you, related to our work for
the Government of Estonia, are the interview notes of potential
witnesses. FSS has always viewed these notes and comments from the
interviewees as highly sensitive and classified as PRIVILEGED AND
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT.
We have attached those notes related to the interviews conducted with
witnesses. They represent the final remaining documents that FSS has to
provide you. We will now expect our payments that are due as you noted
below. Accordingly, please advise when we should expect the final
payments your office to FSS. Our wire instructions are listed below.
Best Regards,
Walter Donaldson
Attorney Client Communication / Attorney Work Product Privileged and
Confidential
Walter B. Donaldson II, CFE, CFCI, CFSSP
Chief Operating Officer
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLP
3711 Kennett Pike, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807D +1 (302) 824-7533
M +1 (302) 588-2795
|
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: THIS EMAIL, INCLUDING ANY ATTACHMENT(S), IS
INTENDED ONLY FOR THE PERSON OR ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS ADDRESSED AND MAY
CONTAIN CONFIDENTIAL AND/OR PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY/CLIENT WORK PRODUCT
COMMUNICATIONS AS WELL AS OTHER CONFIDENTIAL, PROPRIETARY OR SECRET
INFORMATION. IF YOU ARE NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT, PLEASE DO NOT READ
THIS EMAIL OR DISSEMINATE IT TO ANYONE. PLEASE NOTIFY THE SENDER
IMMEDIATELY BY REPLYING TO THIS MESSAGE OR BY CALLING +1 (302) 824-7533
(WE ACCEPT COLLECT CALLS), AND THEN DELETE THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE AND ANY
COPIES OF IT FROM YOUR COMPUTER SYSTEM. ANY USE, DISSEMINATION,
DISTRIBUTION, OR REPRODUCTION OF THIS MESSAGE AND/OR ANY ATTACHMENTS BY
UNINTENDED RECIPIENTS IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED AND MAY BE UNLAWFUL. THANK
YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION.
From: Marju Lepmets <>Date: Friday, July 16, 2021 at 7:34 AMTo: Walter
Donaldson II <>Cc: Benito Romano <>, "Bescript, Patricia" <>, Greg Paw
<>, Keit Pentus-Rosimannus <>, Märten Ross <>Subject: RE: Request for
information
Dear Walter,
The Ministry of Finance, based on the mandate given by the government,
has not changed the position provided in the letter to FSS from June
22,2021. Ministry is waiting all the information related to interviews
conducted with the witnesses to be handed over, until then no payments
will be made.
Best regards,
Marju Lepmets | õigustalituse jurist | ühisosakondTel +372 611 3061 |
Rahandusministeerium | Suur-Ameerika 1, 10122 Tallinn
From: Walter Donaldson <> Sent: Tuesday, July 6, 2021 4:29 PMTo: Marju
Lepmets <>Cc: Benito Romano <>; Bescript, Patricia <>; Greg Paw <>; Keit
Pentus-Rosimannus <>; Märten Ross <>Subject: Re: Request for information
Dear Marju,
I fully understand and am happy to let you know in a separate email when
it has been sent. Please wire all outstanding payments to FSS using the
wire instructions below and advise when complete:
Wire instructions:
Freeh Sporkin Sullivan LLP
M and T Bank
SWIFT: MANTUS33
Account No.: 29597359
Thank you
Walter
On Tue, Jul 6, 2021 at 6:00 AM Marju Lepmets <> wrote:
Dear Mr Donaldson,
We hereby confirm the receipt of your email dated July 1, 2021.
Due to technical and security issues with file download last time and to
be sure that we dont miss your email, we kindly ask you while sending the
letter with a link for downloading the files, please notify me or Märten
with separate email after you have done that.
Best regards,
Marju Lepmets
Marju Lepmets | õigustalituse jurist | ühisosakondTel +372 611 3061 |
Rahandusministeerium |
From: Walter Donaldson <> Sent: Thursday, July 1, 2021 5:24 PMTo: Marju
Lepmets <>; Märten Ross <>; Keit Pentus-Rosimannus <>Cc: Benito Romano
<>; Bescript, Patricia <>; Greg Paw <>Subject: Fwd: Request for
information
Dear Ms. Pentus-Rosimannus:We have reviewed your letter of June 22, 2021,
concerning delivery of materials that became known to FSS during our
representation of the Ministry of Finance of Estonia. As you are aware,
we already have provided extensive documentation of our work.While we do
not agree with the characterization of the materials we have provided
that is contained in your letter, we nonetheless will provide you with
the names of persons interviewed by FSS during our representation as well
as the notes from these interviews. In return, we expect to be paid all
amounts due to FSS. We will deliver the names and the written interview
notes under separate cover. We previously provided all documentary
information provided by the witnesses in our prior
transmissions.Regards,Walter Donaldson
---------- Forwarded message ---------From: <>Date: Tue, Jun 22, 2021 at
1:37 AMSubject: Request for informationTo: Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLP
<>, Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLP <>, AlixPartners <>
Tere! Teile on Rahandusministeeriumi poolt edastatud dokument. Pealkiri:
Request for information Registreerimise kuupäev: 22.06.2021
Registreerimise number: 3.2-12/2527-6. NB! Dokumendile on kehtestatud
juurdepääsupiirang alates 07.06.2021 kuni 07.06.2026, vastavalt AvTS § 35
lg .
Tel. (372) 611 3558e-mail:
P Säästa loodust ja ära prindi seda e-kirja!
________________________________
Käesolev e-kiri võib sisaldada asutusesiseseks kasutamiseks tunnistatud
teavet. This e-mail may contain information which is classified for
official use.
--
Walter B. Donaldson IIChief Operating OfficerFreeh Sporkin & Sullivan,
LLP, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807D +1 (302) 824-7533 M +1 (302) 588-
2795FreehSporkinSullivan.com
P Säästa loodust ja ära prindi seda e-kirja!
________________________________
Käesolev e-kiri võib sisaldada asutusesiseseks kasutamiseks tunnistatud
teavet. This e-mail may contain information which is classified for
official use.
--
Walter B. Donaldson IIChief Operating OfficerFreeh Sporkin & Sullivan,
LLP3711 Kennett Pike, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807D +1 (302) 824-7533
M +1 (302) 588-2795FreehSporkinSullivan.com
P Säästa loodust ja ära prindi seda e-kirja!
________________________________
Käesolev e-kiri võib sisaldada asutusesiseseks kasutamiseks tunnistatud
teavet. This e-mail may contain information which is classified for
official use.
Saatja: Walter Donaldson <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 24.02.2021 03:21
Adressaat: info.fin list <
[email protected]>; Riina Virkus
<
[email protected]>; Märten Ross <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Benito Romano <
[email protected]>; Louis Freeh
<
[email protected]>; Valerie Middlebrooks
<
[email protected]>; Greg Paw <
[email protected]>
Teema: Invoices for FSS
Dear Ms. Virkus,
Attached are the invoices for professional services performed by Freeh
Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP (FSS). There are two separate invoices, one of
which includes the unpaid balance of the January invoice as well as
professional services for February. The second is the termination
agreement invoice in the amount of 2% of the Tender Value. Additionally,
FSS will continue to invoice the Republic of Estonia in the future for
any ongoing communications, professional services or administrative work
related to our contract / Tender. Thank you.
Best regards,
Walter
Attorney Client Communication / Attorney Work Product
Privileged and Confidential
Walter B. Donaldson II, CFE, CFCI, CFSSP
Chief Operating Officer
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan, LLP
3711 Kennett Pike, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807D +1
(302) 824-7533
|
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: THIS EMAIL, INCLUDING
ANY ATTACHMENT(S), IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE PERSON OR
ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS ADDRESSED AND MAY
CONTAIN CONFIDENTIAL AND/OR PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY/CLIENT
WORK PRODUCT COMMUNICATIONS AS WELL AS
OTHER CONFIDENTIAL, PROPRIETARY OR
SECRET INFORMATION. IF YOU ARE NOT THE
INTENDED RECIPIENT, PLEASE DO NOT READ THIS EMAIL
OR DISSEMINATE IT TO ANYONE. PLEASE NOTIFY THE
SENDER IMMEDIATELY BY REPLYING TO THIS MESSAGE OR BY
CALLING +1 (302) 824-7533 (WE ACCEPT COLLECT CALLS), AND
THEN DELETE THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE AND ANY COPIES OF IT
FROM YOUR COMPUTER SYSTEM. ANY
USE, DISSEMINATION, DISTRIBUTION, OR REPRODUCTION OF
THIS MESSAGE AND/OR ANY ATTACHMENTS BY UNINTENDED
RECIPIENTS IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED AND MAY BE
UNLAWFUL. THANK YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION.
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 11.06.2021 09:40
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Request for information
From: Walter Donaldson <> Sent: Friday, June 11, 2021 6:57 AMTo: Märten
Ross <>Cc: Benito Romano <>; Greg Paw <>; Louis J. Freeh <>Subject: Re:
Request for information
Dear Mr. Ross
FSS has cooperated with you and your Ministry of Finance office over the
past several months to ensure we have responded to your requests. I sent
you our January invoice on February 9th and the February invoice on
February 23.
After sending these documents to you, twice, you asked for several
entries to be to be removed because you said they were after the date of
separation. I did as you asked and provided you new invoices, removing
the time on March 31st.
You then asked for further details on our work product on May 3rd, which
we promptly responded to on May 6th. Your last communication to me on May
14 simply acknowledged receipt of all of our information.
FSS and I have been nothing but cooperative with you and your requests.
However, we have still not received either our Professional Services fees
for the work we performed, nor have we received the separation fee you
and your office publicly noted in the media was due to FSS following the
separation. It has now been another month and FSS is contractually
entitled to these payments. Please advise when our past due fees are
going to be paid.
Regards,
Walter Donaldson
On Fri, May 14, 2021 at 1:36 AM Märten Ross <> wrote:
Dear Mr Donaldson,
Recalling some earlier difficulties of receiving certain e-mails I forgot
to confirm the receipt of the message last week. Hereby I do that.
Best,
Märtne Ross
From: Walter Donaldson <> Sent: Thursday, May 6, 2021 7:13 PMTo: info.fin
list <>; Märten Ross <>Cc: Benito Romano <>; Bescript, Patricia
<>Subject: Re: Request for information
Dear Mr. Ross
Please find the attached response to your May 3, 2021 email and letter.
Best Regards,
Walter Donaldson
Attorney Client Communication / Attorney Work Product Privileged and
Confidential
Walter B. Donaldson II, CFE, CFCI, CFSSP
Chief Operating Officer
Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLP
, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807D +1 (302) 824-7533
M +1 (302) 588-2795
|
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: THIS EMAIL, INCLUDING ANY ATTACHMENT(S), IS
INTENDED ONLY FOR THE PERSON OR ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS ADDRESSED AND MAY
CONTAIN CONFIDENTIAL AND/OR PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY/CLIENT WORK PRODUCT
COMMUNICATIONS AS WELL AS OTHER CONFIDENTIAL, PROPRIETARY OR SECRET
INFORMATION. IF YOU ARE NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT, PLEASE DO NOT READ
THIS EMAIL OR DISSEMINATE IT TO ANYONE. PLEASE NOTIFY THE SENDER
IMMEDIATELY BY REPLYING TO THIS MESSAGE OR BY CALLING +1 (302) 824-7533
(WE ACCEPT COLLECT CALLS), AND THEN DELETE THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE AND ANY
COPIES OF IT FROM YOUR COMPUTER SYSTEM. ANY USE, DISSEMINATION,
DISTRIBUTION, OR REPRODUCTION OF THIS MESSAGE AND/OR ANY ATTACHMENTS BY
UNINTENDED RECIPIENTS IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED AND MAY BE UNLAWFUL. THANK
YOU FOR YOUR COOPERATION.
From: "" <>Date: Monday, May 3, 2021 at 06:15To: Walter Donaldson II <>,
Benito Romano <>, AlixPartners <>Subject: Request for information
Tere! Teile on Rahandusministeeriumi poolt edastatud dokument. Pealkiri:
Request for information Registreerimise kuupäev: 03.05.2021
Registreerimise number: 3.2-12/2527-3. NB! Dokumendile on kehtestatud
juurdepääsupiirang alates 30.04.2021 kuni 30.04.2026, vastavalt AvTS § 35
lg 1 p 3.
Tel. (372) 611 3558e-mail:
P Säästa loodust ja ära prindi seda e-kirja!
________________________________
Käesolev e-kiri võib sisaldada asutusesiseseks kasutamiseks tunnistatud
teavet. This e-mail may contain information which is classified for
official use.
Tähelepanu! Tegemist on välisvõrgust saabunud kirjaga.Tundmatu saatja
korral palume linke ja faile mitte avada.
P Säästa loodust ja ära prindi seda e-kirja!
________________________________
Käesolev e-kiri võib sisaldada asutusesiseseks kasutamiseks tunnistatud
teavet. This e-mail may contain information which is classified for
official use.
--
Walter B. Donaldson IIChief Operating OfficerFreeh Sporkin & Sullivan,
LLP3711 Kennett Pike, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE 19807D +1 (302) 824-7533
M +1 (302) 588-2795FreehSporkinSullivan.com
Teie 09.09.2021
Eesti Rahvusringhääling Meie 22.09.2021 nr 1.4-1/6323-2
[email protected]
Vastuskiri teabenõudele
Pöördusite rahandusministeeriumi poole teabenõudega ja palusite väljastada dokumendid, mis
on seotud rahandusministeeriumi ja advokaadibüroo Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan vahel sõlmitud
lepinguga. Vabandame vastuse viibimise pärast.
Vastuskirja manuses on kirjavahetus ministeeriumi ja advokaadibüroo vahel pärast seda, kui
valitsus otsustas USA rahapesuga seotud uurimismenetlustega seotud tegevustes jätkata ilma
advokaadibüroo abita. Lisatud on ka rahandusministeeriumi siseauditi ülevaatlik memo
advokaadibürooga Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan lepingu sõlmimisest ja täitmisest.
Teabenõudega ei ole võimalik väljastada 30.08.2021 kirja (registreeritud nr 3.2-12/6075-1 all)
manuses olnud tunnistajate intervjuude materjale („Interview reports: Government of
Estonia“) ja 14.04.2021 ministeeriumile kättesaadavaks tehtud materjale, millele on avaliku
teabe seaduse § 35 lg 1 punkti 11 alusel kehtestatud juurdepääsupiirang.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Merike Saks
kantsler
Lisa(d):
1. väljaminevad kirjad 13-5.1/720-7; 13-5.1/720-9; 3.2-12/1578-2; 3.2-12/1578-3; 3.2-
12/2527-3; 3.2-12/2527-6;
2. sissetulnud kirjad 13-5.1/720-8; 3.2-12/1578-1; 3.2-12/2527-1; 3.2-12/2527-4; 3.2-
12/2527-7; 3.2-12/6075-1;
3. siseauditi osakonna memo
Marju Lepmets 611 3061
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272
MEMO
Kellele: Keit Pentus-Rosimannus, Merike Saks
Kuupäev: 11. mai 2021
Pealkiri: Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLP lepingu täitmisest
Memo eesmärgiks on anda ülevaade Freeh Sporkin & Sullivan LLPga (edaspidi: FSS) sõlmitud lepingu
täitmisest 2021. mai alguse seisuga.
Töö käigus otsisin vastuseid järgnevatele küsimustele:
1. Millised olid ootused FSS lepingu raames tehtavale tööle?
2. Kuidas oli korraldatud lepingu täitmise dokumendikäive, aruandlus ja järelevalve?
3. Millist informatsiooni on lepingu täitmisel esitatud?
4. Kas tehtud töö vastas lepingule?
Kasutatud materjalid:
Intervjuud Märten Rossi (asekantsler) ja Marju Lepmetsaga (ühisosakonna õigusteenistuse jurist),
RAM ministrite nõunike ette valmistatud lähteülesanne, FSS leping, FSS arved ja nende
kooskõlastusringid e-arvekeskuses 2020 (6 tk) ja 2021. aastast (2 tk), FSS memod ülevaatega tehtud
tööst (november 2020, jaanuar 2021, veebruar 2021), käesolevaks hetkeks FSSi poolt üleantud
materjalid (RAM sisekettal), FSS pakkumine (Deltas), lepingueelne kirjavahetus teiste potentsiaalsete
pakkujatega (Deltas), Märten Rossi memod lepingu täitmisest ja edasise tegevuse võimalustest
(veebruar 2021, 2 tk; mai 2021, 1 tk).
1. Lepingu eel formuleeritud ootused ja leping
Ootused
Ootused sõlmitavale lepingule fikseeriti inglisekeelse lähteülesandega, mille koostajaks olid toonased
rahandusministri nõunikud Kristel Menning ja Kersti Kracht (Kristel Menningi 12. jaanuari 2020 e-kiri
Marju Lepmetsale). Lähteülesanne seadis eesmärgiks luua sidemed rahandusministri ja USA
panganduse regulaatoritega justiitsministeeriumis, SECis New Yorgi osariigi finantsteenuste osakonna
ja Rootsi ning Saksa riiklike uurijatega. Samuti nähti ette, et töö teostaja teeb ka uurimistoiminguid
koostöös FI ja rahandusministeeriumiga. Töö pidi toimuma kahes etapis:
I – sidemete loomine Eesti ja USA regulaatorite vahel, Eesti poole nõustamine, tutvustada USA
regulatsioone Eesti poolele, uurimiseesmärgi ja ulatuse määratlemine, võimalike tunnistajate ringi
väljaselgitamine;
II – uurimise abistamine Eestis ja välismaal, Eesti uurijate nõustamine USA regulatsioonide ja
uurimispraktika kohta, tunnistajaintervjuude läbiviimine, uurimistulemuste vahendamine USA
uurijatele, trahvirahasid puudutavates läbirääkimistes Eesti poole nõustamine.
II etapi tulemusena pidi valmima raport, mis võtaks kokku senised tulemused kohta, kogutud tõendid
ja annaks soovitused edasise tegevuste kohta.
Memo koostajale ei ole teada, kas ja kui palju võisid nõunike esitatud lähteülesande kokkupanemisel
osaleda FSS töötajad või mõned muud konsultandid, kellega eelnevalt konsulteeriti rahandusministri
2019. aasta oktoobri New Yorki visiidil – toimunud kohtumisi ja nende tulemusi nii
rahandusministeeriumi kui ka avalikkuse ees ei tutvustatud. FSS töötajate osalemine lähteülesande
koostamisel oleks vastuolus riigihangete seaduse põhimõtetega – potentsiaalsest huvide konfliktist
tulenevalt võib riigihangete seaduse kohaselt hankest kõrvaldada pakkuja, kes osales hanke
väljatöötamisel või lähteülesande koostamisel (RHS § 95 lg4 p7).
Pakkumiskutse ja leping
Pakkumiskutse ja sõlmitud leping on lähteülesandega võrdlemisi sarnase eesmärgiga, põhjalikumalt
on käsitletud II etapi lõpu raportit, mis pidi sisaldama järgmist:
1) Tehtud uurimistöö tulemuste kokkuvõte;
2) Hinnang võimalikule trahvijagamise kokkuleppele USA võimudega, sh millised on riskid ja
nõudmised;
3) Hinnang Eesti kogukuludele protsessi läbiviimisel;
4) Soovitused edasiseks tegevuseks lähtudes Eesti huvidest.
Marju Lepmetsa sõnul täiendati ootusi analüüsi tulemustele tema soovitusel, et tagada paremini ja
selgemini hinnatav tulemus.
Lisaks lisandus pakkumiskutse ja lepinguga ka III etapp – nõustamine USAga trahvirahade jagamise
lepingu ettevalmistamisel ja sõlmimisel.
Pakkumiskutse edastati 8.06.2020 kolmele potentsiaalsele pakkujale: Cleary Gottlieb Steen &
Hamilton LLP (edaspidi CGSH); Freeh Sporkin Sullivan LLP (edaspidi FSS); White & Case LLP (edaspidi
WC). Pakkumiste esitamise tähtaeg oli 10 päeva, 18.06.2020. Pakkumiskutse sisaldas juba ka lepingu
projekti. Kuidas potentsiaalsete pakkujate ring määratleti, jääb selgusetuks.
Pakkujatest CGSH teatas pärast konsulteerimist rahandusministeeriumiga, et ei saa tulenevalt
seotusest Danske pangaga lepingut sõlmida. Samal põhjusel, so tulenevalt potentsiaalsest huvide
konfliktist oma varasemate klientidega, loobus ka WC. Ainukesena esitas pakkumise FSS, kellega
sõlmiti ka leping 27.06.2020.
2. Lepingu täitmise aruandlus ja dokumendid
Lepingus ei fikseeritud eraldi, milline on tehtud tööst raporteerimise kord ja selle konkreetsed
väljundid. Ainuke fikseeritud tulem on II etapi lõpus esitatav aruanne ja analüüs trahvirahade või
hüvitiste saamise perspektiivikuse kohta. Kuna lepingu täitmine katkes II etapi kestel, siis seda
analüüsi koostatud ei ole.
Samuti ei nõutud lepinguga arvete esitamisel üleandmise- ja vastuvõtuaktide koostamist. Arvetes
kirjutati põhjalikult lahti erinevate FSS töötajate ja partnerite tööaeg, milles näidati ära
kuupäevaliselt konkreetsed tegevused iga töötaja lõikes koos tegevusele kulunud tööajaga, kuid
sellest tavast ei peetud alati kinni (vt tähelepanekuid).
Järelevalvet lepingu sisulise täitmise üle tegid rahandusministri nõunikud Kristel Menning ja Kersti
Kracht, kogu info lepingu täitmise kulust oli koondatud nende ja rahandusministri kätte,
rahandusministeeriumi ametnikud infovahetusse kaasatud ei olnud. K. Kracht ja K. Menning
kinnitasid ka sisust lähtuvalt FSSi esitatud arveid e-arvekeskuses. Arveid on e-arvekeskuses
kinnitanud ka rahandusministeeriumi finantsosakonna töötaja ja juhataja.
Tähelepanekud arvetelt:
1) Mitmetel arvetel on täpsemalt lahti kirjutamata Louis J. Freeh tööaeg – näiteks on see
esitatud kas tundide koondarvuna (9.11.2020 ja 9.01.2021 arvel) või siis küll lahti kirjutatuna
kuupäevade ja tundide lõikes, kuid tegevused on lahti kirjutamata (3.12.2020). Pooltel
arvetel on L. Freeh tööaeg lahti kirjutatud sama detailsusega nagu teistel (10.09.2020 (1),
10.09.2020 (2), 9.02.2021 ja 22.02.2021). Ühel arvel (7.10.2020) on täpselt lahti kirjutamata
esitatud L. Freeh tööaeg tagantjärgi juba möödunud perioodi eest (22,5 töötundi augusti eest
2020, summas 13 500 USD), so perioodil, mille eest FSS oli varasemalt arve juba esitanud.
2) Arvetel esineb kulutusi, mille kohta pole algdokumente esitatud – lepingus lepiti kokku
muude kulude kompenseerimisel nii luba küsimine kui ka dokumentaalsete tõendite
esitamine kulu kohta. 7.10.2020 arvel on täpsemalt lahti kirjutamata L. Freeh muud kulud
summas 5158,33 USD, mis summa poolest vastavad küll lennupiletite pakkumisele, mis on
esitatud 10.09.2020(1) arve juures (sellel arvel see summa ei kajastu), kuid algdokumente
(lennupileteid) arvele lisatud pole. 3.12.2020 arvel on esitatud tõlkekulud summas 250 USD,
mille kohta pole algdokumenti. Pole infot, kas muude kulude tegemine kooskõlastati
eelnevalt nõunikega, nagu nõudis leping.
3) Esineb kulusid, mille tegemine polnud lepinguga lubatud. Näiteks L. Freeh esimese Tallinna
visiidi lennupiletid olid kõik business classi piletid (lisatud 10.09.2020(1) arvele, kokku
summas 16 987,3 USD), kuigi lepinguga oli lubatud kasutada ainult economy classi. Esitatud
arvel on küll summat korrigeeritud (arvel 6 185,40), kuid jääb selgusetuks, millest
korrigeerimisel lähtuti, so esitamata on dokumentaalsed tõestused, nt võrreldavad
pakkumised economy class piletile. 10.09.2020(1) arvele on lisatud kontorikulusid (363,75
USD), mida ei oleks lepingu kohaselt tohtinud lisada.
4) 9.02.2021 arvel on esitatud L. Freeh ettevõttele Alix Partners tehtud korrektsioon (so
vähendus) summas 25 200 USD, arvelt aga ei selgu korrektsiooni põhjus.
3. Lepingu alusel tehtud tööd
Lepingu täitmisel jõuti II etapi algusesse. Kuna lepingu esimene etapp oli kontaktide loomine ja
ülevaate saamine võimalustest, siis sellest olulisi dokumentaalseid materjale järele ei jäänud.
Üleantud materjalides on näiteks ülevaade USA kokkuleppepraktikast (FSS analüüs), Danske ja
Swedbanki rahapesu tõkestamise meetmete analüüse (FSS koostatud), ajakirjanduse väljavõtteid, üks
USA kongressi raport Vene mõjude kohta USA poliitikas, Danske Bank Eesti filiaali ja Swedbanki
siseseid ettekandeid ja protseduurireegleid ning samuti FSS tehtud töö kokkuvõtte memo 30.
oktoobrist 2020. Valdavalt on tegu avalikult kättesaadavate materjalidega, pankade sisedokumendid
pole küll avalikud, kuid kindlasti on nad kättesaadavad Eesti uurimisorganitele.
Materjalides leiduv intervjueeritavate nimekiri on võrdlemisi triviaalne ning tundub olevat koostatud
ainult avalikke allikaid kasutades – näiteks ajakirjanduses läbi käinud Danske ja Swedbanki töötajate
nimed ning üldse inimesed, kes on avalikult rahapesu teemal sõna võtnud, näiteks nagu ajakirjanikud
ja poliitikud. On näha, et nimekiri on läbi töötamata ja ühtlustamata: esineb topeltkandeid; osade
inimeste puhul on lahti kirjutatud, miks nad on nimekirja lülitatud, teiste puhul mitte; osadele on
lisatud kontaktid, teistele jälle mitte. Tehtud intervjuude protokolle üle antud ei ole, kuigi arvete
alusel võib öelda, et mõned intervjuud siiski läbi viidi. Seetõttu pole ka võimalik hinnata, kas
intervjuude käigus koguti mingit kasulikku informatsiooni, mida polnud eelnevalt võimalik nt
riigiorganite töö tulemusena koguda.
Märten Rossi sõnul polnud ka loodud kontaktid Eesti uurimisorganitele eriti kasulikud, need
kontaktid olid ka juba varasemalt olemas, ning uusi lisandus ainult üks või kaks.
Arvete alusel on väga palju tööaega kulunud omavahelistele aruteludele, üksteise materjalide
lugemisele ja läbitöötamisele. Kuigi omavahelised arutelud ja üksteise briifimine on igati loomulik
tööprotsess, siis jääb ikkagi mulje, et palju tööaega kulus lihtsalt meeskonna enda ülalpidamisele.
Viimasele arvele on lisatud ka üsna suur hulk tööaega, mis kulus mitte niivõrd sisulisele tööle kui
kirjavahetusele Rahandusministeeriumiga.
4. Tehtud töö ja lepingu vastavus
Tulenevalt umbmäärasest lähteülesandest ja lepingus sätetatud tööülesannetest on raske anda
hinnangut sellele, kas see töö, mida on praeguseks hetkeks tehtud, vastas algselt püstitatud
ootustele ja lepingule. Teisalt on aga ka väga raske väita, et tehtud töö polnud see, mida lepingut
sõlmides oodati, kuna ka ootused olid formuleeritud väga laialt ja ebakonkreetselt. Kuna
rahandusministeeriumi ametnikke ei kaasatud ja kogu suhtlus toimus rahandusministri ja ministri
nõunikega, siis pole olemas ka head ülevaadet sellest, mis materjale üldse kokku koguti ja kus neid
talletati.
Sisulisest aspektist hinnates tehti lepingu raames vähemalt esimeses etapis paljuski sellist tööd, mis
dubleeris Eesti uurimisorganite ülesandeid – näiteks tunnistajate intervjuud oleks võinud jätta
täielikult uurimisorganitele, kes on ühelt poolt professionaalsemad ning teiselt poolt ka autoriteedi
poolest paremas positsioonis kui üks advokaadibüroo. Kogutud taustainfo nii avalikest kui ka
pangasisestest ettekannetest ning avalike allikate põhjal koostatud intervjueeritavate nimekiri ei
paku uurimisele olulist lisandväärtust ning saadud materjal ei ole midagi sellist, mida uurimisorganid
poleks suutnud koguda ka ilma selle lepinguta. Büroo vahendusel loodud kontaktid ei osutunud
uurimisorganitele uudseteks, välja arvatud ehk ühel-kahel juhul. Suurimat väärtust pakuvad ehk
büroo koostatud analüüsid varasematest USA kokkuleppepraktikatest, kuid seda tööd oleks võinud
tellida ka oluliselt odavama üksiktööna.
Kokkuvõtteks
Kuigi tehtud töö ei paku Eesti-sisesele uurimisele erilist lisandväärtust ja pole praeguseks hetkeks
toonud olulisi uusi teadmisi ja kontakte, on ikkagi väga raske väita, et see töö pole olnud kooskõlas
ootuste ja lepinguga, kuna nende formuleering on samuti üsna laialivalguv ja vähekonkreetne.
Koostas: Gert Schultz
siseauditi osakonna juhataja
Lisa:
Ajajoon
Kuupäev Tegevus
12.01.2020 Kristel Menning edastab lähteülesande Marju Lepmetsale.
Pakkumiskutse edastatud kolmele potentsiaalsele pakkujale:
Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP (edaspidi CGSH); Freeh
Sporkin Sullivan LLP (edaspidi FSS); White & Case LLP (edaspidi
08.06.2020 WC). Tähtaeg 18.06.2020.
10.06.2020 CGSH teavitab huvide konfliktist seoses oma kliendiga - Danske.
17.06.2020 FSS esitab pakkumuse.
RAM vastus CGSH-le: Danske asjaolusid ei ole võimalik
17.06.2020 tellimusest eraldada.
17.06.2020 CGSH teatab, et ei saa hankes osaleda.
WC teatab, et ei saa hankes osaleda, viidates võimalikule huvide
18.06.2020 konfliktile.
27.06.2020 Lepingu sõlmimine FSSiga
2.-4.07.2020 Freeh visiit Tallinnasse.
21.-23.09.2020 Freeh visiit Tallinnasse.
26.01.2021 Ametisse asub uus valitsus.
18.02.2021 FSS saadab e-kirja lepingu lõpetamise kohta.