dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Lennuamet
Kiri sissetulevAvalik

NPA 2016-02

Lennuamet · 29. aprill 2016
Viit
2-4/16/1473-1
Registreeritud
29. aprill 2016
Dokumendi liik
Kiri sissetulev
Adressaat
European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA)
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
2 Õigusalane teenindamine
Sari
2-4 Kirjavahetus rahvusvaheliste lennundusnõuete küsimustes
Toimik
2-4/2016
Vastutaja
Kristel Palts (Lennuamet, Juhtkond, Lennuliiklusteeninduse ja lennuväljade osakond)
Lahendamise tähtaeg
31. august 2016

Failid

  • 📎Appendix 1 to Annex III (ATM_ANS.OR) - Data catalogue_0.pdf806 KB
  • 📎Appendix 1 to Part-AIS - AIP content.pdf279 KB
  • 📎Appendix 2 to Part-AIS - NOTAM format.pdf90 KB
  • 📎Appendix 3 to Part-AIS - SNOWTAM format.pdf105 KB
  • 📎Appendix 4 to Part-AIS - ASHTAM format.pdf58 KB
  • 📎NPA 2016-02 - Comparison tables.pdf5420 KB
  • 📎NPA 2016-02.pdf1520 KB

Sisu (failidest)

European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management RMT.0477 — 27.4.2016 Cross-reference tables This document contains three cross-reference tables developed for the purpose of rule traceability: — Table 1 contains the definitions comparison between ICAO Annex 15 and PANS-AIM, Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 and the NPA text; — Table 2 contains the rule comparison between the provisions of Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 and the NPA text; and — Table 3 contains the rule comparison between the text of the upcoming major amendment to ICAO Annex 15 and new draft PANS-AIM, and the NPA text. The tables 2 and 3 comprises three columns: — The first column contains the text of the provisions to be compared with (ICAO/EC Reg.); — The second column provides the NPA proposed text. — The third column shows if changes have been made to the ICAO/EC Reg. provisions or not and if changes were made, the justification why such changes are proposed. Please note that Table 3 (comparison between ICAO material and the NPA text) is based on the a draft ICAO Annex 15 and PANS-AIM that is currently under approval process at ICAO level. Disclaimer This document, courtesy of EASA, is intended to support stakeholders following the publication of the related EASA NPA on ‘Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management’ (RMT.0477). EASA does not assume any liability for its contents. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Table 1 DEFINITIONS - Comparison between ICAO Annex 15 and PANS-AIM, Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 and the NPA text Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Aerodrome. A defined area on land or water (including --- Not transposed. any buildings, installations and equipment) intended to be used either wholly or in part for the arrival, departure and This term is already defined in Regulation 216/2008. surface movement of aircraft. Aerodrome mapping data (AMD). Data collected for the 10. ‘aerodrome mapping data’ means data collected Not transposed. purpose of compiling aerodrome mapping information. for the purpose of compiling aerodrome mapping This term is already defined in point 14 of Annex I of Note.— Aerodrome mapping data are collected for information; Regulation (EU) …/.. purposes that include the improvement of the user’s situational awareness, surface navigation operations, The Note is not transposed as it is not considered training, charting and planning. relevant in the context of the rules. Aerodrome mapping database (AMDB). A collection of --- Not transposed. aerodrome mapping data organized and arranged as a structured data set. This term is already defined in point 15 of Annex I of Regulation (EU) …/.. Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC). A notice --- ‘Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC)’ means a containing information that does not qualify for the notice containing information that does not qualify for origination of a NOTAM or for inclusion in the AIP, but the origination of a NOTAM or for inclusion in the AIP, which relates to flight safety, air navigation, technical, but which relates to flight safety, air navigation, administrative or legislative matters. technical, administrative or legislative matters; Aeronautical information management (AIM). The --- ‘Aeronautical information management (AIM)’ means dynamic, integrated management of aeronautical the dynamic, integrated management of aeronautical European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA information through the provision and exchange of information through the provision and exchange of quality-assured digital aeronautical data in collaboration quality-assured digital aeronautical data in with all parties. collaboration with all parties; Aeronautical Information Product. Aeronautical data and 7. ‘integrated aeronautical information package’ ‘Aeronautical information product’ means aeronautical information provided either as digital data (hereinafter aeronautical data and aeronautical information sets or as a standardized presentation in paper or IAIP) means a package which consists of the provided either as digital data sets or as a electronic media. Aeronautical Information Products following standardized presentation in paper or electronic include: media. Aeronautical Information products include: elements: — Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP), including — aeronautical information publication (AIP), (a) aeronautical information publications Amendments and Supplements including Amendments and Supplements (hereinafter AIP), — Aeronautical Information Circulars (AIC) — aeronautical information circulars (AIC) including amendments; — Aeronautical charts — aeronautical charts (b) supplements to the AIP; — NOTAM — NOTAM (c) the NOTAM, as defined in point 17 and pre-flight — Digital data sets — gigital data sets information bulletins; Note.— Aeronautical Information Products are intended The Note is not transposed as it is not considered (d) aeronautical information circulars; and primarily to satisfy international requirements for the relevant in the context of the rules. exchange of aeronautical information. (e) checklists and lists of valid NOTAMs; Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP). A publication --- ‘Aeronautical information publication (AIP)’ means a issued by or with the authority of a State and containing publication issued by or with the authority of a State aeronautical information of a lasting character essential to and containing aeronautical information of a lasting air navigation. character essential to air navigation; Aeronautical information service (AIS). A service --- ‘Aeronautical information service’ means a service established within the defined area of coverage established by or on behalf of a Member State, within responsible for the provision of aeronautical data and the defined area of coverage responsible for the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA aeronautical information necessary for the safety, provision of aeronautical information and data regularity and efficiency of air navigation. necessary for the safety, regularity, and efficiency of air navigation; “aeronautical information service provider” means ‘Aeronautical information service provider’ means an the organisation responsible for the provision of an organisation responsible for the provision of an aeronautical information service, certified in aeronautical information service; accordance with the requirements of Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 1035/2011;’ AIP Amendment. Permanent changes to the information --- ‘AIP amendment’ means permanent changes to the contained in the AIP. information contained in the AIP; AIP Supplement. Temporary changes to the information --- ‘AIP supplement’ means temporary changes to the contained in the AIP which are provided by means of information contained in the AIP which are provided special pages. by means of special pages; AIRAC. An acronym (aeronautical information regulation --- ‘Aeronautical information regulation and control and control) signifying a system aimed at advance (AIRAC)’ means a system aimed at advance notification, based on common effective dates, of notification, based on common effective dates, of circumstances that necessitate significant changes in circumstances that necessitate significant changes in operating practices. operating practices; Air defence identification zone (ADIZ). Special designated --- Not transposed. airspace of defined dimensions within which aircraft are required to comply with special identification and/or reporting procedures additional to those related to the provision of air traffic services (ATS). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Air traffic management (ATM). The dynamic, integrated --- Not transposed. management of air traffic and airspace (including air traffic services, airspace management and air traffic flow This term is already defined in Regulation 216/2008 in management) — safely, economically and efficiently — article 3(q). through the provision of facilities and seamless services in collaboration with all parties and involving airborne and ground-based functions. Application. Manipulation and processing of data in --- Not transposed. support of user requirements (ISO 19104* ). This generic definition is not considered relevant in the context of the rules. Area navigation (RNAV). A method of navigation which --- Not transposed. permits aircraft operation on any desired flight path within the coverage of ground- or space-based navigation This term is already defined in point 27 of Annex I of aids or within the limits of the capability of self-contained Regulation (EU) …/.. aids, or a combination of these. The Note is not transposed as it is not considered Note.— Area navigation includes performance-based relevant in the context of the rules. navigation as well as other operations that do not meet the definition of performance-based navigation. ASHTAM. A special series NOTAM notifying by means of a --- Not transposed. specific format change in activity of a volcano, a volcanic eruption and/or volcanic ash cloud that is of significance This term is already defined in point 29 of Annex I of to aircraft operations. Regulation (EU) …/.. Assemble. A process of merging data from multiple --- ‘Assemble’ means a process of merging data from sources into a database and establishing a baseline for multiple sources into a database and establishing a European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA subsequent processing. baseline for subsequent processing; Note.— The assemble phase includes checking the data The Note is not transposed as it is not considered and ensuring that detected errors and omissions are relevant in the context of the rules. rectified. ATS surveillance service. Term used to indicate a service --- Not transposed. provided directly by means of an ATS surveillance system. This term is not used in the rules. ATS surveillance system. A generic term meaning --- Not transposed. variously, ADS-B, PSR, SSR or any comparable ground- based system that enables the identification of aircraft. This term is defined within the scope of ATS. Note.— A comparable ground-based system is one that has been demonstrated, by comparative assessment or other methodology, to have a level of safety and performance equal to or better than monopulse SSR. Automatic dependent surveillance — broadcast (ADS-B). A --- Not transposed. means by which aircraft, aerodrome vehicles and other objects can automatically transmit and/or receive data This term is defined within the scope of ATS. such as identification, position and additional data, as appropriate, in a broadcast mode via a data link. Automatic dependent surveillance — contract (ADS-C). A --- Not transposed. means by which the terms of an ADS-C agreement will be exchanged between the ground system and the aircraft, This term is defined within the scope of ATS. via a data link, specifying under what conditions ADS-C reports would be initiated, and what data would be contained in the reports. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Note.— The abbreviated term “ADS contract” is commonly used to refer to ADS event contract, ADS demand contract, ADS periodic contract or an emergency mode. Automatic terminal information service (ATIS). The --- Not transposed. automatic provision of current, routine information to arriving and departing aircraft throughout 24 hours or a This term is defined within the scope of ATS. specified portion thereof: Data link-automatic terminal information service (D-ATIS). The provision of ATIS via data link. Voice-automatic terminal information service (Voice- ATIS). The provision of ATIS by means of continuous and repetitive voice broadcasts. Bare Earth. Surface of the Earth including bodies of water --- This term is used in the AMC for terrain data set and and permanent ice and snow, and excluding vegetation will be included in the definition in the ED Decision. and man- made objects. Calendar. Discrete temporal reference system that --- Not transposed. provides the basis for defining temporal position to a resolution of one day (ISO 19108*). This term is considered to be self-explanatory. Canopy. Bare Earth supplemented by vegetation height. --- This term is used in the AMC for terrain data set and will be included in the definition in the ED Decision. Confidence level. The probability that the true value of a --- Not transposed. parameter is within a certain interval around the estimate of its value. This term is not used in the rules. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Note.— The interval is usually referred to as the accuracy of the estimate. Controller-pilot data link communications (CPDLC). A --- Not transposed. means of communication between controller and pilot, using data link for ATC communications. This term is defined within the scope of ATS. Culture. All man-made features constructed on the --- Not transposed. surface of the Earth, such as cities, railways and canals. This term is not used in the rules. Cyclic redundancy check (CRC). A mathematical algorithm --- ‘Cyclic redundancy check (CRC)’ means a applied to the digital expression of data that provides a mathematical algorithm applied to the digital level of assurance against loss or alteration of data. expression of data that provides a level of assurance against loss or alteration of data; Data completeness. The degree of confidence that all of --- ‘Completeness (of data)’ means the degree of the data needed to support the intended use is provided. confidence that all of the data needed to support the intended use is provided; Data format. A structure of data elements, records and --- ‘Format (of data)’ means a structure of data elements, files arranged to meet standards, specifications or data records and files arranged to meet standards, quality requirements specifications or data quality requirements; Data product. Data set or data set series that conforms to --- Not transposed. a data product specification (ISO 19131*). The term used is data product specification (below). Data product specification. Detailed description of a data --- ‘Data product specification’ means a detailed set or data set series together with additional information description of a data set or data set series together that will enable it to be created, supplied to and used by with additional information that will enable it to be European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA another party (ISO 19131*). created, supplied to and used by another party; Note.— A data product specification provides a GM1 to ‘Data product specification’: description of the universe of discourse and a specification for mapping the universe of discourse to a A data product specification provides a description of data set. It may be used for production, sales, end-use or the universe of discourse and a specification for other purpose. mapping the universe of discourse to a data set. It may be used for production, sales, end-use or other purpose. Data product specification provide a means by which the content of a data set is precisely specified. A data product specification supports the party generating a data set by providing information as to what exactly should be included within the data set. The content of the data product specification is closely related to the metadata model. The users of the data may determine, by comparing their data product specification with the metadata, how the data may be used in their application and what mitigations, if any, are needed as result of, for example, the quality / completeness of the data. Data timeliness. The degree of confidence that the data is --- ‘Timeliness (of data)’ means the degree of confidence applicable to the period of its intended use that the data is applicable to the period of its intended use; Data traceability: the degree that a system or a data --- ‘Traceability (of data)’ means the degree that a system product can provide a record of the changes made to that or a data product can provide a record of the changes European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA product and thereby enable an audit trail to be followed made to that product and thereby enable an audit from the end-user to the data originator trail to be followed from the end-user to the data originator; Data set. Identifiable collection of data (ISO 19101*). --- ‘Data set’ means identifiable collection of data; Data set series. Collection of data sets sharing the same --- Not transposed. product specification (ISO 19115*). This term is not used in the rules. Aeronautical data. A representation of aeronautical facts, 1. ‘aeronautical data’ means a representation of ’Aeronautical data’ means a representation of concepts or instructions in a formalized manner suitable aeronautical facts, concepts or instructions in a aeronautical facts, concepts or instructions in a for communication, interpretation or processing. formalised manner suitable for communication, formalized manner suitable for communication, interpretation or processing; interpretation or processing; Aeronautical information. Information resulting from the 2. ‘aeronautical information’ means information Not transposed. assembly, analysis and formatting of aeronautical data. resulting from the assembly, analysis and formatting of aeronautical data; This term is already defined in point 13 of Annex I of Regulation (EU) …/.. Data quality. A degree or level of confidence that the data 3. ‘data quality’ means a degree or level of Not transposed. provided meet the requirements of the data user in terms confidence that the data provided meets the of accuracy, resolution, integrity (or equivalent assurance requirements of the data user in terms of accuracy, This term is already defined in point 41 of Annex I of level), traceability, timeliness, completeness and format. resolution and integrity; Regulation (EU) …/.. Data accuracy. A degree of conformance between the 4. ‘accuracy’ means a degree of conformance ‘Data accuracy’ means a degree of conformance estimated or measured value and the true value. between the estimated or measured value and the between the estimated or measured value and the Note.— For measured positional data the accuracy is true value; true value; normally expressed in terms of a distance from a stated The Note is not transposed as it is not considered European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA position within which there is a defined confidence of the relevant in the context of the rules. true position falling. Data resolution. A number of units or digits to which a 5. ‘resolution’ means a number of units or digits to ‘Resolution (of data)’ means a number of units or measured or calculated value is expressed and used. which a measured or calculated value is expressed digits to which a measured or calculated value is and used; expressed and used; Data integrity (assurance level). A degree of assurance 6. ‘integrity’ means a degree of assurance that a ‘Data integrity’ means a degree of assurance that a that aeronautical data and its value has not been lost or data item and its value have not been lost or data item and its value have not been lost or altered altered since the data origination or authorized altered since the data origination or authorised since the data origination or authorised amendment; amendment. amendment; Obstacle. All fixed (whether temporary or permanent) and 8. ‘obstacle data’ means data concerning all fixed Not transposed. mobile objects, or parts thereof, that: (whether temporary or permanent) and mobile a) are located on an area intended for the surface objects, or parts thereof, that are located on an This term is already defined in point 75 of Annex I of movement of aircraft; or area intended for the surface movement of aircraft Regulation (EU) …/. or that extend above a defined surface intended to b) extend above a defined surface intended to protect protect aircraft in flight or that stand outside those aircraft in flight; or defined surfaces and that have been assessed as c) stand outside those defined surfaces and that have being a hazard to air navigation;" been assessed as being a hazard to air navigation. Terrain. The surface of the Earth containing naturally 9. ‘terrain data’ means data about the surface of Not transposed. occurring features such as mountains, hills, ridges, valleys, the earth containing naturally occurring features This term is already defined in point 102 of Annex I of bodies of water, permanent ice and snow, and excluding such as mountains, hills, ridges, valleys, bodies of Regulation (EU) …/.. obstacles. water, permanent ice and snow, and excluding obstacles; Note.— In practical terms, depending on the method of data collection used, terrain represents the continuous European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA surface that exists at the bare Earth, the top of the canopy or something in-between, also known as “first reflective surface”. --- 11. ‘survey data’ means geospatial data that is Not transposed. determined by measurement or survey; The term is not used in the rules --- 12. ‘procedure design’ means the combination of Not transposed. aeronautical data with specific flight instructions to define instrument arrival and/or departure The term used in the rules is ‘instrument flight procedures that ensure adequate standards of flight procedure design’. It will be defined under the scope safety; of the airspace design rules. --- 13. ‘aeronautical information service provider’ ‘Aeronautical information service provider’ means an means the organisation responsible for the organisation responsible for the provision of an provision of an aeronautical information service, aeronautical information service; certified in accordance with Commission Implementing Regulation No 1035/2011"; --- 14. ‘next intended user’ means the entity that ‘Next intended user’ means the entity that receives receives the aeronautical information from the the aeronautical information from the aeronautical aeronautical information service provider; information service provider; --- 15. ‘direct electronic connection’ means a digital Not transposed. connection between computer systems such that data may be transferred between them without Explanation is given in GM1 AIS.OR.210(b) Exchange of manual interaction; aeronautical data and information. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA --- 16. ‘data item’ means a single attribute of a Not transposed. complete data set, which is allocated a value that defines its current status; This term is not used in the rules. NOTAM. A notice distributed by means of 17. ‘NOTAM’ means a notice distributed by means Not transposed. telecommunication containing information concerning of telecommunication containing information the establishment, condition or change in any concerning the establishment, condition or change This term is already defined in point 74 of Annex I of aeronautical facility, service, procedure or hazard, the in any aeronautical facility, service, procedure or Regulation (EU) …/.. timely knowledge of which is essential to personnel hazard, the timely knowledge of which is essential concerned with flight operations. to personnel concerned with flight operations; --- 18. ‘digital NOTAM’ means a data set that contains Not transposed. the information included in a NOTAM in a structured format which can be fully interpreted by This term is not used in the rules. an automated computer system without human interpretation; --- 19. ‘data originator’ means an entity responsible for Not transposed. data origination; This term is not used in the rules. --- 20. ‘data origination’ means the creation of a new ‘Data origination’ means the creation of a new data data item with its associated value, the modification item with its associated value, the modification of the of the value of an existing data item or the deletion value of an existing data item or the deletion of an of an existing data item; existing data item; 21. ‘period of validity’ means the period between --- Not transposed. the date and time on which aeronautical information is published and the date and time on It is considered to be self-explanatory. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA which the information ceases to be effective; 22. ‘data validation’ means the process of ensuring --- ‘Validation’ means the process of ensuring that data that data meets the requirements for the specified meets the requirements for the specified application application or intended use; or intended use; --- 23. ‘data verification’ means the evaluation of the ‘Verification’ means the evaluation of the output of an output of an aeronautical data process to ensure aeronautical data process to ensure correctness and correctness and consistency with respect to the consistency with respect to the inputs and applicable inputs and applicable data standards, rules and data standards, rules and conventions used in that conventions used in that process; process; --- 24. ‘critical data’ means data as classified under Not transposed. point (c) of the integrity classification defined in Chapter 1, Section 1.1 of Annex 15 to the Chicago The classification of critical data is included in the Convention on International Civil Aviation rules. (hereinafter the Chicago Convention);’ --- 25. ‘essential data’ means data as classified under Not transposed. point (b) of the integrity classification defined in The classification of essential data is included in the Chapter 1, Section 1.1 of Annex 15 to the Chicago rules. Convention;’ Datum. Any quantity or set of quantities that may serve as --- ‘Datum’ means any quantity or set of quantities that a reference or basis for the calculation of other quantities may serve as a reference or basis for the calculation of (ISO 19104*). other quantities; Digital Elevation Model (DEM). The representation of --- Not transposed. terrain surface by continuous elevation values at all European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA intersections of a defined grid, referenced to common This term is not used in the rules. datum. Note.— Digital Terrain Model (DTM) is sometimes referred to as DEM. Direct transit arrangements. Special arrangements --- Not transposed. approved by the public authorities concerned by which This term is not used in the rules. traffic which is pausing briefly in its passage through the Contracting State may remain under their direct control. Ellipsoidal height (Geodetic height). The height related to --- Transposed and included in the related GM to the the reference ellipsoid, measured along the ellipsoidal rule. Ellipsoidal height (Geodetic height) is understood outer normal through the point in question. as being the height related to the reference ellipsoid, measured along the ellipsoidal outer normal through the point in question. Feature. Abstraction of real world phenomena (ISO --- ’Feature’ means abstraction of real world phenomena 19101*). Feature attribute. Characteristic of a feature (ISO 19101*). --- ‘Feature attribute’ means the characteristic of a feature having a name, a data type and a value Note.— A feature attribute has a name, a data type and a domain associated with it; value domain associated with it. Feature operation. Operation that every instance of a --- Not transposed. feature type may perform (ISO 19110*). It is not considered necessary to define this term. Note.— An operation upon the feature type dam is to European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA raise the dam. The result of this operation is to raise the level of water in the reservoir. Feature relationship. Relationship that links instances of --- Not transposed. one feature type with instances of the same or a different This term is not used in the rules. feature type (ISO 19101*). Feature type. Class of real world phenomena with --- ‘Feature type’ means a class of real world phenomena common properties (ISO 19110*). with common properties, forming the basic level of classification in a feature catalogue; Note.— In a feature catalogue, the basic level of classification is the feature type. Geodesic distance. The shortest distance between any --- Not transposed. two points on a mathematically defined ellipsoidal This term is not used in the rules. surface. Geodetic datum. A minimum set of parameters required --- Not transposed. to define location and orientation of the local reference This term is not used in the rules. system with respect to the global reference system/frame. Geoid. The equipotential surface in the gravity field of the --- ‘Geoid’ means the equipotential surface in the gravity Earth which coincides with the undisturbed mean sea field of the Earth which coincides with the level (MSL) extended continuously through the undisturbed mean sea level (MSL) extended continents. continuously through the continents. Note.— The geoid is irregular in shape because of local This term is used in AMC/GM for the vertical gravitational disturbances (wind tides, salinity, current, reference and will be included in the definition for the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA etc.) and the direction of gravity is perpendicular to the ED Decision. geoid at every point. The Note is not considered relevant to be transposed with the definition. Geoid undulation. The distance of the geoid above --- This term is used in AMC/GM for the vertical (positive) or below (negative) the mathematical reference reference and will be included in the definition for the ellipsoid. ED Decision. Note.— In respect to the World Geodetic System — 1984 ‘Geoid undulation’ means the distance of the geoid (WGS-84) defined ellipsoid, the difference between the above (positive) or below (negative) the mathematical WGS-84 ellipsoidal height and orthometric height reference ellipsoid. represents WGS-84 geoid undulation. The Note is not considered relevant to be transposed with the definition. Gregorian calendar. Calendar in general use; first --- Not transposed. introduced in 1582 to define a year that more closely This term is explained in the ISO reference in GM1 approximates the tropical year than the Julian calendar ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(c). (ISO 19108*). Note.— In the Gregorian calendar, common years have 365 days and leap years 366 days divided into twelve sequential months. Height. The vertical distance of a level, point or an object --- Not transposed. considered as a point, measured from a specific datum. This term is already defined in point 63 of Annex I of Regulation (EU) …/.. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Heliport. An aerodrome or a defined area on a structure --- ‘Heliport’ means an aerodrome or a defined area on a intended to be used wholly or in part for the arrival, structure intended to be used wholly or in part for the departure and surface movement of helicopters. arrival, departure and surface movement of helicopters; Human Factors principles. Principles which apply to --- Not transposed. aeronautical design, certification, training, operations and This term is not used in the rules. maintenance and which seek safe interface between the human and other system components by proper consideration to human performance. Integrity classification (aeronautical data). Classification --- ‘Integrity classification (aeronautical data)’ means a based upon the potential risk resulting from the use of classification based upon the potential risk resulting corrupted data. Aeronautical data are classified as: from the use of corrupted data, defining routine, essential and critical data; a) routine data: there is a very low probability when using corrupted routine data that the continued safe flight GM1 to ‘Integrity classification’ and landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk with Aeronautical data are classified as : the potential for catastrophe; a) routine data: there is a very low probability when b) essential data: there is a low probability when using using corrupted routine data that the continued safe corrupted essential data that the continued safe flight and flight and landing of an aircraft would be severely at landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk with the risk with the potential for catastrophe; potential for catastrophe; and b) essential data: there is a low probability when using c) critical data: there is a high probability when using corrupted essential data that the continued safe flight corrupted critical data that the continued safe flight and and landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk with the with the potential for catastrophe; and European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA potential for catastrophe. c) critical data: there is a high probability when using corrupted critical data that the continued safe flight and landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk with the potential for catastrophe. International airport. Any airport designated by the --- Not transposed. Contracting State in whose territory it is situated as an This term is not used in the rules. airport of entry and departure for international air traffic, where the formalities incident to customs, immigration, public health, animal and plant quarantine and similar procedures are carried out. International NOTAM office (NOF). An office designated --- ‘International NOTAM office (NOF)’ means an office by a State for the exchange of NOTAM internationally. designated by a State for the exchange of NOTAM internationally; Logon address. A specified code used for data link logon --- Not transposed. to an ATS unit. Manoeuvring area. That part of an aerodrome to be used --- ‘Manoeuvring area’ means that part of an aerodrome for the take-off, landing and taxiing of aircraft, excluding to be used for the take-off, landing and taxiing of aprons. aircraft, excluding aprons; Metadata. Data about data (ISO 19115*). --- ‘Metadata’ means data about data; Note.— A structured description of the content, quality, condition or other characteristics of data. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Minimum en-route altitude (MEA). The altitude for an en- --- Not transposed. route segment that provides adequate reception of This term is already defined in the data catalogue. relevant navigation facilities and ATS communications, complies with the airspace structure and provides the required obstacle clearance. Minimum obstacle clearance altitude (MOCA). The --- Not transposed. minimum altitude for a defined segment of flight that This term is already defined in the data catalogue and provides the required obstacle clearance. will be covered by ASD task. Movement area. That part of an aerodrome to be used for --- ‘Movement area’ means that part of an aerodrome to the take-off, landing and taxiing of aircraft, consisting of be used for the take-off, landing and taxiing of aircraft, the manoeuvring area and the apron consisting of the manoeuvring area and the apron; Navigation specification. A set of aircraft and flight crew --- Not transposed. requirements needed to support performance-based These terms are already defined in the data catalogue. navigation operations within a defined airspace. There are two kinds of navigation specifications: Required navigation performance (RNP) specification. A navigation specification based on area navigation that includes the requirement for performance monitoring and alerting, designated by the prefix RNP, e.g. RNP 4, RNP APCH. Area navigation (RNAV) specification. A navigation specification based on area navigation that does not include the requirement for performance monitoring and European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA alerting, designated by the prefix RNAV, e.g. RNAV 5, RNAV 1. Note 1.— The Performance-based Navigation (PBN) Manual (Doc 9613), Volume II, contains detailed guidance on navigation specifications. Note 2.— The term RNP, previously defined as “a statement of the navigation performance necessary for operation within a defined airspace”, has been removed from this Annex as the concept of RNP has been overtaken by the concept of PBN. The term RNP in this Annex is now solely used in the context of navigation specifications that require performance monitoring and alerting, e.g. RNP 4 refers to the aircraft and operating requirements, including a 4 NM lateral performance with on-board performance monitoring and alerting that are detailed in Doc 9613. Next intended user. The entity that receives the 14. ‘next intended user’ means the entity that ‘Next intended user’ means the entity that receives aeronautical information from the Aeronautical receives the aeronautical information from the the aeronautical information from the aeronautical Information Service. aeronautical information service provider; information service provider; Obstacle/terrain data collection surface. A defined surface --- ’Data collection surface’ means a defined surface intended for the purpose of collecting obstacle/terrain intended for the purpose of collecting obstacle or data. terrain data; Orthometric height. Height of a point related to the geoid, --- Not transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA generally presented as an MSL elevation. This term is explained through the relevant guidance material for vertical reference with regard to the MSL. Performance-based navigation (PBN). Area navigation --- Not transposed. based on performance requirements for aircraft operating This term is not used in the rules. along an ATS route, on an instrument approach procedure or in a designated airspace. Note.— Performance requirements are expressed in navigation specifications (RNAV specification, RNP specification) in terms of accuracy, integrity, continuity, availability and functionality needed for the proposed operation in the context of a particular airspace concept. Portrayal. Presentation of information to humans (ISO --- Not transposed. 19117*). This term is not used in the rules. Position (geographical). Set of coordinates (latitude and --- ‘Position (geographical)’ means a set of coordinates longitude) referenced to the mathematical reference (latitude and longitude) referenced to the ellipsoid which define the position of a point on the mathematical reference ellipsoid which define the surface of the Earth. position of a point on the surface of the Earth; Post spacing. Angular or linear distance between two --- Not transposed. adjacent elevation points. This term is not used in the rules. Precision. The smallest difference that can be reliably --- Not transposed. distinguished by a measurement process. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Note.— In reference to geodetic surveys, precision is a This term is not used in the rules. degree of refinement in performance of an operation or a degree of perfection in the instruments and methods used when taking measurements. Quality. Degree to which a set of inherent characteristics --- Not transposed. fulfils requirements (ISO 9000*). This term is not used in the rules. Note 1.— The term “quality” can be used with adjectives such as poor, good or excellent. Note 2.— “Inherent”, as opposed to “assigned”, means existing in something, especially as a permanent characteristic. Quality assurance. Part of quality management focused on --- Not transposed. providing confidence that quality requirements will be This term is not used in the rules. fulfilled (ISO 9000*). Quality control. Part of quality management focused on --- Not transposed. fulfilling quality requirements (ISO 9000*) This term is not used in the rules. Quality management. Coordinated activities to direct and --- Not transposed. control an organization with regard to quality (ISO 9000*). This term is not used in the rules. Radio navigation service. A service providing guidance --- Not transposed. information or position data for the efficient and safe This term is not used in the rules. operation of aircraft supported by one or more radio European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA navigation aids. Requirement. Need or expectation that is stated, --- Not transposed. generally implied or obligatory (ISO 9000*). Note 1.— “Generally implied” means that it is custom or common practice for the organization, its customers and other interested parties, that the need or expectation under consideration is implied. Note 2.— A qualifier can be used to denote a specific type of requirement, e.g. product requirement, quality management requirement, customer requirement. Note 3.— A specified requirement is one which is stated, for example, in a document. Note 4.— Requirements can be generated by different interested parties. Route stage. A route or portion of a route flown without --- ‘Route stage’ means a route or portion of a route an intermediate landing. flown without an intermediate landing; SNOWTAM. A special series NOTAM given in a standard --- ‘SNOWTAM’ means a special series NOTAM given in a format providing a surface condition report notifying the standard format providing a surface condition report presence or cessation of hazardous conditions due to notifying the presence or cessation of hazardous snow, ice, slush, frost or water associated with snow, conditions due to snow, ice, slush, frost or water slush, ice, or frost on the movement area. associated with snow, slush, ice, or frost on the movement area; [from Amdt 39] Station declination. An alignment variation between the --- Not transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA zero degree radial of a VOR and true north, determined at the time the VOR station is calibrated. Traceability . Ability to trace the history, application or --- ‘Traceability (of data)’ means the degree that a system location of that which is under consideration (ISO 9000*). or a data product can provide a record of the changes made to that product and thereby enable an audit Note.— When considering product, traceability can relate trail to be followed from the end-user to the data to: originator; — the origin of materials and parts; — the processing history; and — the distribution and location of the product after delivery. Validation. Confirmation, through the provision of --- Not transposed. objective evidence, that the requirements for a specific (see above data validation) intended use or application have been fulfilled (ISO 9000*). Verification. Confirmation, through the provision of --- Not transposed. objective evidence, that specified requirements have (see above data verification) been fulfilled (ISO 9000*). Note 1.— The term “verified” is used to designate the corresponding status. Note 2.— Confirmation can comprise activities such as: European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Draft ICAO Annex 15 Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 NPA — performing alternative calculations; — comparing a new design specification with a similar proven design specification; — undertaking tests and demonstrations; and — reviewing documents prior to issue. VOLMET. Meteorological information for aircraft in flight. --- Not transposed. This term is not used in the rules. Data link-VOLMET (D-VOLMET). Provision of current --- Not transposed. aerodrome routine meteorological reports (METAR) and This term is not used in the rules. aerodrome special meteorological reports (SPECI), aerodrome forecasts (TAF), SIGMET, special air-reports not covered by a SIGMET and, where available, AIRMET via data link. VOLMET broadcast. Provision, as appropriate, of current --- Not transposed. METAR, SPECI, TAF and SIGMET by means of continuous This term is not used in the rules. and repetitive voice broadcasts. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Table 2 - Rule comparison between the provisions of Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 and the NPA text. COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No XX/20XX of… The term ‘transposed’ means that the substance of of 26 January 2010 the provisions of Regulation 73/2010 is not changed, ANNEX VI laying down requirements on the quality of although, in some cases, some editorial revisions may aeronautical data and aeronautical information for the SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PROVISION OF have been applied. single European sky AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES (Part-AIS) NOTE 1: When reference is made to Regulation ../…, it refers to the recently adopted Regulation laying down technical requirements and administrative procedures related to service providers and the oversight thereof, still to be published in the EUOJ. NOTE 2: The NPA text sometimes refers to various rule references because the same provisions have been transposed for AIS providers or for service providers or for aviation undertakings. The references are identified in bold character. CHAPTER I --- --- GENERAL PROVISIONS Article 1 --- --- Subject matter This Regulation lays down the requirements on the --- Not transposed since it is the overall subject of the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information draft rules based on the Essential Requirements of European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification in terms of accuracy, resolution and integrity. Reg. 216/2008 (EASA Basic Regulation). Article 2 --- --- Scope 1. This Regulation shall apply to European air traffic Not transposed. management network (EATMN) systems, their constituents and associated procedures involved in the The overall objectives of this paragraph are origination, production, storage, handling, processing, implemented through the NPA. transfer and distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. It shall apply to the following aeronautical data and aeronautical information: (a) the integrated aeronautical information package as defined in Article 3(7) made available by Member States, with the exception of aeronautical information circulars; (b) electronic obstacle data, or elements thereof, where made available by Member States; (c) electronic terrain data, or elements thereof, where made available by Member States; (d) aerodrome mapping data, where made available by Member States. 2. This Regulation shall apply to the following parties: --- Not transposed as such. (a) air navigation service providers; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification (b) operators of those aerodromes and heliports, for This NPA applies to: which instrument flight rules (IFR) or Special-visual flight • AIS providers (Part-AIS), rules (VFR) procedures have been published in national aeronautical information publications; • service providers (Part-ATM/ANS.OR.A) (c) public or private entities providing, for the purposes • aviation undertakings (data originators) of this Regulation: • aerodrome operators. (i) services for the origination and provision of survey The overall objectives of this paragraph are data; implemented through the NPA. (ii) procedure design services; (iii) electronic terrain data; (iv) electronic obstacle data. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 3. This Regulation shall apply up to the moment when --- Not transposed as such. the aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information are made available by the aeronautical information The overall objectives of this paragraph is service provider to the next intended user. implemented through the NPA. In the case of distribution by physical means, this Regulation shall apply up to the moment when the aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information has been made available to the organisation responsible for providing the physical distribution service. In the case of automatic distribution through the use of a direct electronic connection between the aeronautical information service provider and the entity receiving the aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information, this Regulation shall apply: (a) up to the moment when the next intended user accesses and extracts aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information held by the aeronautical information service provider; or (b) up to the moment when the aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information is delivered by the aeronautical information service provider, into the next intended user’s system. Article 3 --- Please see the comparison table for the definitions, in Definitions this NPA. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification For the purpose of this Regulation, the definitions in --- --- Article 2 of Regulation (EC) No 549/2004 shall apply. The following definitions shall also apply: 1. ‘aeronautical data’ means a representation of ’Aeronautical data’ means a representation of aeronautical facts, concepts or instructions in a aeronautical facts, concepts or instructions in a formalised manner suitable for communication, formalized manner suitable for communication, interpretation or processing; interpretation or processing; 2. ‘aeronautical information’ means information --- Already in definition 75 of Annex I of Regulation ../… resulting from the assembly, analysis and formatting of aeronautical data; 3. ‘data quality’ means a degree or level of confidence --- Already in definition 41 of Annex I of Regulation ../… that the data provided meets the requirements of the data user in terms of accuracy, resolution and integrity; 4. ‘accuracy’ means a degree of conformance between ‘Data accuracy’ means a degree of conformance Transposed. the estimated or measured value and the true value; between the estimated or measured value and the true value; 5. ‘resolution’ means a number of units or digits to which ‘Resolution (of data)’ means a number of units or Transposed. a measured or calculated value is expressed and used; digits to which a measured or calculated value is expressed and used; 6. ‘integrity’ means a degree of assurance that a data ‘Data integrity’ means a degree of assurance that a Transposed. item and its value have not been lost or altered since the data item and its value have not been lost or altered European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification data origination or authorised amendment; since the data origination or authorised amendment; 7. ‘integrated aeronautical information package’ Aeronautical Information Product. Aeronautical data Not transposed. (hereinafter IAIP) means a package which consists of the and aeronautical information provided either as following elements: The concept of ‘integrated aeronautical information digital data sets or as a standardized presentation in package’ is replaced by ‘aeronautical information (a) aeronautical information publications (hereinafter paper or electronic media. Aeronautical Information product’ as per the upcoming amendment to ICAO AIP), including amendments; Products include: Annex 15. (b) supplements to the AIP; — Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP), (c) the NOTAM, as defined in point 17 and pre-flight including Amendments and Supplements information bulletins; — Aeronautical Information Circulars (AIC) (d) aeronautical information circulars; and — Aeronautical charts (e) checklists and lists of valid NOTAMs; — NOTAM — Digital data sets 8. “obstacle data” means data concerning all fixed --- Already in definition 75 of Annex I of Regulation ../… (whether temporary or permanent) and mobile objects, or parts thereof, that are located on an area intended for the surface movement of aircraft or that extend above a defined surface intended to protect aircraft in flight or that stand outside those defined surfaces and that have been assessed as being a hazard to air navigation;’ 9. ‘terrain data’ means data about the surface of the --- Already in definition 75 of Annex I of Regulation ../… earth containing naturally occurring features such as mountains, hills, ridges, valleys, bodies of water, European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification permanent ice and snow, and excluding obstacles; 10. “aerodrome mapping data” means data collected for --- Already in definition 14 of Annex I of Regulation ../… the purpose of compiling aerodrome mapping information’; 11. ‘survey data’ means geospatial data that is Not transposed. determined by measurement or survey; The term is not used in the rules 12. ‘procedure design’ means the combination of --- Not transposed. aeronautical data with specific flight instructions to define instrument arrival and/or departure procedures This term will be defined in the context of the NPA on that ensure adequate standards of flight safety; airspace design requirements. 13. “aeronautical information service provider” means ‘Aeronautical information service provider’ means Transposed. the organisation responsible for the provision of an an organisation responsible for the provision of an aeronautical information service, certified in accordance aeronautical information service; with the requirements of Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 1035/2011;’ 14. ‘next intended user’ means the entity that receives ‘Next intended user’ means the entity that receives Transposed. the aeronautical information from the aeronautical the aeronautical information from the aeronautical information service provider; information service provider; 15. ‘direct electronic connection’ means a digital --- Not transposed. connection between computer systems such that data may be transferred between them without manual Explanation is given in GM1 AIS.OR.210(b) Exchange interaction; of aeronautical data and information. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 16. ‘data item’ means a single attribute of a complete --- Not transposed. data set, which is allocated a value that defines its current status; This term is not used in the rules. 17. ‘NOTAM’ means a notice distributed by means of --- Already in definition 74 of Annex I of Regulation ../… telecommunication containing information concerning the establishment, condition or change in any aeronautical facility, service, procedure or hazard, the timely knowledge of which is essential to personnel concerned with flight operations; 18. ‘digital NOTAM’ means a data set that contains the --- Not transposed. information included in a NOTAM in a structured format which can be fully interpreted by an automated This term is not used in the rules. computer system without human interpretation; 19. ‘data originator’ means an entity responsible for data --- Not transposed. origination; This term is not used in the rules. 20. ‘data origination’ means the creation of a new data ‘Data origination’ means the creation of a new data Transposed. item with its associated value, the modification of the item with its associated value, the modification of value of an existing data item or the deletion of an the value of an existing data item or the deletion of existing data item; an existing data item; 21. ‘period of validity’ means the period between the --- Not transposed. date and time on which aeronautical information is published and the date and time on which the It is considered to be self-explanatory. information ceases to be effective; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 22. ‘data validation’ means the process of ensuring that ‘Validation’ means the process of ensuring that data data meets the requirements for the specified meets the requirements for the specified application application or intended use; or intended use; 23. ‘data verification’ means the evaluation of the output ‘Verification’ means the evaluation of the output of Transposed. of an aeronautical data process to ensure correctness an aeronautical data process to ensure correctness and consistency with respect to the inputs and applicable and consistency with respect to the inputs and data standards, rules and conventions used in that applicable data standards, rules and conventions process; used in that process; 24. “critical data” means data as classified under point (c) Not transposed. of the integrity classification defined in Chapter 1, Section 1.1 of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention on The classification of critical data is included in the International Civil Aviation (hereinafter the Chicago rules. Convention); 25. “essential data” means data as classified under point Not transposed. (b) of the integrity classification defined in Chapter 1, The classification of essential data is included in the Section 1.1 of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention;’ rules. CHAPTER II --- --- INTEROPERABILITY AND PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS Article 4 AIS.OR.200 General Article 4 of Regulation 73/2010 introduces the Data set requirements that are described in Annex I. Please An aeronautical information services provider shall European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall provide ensure that: see under Annex I (below) of this table. aeronautical data and aeronautical information in (a) aeronautical data and aeronautical In this NPA, the data set specifications are contained accordance with the data set specifications described in in the data catalogue which is in Appendix 1 to Annex information are provided in accordance with Annex I. III of Regulation ../.. the specifications laid down in the data catalogue, as specified in Appendix 1 to Annex The similar reference to the data catalogue is made III to Regulation EU …/…, and the applicable for the origination requirements in Appendix 1 to Article 3 of Regulation ../.. data quality requirements, as specified in ATS.TR.200; and (b) data quality requirements are maintained from reception through to distribution to the next intended user. Appendix 1 to Article 3 4. DATA CATALOGUE Aeronautical data shall be originated in accordance with the data catalogue specified in Appendix 1 to Subpart A of Annex III. Article 5 --- --- Data exchange 1. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that AIS.OR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data An Transposed. the aeronautical data and aeronautical information aeronautical information services provider shall referred to in the second subparagraph of Article 2(1) are Article 5.1 of Reg. 73/2010 is transposed for AIS European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification transferred between themselves by direct electronic ensure that: providers, service providers and for those who connection. originate data. (b) aeronautical data is exchanged through electronic means. The NPA text proposes not to limit the exchange of aeronautical data to ‘direct connection’. The proposal ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aims at allowing flexibility in terms of operational aeronautical information implementation. […] service providers shall: (c) exchange aeronautical data through electronic means. Appendix 1 to Article 3 9. DATA EXCHANGE Aeronautical data shall be exchanged through electronic means. 2. Air navigation service providers shall ensure that the AIS.OR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and Transposed. aeronautical data and aeronautical information referred aeronautical information to in the second subparagraph of Article 2(1) are Please see under Annex II of Regulation 73/2010 in transferred between themselves in accordance with the An aeronautical information services provider shall this table for the format requirements. data exchange format requirements laid down in Annex ensure that: II. (a) the format of aeronautical data is based on an aeronautical information exchange model designed to be globally interoperable. 3. Member States may exclude digital NOTAM from the --- Not transposed. Digital NOTAM is not explicitly data exchange format referred to in paragraph 2. required as standard in the context of ICAO Annex 15. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 4. Aeronautical information service providers shall NOTE: Transposed. ensure that all aeronautical data and aeronautical information within the AIPs, AIP amendments and AIP No NPA text is reproduced here because the Please see the comparison table ‘ICAO Annex 15 rules supplements provided by a Member State are made transposed provisions are spread out in different and EASA rules’ and refer to AIS.OR.305, AIS.OR.310 available to the next intended user, as a minimum: requirements of the rules. The NPA text covers the and AIS.OR.315 and AIS.TR.305, AIS.TR.310, relevant requirements of ICAO Annex 15 in chapter 4 AIS.TR.315. (a) in accordance with the publication requirements and chapter 6 paragraph 6. identified in the ICAO standards referred to in points 4 and 8 of Annex III; (b) in a way that allows the content and format of the documents to be directly readable on a computer screen; and (c) in accordance with the data exchange format --- This article introduces the requirements that are requirements laid down in Annex II. described in Annex II. Please see under Annex II (below) of this table. Article 6 --- --- Data quality 1. Member States shall ensure that air navigation service --- This article introduces the requirements that are providers comply with the data quality requirements laid described in Annex IV, Part A. Please see under Annex down in Annex IV, Part A. IV, Part A (below) of this table. 2. When providing aeronautical data and/or aeronautical --- This article introduces the requirements that are information, the parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall described in Annex IV, Part B. Please see under Annex European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification comply with the evidence requirements laid down in IV, Part B (below) of this table. Annex IV, Part B. 3. When exchanging aeronautical data and/or AIS.OR.205 Formal arrangements Transposed. The NPA text covers the formal aeronautical information between themselves, the arrangements between service providers, between An aeronautical information services provider shall parties referred to in Article 2(2), shall establish formal AIS providers and between aviation undertakings and ensure that formal arrangements are established: arrangements in accordance with the requirements laid organisation requesting the data. down in Annex IV, Part C. (b) between themselves when exchanging The text of Annex IV, Part C of Regulation 73/2010 is aeronautical information and data. now contained at AMC level for both AIS.OR.205 and ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(d) Formal arrangements ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(d) and reproduced with no […] service providers service providers shall: changes, please see below in Annex IV, Part C. (d) establish formal arrangements between For Appendix 1 for aviation undertakings themselves when exchanging aeronautical data and requirements, the content of Annex IV, Part C of aeronautical information; Regulation 73/2010 is reduced to fit origination. APPENDIX 1 to Article 3 3. FORMAL ARRANGEMENTS (a) Organisations originating data shall establish formal arrangements with: (1) parties requesting the data and, when different, (2) those to which the data are delivered. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 4. When acting as data originators, the parties referred ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and Transposed. to in Article 2(2), shall comply with the data origination aeronautical information requirements laid down in Annex IV, Part D. ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 is meant to cover all service (a) When originating, processing or transmitting providers involved in the origination of data. aeronautical data to the aeronautical information The Appendix 1 to Article 3 on the requirements for services provider, service providers shall […] aviation undertakings contains the data origination APPENDIX 1 to Article 3 requirements. [this Appendix covers the data origination This article 6.4 introduces the requirements that are requirements for aviation undertakings] described in Annex IV, Part A. Please see under Annex IV, Part A (below) of this table. 5. Aeronautical information service providers shall AIS.OR.200 General Transposed. ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information provided by data originators not referred to An aeronautical information services provider shall This NPA does not limit the data originators to those in Article 2(2) are made available to the next intended ensure that: referred to in Reg. 73/2010. The concept of aviation user with sufficient quality to meet the intended use. undertakings is broader. The aviation undertakings (a) aeronautical data and aeronautical information are requested to comply with the requirements are provided in accordance with the specifications applicable to them in Appendix 1 to Article 3 of laid down in the data catalogue, as specified in regulation (EU) No ../.. Appendix 1 to Annex III to Regulation EU…/…, and the applicable data quality requirements, as specified in ATS.TR.200; and (b) data quality requirements are maintained from reception through to distribution to the next intended user. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and 6. When acting as the entity responsible for the official Transposed. request for a data origination activity, the parties aeronautical information referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that: […] service providers shall: (g) when requesting a (a) the data are created, modified or deleted in data origination activity, ensure, through formal compliance with their instructions; arrangements, that: (1) the data are created, modified or deleted in compliance with their instructions; (b) without prejudice to Annex IV, Part C, their data ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(g) Aeronautical data and Transposed. origination instructions contain, as a minimum: aeronautical information (i) an unambiguous description of the data that are to be (2) their instructions contain, as a minimum: created, modified or deleted; (ii) confirmation of the entity to which the data are to be (i) an unambiguous description of the data that are provided; to be created, modified or deleted; (iii) the date and time by which the data are to be (ii) confirmation of the entity to which the data are provided; to be provided; (iv) the data origination report format to be used by the (iii) the date and time by which the data are to be data originator. provided; (iv) the data origination report format to be used (V) the requirement to identify any limitation on the use of the data. 7. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall comply with --- This article introduces the requirements that are the data process requirements laid down in Annex IV, European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Part E. described in Annex IV, Part E. Please see under Annex IV, Part E (below) of this table. 8. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that AIS.OR.235 Error reporting and corrective actions Transposed. error reporting, feedback and rectification mechanisms An aeronautical information services provider shall This article introduces the requirements that are are established and operated in accordance with the ensure that error reporting, measurement and described in Annex IV, Part F. Please see under Annex requirements laid down in Annex IV, Part F. corrective mechanisms are established and IV, Part F (below) of this table. maintained. Article 7 --- --- Consistency, timeliness and personnel performance 1. Where aeronautical data or aeronautical information AIS.OR.250 Consistency Transposed. is duplicated in the AIP of more than one Member State, the aeronautical information service providers Where aeronautical data or aeronautical information responsible for those AIPs shall establish mechanisms to is duplicated in the AIP of more than one Member ensure consistency between the duplicated information. State, the aeronautical information service providers responsible for those AIPs shall establish mechanisms to ensure consistency between the duplicated information. 2. Aeronautical information service providers shall AIS.OR.240 Data limitations Transposed. ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information items published in the AIP of their Member An aeronautical information service provider shall State are annotated to indicate those that do not meet identify the aeronautical data and aeronautical the data quality requirements laid down in this information that do not meet the data quality Regulation. requirements. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification AIS.TR.240 Data limitations The identification of data not meeting the data quality requirements shall be made with an annotation or by explicitly providing the quality value. 3. Aeronautical information service providers shall AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. ensure that the most current update cycles applicable to AIP amendments and AIP supplements are made publicly (b) The most current update cycles applicable to AIP available. Supplements shall be made publicly available. AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments (d) The most current update cycles applicable to AIP Amendments shall be made publicly available 4. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that AIS.OR.600 General requirements The NPA text proposes a proportionate approach their personnel responsible for tasks in the provision of related to personnel training requirements for AIS aeronautical data or aeronautical information are made An aeronautical information services provider shall personnel and for data originators. aware of and apply: ensure that personnel responsible for tasks in the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical (a) the requirements for AIP amendments, AIP information is: The change is made to reflect the changes introduced supplements and NOTAM laid down in the ICAO at ICAO level and therefore to be more exhaustive standards referred to in points 5, 6 and 7 of Annex III; (a) made aware of and apply: than AIPs and NOTAM. (1) the requirements for aeronautical products and (b) the update cycles applicable to the issue of AIP services; Transposed. amendments and supplements referred to in point (a) of this paragraph for the areas for which they are providing (2) the update cycles applicable to the issue of AIP European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification aeronautical data or aeronautical information. amendments and supplements for the areas for which they are providing aeronautical data or 5. Without prejudice to Implementing Regulation (EU) No aeronautical information. Transposed. 1035/2011, the parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that their personnel responsible for tasks in the (b) adequately trained, competent and authorised provision of aeronautical data or aeronautical for the job they are required to do. information are adequately trained, competent and Appendix 1 to Article 3 authorised for the job they are required to do. 11 PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS Personnel responsible for originating aeronautical data or aeronautical information shall be adequately trained, competent and authorised for the job they are required to do. Article 8 --- --- Tools and software requirements The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that all ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Tools and software Transposed for all service providers. tools and software used to support the origination, […] service providers shall: This article introduces the requirements that are production, storage, handling, processing and transfer of described in Annex V. Please see under Annex V aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information (f) ensure that all tools and software used to support (below) comply with the requirements laid down in Annex V. or automate aeronautical data and aeronautical information processes perform their functions without adversely impacting on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. Article 9 --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Data protection 1. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that --- This article introduces the requirements that are aeronautical data and aeronautical information are described in Annex VI. Please see under Annex VI protected in accordance with the requirements laid (below) down in Annex VI. 2. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that AIS.TR.200 General The requirement on traceability is covered by traceability is maintained on each data item during its (d) Traceability of aeronautical data shall be ensured ATM/ANS.OR.B.030 Record keeping period of validity and for at least 5 years following the and retained. end of that period or until 5 years after the end of the (b) the format and the retention period of the period of validity for any data item calculated or derived records shall be specified in the service provider’s from it, whichever is later. management system procedures. CHAPTER III --- --- QUALITY, SAFETY AND SECURITY MANAGEMENT REQUIREMENTS Article 10 --- --- Management requirements 1. Without prejudice to Implementing Regulation (EU) No --- Not transposed. 1035/2011, the parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall implement and maintain a quality management system The quality management requirements are covered covering their aeronautical data and aeronautical by ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. information provision activities, in accordance with the requirements laid down in Annex VII, Part A. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 2. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that --- Not transposed. the quality management system referred to in paragraph 1 of this Article defines procedures to meet the safety The safety management objectives are not considered management objectives laid down in Annex VII, Part B as being safety requirement as such but overall and the security management objectives laid down in objectives that are either statements or more specific Annex VII, Part C. requirements already covered throughout Regulation (EU) ../.. The security management requirements are covered under ATM/ANS.OR.D.010 of Regulation (EU) ../.. 3. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall ensure that --- Not transposed. any changes to the existing systems referred to in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) or the introduction of The safety assessment requirements are covered new systems are preceded by a safety assessment, under ATM/ANS.OR.A.045 changes to a functional including hazard identification, risk assessment and system and ATM/ANS.OR.C.055 Safety support mitigation, conducted by the parties concerned. assessment and assurance of changes to the functional system of Regulation (EU) ../... 4. During that safety assessment, the requirements --- The safety assessment requirements are covered referred to in Article 7(3), Annex I, Annex II and points 1 under ATM/ANS.OR.A.045 changes to a functional and 2 of Part A of Annex IV shall be considered as safety system and ATM/ANS.OR.C.055 Safety support requirements and shall be taken into consideration, as a assessment and assurance of changes to the minimum. functional system of Regulation (EU) ../.. CHAPTER IV --- --- CONFORMITY ASSESSMENT AND ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Article 11 --- Not transposed. Conformity or suitability for use of constituents The NPA does not cover the requirements on Before issuing EC declarations of conformity or suitability manufacturers but only on service providers. for use as referred to in Article 5 of Regulation (EC) No It is considered that the requirements on systems or 552/2004, manufacturers of constituents of the systems constituents used in the framework of EATMN are referred to in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) of this sufficiently covered by Regulation (EC) No 552/2004 Regulation, or their authorised representatives on interoperability. established in the Union, shall assess the conformity or suitability for use of those constituents in compliance with the requirements laid down in Annex VIII. Article 12 --- --- Verification of systems 1. Air navigation service providers which can --- Not transposed. demonstrate or have demonstrated that they fulfil the conditions laid down in Annex IX shall conduct a The procedures for the EC declarations of verification verification of the systems referred to in the first of systems are considered as being sufficiently subparagraph of Article 2(1) in accordance with the covered by Article 6 and related Annex IV of requirements laid down in Annex X, Part A. Regulation (EC) No 552/2004. 2. Air navigation service providers which cannot --- The procedures for the EC declarations of verification demonstrate that they fulfil the conditions laid down in of systems are considered as being sufficiently Annex IX shall subcontract to a notified body a covered by Article 6 and related Annex IV of verification of the systems referred to in the first Regulation (EC) No 552/2004, and also in the case of subparagraph of Article 2(1). That verification shall be the intervention of notified bodies in article 8 of said European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification conducted in accordance with the requirements laid regulation. down in Annex X, Part B. Article 13 --- --- Additional requirements The parties referred to in Article 2(2)(b) and (c) shall: --- --- (a) ensure the security clearance of their personnel --- Not transposed. responsible for tasks in the origination, production, storage, handling, processing, transfer and distribution of For service providers, the security clearance aeronautical data or aeronautical information, as requirements are already covered by appropriate; ATM/ANS.OR.D.010(c). For aviation undertakings it is considered that these requirements are not proportionate. (b) ensure that their personnel responsible for tasks in --- Not transposed. the provision of aeronautical data or aeronautical information are made duly aware of the requirements This paragraph is covered by AIS.OR.600 General laid down in this Regulation; requirements for personnel. (c) develop and maintain operations manuals containing --- Not transposed. For service providers, such the necessary instructions and information to enable requirements are already covered by their personnel responsible for tasks in the provision of ATM/ANS.OR.B.035. For aviation undertakings it is aeronautical data or aeronautical information to apply considered that these requirements are not this Regulation; proportionate. (d) ensure that the manuals referred to in point (c) are --- Not transposed. For service providers, such European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification accessible and kept up to date and that their update and requirements are already covered by distribution are subject to appropriate quality and ATM/ANS.OR.B.035(a). For aviation undertakings it is documentation configuration management; considered that these requirements are not proportionate. (e) ensure that their working methods and operating --- Not transposed. procedures comply with this Regulation. Self-evident objectives. CHAPTER V --- This chapter V is specific to Regulation (EU) No FINAL PROVISIONS 73/2010. Such provisions will be discussed at the appropriate stage of the EASA Opinion. Article 14 --- --- Transitional provisions 1. Member States which, prior to the entry into force of --- This paragraph is applicable for Regulation (EU) No this Regulation, have notified a relevant difference to 73/2010 only. ICAO in accordance with Article 38 of the Chicago Convention, may maintain their national provisions on the subjects listed in Annex XI to this Regulation until 30 June 2014 at the latest. 2. Aeronautical data and aeronautical information --- This paragraph is applicable for Regulation (EU) No published before 1 July 2013 and not amended shall be 73/2010 only. brought in line with this Regulation by 30 June 2017 at European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification the latest. Article 15 --- --- Entry into force and application 1. This Regulation shall enter into force on the 20th day --- This paragraph is applicable for Regulation (EU) No following its publication in the Official Journal of the 73/2010 only. European Union. It shall apply from 1 July 2013. --- This paragraph is applicable for Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 only. 2. By way of derogation from the second subparagraph --- This paragraph is applicable for Regulation (EU) No of paragraph 1, Article 4, Article 5(1), Article 5(2), Article 73/2010 only. 5(3) and Article 5(4)(c) shall apply from 1 July 2014. This Regulation shall be binding in its entirety and --- This paragraph is applicable for Regulation (EU) No directly applicable in all Member States. 73/2010 only. Done at Brussels, 26 January 2010. --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification ANNEX I The NPA text introduces the data catalogue, which --- partially covers the data set specifications foreseen in DATA SET SPECIFICATIONS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 4 Article 4 of Regulation 73/2010. PART A --- --- IAIP, aerodrome mapping and electronic obstacle data 1. The aeronautical data and aeronautical information AIS.OR.200 General Transposed. referred to in points (a), (b) and (d) of the second subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall be provided An aeronautical information services provider shall The ICAO data catalogue is entirely transposed from according to a common data set specification which ensure that: ICAO. The data set specifications are identified shall: throughout the rules in Part-AIS. (a) aeronautical data and aeronautical information (a) be documented either: are provided in accordance with the The data catalogue covers: — by using the unified modelling language (UML), specifications laid down in the data catalogue, as specified in the document referred to in point 13 — definition of aeronautical features specified in Appendix 1 to Annex III to of Annex III, in the form of class diagrams and Regulation EU …/…, and the applicable data — the values of each attributes and the definition of associated definitions for classes, attributes, quality requirements, as specified in ATS.TR.200; a temporal model associations and lists of values, or — by using a feature catalogue specified in — the constraints of the possible values accordance with the ISO standard referred to in — the naming convention point 25 of Annex III; (b) define, as individual data elements, each aeronautical — the description of geometrical elements feature for which the information is requested to be The description of the metadata elements are published in accordance with the ICAO standards covered in the metadata requirements. referred to in point 10 of Annex III and the Eurocae document referred to in point 24 of Annex III; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification (c) provide for each attribute the definition of its allowable values in the form of a data type, a range of values or an enumerated list; (d) include the definition of a temporal model, UTC based, which can express the complete lifecycle of an aeronautical feature: — from the creation date and time to the date and time of permanent withdrawal, — including the permanent changes that create new baselines for that feature; (e) include the definition of the rules that may constrain the possible values of the feature properties or the temporal variation of these values. This shall include, as a minimum: — constraints that impose accuracy, resolution and integrity for positional (horizontal and vertical) data, — constraints that impose the timeliness of the data; (f) apply a naming convention for features, attributes and associations, which avoids the use of abbreviations; (g) base the description of geometrical elements (point, curve, surface) on the ISO standard referred to in point 14 of Annex III; (h) base the description of the metadata information on the ISO standard referred to in point 5 of Annex III; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification (i) include the metadata items listed in Annex I, Part C. 2. Regarding the ISO standards, the relevant certificate --- Not transposed. issued by an appropriately accredited organisation, shall be considered as a sufficient means of This paragraph is already covered by AMC1 compliance. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) ATM/ANS.OR.B.005(a) Management system with shall accept the disclosure of the documentation regard to ISO 9001 certificate for service providers. related to the certification to the national supervisory authority upon the latter’s request. PART B --- --- Electronic terrain data sets The electronic terrain data referred to in point (c) of the --- second subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall: (a) be provided digitally in accordance with the ICAO NOTE: No NPA text is reproduced here because the Transposed. standards referred to in points 9, 9a and 12 of Annex transposed provisions are spread out in different III; requirements of the rules. The NPA text covers the relevant requirements of ICAO Annex 15 (chapter 10 and Appendix 8). (b) include the metadata items listed in Annex I, Part C. --- The NPA text covers the requirements laid down in Annex I, Part C of Reg. 73/2010. Please see below in Part C. PART C --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Metadata The metadata for the data set specifications defined in ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Transposed. Part A and Part B shall include the following items, as a minimum: […] service providers shall: It is proposed to define a minimum set of data in (a) the data originator of the data; order to make the implementation feasible. The (e) collect metadata for aeronautical data processes proposal text is based on ICAO Annex15 and PANS- and exchange points and maintain them up to those (b) amendments made to the data; AIM. parties receiving the data. The metadata to be (c) the persons or organisations that have interacted collected shall include, as a minimum: The metadata requirements are applicable to service with the data and when; providers, AIS providers and aviation undertakings. (d) details of any validation and verification of the data (1) the identification of the organizations or entities that has been performed; performing any action of originating, transmitting or (e) effective start date and time of the data; manipulating the data; (f) for geospatial data: (2) the action performed; and — the earth reference model used, (3) the date and time the action was performed. —the coordinate system used; (g) for numerical data: AIS.TR.225 Metadata — the statistical accuracy of the measurement or The metadata to be collected shall include, as a calculation technique used, minimum: — the resolution, — the confidence level as required by the ICAO (a) the identification of the organizations or entities standards referred to in points 1 and 12 of Annex performing any action of originating, transmitting or III and in other relevant ICAO standards; manipulating the data; (h) details of any functions applied if data has been (b) the action performed; and subject to conversion/transformation; (c) the date and time the action was performed. (i) details of any limitations on the use of the data. Appendix 1 to Article 3 European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 7. Metadata Metadata shall be collected and maintained up to the next intended user. The metadata shall include, as a minimum: The identification of the organizations or entities performing any action of originating, transmitting or manipulating the data; The action performed; and The date and time the action was performed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification ANNEX II --- --- AERONAUTICAL DATA EXCHANGE FORMAT REQUIREMENTS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 5 PART A --- --- IAIP, aerodrome mapping and electronic obstacle data 1. The aeronautical data and aeronautical information AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and --- referred to in points (a), (b) and (d) of the second aeronautical information subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall be formatted in accordance with a common specification, which shall: Except for terrain data, the exchange format of aeronautical data shall: [see 2nd row below] — use the extensible mark-up language (XML) AMC1 AIS.OR.210(a) Exchange of aeronautical data Transposed. specification as defined in the ISO standard referred and aeronautical information to in Annex III point 17 for data encoding, — be expressed in the form of an XML schema; in EXCHANGE MODEL addition, a schematron as defined in the ISO An aeronautical information services provider should standard referred to in point 19 of Annex III may be use an aeronautical information exchange model used for expressing business rules, that describes the features and their properties (attributes and associations) within the AIM domain and includes an XML schema. — enable the exchange of data for both individual (a) enable the exchange of data for both individual Transposed. features and feature collections, features and feature collections; — enable the exchange of baseline information as a (b) enable the exchange of baseline information as a Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification result of permanent changes, result of permanent changes; — be structured in accordance with the features, (c) be in accordance with the subjects, properties Transposed. attributes and associations of the data set definition and associations of the data catalogue and be described in Annex I, Part A; the mapping rules shall documented through mapping rules. be documented, — implement strictly the enumerated lists of values --- Not transposed. and range of values defined for each attribute in the data set, — comply with the geography mark-up language (GML) --- Not transposed. specification, as defined in the reference referred to in point 18 of Annex III, for the encoding of geographical information. 2. Regarding the ISO standards, the relevant certificate --- This paragraph is covered by AMC1 issued by an appropriately accredited organisation, ATM/ANS.OR.B.005(a) Management system with shall be considered as a sufficient means of regard to ISO 9001 certificate for air navigation compliance. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) services providers shall accept the disclosure of the documentation related to the certification to the national supervisory authority upon the latter’s request. PART B --- --- Electronic terrain data 1. The electronic terrain data referred to in point (c) of AMC2 AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data Transposed. the second subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall be and aeronautical information provided in a common format compliant with the ISO standards referred to in points 14 to 18 of Annex III. ELECTRONIC TERRAIN DATA European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Electronic terrain data should be provided in a common format compliant with ISO 19107:2003 — Geographic information — Spatial schema (Edition 1 — 8.5.2003) and 19136:2007 — Geographic information — Geography Mark-up Language (GML) (Edition 1 — 23.8.2007). 2. Regarding the ISO standards, the relevant certificate This paragraph is already covered by AMC1 issued by an appropriately accredited organisation, ATM/ANS.OR.B.005(a) Management system with shall be considered as a sufficient means of regard to ISO 9001 certificate for air navigation compliance. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) services providers shall accept the disclosure of the documentation related to the certification to the national supervisory authority upon the latter’s request. This Annex is specific to Reg. 73/2010 – the referred ANNEX III provisions of ICAO Annex 15 have been transposed. PROVISIONS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLES AND ANNEXES 1. Chapter 3, Section 3.7 (Quality management system) --- The quality system is already covered in of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention — ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 of Regulation XX/XXXX Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 2. Chapter 3, Section 1.2.1 (Horizontal reference system) --- The horizontal reference system is now transposed of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention — and no reference to Annex 15 is no longer needed. Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 3. Chapter 3, Section 1.2.2 (Vertical reference system) of --- The vertical reference system is now transposed and Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention — Aeronautical no reference to Annex 15 is no longer needed. Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 4. Chapter 4 (Aeronautical Information Publications --- Chapter 4 on AIP is now transposed and no reference (AIP)) of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention — to Annex 15 is no longer needed. Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 5. Chapter 4, Section 4.3 (Specifications for AIP --- Chapter 4 on AIP is now transposed and no reference Amendments) of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention to Annex 15 is no longer needed. — Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 6. Chapter 4, Section 4.4 (Specifications for AIP --- Chapter 4 on AIP is now transposed and no reference Supplements) of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention to Annex 15 is no longer needed. — Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 7. Chapter 5 (NOTAM) of Annex 15 to the Chicago --- Chapter 5 on AIP is now transposed and no reference Convention — Aeronautical Information Services to Annex 15 is no longer needed. (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 8. Chapter 6, Section 6.2 (Provision of information in --- Chapter 6 on AIP is now transposed and no reference paper copy form) of Annex 15 to the Chicago to Annex 15 is no longer needed. Convention — Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Amendment No 37). 9. Chapter 10, Section 10.1 (Coverage areas and --- Chapter 10 on AIP is now transposed and no requirements for data provision) of Annex 15 to the reference to Annex 15 is no longer needed. Chicago Convention — Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 9a.Chapter 10, Section 10.2 (Terrain data set — content, --- Chapter 10 on AIP is now transposed and no numerical specification and structure) of Annex 15 to reference to Annex 15 is no longer needed. the Chicago Convention — Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 10.Appendix 1 (Contents of Aeronautical Information --- Appendix 1 on the AIP content is now transposed and Publication (AIP)) of Annex 15 to the Chicago no reference to Annex 15 is no longer needed. Convention — Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 11.Appendix 7 (Aeronautical data publication resolution --- Appendix 7 on data quality is included in the data and integrity classification) of Annex 15 to the catalogue and thus transposed, no reference to Annex Chicago Convention — Aeronautical Information 15 is no longer needed. Services (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). 12.Appendix 8 (Terrain and obstacle data requirements) --- Appendix 8 on Terrain and obstacle data is now of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention — transposed and no reference to Annex 15 is no longer Aeronautical Information Services (Fourteenth edition needed. — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 13.Object Management Group Unified Modelling --- The reference to the UML specification is now Language (UML) Specification Version 2.1.1. referred to in guidance material to the related requirement. 14.International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in 19107:2003 — Geographic information — Spatial guidance material to the related requirement. schema (Edition 1 — 8.5.2003). 15.International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in 19115:2003 — Geographic information — Metadata guidance material to the related requirement. (Edition 1 — 8.5.2003 [Corrigendum Cor 1:2006 5.7.2006]). 16.International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in 19139:2007 — Geographic information — Metadata guidance material to the related requirement. — XML schema implementation (Edition 1 — 17.4.2007). 17.International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in 19118:2011 — Geographic information — Encoding guidance material to the related requirement. (Edition 2 — 10.10.2011). 18.International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in 19136:2007 — Geographic information — Geography guidance material to the related requirement. Mark-up Language (GML) (Edition 1 — 23.8.2007). 19.International Organisation for Standardisation, --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in ISO/IEC 19757-3:2006 — Information technology — guidance material to the related requirement. Document Schema Definition Languages (DSDL) — Part 3: Rule-based validation — Schematron (Edition 1 — 24.5.2006). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 20. ICAO Doc 9674-AN/946 — World Geodetic System — --- The reference to the World Geodetic System Manual 1984 Manual (Second Edition — 2002). is now referred to in guidance material to the related requirement. 21.Chapter 7, Section 7.3.2 (Cyclic redundancy check --- The reference to the ICAO Doc 9674-AN/946 is now (CRC) algorithm) of ICAO Doc 9674-AN/946 — World referred to in guidance material to the related Geodetic System — 1984 (WGS-84) Manual (Second requirement. Edition — 2002). 22.International Organisation for Standardisation, --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in ISO/IEC 27002:2005 — Information technology — guidance material to the related requirement. Security techniques — Code of practice for information security management (Edition 1 — 15.6.2005). 23.International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in 28000:2007: — Specification for security guidance material to the related requirement. management systems for the supply chain (Edition 1 — 21.9.2007 under revision, to be replaced by Edition 2 target date 31.1.2008 [At enquiry stage]). 24.Eurocae ED-99A, User Requirements for Aerodrome --- The reference to Eurocae ED-99A document is now Mapping Information (October 2005). referred to in guidance material to the related requirement. 25.International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO --- The ISO document reference is now referred to in 19110:2005 — Geographic information — guidance material to the related requirement. Methodology for feature cataloguing (Edition 1). --- This NPA text covers article 6.1 of ADQ IR, as the data European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification ANNEX IV catalogue will cover the data quality requirements in DATA QUALITY REQUIREMENTS REFERRED TO IN Annex IV, Part A of Regulation (EU) No 73/2010. ARTICLES 6 AND 7 PART A --- --- Data quality requirements 1. Data quality requirements for each data item within --- This paragraph refers to Appendix 7 of ICAO Annex 15 the scope of aeronautical data and aeronautical (data quality requirements) and is now covered by information referred to in the second subparagraph Appendix 1 to Annex III (ATM/ANS.OR) containing the of Article 2(1) shall be as defined by the ICAO data catalogue. standards referred to in Annex III point 11 and other relevant ICAO standards without prejudice to point 2 of this Annex. 2. Data quality requirements for a data item within the --- Not transposed. scope of aeronautical data and aeronautical information referred to in the second subparagraph It is considered that the data catalogue will cover all of Article 2(1) shall be established based on a safety data item with specified data quality requirements. assessment of the intended uses of the data item The data catalogue covers the referred (point 11 of where: Annex III) Appendix 7 of Annex 15. (a) a data item is not defined by the ICAO data quality standards referred to in point 11 of Annex III and other relevant ICAO standards; or (b) the data quality requirements for a data item are not met by the ICAO data quality standards referred to in point 11 of Annex III and other relevant ICAO standards. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 3. The data quality requirements for the data items --- Transposed through the verification and validation referred to in point 2 shall be developed in process rules. accordance with a standardised process describing the methodology for the derivation and validation of these requirements prior to publication, taking due account of the potential impact on relevant ICAO provisions. 4. Where a data item has more than one intended use, --- Not transposed. only the most stringent data quality requirements, arising from the safety assessment referred to in point 2, shall be applied to it. 5. Data quality requirements shall be defined to cover --- The data quality requirements are covered by the the following for each data item within the scope of data catalogue. aeronautical data and aeronautical information referred to in the second subparagraph of Article 2(1): The NPA contains provisions reflecting the objective (a) the accuracy and resolution of the data; and notably, processes that are adequate to ensure (b) the integrity level of the data; the timely collection, processing, storing, integration, (c) the ability to determine the origin of the data; exchange and delivery of quality-assured aeronautical (d) the level of assurance that data is made available data and aeronautical information. to the next intended user prior to its effective start date/time and not deleted before its effective end date/time. 6. All of the data items needed to support each --- Not transposed. This requirement reflect internal application data set and/or a valid subset of the data arrangements within the relevant parties and not set shall be defined. subject to be regulated. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification PART B --- --- Evidence requirements Arguments and evidence shall be generated to show --- --- that: (a) accuracy and resolution requirements are complied --- Not transposed. The requirement to ensure that the with at data origination and maintained through to data quality requirements are met is already covered publication to the next intended user, including, throughout the rules. whenever the resolution of a data item is reduced or changed, or the data is translated into a different coordinate system or unit of measurement; (b) the origin and change history for each data item is --- Not transposed. The requirement to ensure that the recorded and available for audit; data quality requirements are met is already covered throughout the rules. (c) the aeronautical data or aeronautical information is --- Not transposed. The requirement to ensure that the complete or any missing items are declared; data quality requirements are met is already covered throughout the rules. (d) all data origination, production, storage, handling, --- Not transposed. The requirement to ensure that the processing, transfer or distribution processes used for data quality requirements are met is already covered each data item are defined and adequate for the throughout the rules. assigned level of integrity of the data item; (e) data validation and verification processes are ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Verification and validation Transposed. adequate for the assigned integrity level of the data processes item; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification […] service providers shall: (h) ensure that validation and verification techniques are employed throughout the aeronautical data processing chain to ensure that the aeronautical data meets the associated data quality requirements, […] (f) manual or semi-automated data processes are AIS.OR.600 General requirements The performance of data processes are part of the performed by trained and qualified staff, with clearly duties of relevant personnel and are therefore defined roles and responsibilities that are recorded in An aeronautical information services provider shall covered for AIS providers and for the personnel of the organisation’s quality system; ensure that personnel responsible for tasks in the entities originating data. provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information is: (b) adequately trained, competent and authorised for the job they are required to do. Appendix 1 to Article 3 11. PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS Personnel responsible for originating aeronautical data or aeronautical information shall be adequately trained, competent and authorised for the job they are required to do (g) all tools and/or software used to support or --- This paragraph refers to Annex V, please see below implement the processes are validated as fit for the part on Tools and software requirements. purpose in accordance with Annex V; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification (h) an effective error reporting, measurement and --- This paragraph refers to Annex IV, Part F please see corrective action process is in operation in below the part on Error reporting and rectification accordance with Part F requirements. PART C AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(d) Transposed for service providers and AIS providers. Formal arrangements AMC1 AIS.OR.205 Formal arrangements European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Formal arrangements shall include the following CONTENT Transposed. minimum content: (a) the scope of aeronautical data or aeronautical Formal arrangements should include the following information to be provided; minimum content: (b) the accuracy, resolution and integrity requirements (a) the aeronautical data to be provided; for each data item supplied; (c) the required methods for demonstrating that the (b) the data quality requirements for each data item data provided conforms with the specified supplied according to the data catalogue; requirements; (c) the method(s) for demonstrating that the data (d) the nature of action to be taken in the event of provided conforms with the specified requirements; discovery of a data error or inconsistency in any data provided; (d) the action to be taken in the event of discovery (e) the following minimum criteria for notification of data of a data error or inconsistency in any data provided; changes: (e) the following minimum criteria for notification of — criteria for determining the timeliness of data data changes: provision based on the operational or safety (f) criteria for determining the timeliness of data significance of the change, provision based on the operational or safety — any prior notice of expected changes, significance of the change, — the means to be adopted for notification; (f) the party responsible for documenting data changes; (g) any prior notice of expected changes, (g) the means to resolve any potential ambiguities (h) the means to be adopted for notification; caused where different formats are used to exchange aeronautical data or aeronautical information; (i) the party responsible for documenting data (h) any limitations on the use of data; changes; (i) requirements for the production of quality reports by (j) data exchange details such as format or format data providers to facilitate verification of data quality change processes; by the data users; (j) metadata requirements; (k) any limitations on the use of data; (k) contingency requirements concerning the continuity (l) requirements for the production of data of data provision. origination quality reports ; (m) metadata requirements; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification PART D ---- ---- Data origination 1. The surveying of radio navigation aids and the --- Transposed throughout the data origination origination of calculated or derived data whose requirements. coordinates are published in the AIP shall be carried out in accordance with appropriate standards and at least in accordance with the relevant ICAO provisions referred to in point 20 of Annex III. 2. All surveyed data shall be referenced to WGS-84 as --- Transposed. The use of WGS 1984 is required under specified in the ICAO provisions referred to in point 2 ATM/ANS.OR.A.105 (a) of Annex III. 3. A geoid model, sufficient to meet the ICAO provisions --- Transposed. The use of the vertical reference system referred to in point 3 of Annex III and the aeronautical is required under ATM/ANS.OR.A.105 (b) and the data and aeronautical information quality Earth Gravitational Model — 1996 (EGM-96) is requirements laid down in Annex IV, shall be used in referred to in the related AMC. order that all vertical data (surveyed, calculated or derived) may be expressed relative to mean sea level via the Earth Gravitational Model 1996. A ‘geoid’ means the equipotential surface in the gravity field of the Earth, which coincides with the undisturbed mean sea level extended continuously through the continents. 4. Surveyed, calculated and derived data shall be --- Not transposed. This requirement is considered as not maintained throughout the lifetime of each data item. practicable. It is questionable how this requirement European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification can be ensured. 5. Survey data categorised as critical or essential data --- Not transposed. This requirement is considered to shall be subject to a full initial survey, and thereafter apply to aerodrome operators when they originate shall be monitored for changes on a yearly basis, as a aeronautical data. minimum. Where changes are detected, re-survey of the relevant data shall be undertaken. 6. The following electronic survey data capture and --- Not transposed. This requirement is considered to storage techniques shall be employed: apply to aerodrome operators when they originate (a) reference point coordinates shall be loaded to the aeronautical data. surveying equipment by digital data transfer; (b) the measurements in the field shall be stored digitally; (c) raw data shall be digitally transferred and loaded into the processing software. 7. All survey data categorised as critical data shall be --- Not transposed. This requirement is considered to subject to sufficient additional measurement to apply to aerodrome operators when they originate identify survey errors not detectable by single aeronautical data. measurement. 8. Aeronautical data and aeronautical information shall Appendix 1 to Article 3 Transposed. be validated and verified prior to use in deriving or calculating other data. 6. DATA VERIFICATION AND VALIDATION In general, this requirement is transposed throughout the rules on verification and validation process. When using aeronautical data to derive or calculate new aeronautical data, the initial data shall be verified and validated, except when provided by an European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification authoritative source. PART E --- --- Data process requirements 1. Where processes or parts of processes used in the Transposed. origination, production, storage, handling, processing, AMC1 AIS.OR.200 General transfer and distribution of aeronautical data and AUTOMATED DATA PROCESS aeronautical information are subject to automation Where processes or parts of processes used in the they shall be: origination, production, storage, handling, processing, transfer and distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical information are subject to automation they should be: (a) automated to a level commensurate with the (a) automated to a level commensurate with the context of the data process; context of the data process; (b) automated to optimise the allocation and (b) automated to optimise the allocation and interaction of human and machine to achieve a interaction of human and machine to achieve a high degree of safety and quality benefits of the high degree of safety and quality benefits of the process; process; (c) designed to avoid the introduction of data errors; (c) designed to avoid the introduction of data errors; and (d) designed to detect errors in received/input data. (d) designed to detect errors in received/input data. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 2. Where aeronautical data and aeronautical ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and Transposed. information is entered manually, it shall be subject to aeronautical information independent verification to identify any errors that may have been introduced. (h) (2) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information entered manually shall be subject to independent verification to identify any errors that may have been introduced. PART F AIS.TR.235 Error reporting and corrective actions --- Error reporting and rectification requirements The error reporting, measurement and corrective action The error reporting, measurement and corrective Transposed. mechanisms shall ensure that: mechanisms shall ensure that: (f) and (g) are not transposed as they are considered (a) problems identified during aeronautical data and to cover internal arrangements to keep statistics of (a) problems identified during aeronautical data and aeronautical information origination, production, errors. aeronautical information origination, production, storage, handling and processing, or those identified storage, handling and processing, or those reported by users after publication, are recorded and reported by users after publication, are recorded; This requirements is also transposed in: to the aeronautical information service provider; (b) all problems reported with the aeronautical data and (b) all problems reported with the aeronautical data Appendix 1 to Article 3 aeronautical information are analysed by the and aeronautical information are analysed by the 10 ERROR HANDLING REQUIREMENTS aeronautical information service provider and the aeronautical information service provider and the necessary corrective actions are determined; The error handling and corrective action mechanisms necessary corrective actions are determined; shall ensure that: (c) all errors, inconsistencies and anomalies detected in (c) all errors, inconsistencies and anomalies detected 9.1.2 errors identified during data origination and critical and essential aeronautical data and in critical and essential aeronautical data and aeronautical information are urgently resolved; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification aeronautical information are urgently resolved; after data delivery are addressed or resolved. (d) affected data users are warned of errors by the 9.1.3 priority and urgency are given to errors in (d) affected users are warned of errors by the most aeronautical information service provider by the most critical and essential aeronautical data. effective means, taking into account the integrity effective means, taking into account the integrity level of the aeronautical data and aeronautical level of the aeronautical data and aeronautical information. information and using the notification criteria agreed in the formal arrangements in accordance with Annex IV, Part C point (d); (e) error feedback from data users and other (e) error feedback is facilitated and encouraged; aeronautical data and aeronautical information providers is facilitated and encouraged; (f) error rates for aeronautical data and aeronautical --- information are recorded on each occasion that aeronautical data and aeronautical information is transferred between the parties referred to in Article 2(2); (g) error rates for those errors detected prior to transfer --- and those reported after transfer can be identified separately. --- --- ANNEX V TOOLS AND SOFTWARE REQUIREMENTS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 8 European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 1. Tools used to support or automate aeronautical data --- The NPA text proposes to directly identify the and aeronautical information processes shall meet necessary tools and software requirements. The the requirements of points 2 and 3, where the tool: introduction of situations where the tools and — has the potential to create errors in critical or software requirements need to apply, is not essential data items, considered necessary. — is the sole means of detecting errors in critical or essential data items, — is the sole means of detecting discrepancies between multiple versions of manually entered data. 2. For the tools referred to in point 1, performance, ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and Transposed. functionality and integrity level requirements shall be aeronautical information defined to ensure that the tool performs its function within the data process without adversely impacting […] service providers shall: (f) ensure that all tools the quality of aeronautical data or aeronautical and software used to support or automate information. aeronautical data and aeronautical information processes perform their functions without adversely impacting on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. 3. The tools referred to in point 1 shall be validated and ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and Transposed. verified against the requirements referred to in point aeronautical information 2. This paragraph is transposed through the validation […] service providers shall: (h) ensure that validation and verification processes that includes tools and and verification techniques are employed software performances. GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) throughout the aeronautical data processing chain covers the validation of software. to ensure that the aeronautical data meets the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification associated data quality requirements. 4. The tools referred to in point 1, which are AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data Transposed implemented fully or partially in software, shall satisfy and aeronautical information the following additional requirements: TOOLS The tools used to support or automate aeronautical data and aeronautical information processes which are implemented fully or partially in software, should: — the software requirements shall correctly state (a) correctly state what is required by the software Transposed what is required by the software in order to satisfy in order to satisfy the tool requirements, the tool requirements, — all software requirements shall be traceable to the (b) be traceable to the tool requirements referred Transposed tool requirements referred to in point 2, to in point 2, — the validation and verification of software, as GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data Transposed. defined in points 5 and 6 respectively, shall be and aeronautical information applied to a known executable version of the software in its target operating environment. (a) A means by which ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) can be met, is through the validation and verification of software applied to a known executable version of the software in its target operating environment. 5. The validation of software means the process of (b) The validation of software is a process of Transposed. ensuring that software meets the requirements for ensuring that software meets the requirements for the specified application or intended use of the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification aeronautical data or aeronautical information. the specified application or intended use of the aeronautical data or aeronautical in-formation. 6. The verification of software means the evaluation of (c) The verification of software is an evaluation of Transposed. the output of an aeronautical data and/or the output of an aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information software development aeronautical information software development process to ensure correctness and consistency with process to ensure correctness and consistency with respect to the inputs and applicable software respect to the inputs and applicable software standards, rules and conventions used in that process. standards, rules and conventions used in that process. ANNEX VI ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and --- DATA PROTECTION REQUIREMENTS REFERRED TO IN aeronautical information ARTICLE 9 1. All data transferred in an electronic format shall be […] service providers shall: Transposed. protected against loss or alteration of data by the application of the CRC32Q algorithm as referred to in (h) ensure that validation and verification The NPA required validation and verification process point 21 of Annex III. The cyclic redundancy check techniques are employed throughout the requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f). The (hereinafter CRC) value shall be applied before the aeronautical data processing chain to ensure that verification encompasses digital error detection final verification of the data prior to storage or the aeronautical data meets the associated data techniques during the transmission of data. This transfer. quality requirements and that: addresses data protection. 2. Where the physical size of data exceeds that which (1) the verification ensures that aeronautical data The protection of data applies to all those who handle may be protected at the required level of integrity by was received without corruption and that the aeronautical data. The NPA proposes a flexible a single CRC, multiple CRC values shall be used. aeronautical data process does not introduce approach by ensuring the protection of data through 3. Aeronautical data and aeronautical information shall corruption. Verification of received aeronautical verification and validation techniques enabling the be given an appropriate level of security protection data shall involve checks that ensure the integrity of protection of data, one of them being the Cyclic during storage and when exchanged between the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification parties referred to in Article 2(2), to ensure that the the transmitted data. Redundancy Check. The objective to protect data is data cannot be accidentally changed or subjected to ensured as the verification ensures that aeronautical (2) aeronautical data and aeronautical information unauthorised access and/or alteration at any stage. data was received without corruption and that the entered manually are subject to independent 4. The storage and transfer of aeronautical data and aeronautical data process does not introduce verification to identify any errors that may have aeronautical information shall be protected by a corruption. Then, the validation enables to check the been introduced. suitable authentication process such that recipients data for its use. are able to confirm that the data or information has (i) ensure that digital data error detection been transmitted by an authorised source. techniques are used during the transmission and/or storage of aeronautical data and digital data sets and apply to all integrity levels of data sets. (j) ensure that the transfer of aeronautical data shall be subject to a suitable authentication process such that recipients are able to confirm that the data or information has been transmitted by an authorised source. Appendix 1 to Article 3 8. DATA ERROR DETECTION AND AUTHENTICATION (c) The transfer of aeronautical data shall be subject to a suitable authentication process such that recipients are able to confirm that the data or information has been transmitted by an authorised source. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification ANNEX VII --- --- QUALITY, SAFETY AND SECURITY MANAGEMENT REQUIREMENTS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 10 PART A --- The quality management system is sufficiently covered through ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 Management Quality management system system. The elements of the management system include the elements of the QMS in Reg. 73/2010 and it is therefore not necessary to transpose this Part A. 1. A quality management system supporting the --- The management system in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 origination, production, storage, handling, processing, applies to aeronautical data and aeronautical transfer and distribution of aeronautical data and information. aeronautical information shall: — define the quality policy in such a way as to meet --- The policy is covered by the management system the needs of different users as closely as possible, requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 — set up a quality assurance programme that --- The required procedures are covered by the contains procedures designed to verify that all management system requirements in operations are being conducted in accordance ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 with applicable requirements, standards and procedures, including the relevant requirements of this Regulation, — provide evidence of the functioning of the quality --- The provision of evidence is covered by the system by means of manuals and monitoring management system requirements in documents, ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification — appoint management representatives to monitor --- The appointment of managers are covered by the compliance with, and adequacy of, procedures to management system requirements in ensure safe and efficient operational practices, ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 — perform reviews of the quality system in place and --- The reviews are covered by the management system take remedial actions, as appropriate. requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 2. An EN ISO 9001 certificate, issued by an appropriately --- This paragraph is already covered by AMC1 accredited organisation, shall be considered as a ATM/ANS.OR.B.005(a) Management system with sufficient means of compliance to the requirements regard to ISO 9001 certificate for air navigation of point 1. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) shall services providers accept the disclosure of the documentation related to the certification to the national supervisory authority upon the latter’s request. PART B --- This Part B states some general objectives, which are already covered by the management system Safety management objectives requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 1. The safety management objectives shall be: --- --- — to minimise the contribution to the risk of an --- This objective is covered by the management system aircraft accident arising from data errors as far as requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005, in the overall reasonably practicable, safety policy. — to promote awareness of safety around the --- This function is foreseen by the management system organisation by sharing lessons arising from safety requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005, in the overall activities and by involving all staff to propose European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification solutions to identified safety issues and safety policy. improvements to assist the effectiveness and efficiency of the processes, — to ensure that a function is identified within the --- This function is foreseen by the management system organisation being responsible for development requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005. and maintenance of the safety management objectives, — to ensure that records are kept and monitoring is --- Records requirements are covered through carried out to provide safety assurance of their ATM/ANS.OR.B.030 Record keeping. activities, — to ensure improvements are recommended, --- This objective is foreseen by the management system where needed, to provide assurance of the safety requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005. of activities. 2. The achievement of the safety management --- This paragraph is a statement rather than a objectives shall be afforded the highest priority over requirement itself. The management system commercial, operational, environmental or social underlines the need to have a policy with regard to pressures. safety. The policy needs to reflect organisational commitments regarding performance of the services and safety and has to include a commitment to improve towards the highest performance standards so as to support the achievement of the highest level of safety and to enforce the performance of the service required to support the achievement of the highest level of safety in the airspace where the service is provided. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification PART C --- This Part C contains requirements which are already covered by the security management requirements in Security management objectives ATM/ANS.OR.D.010 1. The security management objectives shall be: --- --- — to ensure the security of aeronautical data --- The security of the data is covered by aeronautical information received, produced or ATM/ANS.OR.D.010 Security management, in (a)(2). otherwise employed so that it is protected from interference and access to it is restricted only to those authorised, — to ensure that the security management measures --- This requirement is already covered by the security of an organisation meet appropriate national or management requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.D.010, international requirements for critical when defining the procedures related to the risk infrastructure and business continuity, and assessment and mitigation. international standards for security management, including the ISO standards referred to in points 22 and 23 of Annex III. 2. Regarding the ISO standards, the relevant certificate --- This paragraph is already covered by AMC1 issued by an appropriately accredited organisation, ATM/ANS.OR.B.005(a) Management system with shall be considered as a sufficient means of regard to ISO 9001 certificate for air navigation compliance. The parties referred to in Article 2(2) services providers shall accept the disclosure of the documentation related to the certification to the national supervisory authority upon the latter’s request. The NPA does not cover the requirements on European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification ANNEX VIII manufacturers but on service providers. The Requirements for the assessment of the conformity or procedures for the EC declarations of conformity or suitability for use of constituents referred to in Article suitability are considered as being sufficiently covered 11 by Article 5 and related Annex III of Reg. 552/2004. 1. The verification activities shall demonstrate the --- The procedures for the EC declarations of conformity conformity of constituents with the interoperability, or suitability are considered as being sufficiently performance, quality and safety requirements of this covered by Article 5 and related Annex III of Reg. Regulation, or their suitability for use whilst these 552/2004. constituents are in operation in the test environment. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 2. The manufacturer, or its authorised representative --- The procedures for the EC declarations of conformity established in the Union, shall manage the conformity or suitability are considered as being sufficiently assessment activities and shall in particular: covered by Article 5 and related Annex III of Reg. — determine the appropriate test environment, 552/2004, in particular its point 2 (scope). — verify that the test plan describes the constituents in the test environment, — verify that the test plan provides full coverage of applicable requirements, — ensure the consistency and quality of the technical documentation and the test plan, — plan the test organisation, staff, installation and configuration of test platform, — perform the inspections and tests as specified in the test plan, — write the report presenting the results of inspections and tests. 3. The manufacturer, or its authorised representative --- The procedures for the EC declarations of conformity established in the Union, shall ensure that the or suitability are considered as being sufficiently constituents involved in the origination, production, covered by Article 5 and related Annex III of Reg. storage, handling, processing, transfer and 552/2004, in particular its point 3 (scope), which distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical covers the requirements for any used constituents. information integrated in the test environment meet the interoperability, performance, quality and safety requirements of this Regulation. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 4. Upon satisfying completion of verification of --- The procedures for the EC declarations of conformity conformity or suitability for use, the manufacturer, or or suitability are considered as being sufficiently its authorised representative established in the covered by Article 5 and related Annex III of Reg. Union, shall under its responsibility draw up the EC 552/2004, in particular its point 3 (scope), which declaration of conformity or suitability for use, covers the requirements for any used constituents. specifying notably the requirements of this Regulation met by the constituent and its associated conditions of use in accordance with point 3 of Annex III to Regulation (EC) No 552/2004. This Annex IX lays down the condition to perform the verification activities. As the procedures for the EC ANNEX IX declarations of verification of systems are considered as being sufficiently covered by Article 6 and related CONDITIONS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 12 Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004, this Annex IX is not transposed. 1. The air navigation service provider must have in place --- --- reporting methods within the organisation that ensure and demonstrate impartiality and independence of judgement in relation to the verification activities. 2. The air navigation service provider must ensure that --- --- the personnel involved in verification processes carry out the checks with the greatest possible professional integrity and the greatest possible technical competence, and are free of any pressure and incentive, in particular of a financial type, which could affect their judgment or the results of their checks, in particular from persons or groups of persons affected European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification by the results of the checks. 3. The air navigation service provider must ensure that --- --- the personnel involved in verification processes, have access to the equipment that enables them to properly perform the required checks. 4. The air navigation service provider must ensure that --- --- the personnel involved in verification processes, have sound technical and vocational training, satisfactory knowledge of the requirements of the verifications they have to carry out, adequate experience of such operations, and the ability required to draw up the declarations, records and reports to demonstrate that the verifications have been carried out. 5. The air navigation service provider must ensure that --- --- the personnel involved in verification processes, are able to perform their checks with impartiality. Their remuneration shall not depend on the number of checks carried out, or on the results of such checks. --- The procedures for the EC declarations of verification ANNEX X of systems are considered as being sufficiently PART A covered by Article 6 and related Annex IV of Reg. Requirements for the verification of systems referred to 552/2004 in Article 12(1) 1. The verification of systems identified in the first --- Not transposed. See Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall demonstrate the Systems, in particular its point 2 (Verification conformity of these systems with the interoperability, European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification performance and safety requirements of this procedure for systems). Regulation in an assessment environment that reflects the operational context of these systems. 2. The verification of systems identified in the first --- Not transposed. See Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall be conducted in Constituents, in particular its point 3 (Technical file). accordance with appropriate and recognised testing practices. 3. Test tools used for the verification of systems --- Not transposed. See Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall Systems, in particular its point 2 (Verification have appropriate functionalities. procedure for systems). 4. The verification of systems identified in the first --- Not transposed. See Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall produce the Constituents, in particular its point 3 (Technical file). elements of the technical file required by point 3 of Annex IV to Regulation (EC) No 552/2004 including the following elements: — description of the implementation, — the report of inspections and tests achieved before putting the system into service. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 5. The air navigation service provider shall manage the --- No transposed. See Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on verification activities and shall in particular: Systems, in particular its point 1 (Contents of EC — determine the appropriate simulated operational declaration of verification of systems). and technical environment reflecting the operational environment, — verify that the test plan describes the integration of systems identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) in an operational and technical assessment environment, — verify that the test plan provides full coverage of the applicable interoperability, performance and safety requirements of this Regulation, — ensure the consistency and quality of the technical documentation and the test plan, — plan the test organisation, staff, installation and configuration of the test platform, — perform the inspections and tests as specified in the test plan, — write the report presenting the results of inspections and tests. 6. The air navigation service provider shall ensure that --- This paragraph is applicable in the context of the systems identified in the first subparagraph of Regulation 73/2010 only. Article 2(1) under its responsibility meet the interoperability, performance and safety requirements of this Regulation. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification 7. Upon satisfying completion of verification of --- Please see Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on Systems, in conformity, air navigation service providers shall draw particular its point 4 (Submission). up the EC declaration of verification of system and submit it to the national supervisory authority together with the technical file as required by Article 6 of Regulation (EC) No 552/2004. PART B --- Not transposed. See Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on Systems when it is referred to notified body, as per Requirements for the verification of systems referred to Article 8 of said regulation. in Article 12(2) 1. The verification of systems identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall demonstrate the conformity of these systems with the interoperability, performance and safety requirements of this Regulation in an assessment environment that reflects the operational context of these systems. 2. The verification of systems identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall be conducted in accordance with appropriate and recognised testing practices. 3. Test tools used for the verification of systems identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall have appropriate functionalities. 4. The verification of systems identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) shall produce the elements of the technical file required by point 3 of European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification Annex IV to Regulation (EC) No 552/2004 including the following elements: — description of the implementation, — the report of inspections and tests achieved before putting the system into service. 5. The air navigation service provider shall determine the appropriate operational and technical assessment environment reflecting the operational environment and shall have verification activities performed by a notified body. 6. The notified body shall manage the verification --- Not transposed. See Annex IV of Reg. 552/2004 on activities and shall in particular: Systems when it is referred to notified body, as per — verify that the test plan describes the integration Article 8 of said regulation. of systems identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) in an operational and technical assessment environment, — verify that the test plan provides full coverage of the applicable interoperability, performance and safety requirements of this Regulation, — ensure the consistency and quality of the technical documentation and the test plan, — plan the test organisation, staff, installation and configuration of the test platform, — perform the inspections and tests as specified in the test plan, — write the report presenting the results of European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 NPA Text Justification inspections and tests. 7. The notified body shall ensure that the systems identified in the first subparagraph of Article 2(1) operated in an operational assessment environment meet the interoperability, performance and safety requirements of this Regulation. 8. Upon satisfying completion of verification tasks, the notified body shall draw up a certificate of conformity in relation to the tasks it carried out. 9. Then the air navigation service provider shall draw up --- Not transposed. The EC declaration of verification of the EC declaration of verification of system and system is already required under Article 6 of submit it to the national supervisory authority Regulation (EC) No 552/2004. together with the technical file as required by Article 6 of Regulation (EC) No 552/2004. ANNEX XI ICAO DIFFERENCES REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 14 This Annex XI is applicable in the context of Regulation 73/2010 only and is therefore not transposed. Chapter 3, Section 3.5.2 (Cyclic redundancy check) of Annex 15 to the Chicago Convention — Aeronautical Information Services. (Fourteenth edition — July 2013, incorporating Amendment No 37). --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Table 3 - Rule comparison between the text of the upcoming major amendment to ICAO Annex 15 and new draft PANS-AIM, and the NPA text. ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS AND The term ‘transposed’ means that the substance of the ICAO provisions is not changed, although, in some cases, some editorial revisions may have been applied. RECOMMENDED PRACTICES --- NOTE1: When reference is made to Annex III to Regulation (EU) No ../.., it refers to Part-ATM/ANS.OR in draft Regulation laying down technical requirements and administrative procedures related to service providers and the oversight thereof, still to be adopted. NOTE 2: When reference is made to Appendix 1 to Article 3, it refers to the Appendix on requirements for aviation undertakings that is linked to Article 3.1 to Regulation laying down technical requirements and administrative procedures related to service providers and the oversight thereof, still to be adopted. CHAPTER 1. GENERAL AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical --- information services providers Note 1.— The object of the aeronautical information (a) An aeronautical information services provider The ICAO Note 1 generally states what AIS needs to service (AIS) is to ensure the flow of aeronautical data shall ensure the provision of aeronautical data and ensure. The NPA text reproduces the ICAO text to and aeronautical information necessary for global air aeronautical information necessary for the safety, highlight the general responsibility of an AIS traffic management (ATM) system safety, regularity, regularity and efficiency of air navigation. provider. economy and efficiency in an environmentally The second and third paragraphs are explanatory sustainable manner. The role and importance of material that are not considered to be reproduced. aeronautical data and aeronautical information changed European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) significantly with the implementation of area navigation (RNAV), performance-based navigation (PBN), airborne computer-based navigation systems and data link systems. Corrupt, erroneous, late, or missing aeronautical data and aeronautical information can potentially affect the safety of air navigation. Note 2.— These Standards and Recommended Practices --- This Note is applicable in the framework of ICAO are to be used in conjunction with the Procedures for Air rules and not relevant to be transposed in EU rules. Navigation Services — ICAO Abbreviations and Codes (PANS-ABC, Doc 8400). Note 3.— These Standards and Recommended Practices --- This Note is not considered to be transposed as it are to be used in conjunction with the Procedures for refers to the PANS-AIM which is now transposed. Aeronautical Information Management (PANS-AIM, Doc XXXX). Note 4.— Guidance material on the organization and GM1 to Annex VI – Part-AIS Transposed. operation of aeronautical information services is DOC 8126 contained in the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc 8126). Guidance material on the organization and operation of aeronautical information services is contained in the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (ICAO Doc 8126). 1.1 Definitions Please see separate cross reference table --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 1.2 Common reference systems for air navigation ATM/ANS.OR.A.085 Common reference systems The common reference system requirements are for air navigation not included in Annex VI (Part-AIS) but in Annex III (Part-ATM/ANS.OR) as they are applicable to all service providers. 1.2.1 Horizontal reference system --- --- 1.2.1.1 World Geodetic System — 1984 (WGS-84) shall (a) For the purpose of air navigation, service Transposed. be used as the horizontal (geodetic) reference system for providers shall use shall use the World Geodetic The second part of the paragraph is covered by the international air navigation and published aeronautical System — 1984 (WGS-84) as the horizontal specifications in the data catalogue. geographical coordinates (indicating latitude and reference system. longitude) shall be expressed in terms of the WGS-84 Appendix 1 to Article 3 geodetic reference datum. 2. Common reference systems The World Geodetic System WGS-84 shall be used as the horizontal reference system for data origination. Note 1.— Comprehensive guidance material concerning --- Guidance on WGS-84 is provided, based on the WGS-84 is contained in the World Geodetic System — EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of 1984 (WGS-84) Manual (Doc 9674). Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, edition 1.0 of 04/02/2013) 1.2.1.2 Recommendation.— In precise geodetic --- Guidance on WGS-84 is provided, based on the applications and some air navigation applications, EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) temporal changes in the tectonic plate motion and tidal Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material effects on the Earth’s crust should be modelled and (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, edition 1.0 of estimated. To reflect the temporal effect, an epoch 04/02/2013) should be included with any set of absolute station coordinates. Note 1.— The epoch of the WGS-84 (G873) reference --- Guidance on WGS-84 is provided, based on the frame is 1997.0 while the epoch of the latest updated EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of WGS-84 (G1150) reference frame, which includes plate Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material motion model, is 2001.0. (G indicates that the (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, edition 1.0 of coordinates were obtained through Global Positioning 04/02/2013) System (GPS) techniques, and the number following G indicates the GPS week when these coordinates were implemented in the United States of America’s National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency’s (NGA’s) precise ephemeris estimation process.) Note 2.— The set of geodetic coordinates of globally --- Guidance on WGS-84 is provided, based on the distributed permanent GPS tracking stations for the most EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of recent realization of the WGS-84 reference frame (WGS- Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material 84 (G1150)) is provided in Doc 9674. For each permanent (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, edition 1.0 of GPS tracking station, the accuracy of an individually 04/02/2013) estimated position in WGS-84 (G1150) has been in the order of 1 cm (1s). Note 3.— Another precise worldwide terrestrial --- Guidance on WGS-84 is provided, based on the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) coordinate system is the International Earth Rotation EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of Service (IERS) Terrestrial Reference System (ITRS), and Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material the realization of ITRS is the IERS Terrestrial Reference (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, edition 1.0 of Frame (ITRF). Guidance material regarding the ITRS is 04/02/2013) provided in Appendix C of Doc 9674. The most current realization of the WGS-84 (G1150) is referenced to the ITRF 2000 epoch. The WGS-84 (G1150) is consistent with the ITRF 2000 and in practical realization the difference between these two systems is in the one to two centimetre range worldwide, meaning WGS-84 (G1150) and ITRF 2000 are essentially identical. 1.2.2 Vertical reference system --- --- 1.2.2.1 Mean sea level (MSL) datum, shall be used as ATM/ANS.OR.A.085 Common reference systems Transposed. the vertical reference system for international air for air navigation navigation. (b) For the purpose of air navigation, service providers shall use the Mean Sea Level (MSL) datum as the vertical reference system. Appendix 1 to Article 3 Requirements for aviation undertakings 2. Common reference systems for air navigation (b) The Mean Sea Level (MSL) datum shall be used European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) as the vertical reference system for data origination. Note 1.— The geoid globally most closely approximates GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.B.085(b) Transposed. MSL. It is defined as the equipotential surface in the MEAN SEA LEVEL gravity field of the Earth which coincides with the undisturbed MSL extended continuously through the (a) The geoid globally most closely approximates continents. MSL. It is defined as the equipotential surface in the gravity field of the Earth which coincides with the undisturbed MSL extended continuously through the continents. Note 2.— Gravity-related heights (elevations) are also (b) Gravity-related heights (elevations) are also Transposed. referred to as orthometric heights while distances of referred to as orthometric heights while distances of points above the ellipsoid are referred to as ellipsoidal points above the ellipsoid are referred to as heights. ellipsoidal heights. 1.2.2.2 The Earth Gravitational Model — 1996 (EGM- AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(b) Transposed. 96), shall be used by international air navigation as the VERTICAL REFERENCE SYSTEM This ICAO standard has been transposed at the level global gravity model. of AMC because the ICAO Annex allows for further (a) A service provider should use the Earth alternatives (such as 1.2.2.3 below). Gravitational Model — 1996 (EGM-96), as the global gravity model. 1.2.2.3 At those geographical positions where the AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(b) Transposed. accuracy of EGM-96 does not meet the accuracy VERTICAL REFERENCE SYSTEM This ICAO standard has been transposed at the level European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) requirements for elevation and geoid undulation (b) At those geographical positions where the of AMC because this paragraph only constitutes an specified in Annex 14, Volumes I and II, on the basis of accuracy of EGM-96 does not meet the accuracy alternative. EGM-96 data, regional, national or local geoid models requirements for elevation and geoid undulation containing high resolution (short wavelength) gravity specified in Annex 14, Volumes I and II, on the basis field data shall be developed and used. When a geoid of EGM-96 data, regional, national or local geoid model other than the EGM-96 model is used, a models containing high resolution (short description of the model used, including the parameters wavelength) gravity field data should be developed required for height transformation between the model and used. When a geoid model other than the EGM- and EGM-96, shall be provided in the Aeronautical 96 model is used, a description of the model used, Information Publication (AIP). including the parameters required for height transformation between the model and EGM-96, should be provided in the Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP). Note.— Specifications governing determination and --- Transposed. See Appendix 1 (data catalogue) reporting (accuracy of field work and data integrity) of elevation and geoid undulation at specific positions at aerodromes/heliports are given in Annex 14, Volumes I and II, Chapter 2, and Table A5-2 and Table 2 of Appendices 5 and 1, respectively. 1.2.2.4 In addition to elevation referenced to the MSL --- Not transposed as such. This paragraph is covered (geoid), for the specific surveyed ground positions, geoid by Appendix 1 (AIP content) to Part-AIS. undulation (referenced to the WGS-84 ellipsoid) for those positions specified in Appendix 1 shall also be European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) published. 1.2.3 Temporal reference system --- --- 1.2.3.1 For international civil aviation, the Gregorian ATM/ANS.OR.A.085 Common reference systems Transposed. calendar and Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) shall be for air navigation used as the temporal reference system. (c) For the purpose of air navigation, service providers shall use the Gregorian calendar and Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) as the temporal reference system. Appendix 1 to Article 3 2. Common reference systems for air navigation (c) The Gregorian calendar and Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) shall be used as the temporal reference systems for data origination. Note 1.— A value in the time domain is a temporal GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(c) Transposed. position measured relative to a temporal reference TEMPORAL REFERENCE SYSTEM system. (a) A value in the time domain is a temporal position measured relative to a temporal reference system. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Note 2.— Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) is a time --- Not transposed. This note is not considered as scale maintained by the Bureau International de l’Heure being explanatory material facilitating the (BIH) and the IERS and forms the basis of a coordinated understanding of the requirement. dissemination of standard frequencies and time signals. Note 3.— See Attachment D of Annex 5 for guidance --- Not transposed. This note is not considered as material relating to UTC. being explanatory material facilitating the understanding of the requirement. Note 4.— ISO Standard 8601 specifies the use of the GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(c) Transposed. Gregorian calendar and 24-hour local or UTC for TEMPORAL REFERENCE SYSTEM information interchange while ISO Standard 19108 prescribes the Gregorian calendar and UTC as the (b) ISO Standard 19108 prescribes the Gregorian primary temporal reference system for use with calendar and UTC as the primary temporal reference geographic information. system for use with geographic information. (c) ISO Standard 8601 specifies the presentation of dates and times for information interchange; 1.2.3.2 When a different temporal reference system --- This paragraph is not transposed as it is considered is used for some applications, the feature catalogue, or not relevant in the context of the rules. the metadata associated with an application schema or a data set, as appropriate, shall include either a description of that system or a citation for a document that describes that temporal reference system. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Note.— ISO Standard 19108, Annex D, describes some --- This paragraph is not transposed as it is considered aspects of calendars that may have to be considered in not relevant in the context of the rules. such a description. 1.3 Miscellaneous specifications --- --- 1.3.1 Aeronautical Information Products intended for AIS.TR.300 General Transposed. international distribution shall include English text for (a) Aeronautical Information Products intended for those parts expressed in plain language. international distribution shall include English text for those parts expressed in plain language. 1.3.2 Place names shall be spelt in conformity with local AIS.TR.300 General Transposed. usage, transliterated, when necessary, into the ISO-Basic (b) Place names shall be spelt in conformity with Latin alphabet. local usage, transliterated, when necessary, into the ISO-Basic Latin alphabet. 1.3.3 Recommendation.— Units of measurement used --- Not transposed. The reference to the units of in the origination, processing and distribution of measurement is covered by the data catalogue aeronautical data and aeronautical information should (Appendix 1 to Annex III of Regulation (EU) ../…) be consistent with the decision taken by the State in respect of the use of the tables contained in Annex 5 — Units of Measurement to be Used in Air and Ground Operations. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 1.3.4 ICAO abbreviations shall be used in the AIS.TR.300 General Transposed. aeronautical information services whenever they are (c) ICAO abbreviations shall be used in the appropriate and their use will facilitate distribution of aeronautical information services whenever they are aeronautical data and aeronautical information. appropriate and their use will facilitate distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. 1.4 Language proficiency AIS.OR.605 Language proficiency --- An Aeronautical Information Service provider shall An aeronautical information services provider shall Transposed. ensure that AIS personnel are proficient in speaking, ensure that its personnel is proficient in speaking, reading, writing and understanding English, as required reading, writing and understanding English, as for the functions that they are expected to perform. required for the functions that it is expected to perform. CHAPTER 2. RESPONSIBILITIES AND FUNCTIONS --- --- 2.1 State responsibilities --- -- 2.1.1 Each Contracting State shall: GM1 to Article 3.1 Transposed. a) provide an aeronautical information service; or AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES b) agree with one or more other Contracting State(s) for According to ICAO Annex 15, the Member States the provision of a joint service; or remain responsible for the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. In that regard c) delegate the authority for the provision of the service they may: to a non-governmental agency, provided the Standards European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) and Recommended Practices of this Annex are a) provide an aeronautical information service adequately met. themselves; or b) agree with one or more other Contracting State(s) for the provision of a joint service; or c) delegate the authority for the provision of the service to a non-governmental agency, provided the Standards and Recommended Practices of this Annex are adequately met. 2.1.2 Each Contracting State shall ensure that the GM1 to Article 3.1 Transposed. provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical Member States will ensure that the provision of information covers its own territory and those areas over aeronautical data and aeronautical information the high seas for which it is responsible for the provision covers its own territory and those areas over the of air traffic services. high seas for which it is responsible for the provision of air traffic services. 2.1.3 The State concerned shall remain responsible for AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical Transposed. the aeronautical data and aeronautical information information services providers The first sentence is covered by the GM1 above. provided in accordance with 2.1.2. Aeronautical data and (g) An aeronautical information services provider aeronautical information provided for and on behalf of a shall clearly indicate that aeronautical data and State shall clearly indicate that they are provided under aeronautical information provided for and on behalf the authority of that State, irrespective of the format in of a Member State are provided under the authority which it is provided. of that Member State, irrespective of the format in which it is provided. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 2.1.4 Each Contracting State shall ensure that the --- Not transposed. This provision is addressed to aeronautical data and aeronautical information provided Contracting States but the requirements are is complete, timely and of required quality in accordance covered under the AIS providers’ responsibilities. with 3.2. 2.1.5 Each contracting State shall ensure that formal ATM/ANS.OR.A.085 Formal arrangements Transposed. arrangements are established between originators of (d) Formal arrangements in relation with the Formal arrangements are established: aeronautical data and aeronautical information and the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical aeronautical information service in relation to the timely — between AIS providers themselves; information between service providers shall be and complete provision of aeronautical data and — between service providers themselves; established. aeronautical information. AIS.OR.205 Formal arrangements — between service providers and aviation undertakings; and An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that formal arrangements are established: — between AIS providers and aviation undertakings. (a) with all parties transmitting data to them; and (b) between themselves when exchanging aeronautical information and data. Appendix 1 to Article 3 3. Formal arrangements (a) Organisations originating data shall establish formal arrangements with: (1) parties requesting the data and; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) (2) when different, those to which the data are delivered. Note.— The scope of aeronautical data and aeronautical --- This Note is not considered relevant to transpose as information that would be the subject of formal the scope of the formal arrangements is included in arrangements is specified in Chapter 4. the rules. 2.2 AIS responsibilities and functions AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical --- information services providers 2.2.1 An aeronautical information service shall ensure (c) An aeronautical information services provider Transposed. that aeronautical data and aeronautical information shall ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical necessary for the safety, regularity or efficiency of air information are available for operations in a form navigation is made available in a form suitable for the suitable for: operational requirements of the ATM community, (1) personnel involved in flight operations, including including: flight crews, flight planning, and flight simulators; a) those involved in flight operations, including flight and crews, flight planning and flight simulators; and (2) air traffic services providers responsible for flight b) the air traffic services unit responsible for flight information service, and the services responsible for information service and the services responsible for pre- pre-flight information. flight information. Note.— A description of the ATM community is --- This Note is not transposed because the term ‘ATM contained in the Global Air Traffic Management community’ is not used in the rules. Operational Concept (Doc 9854). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 2.2.2 An aeronautical information service shall receive, AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical Transposed. collate or assemble, edit, format, publish/store and information services providers The second sentence is not transposed as it is distribute aeronautical data and aeronautical (b) An aeronautical information services provider considered to be a generic statement rather than a information concerning the entire territory of the State shall receive, collate or assemble, edit, format, requirement per se. as well as those areas over the high seas in which the publish, store and distribute aeronautical data and State is responsible for the provision of air traffic aeronautical information concerning the entire services. Aeronautical data and aeronautical information territory of a Member State as well as those areas shall be provided as aeronautical information products. over the high seas in which the Member State is responsible for the provision of air traffic services. Note.— An aeronautical information service may include --- This note is not considered as being explanatory origination functions. material facilitating the understanding of the requirement. The NPA covers origination requirements. 2.2.3 Where 24-hour service is not provided, service AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical Transposed. shall be available during the whole period an aircraft is in information services providers The proposed text takes into account the actual flight in the area of responsibility of an aeronautical (e) An aeronautical information services provider European operational environment. information service, plus a period of at least two hours shall provide 24-hour services for NOTAM before and after such a period. The service shall also be [This paragraph is combined with parts of 5.5.1 origination and issuance in its area of responsibility available at such other time as may be requested by an below] and pre-flight information needed in relation to appropriate ground organization. route stages originating at the aerodrome/heliport in its area of responsibility. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 2.2.4 An aeronautical information service shall, in GM1 AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical Transposed. addition, obtain aeronautical data and aeronautical information services providers information to enable it to provide pre-flight information An aeronautical information service provider obtains service and to meet the need for in-flight information: aeronautical data and aeronautical information to a) from the aeronautical information services of other enable it to provide pre-flight information service States; and to meet the need for in-flight information: b) from other sources that may be available. a) from the aeronautical information services of other States; b) from other sources that may be available. Note.— One such source is the subject of a provision in --- This note is not considered as being explanatory 5.7. material facilitating the understanding of the requirement. 2.2.5 Aeronautical data and aeronautical --- This provision is not relevant as it is considered as information obtained under 2.2.4 a) shall, when not being practicable. distributed, be clearly identified as having the authority of the State of Origin. 2.2.6 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information --- This provision is not relevant as it is considered as obtained under 2.2.4 b) shall, if possible, be verified not being practicable. before distribution and if not verified shall, when distributed, be clearly identified as such. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 2.2.7 An aeronautical information service shall AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical Transposed. promptly make available to the aeronautical information information services providers The last part of the sentence is already covered services of other States any aeronautical data and (d) An aeronautical information services provider AIS.OR.105(a). aeronautical information necessary for the safety, shall promptly make available to other aeronautical regularity or efficiency of air navigation required by information services providers any aeronautical data them, to enable them to comply with 2.2.1. and aeronautical information required by them. 2.3 Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical --- --- information 2.3.1 Each State shall designate the office to which all GM1 to Article 3.1 Transposed as explanatory material to the aeronautical information products provided by other obligation of the Member States laid down in Each Member State designates the office to which all States shall be addressed. Such an office shall be Article 3(1) of Regulation (EU) .../… aeronautical information products provided by other qualified to deal with requests for aeronautical data and States shall be addressed. Such an office shall be aeronautical information provided by other States. qualified to deal with requests for aeronautical data and aeronautical information provided by other States. 2.3.2 Recommendation — Formal arrangements should --- Not transposed. It is considered that this paragraph be established between those parties providing is out of the scope of the regulation. Formal aeronautical information on behalf of the States and arrangements cannot be imposed on such users. their users in relation to the provision of the service. Note. — Guidance material on such formal arrangements --- Not transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) may be found in XXXX 2.3.3 Where more than one international NOTAM office GM1 to Article 3.1 Transposed as explanatory material to the is designated within a State, the extent of responsibility obligation of the Member States laid down in Where more than one international NOTAM office is and the territory covered by each office shall be defined. Article 3(1) of Regulation (EU) .../… designated within a State, the extent of responsibility and the territory covered by each office shall be defined. 2.3.4 An aeronautical information service shall arrange, --- Not transposed. This paragraph is not a as necessary, to satisfy operational requirements for the requirement as such but is considered to be issuance and receipt of NOTAM distributed by internal arrangement within AIS providers. telecommunication. 2.3.5 Wherever practicable, direct contact between --- Not transposed. This paragraph is considered aeronautical information services shall be established in current practice and therefor it is not necessary to order to facilitate the international exchange of regulate it. aeronautical data and aeronautical information. 2.3.6 Except as provided in 2.3.8, one copy of each of the --- Not transposed. This requirement relates to following aeronautical information products (where contractual arrangements for the free exchange of available) that have been requested by the aeronautical AI products. It is considered not necessary to information service of an ICAO Contracting State shall be transpose in the framework of safety rules. provided in the mutually-agreed form(s), without charge, even where authority for publication/storage and distribution has been delegated to a non-governmental European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) agency: — Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP), including Amendments and Supplements — Aeronautical Information Circulars (AIC) — NOTAM 2.3.7 Recommendation.— The exchange of more than --- Not transposed. This requirement relates to one copy of the elements of the aeronautical information contractual arrangements for the free exchange of products and other air navigation documents, including AI products. It is considered not necessary to those containing air navigation legislation and transpose in the framework of safety rules. regulations, should be subject to bilateral agreement between the participating States and entities. 2.3.8 Where aeronautical information and aeronautical --- Not transposed. This requirement relates to data is provided in the form of digital data sets to be contractual arrangements for the free exchange of used by Aeronautical Information Services, it shall be AI products. It is considered not necessary to provided on the basis of agreement between the transpose in the framework of safety rules. concerned Contracting States Note. - The intention is that States are able to access --- This Note is not transposed as it self-explanatory. foreign data for the purposes specified in 2.2.4. 2.3.9 Recommendation.— The procurement of --- This paragraph is not transposed as it is related to aeronautical data and aeronautical information, procurement arrangements requirements, which including the elements of the aeronautical information considered not necessary to transpose in the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) products, and other air navigation documents, framework of safety rules. including those containing air navigation legislation and regulations, by States other than ICAO Contracting States and by other entities should be subject to separate agreement between the participating States and entities. 2.4 Copyright --- The NPA does not cover copyright matters. Note.— In order to protect the investment in the --- The NPA does not cover copyright matters. products of a State’s AIS as well as to ensure better control of their use, States may wish to apply copyright to those products in accordance with their national laws. 2.4.1 Any aeronautical information product which has --- The NPA does not cover copyright matters. been granted copyright protection by the State and provided to another State in accordance with 2.3, such products shall only be made available to a third party on the condition that the third party is made aware that the product is copyright protected and provided that it is appropriately annotated that the product is subject to copyright by the State. 2.4.2 When aeronautical information and aeronautical --- The NPA does not cover copyright matters. data is provided to the State in accordance with 2.3.8, the receiving State shall not provide digital data sets of the providing State to any third party, without the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) consent of the providing State. 2.5 Cost recovery --- The NPA dos not cover cost recovery requirements. 2.5.1 Recommendation.— The overhead cost of --- The NPA dos not cover cost recovery requirements. collecting and compiling aeronautical data and aeronautical information should be included in the cost basis for airport and air navigation services charges, as appropriate, in accordance with the principles contained in ICAO’s Policies on Charges for Airports and Air Navigation Services (Doc 9082). Note.— When costs of collection and compilation of --- The NPA dos not cover cost recovery requirements. aeronautical data and aeronautical information are recovered through airports and air navigation services charges, the charge to an individual customer for the supply of a particular AIS product may be based on the costs of printing paper copies, production of electronic media, and costs of distribution. CHAPTER 3. AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION --- --- MANAGEMENT 3.1 Information management requirements AIS.OR.100 Information management --- The information management resources and processes An aeronautical information services provider shall Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) established by an aeronautical information service shall establish information management resources and be adequate to ensure the timely collection, processing, processes that are adequate to ensure the timely storing, integration, exchange and delivery of quality- collection, processing, storing, integration, exchange assured aeronautical data and aeronautical information and delivery of quality-assured aeronautical data within the ATM system. and aeronautical information within the ATM system. 3.2 Data quality specifications Section 2 Data quality requirements --- 3.2.1 Accuracy --- --- The order of accuracy for aeronautical data shall be in AIS.TR.200 General Transposed. accordance with its intended use. (a) The accuracy for aeronautical data shall be as in the data catalogue, as specified in Appendix 1 to Annex III. ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (b)(1) the accuracy of aeronautical data, as specified in the data catalogue. Appendix 1 to Article 3 5. DATA QUALITY The accuracy for aeronautical data shall be as specified in the Data Catalogue. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Note.— Specifications governing the order of accuracy --- This Note is not transposed as the order of the (including confidence level) for aeronautical data are accuracy is contained in the data catalogue. provided in PANS-AIM Appendix 1. 3.2.2 Resolution --- --- The order of resolution of aeronautical data shall be AIS.TR.200 General Transposed. commensurate with the actual data accuracy. (b) The order of resolution of aeronautical data shall be commensurate with the actual data accuracy. ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (b)(3) the resolution of aeronautical data, which shall be commensurate with the actual data accuracy. Appendix 1 Article 3 5. DATA QUALITY (c) The resolution of aeronautical data shall be commensurate with the actual data accuracy. Note 1. — Specifications governing the publication --- This Note is not necessary to transpose as the resolution of the data are specified in the PANS-AIM publication resolution is contained in the data Appendix 1 catalogue. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Note 2. — The resolution of the data contained in the GM1 AIS.TR.200(b) General Transposed. database may be the same or finer than the publication The resolution of the data contained in the database resolution. may be the same or finer than the publication resolution. 3.2.3 Integrity --- --- 3.2.3.1 The integrity of aeronautical data shall be AIS.TR.200 General Transposed. maintained throughout the data process from origination (c) The integrity of aeronautical data shall be to distribution to the next intended user. maintained throughout the data process from reception to distribution to the next intended user. ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (b)(2) the integrity of aeronautical data shall be maintained throughout the data process. Appendix 1 Article 3 5. DATA QUALITY (b) The integrity of aeronautical data, which shall be maintained throughout the data process from origination to distribution to the next intended user. Note: Specifications governing the integrity classification --- This Note is not necessary to transpose as the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) related to aeronautical data are provided in PANS-AIM, integrity classification is contained in the data Appendix 1 catalogue. 3.2.3.2 Based on the applicable integrity classification, Appendix 1 Data origination Transposed. procedures shall be put in place in order to: 5. DATA QUALITY a) for routine data: avoid corruption throughout the (b) Based on the integrity classification specified in processing of the data; the data catalogue, procedures shall be put in place b) for essential data: assure corruption does not occur at in order to: any stage of the entire process and may include (1) for routine data, avoid corruption throughout additional processes as needed to address potential risks the processing of the data; in the overall system architecture to further assure data integrity at this level; and (2) for essential data, assure that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and c) for critical data: assure corruption does not occur at additional processes are included, as needed, to any stage of the entire process and include additional address potential risks in the overall system integrity assurance processes to fully mitigate the effects architecture to further assure data integrity at of faults identified by thorough analysis of the overall this level; and system architecture as potential data integrity risks. (3) for critical data, assured that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and additional integrity assurance processes are included to fully mitigate the effects of faults identified by thorough analysis of the overall system architecture as potential data integrity risks. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 3.2.4 Traceability --- --- 3.2.4.1 Traceability of aeronautical data shall be ensured AIS.TR.200 General Transposed. and retained as long as the data is in use. (d) Traceability of aeronautical data shall be ensured and retained. ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (b)(4) traceability of aeronautical data; Appendix 1 to Article 3 5. DATA QUALITY (e) Traceability of aeronautical data shall be ensured. Note - Configuration management is essential for --- This note is not considered as being explanatory compliance with traceability requirements. material facilitating the understanding of the requirement. 3.2.5 Timeliness --- --- 3.2.5.1 Timeliness shall be ensured by including AIS.TR.200 General Transposed. limitations on the effective period with the data (e) Timeliness shall be ensured by including any elements. limits on the effective period with the data elements. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (b)(5) timeliness of the data, by including any limits on the effective period with the data elements. Appendix 1 Article 3 5. DATA QUALITY (e) Timeliness shall be ensured by including any limits on the effective period with the data elements. Note 1 - These limits may be associated with individual --- This note is not considered as being explanatory data elements or data sets. material facilitating the understanding of the requirement. Note 2 - If the effective period is defined for a data set, it --- This note is not considered as being explanatory should account for the effective dates of all of the material facilitating the understanding of the individual data elements. requirement. 3.2.6 Completeness --- --- 3.2.6.1 Completeness of the aeronautical data shall be AIS.TR.200 General Transposed. ensured in order to support the intended use. (f) Completeness of the aeronautical data shall be ensured in order to support the intended use. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (b)(6) completeness of the aeronautical data shall be ensured in order to support the intended use. Appendix 1 Article 3 5. DATA QUALITY (f) Completeness of the aeronautical data, in order to support the intended use. 3.2.7 Format --- --- 3.2.7.1 The format of delivered data shall be adequate to AIS.TR.200 General Transposed. ensure that the data is interpreted in a manner that is (g) The format of delivered data shall be adequate to consistent with the intended use of the data. ensure that the data is interpreted in a manner that is consistent with the intended use of the data. ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (b)(7) the format of delivered data, which shall be adequate to ensure that the data is interpreted in a manner that is consistent with the intent of the data. Appendix 1 Article 3 European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5. DATA QUALITY (g) The format of delivered data shall be adequate to ensure that the data is interpreted in a manner that is consistent with the intent of the data. 3.3 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and --- validation and verification aeronautical information 3.3.1 Material to be issued as part of an aeronautical When originating, processing or transmitting data to Transposed. information product shall be thoroughly checked before the aeronautical information services provider, it is submitted to the aeronautical information service, in service providers shall: order to make certain that all necessary information has (h) ensure that validation and verification been included and that it is correct in detail. techniques are employed throughout the 3.3.2 An aeronautical information service shall establish aeronautical data processing chain to ensure verification and validation procedures which ensure that that the aeronautical data meets the associated upon receipt of aeronautical data and aeronautical information, quality requirements are met. data quality requirements, and that: […] 3.4 Data error detection --- --- 3.4.1 Digital data error detection techniques shall be AIS.OR.230 Authentication and data error detection Transposed. used during the transmission and/or storage of An aeronautical information services provider shall aeronautical data and digital data sets. ensure that: Digital data error detection techniques are used European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) during the transmission and/or storage of aeronautical data and digital data sets; ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (i) ensure that digital data error detection techniques are used during the transmission and/or storage of aeronautical data and digital data sets. Appendix 1 Article 3 8 DATA ERROR DETECTION AND AUTHENTICATION (a) Digital data error detection techniques shall be used during the transmission and/or storage of aeronautical data and digital data sets. 3.4.2 Digital data error detection techniques shall apply AIS.OR.235 Authentication and data error detection Transposed. to all integrity levels of data sets as specified in 3.2.3. An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that: (2) Digital data error detection techniques apply to all integrity levels of data sets. ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information (i) ensure that digital data error detection techniques […] apply to all integrity levels of data European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) sets. Appendix 1 Article 3 8 DATA ERROR DETECTION AND AUTHENTICATION (b) Digital data error detection techniques shall apply to all integrity levels of data sets. 3.5 Use of automation --- --- 3.5.1 Automation shall be applied in order to ensure the --- Not transposed as it is considered as being current timeliness, quality, efficiency and cost- effectiveness of practice in Europe. aeronautical information services. Note.— Guidance on the development of databases and GM1 to Annex VI – Part-AIS Transposed. the establishment of data exchange services is contained DOC 8126 It is proposed to apply this GM to Part-AIS in its in the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc entirety. 8126). Guidance material on the organization and operation of aeronautical information services is contained in the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (ICAO Doc 8126). 3.5.2 In order to meet the data quality requirements, AMC1 AIS.OR.200 General Transposed. automation shall: AUTOMATION a) enable digital aeronautical data exchange between the (a) In order to meet the data quality requirements, parties involved in the data processing chain; and automation should enable digital aeronautical European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) data exchange between aeronautical information services providers. b) use aeronautical information exchange models and AIS.OR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and Transposed. data exchange models designed to be globally aeronautical information interoperable. An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that: (a) the format of aeronautical data is based on an aeronautical information exchange model designed to be globally interoperable; 3.6 Quality management system --- The quality management requirements are covered by ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. 3.6.1 Quality management systems shall be --- The Quality management systems is covered by implemented and maintained encompassing all functions ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. of an aeronautical information service, as outlined in 2.2. The execution of such quality management systems shall be made demonstrable for each function stage. Note.— Guidance material is contained in the Manual on --- Not transposed. The relevant guidance material is the Quality Management System for Aeronautical already contained in the related AMC/GM to Information Services (Doc 9839). ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. 3.6.2 Recommendation.— Quality management should --- The quality management requirements are covered European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) be applicable to the whole aeronautical information data by ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. chain from data origination to distribution to the next intended user, taking into consideration the intended use of data. 3.6.3 Recommendation.— The quality management --- This paragraph is covered by AMC1 system established in accordance with 3.6.1 should ATM/ANS.OR.B.005(a) of Regulation (EU) .../.. with follow the International Organization for Standardization regard to ISO 9001 certificate for air navigation (ISO) 9000 series of quality assurance standards, and be services providers. certified by an accredited certification body. 3.6.4 Within the context of the established quality --- The quality management covered by management system, the competencies and the ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires a associated knowledge, skills and abilities required for process to ensure that personnel are trained and each function shall be identified, and personnel assigned competent to perform their duties. to perform those functions shall be appropriately trained. Processes shall be in place to ensure that personnel possess the competencies required to perform specific assigned functions. Appropriate records shall be maintained so that the qualifications of personnel can be confirmed. Initial and periodic assessments shall be established that require personnel to demonstrate the required competencies. Periodic assessments of personnel shall be used as a means to detect and correct shortfalls in knowledge, skills and European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) abilities. 3.6.5 Each quality management system shall include --- Not transposed. the necessary policies, processes and procedures, This paragraph is covered throughout the rules including those for the use of metadata, to ensure and related to metadata, error detection and verify that aeronautical data is traceable throughout the verification and validation processes. aeronautical information data chain so as to allow any data anomalies or errors detected in use to be identified by root cause, corrected and communicated to affected users. 3.6.6 The established quality management system --- Not transposed. It is part of the management shall provide users with the necessary assurance and system policy to be put in place. confidence that distributed aeronautical data and aeronautical information satisfy the aeronautical data quality requirements. 3.6.7 All necessary measures shall be taken to monitor --- The quality management covered by compliance with the quality management system in ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires the place. establishment of a function to monitor compliance of the organisation. 3.6.8 Demonstration of compliance of the quality --- The quality management covered by management system applied shall be by audit. If ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires a nonconformity is identified, initiating action to correct its compliance monitoring system that includes a cause shall be determined and taken without undue feedback system of findings to ensure European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) delay. All audit observations and remedial actions shall implementation of corrective actions as necessary be evidenced and properly documented. and a process to review the causes of underperformance of the management system, determine their implications and eliminate or mitigate such causes. 3.7 Safety management --- --- 3.7.1 A safety process shall be established to --- This paragraph states some general objectives, demonstrate commitment to safety management in which are already covered by the management order to meet defined safety objectives. system requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 of Regulation (EU) .../.. 3.7.2 Safety management activities shall, as a --- The quality management covered by minimum: ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires the establishment of a process to identify changes a) ensure hazards and safety risks associated with within the organisation and the context in which it changes to AIM processes, procedures, resources and operates, which may affect established processes, systems are assessed and mitigated; procedures and services and, where necessary, change the management system and/or the functional system to accommodate them. b) ensure that review and monitoring processes are in --- The quality management covered by place to identify potential safety issues; ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires the establishment of a function to monitor compliance of the organisation with the relevant requirements European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) and the adequacy of the procedures. c) ensure that procedures are in place to assess and AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical Transposed. mitigate safety risks to aviation arising from data and information services providers information errors; (f) An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that procedures are in place to assess and mitigate safety risks to aviation arising from data and information errors. d) identify roles and responsibilities within the --- The quality management covered by organisation for the performance of the safety ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires management functions; clearly defined lines of responsibility and accountability throughout the organisation. e) promote awareness of safety by involving all --- The quality management covered by personnel to identify safety issues and propose solutions ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires to identified safety issues; formal means to ensure that all personnel are fully aware of the management system, that conveys critical information, and explains why particular actions are taken and why procedures are introduced or changed. f) document procedures relating to safety management --- The quality management covered by activities and ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. requires to document all management system key processes. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) g) ensure that records pertaining to safety management --- Record keeping are required under performance are kept. ATM/ANS.OR.B.030 of Regulation (EU) .../.. Note 1 — The above activities may be included in the --- Not transposed as relevant guidance material is implementation of a Safety Management System as already contained in the related AMC/GM to described in Annex 19 Safety Management and detailed ATM/ANS.OR.B of Regulation (EU) .../.. in the Safety Management Manual (SMM) (Doc 9859). Note 2 — Guidance pertaining to the relationship --- The reference to PANS-AIM is not relevant as it has between SMS and QMS may be found in the PANS-AIM been transposed in this NPA. and in the QMS Manual (Doc 9839). 3.8 Human Factors considerations --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 3.8.1 The organization of the aeronautical --- Not transposed. These paragraphs are very generic information services as well as the design, contents, provisions and do not identify specific requirements processing and distribution of aeronautical data and on service providers. aeronautical information shall take into consideration Human Factors principles which facilitate their optimum utilization. 3.8.2 Due consideration shall be given to the integrity of information where human interaction is required and mitigating steps taken where risks are identified. Note.— This may be accomplished through the design of systems, through operating procedures or through improvements in the operating environment. CHAPTER 4. SCOPE OF AERONAUTICAL DATA AND --- --- AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION Note 1 — The scope of aeronautical data and --- This Note is not considered necessary to transpose aeronautical information that is managed by an AIS is as it only explains what chapter 4 includes. described in this chapter. Note 2 — The scope of aeronautical data and --- This Note is not considered necessary to transpose aeronautical information provides the minimum as it explains the scope in the framework of ICAO requirement to support aeronautical information Annex 15. products and services, aeronautical navigation data European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) bases, air navigation applications and ATM systems. Note 3 — Aeronautical data and aeronautical --- Not transposed. information in each sub-domain may be originated by more than one organization or authority. 4.1 Origination of aeronautical data and aeronautical --- --- information 4.1.1 The aeronautical data and aeronautical --- This paragraph is covered by the domains included information originated in the following sub-domains shall in the data catalogue (Appendix 1 to Annex III of include: Regulation (EU) .../..) and applies to origination activities. a) National regulations, rules and procedures; b) Aerodromes and heliports; c) Airspace; d) ATS and other routes; e) Instrument flight procedures; f) Radio navigation aids/systems; g) Obstacles; and h) Geographic information. Note. — The contents of each sub-domain are described --- Not transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) fully in Appendix1 and Appendix 2 to the PANS-AIM. 4.1.2 Determination and reporting of aeronautical data --- This paragraph is covered by the domains included shall be in accordance with the required accuracy and in the data catalogue (Appendix 1 to Annex III of integrity classification. Regulation (EU) .../..) and applies to origination activities. Note. — Specifications governing the accuracy --- This Note is not transposed. The accuracy requirements and integrity classification related to requirements and integrity classification are aeronautical data are contained in the PANS-AIM contained in the data catalogue. Appendix 1. 4.1.3 Originators shall take into account accuracy --- This paragraph is covered by point 5 (data quality requirements and integrity classification for aeronautical requirements) of Appendix 1 to Article 3 data. requirements for aviation undertakings. 4.2 Metadata --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 4.2.1 Metadata shall be collected for aeronautical data ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and Transposed. processes and exchange points. aeronautical information 4.2.2 Metadata collection shall be applied throughout […] service providers shall: the aeronautical information data chain, from origination (e) collect metadata for aeronautical data processes to distribution to the next intended user. and exchange points and maintain them up to those parties receiving the data. AIS.OR.225 Metadata requirements An aeronautical information services provider shall collect and retain metadata. Appendix 1 Article 3 7. Metadata Metadata shall be collected and maintained up to the next intended user. Note. — The metadata requirement is not intended to GM1 AIS.OR.225 Metadata requirements Transposed. contradict existing privacy regulations. When collecting metadata, the protection of The reference to EU related directive is added. individuals with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, apply, in accordance with Directive 95/46/EC on Data protection. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) CHAPTER 5. AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION --- --- PRODUCTS AND SERVICES 5.1 General --- --- 5.1.1 Aeronautical information shall be provided in the --- Not transposed. form of Aeronautical Information Products and This paragraph is considered as being a generic associated services. statement rather than a requirement per se. Note. — Cases where digital data sets may replace the --- This Note is not considered to be transposed as it corresponding elements of the standardized refers to the PANS-AIM which is now transposed. presentation are detailed in PANS-AIM. 5.1.2 Where aeronautical data and aeronautical AIS.OR.300 General Transposed. information are provided in multiple formats, processes An aeronautical information services provider shall shall be implemented to ensure data and information ensure that, where aeronautical data and consistency between formats. aeronautical information are provided in multiple formats, processes are implemented to ensure data and information consistency between those formats. 5.1.3 Aeronautical data shall be provided in accordance --- This paragraph is covered by AIS.TR.200(b) with the resolution requirements. Note.— Specifications governing the order of resolution --- This Note is not necessary to transpose as the order for aeronautical data are provided in the PANS-AIM European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Appendix 1 of resolution is contained in the data catalogue. 5.1.4 Geographical coordinates whose accuracy does not AIS.TR.240 Data limitations Transposed. meet the requirements shall be identified. An aeronautical information service provider shall identify the aeronautical data and aeronautical information that do not meet the data quality requirements. 5.2 Aeronautical information in a standardized --- --- presentation 5.2.1 The AIP, AIP Amendment, AIP Supplement and AIC AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. shall be provided on paper and/or as an electronic (AIP) The AIC is covered in the AIS.TR.320 (a) document “Electronic AIP” (eAIP) that allows for both (a) The AIP, AIP Amendment, AIP Supplement shall displaying on a computer screen and printing on paper. be provided on paper and/or as an electronic document “Electronic AIP” (eAIP) that allows for displaying on computer screen and printing on paper. 5.2.2 Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP) AIS.OR.305 Aeronautical information publication --- (AIP) 5.2.2.1 An Aeronautical Information Publication and its An aeronautical information services provider shall Transposed. Amendments shall contain aeronautical information of issue aeronautical information of lasting character, lasting character (permanent information and long permanent information and long duration European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) duration temporary changes) essential to air navigation. temporary changes, essential to air navigation as AIP, including amendments and supplements. 5.2.2.2 Aeronautical Information Publications shall AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. include: (AIP) (b) The AIP shall include: a) a statement of the competent authority responsible (1) a statement of the competent authority Transposed. for the air navigation facilities, services or procedures responsible for the air navigation facilities, services covered by the AIP; or procedures covered by the AIP; b) the general conditions under which the services or (2) the general conditions under which the services Transposed. facilities are available for international use; or facilities are available for international use; c) a list of significant differences between the national (3) a list of significant differences between the Transposed. regulations and practices of the State and the related national regulations and practices of the State and ICAO Standards, Recommended Practices and the related ICAO Standards, Recommended Practices Procedures, given in a form that would enable a user to and Procedures, given in a form that would enable a differentiate readily between the requirements of the user to differentiate readily between the State and the related ICAO provisions; requirements of the State and the related ICAO provisions; d) the choice made by a State in each significant case (4) the choice made by a State in each significant Transposed. where an alternative course of action is provided for in case where an alternative course of action is ICAO Standards, Recommended Practices and provided for in ICAO Standards, Recommended European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Procedures. Practices and Procedures. 5.2.3 AIP Supplement --- --- 5.2.3.1 AIP Supplement shall contain temporary changes AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. to the information contained in the AIP provided by (a) The AIP Supplement shall be provided by means The reference to ‘temporary changes’ is included in means of distinctive pages. of distinctive pages. AIS.OR.315. 5.2.3.2 A checklist of valid AIP Supplements shall be AIS.OR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. regularly provided. An aeronautical information services provider shall: (b) regularly provide a checklist of the valid AIP Supplements. 5.2.4 Aeronautical Information Circulars (AIC) --- --- 5.2.4.1 An AIC shall be used to provide: AIS.OR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. a) a long-term forecast of any major change in (a) An aeronautical information services provider legislation, regulations, procedures or facilities; or shall issue the following as an AIC: b) information of a purely explanatory or advisory nature (1) a long-term forecast of any major change in liable to affect flight safety; or legislation, regulations, procedures or facilities; or c) information or notification of an explanatory or (2) information of a purely explanatory or advisory advisory nature concerning technical, legislative or nature liable to affect flight safety; or purely administrative matters. (3) information or notification of an explanatory or European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) advisory nature concerning technical, legislative or purely administrative matters. 5.2.4.2 An AIC shall not be used for information that AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. qualifies for inclusion in AIP or NOTAM. (c) The AIC shall not be used for information that qualifies for inclusion in AIP or NOTAM. 5.2.4.3 The validity of AIC currently in force shall be AIS.OR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. reviewed at least once a year. (b) An aeronautical information services provider shall review the validity of AIC currently in force at least once a year. 5.2.4.4 A checklist of the currently valid AIC shall be AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. regularly provided. (h) A checklist of AIC currently in force shall be The text is based on PANS-AIM 5.2.2.8. issued at least once a year, with distribution as for the AIC. 5.2.5 Aeronautical Charts --- --- Note.— Annex 4 provides standards and recommended --- The ICAO Annex 4 is included in Part-AIS and practices including provision requirements for each chart referred to in AMC. type. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.2.5.1 The aeronautical charts listed alphabetically AIS.OR.325 Aeronautical charts Transposed. below shall, when made available for designated (p) Chart distribution requirements international aerodromes/heliports, form part of the AIP, or be provided separately to recipients of the AIP: An aeronautical information service provider shall ensure that the following aeronautical charts, where a) Aerodrome/Heliport Chart — ICAO; made available: b) Aerodrome Ground Movement Chart — ICAO; (1) form part of the AIP or are provided separately c) Aerodrome Obstacle Chart — ICAO Type A; to recipients of the AIP: d) Aerodrome Terrain and Obstacle Chart — ICAO (i) aerodrome obstacle chart — type A; (Electronic); (ii) aerodrome/heliport chart; e) Aircraft Parking/Docking Chart — ICAO; (iii) aerodrome ground movement chart; f) Area Chart — ICAO; (iv) aircraft parking/docking chart; g) ATC Surveillance Minimum Altitude Chart — ICAO; (v) precision approach terrain chart; h) Instrument Approach Chart — ICAO; (vi) ATC surveillance minimum altitude chart; i) Precision Approach Terrain Chart — ICAO; (vii) area chart; j) Standard Arrival Chart — Instrument (STAR) — ICAO; (viii) standard arrival chart — instrument k) Standard Departure Chart — Instrument (SID) — ICAO; (STAR); l) Visual Approach Chart — ICAO. (ix) standard departure chart — instrument (SID); (x) instrument approach chart; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) (xi) visual approach chart; and (xii) en route chart; and 5.2.5.2 The “Enroute Chart — ICAO” shall, when --- Transposed in (12) above available, form part of the AIP, or be provided separately to recipients of the AIP. 5.2.5.3 The aeronautical charts listed alphabetically AIS.OR.325 Aeronautical charts Transposed. below shall, when available, be provided as Aeronautical (p) Chart distribution requirements The charts not included are considered as not being Information Products: relevant. (2) are provided as part of the aeronautical a) Aerodrome Obstacle Chart — ICAO Type B; information products: b) The World Aeronautical Chart — ICAO 1:1 000 000; (i) aerodrome obstacle chart — type B; c) The Aeronautical Chart — ICAO 1:500 000 (ii) world aeronautical chart 1:1 000 000; and d) The Aeronautical Navigation Chart — ICAO Small Scale (iii) world aeronautical chart 1:500 000. e) The Plotting Chart — ICAO chart f) ATC Surveillance Minimum Altitude Chart — ICAO. 5.2.5.4 Recommendation - Electronic aeronautical charts --- Not transposed. should be provided based on digital databases and the use of geographic information systems. 5.2.5.5 Aeronautical data shall be provided in accordance --- The resolution requirements are covered in the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) with the charting resolution requirements. data catalogue. Note.— Specifications governing the order of charting --- This Note is not considered to be transposed as it resolution for aeronautical data are provided in PANS- refers to the PANS-AIM which is now transposed, AIM Appendix 1. included Appendix 1 which is the data catalogue. 5.2.6 NOTAM --- --- 5.2.6.1 A NOTAM shall contain information concerning AIS.OR.330 NOTAM Transposed. the establishment, condition or change in any (b) issue information concerning the establishment, aeronautical facility, service, procedure or hazard, the condition or change in any aeronautical facility, timely knowledge of which is essential to personnel service, procedure or hazard, the timely knowledge concerned with flight operations. of which is essential to personnel concerned with flight operations, as a NOTAM. Note.— Detailed specifications for NOTAM, including --- The reference to PANS-AIM is not relevant as the formats for SNOWTAM and ASHTAM, are contained in formats for SNOWTAM and ASHTAM have been PANS-AIM. transposed in this NPA. 5.2.6.2 A checklist of valid NOTAM shall be regularly AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. provided. (s) A checklist of valid NOTAM shall be regularly provided. 5.3 Digital data sets --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.1 General 5.3.1.1 When provided, digital data shall be in the form AIS.OR.335 General Transposed. of the following data sets: (a) When provided, an aeronautical information a) Aeronautical (AIP) data set; services provider shall ensure that digital data is in the form of the following data sets: b) Terrain data sets; (1) AIP data set; c) Obstacle data sets; (2) Terrain data sets; d) Aerodrome mapping data sets; and (3) Obstacle data sets; e) Instrument flight procedure data sets. (4) Aerodrome mapping data sets; and (5) Instrument flight procedure data sets. 5.3.1.2 Each data set shall include the minimum set of AIS.OR.335 General Transposed. metadata that needs to be provided to the next intended (b) Each data set shall include a minimum set of user. metadata that needs to be provided to the next intended user. 5.3.1.3 A checklist of valid data sets shall be regularly AIS.OR.335 General Transposed. provided. (c) A checklist of valid data sets shall be regularly provided. 5.3.2 Aeronautical (AIP) data set --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.2.1 The Aeronautical (AIP) data set shall contain the AIS.OR.345 AIP data set There is no obligation to provide an AIP data set. digital representation of aeronautical information of When provided, an aeronautical information lasting character (permanent information and long services provider shall ensure that the AIP data set duration temporary changes) essential to air navigation. contains the digital representation of aeronautical information of lasting character - including permanent information and long duration temporary changes - essential to air navigation. Note. — The exact content of the Aeronautical (AIP) --- This Note is not transposed. The Appendix 1 to data set is specified in PANS-AIM. Part-AIS covers the content of the AIP. 5.3.2.2 Recommendation. — The Aeronautical (AIP) --- Covered by AIS.OR.345 above. data set should be provided. 5.3.2.3 Recommendation. — When it is not possible to --- Covered by AIS.OR.345 above. provide a complete Aeronautical (AIP) data set, the data subset(s) that are available should be provided. 5.3.3 Terrain and obstacle data sets AIS.OR.350 Terrain and Obstacle data – general --- requirements The coverage areas for sets of electronic terrain and When made available, an aeronautical information Transposed. obstacle data shall be as specified in Appendix 1. services provider shall ensure that terrain and obstacle data are provided in accordance with AIS.TR.350. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.3.1 Terrain data sets --- --- 5.3.3.1.1 Terrain data sets shall contain the digital AIS.TR.355 Terrain data sets Transposed. representation of the terrain surface in the form of (a) Terrain data sets shall contain the digital continuous elevation values at all intersections (points) representation of the terrain surface in the form of a defined grid, referenced to common datum. of continuous elevation values at all intersections of a defined grid, referenced to common datum;. 5.3.3.1.2 Terrain data shall be provided for Area 1. AIS.OR.355 Terrain data sets Transposed. Where made available, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that terrain data are provided: (a) for area 1; 5.3.3.1.3 For aerodromes regularly used by international (b) for aerodromes regularly used by international Transposed. civil aviation, terrain data shall be provided for: civil aviation, to cover: (b)(2) Covers the recommendation below 5.3.3.1.4 a) Area 2a; (1) area 2a; b) the take-off flight path area; and (2) areas 2b, 2c and 2d for terrain that penetrates the relevant terrain data collection c) an area bounded by the lateral extent of the surface; aerodrome obstacle limitation surfaces. (3) the take-off flight path area; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) (4) an area bounded by the lateral extent of the aerodrome obstacle limitation surfaces; 5.3.3.1.4 Recommendation.— For aerodromes regularly --- Not transposed. used by international civil aviation, terrain data should It is already covered by (b)(2) above be provided for Areas 2b, 2c and 2d for terrain that penetrates the relevant terrain data collection surface specified in Appendix 1. 5.3.3.1.5 Recommendation.— Arrangements should be --- Not transposed. made for the coordination of providing terrain data for adjacent aerodromes where their respective coverage areas overlap to assure that the data for the same terrain are correct. 5.3.3.1.6 Recommendation.— For those aerodromes --- Not transposed. located near territorial boundaries, arrangements should be made among States concerned to share terrain data. 5.3.3.1.7 Recommendation.— For aerodromes regularly AIS.OR.355 Terrain data sets Transposed. used by international civil aviation, terrain data should (b) for aerodromes regularly used by international be provided for Area 3. civil aviation, to cover: (5) area 3; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.3.1.8 For aerodromes regularly used by international AIS.OR.355 Terrain data sets Transposed. civil aviation, terrain data shall be provided for Area 4 (b) for aerodromes regularly used by international for all runways where precision approach Category II or civil aviation, to cover: III operations have been established and where detailed terrain information is required by operators to enable (6) area 4 for all runways where precision approach them to assess the effect of terrain on decision height category II or III operations have been established determination by use of radio altimeters. and where detailed terrain information is required by operators to enable them to assess the effect of terrain on decision height determination by use of radio altimeters; 5.3.3.1.9 Recommendation.— Where additional terrain GM1 AIS.OR.355 Terrain data sets Transposed. data are collected to meet other aeronautical Where additional terrain data are collected to meet requirements, the terrain data sets should be expanded other aeronautical requirements, the terrain data to include these additional data. sets should be expanded to include these additional data. 5.3.3.2 Obstacle data sets --- --- 5.3.3.2.1 Obstacle data sets shall contain the digital AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. representation of the vertical and horizontal extent of (f) Obstacle data sets shall contain the digital obstacles. representation of the vertical and horizontal extent of obstacles. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.3.2.2 Obstacles shall not be included in terrain data AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. sets. (g) Obstacles shall not be included in terrain data sets. 5.3.3.2.3 The obstacle data shall be provided for AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. obstacles in Area 1 whose height is 100 m or higher Where made available, an aeronautical information above ground. services provider shall ensure that obstacle data are provided: (a) for obstacles in area 1 whose height is 100 m or higher above ground. 5.3.3.2.4 For aerodromes regularly used by international AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. civil aviation, obstacle data shall be provided for all Where made available, an aeronautical information obstacles within Area 2 that are assessed as being a services provider shall ensure that obstacle data are hazard to air navigation. provided: (b) for aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation, for all obstacles within area 2 that are assessed as being a hazard to air navigation. 5.3.3.2.5 For aerodromes regularly used by international AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. civil aviation, obstacle data shall be provided for: Where made available, an aeronautical information a) Area 2a , for those obstacles that penetrate the services provider shall ensure that obstacle data are relevant obstacle data collection surface specified in provided: European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Appendix 1; (c) for aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation, to cover: b) objects in the take-off flight path area which project above a plane surface having a 1.2 per cent slope and (1) area 2a , for those obstacles that penetrate having a common origin with the take-off flight path the relevant obstacle data collection surface; area; and (2) objects in the take-off flight path area which c) penetrations of the aerodrome obstacle limitation project above a plane surface having a 1.2 per cent surfaces. slope and having a common origin with the take-off flight path area; (3) penetrations of the aerodrome obstacle limitation surfaces; Note.— Take-off flight path areas are specified in Annex --- This note is not considered as being explanatory 4, 3.8.2. Aerodrome obstacle limitation surfaces are material facilitating the understanding of the specified in Annex 14, Volume 1, Chapter 4. requirement. 5.3.3.2.6 Recommendation.— For aerodromes regularly AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. used by international civil aviation, obstacle data should (c) for aerodromes regularly used by international The last part of the sentence is included in be provided for Areas 2b, 2c and 2d for obstacles that civil aviation, to cover: AIS.TR.360, items (c) (2) and (c) (3). penetrate the relevant obstacle data collection surface specified in Appendix 1, except that data need not be (4) areas 2b, 2c, 2d for obstacles that penetrate the collected for obstacles less than a height of 3 m above relevant obstacle data collection surfaces; ground in Area 2b and less than a height of 15 m above ground in Area 2c. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.3.2.7 Recommendation.— Arrangements should be --- Not transposed. made for the coordination of providing obstacle data for adjacent aerodromes where their respective coverage areas overlap to assure that the data for the same obstacle are correct. 5.3.3.2.8 Recommendation.— At those aerodromes --- Not transposed. located near territorial boundaries, arrangements should be made among States concerned to share obstacle data. 5.3.3.2.9 Recommendation.— For aerodromes regularly AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. used by international civil aviation, obstacle data should (c) for aerodromes regularly used by international be provided for Area 3 for obstacles that penetrate the civil aviation, to cover: relevant obstacle data collection surface specified in Appendix 1. (5) area 3 for obstacles that penetrate the relevant obstacle data collection surface; 5.3.3.2.10 For aerodromes regularly used by AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. international civil aviation, obstacle data shall be (c) for aerodromes regularly used by international The sentence in italic is not transposed as no provided for Area 4 for obstacles that penetrate the civil aviation, to cover: vertical obstacle data collection surface has been relevant obstacle data collection surface specified in defined by ICAO. Appendix 1, for all runways where precision approach (6) area 4, for all runways where precision Category II or III operations have been established. approach category II or III operations have been established; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.3.2.11 Recommendation.— Where additional GM1 AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. obstacle data are collected to meet other aeronautical Where additional obstacle data are collected to requirements, the obstacle data sets should be expanded meet other aeronautical requirements, the obstacle to include these additional data. data sets should be expanded to include these additional data. 5.3.4 Aerodrome mapping data sets --- --- 5.3.4.1 Aerodrome mapping data sets shall contain the AIS.TR. 365 Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. digital representation of aerodrome features. (a) Aerodrome mapping data sets shall contain the digital representation of aerodrome features. Note 1.— Aerodrome features consist of attributes and GM1 AIS.TR. 365 Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. geometries, which are characterized as points, lines or Aerodrome features consist of attributes and polygons. Examples include runway thresholds, taxiway geometries, which are characterized as points, lines guidance lines and parking stand areas. or polygons. Examples include runway thresholds, taxiway guidance lines and parking stand areas. 5.3.4.2 Recommendation.— Aerodrome mapping data --- Not transposed. It is not considered to be a means sets should be provided for aerodromes regularly used of compliance in the context of the draft rules and by international civil aviation. not considered necessary to elevate it to a requirement. 5.3.5 Instrument flight procedure data sets --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 5.3.5.1 Instrument flight procedure data sets shall AIS.TR.370 Instrument flight procedure data sets Transposed. contain the digital representation of instrument flight (a) Instrument flight procedure data sets shall procedures. contain the digital representation of instrument flight procedures. Note. — The exact content of the instrument flight --- The reference to PANS-AIM is not relevant as the procedure data sets is specified in PANS-AIM. exact content of the instrument flight procedure data sets has been transposed in this NPA. 5.3.5.2 Recommendation. — Instrument flight --- Not transposed. It is not considered to be a means procedures data sets should be made available for of compliance in the context of the draft rules and aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation. not considered necessary to elevate it to a requirement. 5.4 Distribution services AIS.OR.400 Distribution services --- 5.4.1 General --- --- 5.4.1.1 Aeronautical Information Products shall be An aeronautical information services provider shall: Transposed. distributed to those users who requested them. (a) distribute aeronautical information products to those users who requested them. 5.4.1.2 AIP, AIP Amendments, AIP Supplements and AIC (b) make available AIP, AIP amendments, AIP Transposed. shall be made available by the most expeditious means. supplements and AIC by the most expeditious European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) means. 5.4.1.3 Recommendation. - Global communication --- Not transposed. networks and Web services shall, whenever practicable, The mean by which the provision is ensured is not be employed for the provision of Aeronautical considered necessary to transpose. Information Products. 5.4.2 NOTAM distribution --- -- 5.4.2.1 NOTAM shall be prepared in conformity with the --- This paragraph is not transposed as the AFS is relevant provisions of the ICAO communication required. procedures. 5.4.2.2 The AFS shall, whenever practicable, be AIS.OR.400 Distribution services Transposed. employed for NOTAM distribution. An aeronautical information services provider shall: (c) ensure that NOTAM are distributed through the aeronautical fix services, whenever practicable. 5.4.2.3 The originating State shall select the NOTAM that --- Not transposed. Covered by AIS.OR.400 and are to be given international distribution. AIS.TR.400 5.4.2.4 International exchange of NOTAM shall take place AIS.OR.330 NOTAM Transposed. only as mutually agreed between the international An aeronautical information services provider shall: NOTAM offices and multinational NOTAM Processing Units concerned. (c) ensure that international exchange of NOTAM European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) takes place only as mutually agreed between the international NOTAM offices and multinational NOTAM processing units concerned. 5.4.2.5 The Originating State shall upon request grant --- Covered by AIS.OR.400 and AIS.TR.400 distribution of NOTAM series other than those distributed internationally. 5.4.2.6 Recommendation.— Selective distribution list GM1 AIS.OR.400(d) Distribution services Transposed. should be used when practicable. DISTIBUTION OF NOTAM Selective distribution list should be used when practicable. Note.— Guidance material relating to this is contained in --- As the reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made several the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc times throughout the ICAO Annex 15 (and PANS- 8126). AIM), A general reference in the introduction of the AMC/GM is made underlining that when never deemed suitable, rules may be supported by the material contained in this ICAO document. This will avoid repeating several GM referring to Doc 8126. 5.5 Pre-Flight Information Service AIS.OR.405 Pre-flight information services --- 5.5.1 For any aerodrome/heliport used for international An aeronautical information services provider shall Transposed. air operations, aeronautical information relative to the ensure that: route stages originating at the aerodrome/heliport shall European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) be made available to flight operations personnel, (a) for any aerodrome/heliport regularly used by including flight crews and services responsible for pre- international civil aviation, aeronautical flight information. information relative to the route stages originating at the aerodrome/heliport is made available to flight operations personnel, including flight crews and services responsible for pre-flight information; and 5.5.2 Aeronautical information provided for pre-flight (b) aeronautical information provided for pre-flight Transposed. planning purposes shall include information of planning purposes includes information of operational significance from the elements of the operational significance from the elements of the Aeronautical Information Products. aeronautical information products. Note 1.— The elements of the Aeronautical Information --- Not transposed. Products may be limited to national publications and when practicable, those of immediately adjacent States, provided a complete library of aeronautical information is available at a central location and means of direct communications are available with that library. Note 2.— A recapitulation of valid NOTAM of operational GM1 to Annex VI – Part-AIS Transposed. significance and other information of urgent character DOC 8126 can be made available to flight crews in the form of plain-language pre-flight information bulletins (PIB). Guidance material on the organization and Guidance on the preparation of PIB is contained in the operation of aeronautical information services is Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc 8126). contained in the Aeronautical Information Services European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Manual (ICAO Doc 8126). 5.6 Post-flight information Service --- Post-flight information is not transposed as it is not a requirement put on AIS providers. 5.6.1 For any aerodrome/heliport used for international --- Post-flight information is not transposed as it is not air operations, arrangements shall be made to receive a requirement put on AIS providers. information concerning the state and operation of air navigation facilities or services noted by aircrews. 5.6.2 The arrangements specified in 5.6.1 shall ensure --- Post-flight information is not transposed as it is not that such information is made available to the a requirement put on AIS providers. aeronautical information service for distribution as the circumstances necessitate. 5.6.3 For any aerodrome/heliport used for international --- Post-flight information is not transposed as it is not air operations, arrangements shall be made to receive a requirement put on AIS providers. information concerning the presence of wildlife hazard observed by aircrews. 5.6.4 The information about presence of wildlife hazard --- Post-flight information is not transposed as it is not shall be made available to the aeronautical information a requirement put on AIS providers. service for distribution as the circumstances necessitate. Note.— See Annex 14, Volume I, Chapter 9, Section 9.4. --- Not transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) CHAPTER 6. AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION UPDATES Section 5 Aeronautical information products --- updates 6.1 General specifications AIS.OR.500 General --- 6.1.1 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information An aeronautical information services provider shall Transposed. shall be amended or reissued to be kept up to date. ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are amended or reissued to keep them up to date. 6.2 Aeronautical Information Regulation and Control AIS.OR.505 AIRAC --- (AIRAC) 6.2.1 Information concerning the following (a) An aeronautical information services provider Transposed. circumstances shall be distributed under the regulated shall ensure that information concerning the system (AIRAC), i.e. basing establishment, withdrawal or following circumstances is distributed under the significant changes upon a series of common effective AIRAC system - i.e. basing establishment, withdrawal dates at intervals of 28 days, including 14 January 2010: or significant changes upon a series of common effective dates at intervals of 28 days, including [XX/XX/2016]: a) Limits (horizontal and vertical), regulations and (1) Horizontal and vertical limits, regulations and Transposed. procedures applicable to: procedures applicable to: 1) flight information regions; (i) flight information regions; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 2) control areas; (ii) control areas; 3) control zones; (iii) control zones; 4) advisory areas; (iv) advisory areas; 5) ATS routes; (v) ATS routes; 6) permanent danger, prohibited and restricted areas (vi) permanent danger, prohibited and restricted (including type and periods of activity when known) and areas (including type and periods of activity when ADIZ; known) and ADIZ; 7) permanent areas or routes or portions thereof where (vii) permanent areas or routes or portions thereof the possibility of interception exists. where the possibility of interception exists. b) Positions, frequencies, call signs, identifiers, known (2) Positions, frequencies, call signs, identifiers, Transposed. irregularities and maintenance periods of radio known irregularities and maintenance periods of navigation aids, and communication and surveillance radio navigation aids, and communication and facilities. surveillance facilities. c) Holding and approach procedures, arrival and (3) Holding and approach procedures, arrival and Transposed. departure procedures, noise abatement procedures and departure procedures, noise abatement procedures any other pertinent ATS procedures. and any other pertinent ATS procedures. d) Transition levels, transition altitudes and minimum (4) Transition levels, transition altitudes and Transposed. sector altitudes. minimum sector altitudes. e) Meteorological facilities (including broadcasts) and (5) Meteorological facilities (including broadcasts) Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) procedures. and procedures. f) Runways and stopways. (6) Runways and stopways. Transposed. g) Taxiways and aprons. (7) Taxiways and aprons. Transposed. h) Aerodrome ground operating procedures (including (8) Aerodrome ground operating procedures Transposed. low visibility procedures). (including low visibility procedures). i) Approach and runway lighting. (9) Approach and runway lighting. Transposed. j) Aerodrome operating minima if published by a State. (10) Aerodrome operating minima if published by a Transposed. State. 6.2.2 The information notified under the AIRAC system (b) An aeronautical information services provider Transposed. shall not be changed further for at least another 28 days shall ensure that: after the effective date, unless the circumstance notified (1) the information notified under the AIRAC system is of a temporary nature and would not persist for the is not changed further for at least another 28 days full period. after the effective date, unless the circumstance notified is of a temporary nature and would not persist for the full period; 6.2.3 Information provided under the AIRAC system shall (2) the information provided under the AIRAC Transposed. be distributed/made available by the AIS so as to reach system is distributed/made available so as to reach recipients at least 28 days in advance of the AIRAC recipients at least 28 days in advance of the AIRAC European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) effective date. effective date; 6.2.4 When information has not been submitted by the (3) when information has not been submitted under Transposed. AIRAC date, a NIL notification shall be distributed not the AIRAC system, a NIL notification is distributed by later than one cycle before the AIRAC effective date the NOTAM checklist not later than one cycle before concerned. the AIRAC effective date concerned; 6.2.5 Implementation dates other than AIRAC effective (4) implementation dates other than AIRAC effective Transposed. dates shall not be used for pre-planned operationally dates are not used for pre-planned operationally significant changes requiring cartographic work and/or significant changes requiring cartographic work for updating of navigation databases. and/or for updating of navigation databases. 6.2.6 Recommendation.— The regulated system (AIRAC) GM2 AIS.OR.505(a) AIRAC Transposed. should also be used for the provision of information USE OF AIRAC SYSTEM relating to the establishment and withdrawal of, and premeditated significant changes in, the circumstances The AIRAC may be used for the provision of listed below: information relating to the establishment and a) Position, height and lighting of navigational obstacles. withdrawal of, and premeditated significant changes in, the circumstances listed below: b) Hours of service of aerodromes, facilities and services. (a) Position, height and lighting of navigational c) Customs, immigration and health services. obstacles. d) Temporary danger, prohibited and restricted areas (b) Hours of service of aerodromes, facilities and and navigational hazards, military exercises and mass services. movements of aircraft. (c) Customs, immigration and health services. e) Temporary areas or routes or portions thereof where (d) Temporary danger, prohibited and restricted European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) the possibility of interception exists. areas and navigational hazards, military exercises and mass movements of aircraft. (e) Temporary areas or routes or portions thereof where the possibility of interception exists. 6.2.7 Recommendation.— Whenever major changes are GM3 AIS.OR.505(a) AIRAC Transposed. planned and where advance notice is desirable and ADVANCE NOTIFICATION OF MAJOR CHANGES possible, information should be distributed/made available by the AIS so as to reach recipients at least 56 Whenever major changes are planned and where days in advance of the AIRAC effective date. This should advance notice is desirable and possible, information be applied to the establishment of, and premeditated may be distributed and/or made available by the major changes in, the circumstances listed below, and aeronautical information services provider, other major changes if deemed necessary. whenever practicable, so as to reach recipients at a) New aerodromes for international IFR operations. least 56 days in advance of the AIRAC effective date. This may apply to the establishment of, and b) New runways for IFR operations at international premeditated major changes in the circumstances aerodromes. listed below, and other major changes if deemed c) Design and structure of the air traffic services route necessary: network. (a) New aerodromes for international IFR d) Design and structure of a set of terminal procedures operations; (including change of procedure bearings due to magnetic (b) New runways for IFR operations at international variation change). aerodromes; e) Circumstances listed in 6.2.1 if the entire State or any (c) Design and structure of the ATS route network; significant portion thereof is affected or if cross-border (d) Design and structure of a set of terminal European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) coordination is required. procedures (including change of procedure bearings due to magnetic variation change); (e) Circumstances listed in AIS.OR.505(a)(10) if the entire State or any significant portion thereof is affected or if cross-border coordination is required. Note. — Guidance on what constitutes a major change is --- The reference to PANS-AIM is not relevant as it has included in PANS-AIM. been transposed in this NPA. 6.3 Aeronautical Information Product updates --- --- 6.3.1 AIP updates --- --- 6.3.1.1 AIP shall be amended or reissued at such regular AIS.OR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. intervals as may be necessary to keep them up to date. An aeronautical information services provider shall: (b) ensure that the AIP is amended or re-issued at such regular intervals as necessary to ensure the information is complete and up to date. 6.3.1.2 Permanent changes to the AIP shall be published AIS.OR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. as AIP Amendments. An aeronautical information services provider shall: (a) provide permanent changes to the AIP as AIP Amendments. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 6.3.1.3 Temporary changes of long duration (three AIS.OR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. months or longer) and information of short duration An aeronautical information services provider shall: which contains extensive text and/or graphics shall be published as AIP Supplements. (a) issue temporary changes of long duration - three months or longer - and information of short duration which contains extensive text and/or graphics as AIP Supplements. 6.3.2 NOTAM AIS.OR.510 NOTAM updates --- 6.3.2.1 When an AIP Amendment or an AIP Supplement (b) An aeronautical information services provider Transposed. is published in accordance with AIRAC procedures, a shall provide a ‘Trigger’ NOTAM when an AIP “Trigger” NOTAM shall be provided giving a brief amendment or an AIP supplement is published in description of the contents. accordance with AIRAC procedures. 6.3.2.2 A NOTAM shall be originated and issued promptly AIS.OR.330 NOTAM Transposed. whenever the information to be distributed is of a An aeronautical information services provider shall: temporary nature and of short duration or when operationally significant permanent changes, or (a) originate and issue promptly a NOTAM whenever temporary changes of long duration are made at short the information to be distributed is of a temporary notice, except for extensive text and/or graphics. nature and of short duration or when operationally significant permanent changes, or temporary changes of long duration are made at short notice, except for extensive text and/or graphics; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) 6.3.2.3 A NOTAM shall be originated and provided AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. concerning the following information: A NOTAM shall not contain the following a) establishment, closure or significant changes in information: operation of aerodrome(s) or heliport(s) or runways; (1) establishment, closure or significant changes in b) establishment, withdrawal and significant changes in operation of aerodrome(s) or heliport(s) or runways; operation of aeronautical services (AGA, AIS, ATS, CNS, (2) establishment, withdrawal and significant MET, SAR, etc.); changes in operation of aeronautical services, such c) establishment, withdrawal and significant changes in as AGA, AIS, ATS, CNS, MET, SAR, etc.; operational capability of radio navigation and air-ground (3) establishment, withdrawal and significant communication services. This includes: interruption or changes in operational capability of radio navigation return to operation, change of frequencies, change in and air-ground communication services; notified hours of service, change of identification, change of orientation (directional aids), change of location, (4) unavailability of back-up and secondary systems, power increase or decrease amounting to 50 per cent or having a direct operational impact; more, change in broadcast schedules or contents, or (5) establishment, withdrawal or significant changes irregularity or unreliability of operation of any radio made to visual aids; navigation and air-ground communication services or limitations of relay stations including operational impact, (6) interruption of or return to operation of major affected service, frequency and area; components of aerodrome lighting systems; d) unavailability of back-up and secondary systems, (7) establishment, withdrawal or significant changes having a direct operational impact; made to procedures for air navigation services; e) establishment, withdrawal or significant changes (8) occurrence or correction of major defects or made to visual aids; impediments in the manoeuvring area; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) f) interruption of or return to operation of major (9) changes to and limitations on availability of fuel, components of aerodrome lighting systems; oil and oxygen; g) establishment, withdrawal or significant changes (10) major changes to search and rescue facilities made to procedures for air navigation services; and services available; h) occurrence or correction of major defects or (11) establishment, withdrawal or return to impediments in the manoeuvring area; operation of hazard beacons marking obstacles to air navigation; i) changes to and limitations on availability of fuel, oil and oxygen; (12) changes in regulations requiring immediate action; j) major changes to search and rescue facilities and services available; (13) presence of hazards which affect air navigation; k) establishment, withdrawal or return to operation of (14) planned laser emissions, laser displays and hazard beacons marking obstacles to air navigation; search lights if pilots night vision is likely to be impaired; l) changes in regulations requiring immediate action, e.g. prohibited areas for SAR action; (15) erecting or removal of, or changes to, obstacles to air navigation in the take-off/climb, missed m) presence of hazards which affect air navigation approach, approach areas and runway strip; (including obstacles, military exercises, displays, fireworks, sky lanterns, races and major parachuting (16) establishment or discontinuance, including events outside promulgated sites); activation or deactivation, as applicable, or changes in the status of prohibited, restricted or danger n) planned laser emissions, laser displays and search areas; lights if pilots night vision is likely to be impaired; (17) establishment or discontinuance of areas or o) erecting or removal of, or changes to, obstacles to air routes or portions thereof where the possibility of navigation in the take-off/climb, missed approach, European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) approach areas and runway strip; interception exists and where the maintenance of guard on the VHF emergency frequency 121.5 MHz p) establishment or discontinuance (including activation is required; or deactivation) as applicable, or changes in the status of prohibited, restricted or danger areas; (18) allocation, cancellation or change of location indicators; q) establishment or discontinuance of areas or routes or portions thereof where the possibility of interception (19) changes in aerodrome/heliport rescue and exists and where the maintenance of guard on the VHF firefighting category; emergency frequency 121.5 MHz is required; (20) presence or removal of, or significant changes r) allocation, cancellation or change of location in, hazardous conditions due to snow, slush, ice, indicators; radioactive material, toxic chemicals, volcanic ash deposition or water on the movement area; s) changes in aerodrome/heliport rescue and fire fighting category provided (see Annex 14, Volume I, (21) outbreaks of epidemics necessitating changes in Chapter 9, and Attachment A, Section 17); notified requirements for inoculations and quarantine measures; t) presence or removal of, or significant changes in, hazardous conditions due to snow, slush, ice, radioactive (22) forecasts of solar cosmic radiation, where material, toxic chemicals, volcanic ash deposition or provided; water on the movement area; (23) an operationally significant change in volcanic u) outbreaks of epidemics necessitating changes in activity, the location, date and time of volcanic notified requirements for inoculations and quarantine eruptions and/or horizontal and vertical extent of measures; volcanic ash cloud, including direction of movement, flight levels and routes or portions of routes which v) forecasts of solar cosmic radiation, where provided; could be affected; w) an operationally significant change in volcanic (24) release into the atmosphere of radioactive European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) activity, the location, date and time of volcanic eruptions materials or toxic chemicals following a nuclear or and/or horizontal and vertical extent of volcanic ash chemical incident, the location, date and time of the cloud, including direction of movement, flight levels and incident, the flight levels and routes or portions routes or portions of routes which could be affected; thereof which could be affected and the direction of movement; x) release into the atmosphere of radioactive materials or toxic chemicals following a nuclear or chemical (25) establishment of operations of humanitarian incident, the location, date and time of the incident, the relief missions, together with procedures and/or flight levels and routes or portions thereof which could limitations which affect air navigation; be affected and the direction of movement; (26) implementation of short-term contingency y) establishment of operations of humanitarian relief measures in cases of disruption, or partial missions, such as those undertaken under the auspices of disruption, of air traffic services and related the United Nations, together with procedures and/or supporting services; and limitations which affect air navigation; and (27) specific loss of satellite based navigation z) implementation of short-term contingency measures systems integrity. in cases of disruption, or partial disruption, of air traffic services and related supporting services. aa) specific loss of satellite based navigation systems integrity. Note.— See Annex 11, 2.28 and Attachment D to that --- This Note is not considered to constitute necessary Annex. material to understand the rule. 6.3.2.4 The following information shall not be notified by AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. NOTAM: A NOTAM shall not contain the following European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) information: a) routine maintenance work on aprons and taxiways (1) routine maintenance work on aprons and which does not affect the safe movement of aircraft; taxiways which does not affect the safe movement of aircraft; b) runway marking work, when aircraft operations can safely be conducted on other available runways, or the (2) runway marking work, when aircraft operations equipment used can be removed when necessary; can safely be conducted on other available runways, or the equipment used can be removed when c) temporary obstructions in the vicinity of necessary; aerodromes/heliports that do not affect the safe operation of aircraft; (3) temporary obstructions in the vicinity of aerodromes/heliports that do not affect the safe d) partial failure of aerodrome/heliport lighting facilities operation of aircraft; where such failure does not directly affect aircraft operations; (4) partial failure of aerodrome/heliport lighting facilities where such failure does not directly affect e) partial temporary failure of air-ground aircraft operations; communications when suitable alternative frequencies are available and are operative; (5) partial temporary failure of air-ground communications when suitable alternative f) the lack of apron marshalling services and road traffic frequencies are available and are operative; closures, limitations and control; (6) the lack of apron marshalling services and road g) the unserviceability of location, destination or other traffic closures, limitations and control; instruction signs on the aerodrome movement area; (7) the unserviceability of location, destination or h) parachuting when in uncontrolled airspace under VFR other instruction signs on the aerodrome movement (see 5.1.1.1 l)), when controlled, at promulgated sites or area; within danger or prohibited areas; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) i) training activities by ground units; (8) parachuting when in uncontrolled airspace under VFR, when controlled, at promulgated sites or within j) unavailability of back-up and secondary systems if danger or prohibited areas; these do not have an operational impact; (9) training activities by ground units; k) limitations to airport facilities or general services with no operational impact; (10) unavailability of back-up and secondary systems if these do not have an operational impact; l) national regulations not affecting general aviation; (11) limitations to airport facilities or general m) announcement or warnings about possible/potential services with no operational impact; limitations, without any operational impact; (12) national regulations not affecting general n) general reminders on already published information; aviation; o) availability of equipment for ground units without (13) announcement or warnings about containing information on the operational impact for possible/potential limitations, without any airspace and facility users; operational impact; p) information about laser emissions without any (14) general reminders on already published operational impact and fireworks below minimum flying information; heights; (15) availability of equipment for ground units q) closure of movement area parts in connection with without containing information on the operational planned work locally coordinated of duration of less than impact for airspace and facility users; one hour; (16) information about laser emissions without any r) closure, changes, unavailability in operation of operational impact and fireworks below minimum aerodrome(s)/heliport(s) other than flying heights; aerodrome(s)/heliport(s) operation hours. (17) closure of movement area parts in connection European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) s) other non-operational information of a similar with planned work locally coordinated of duration temporary nature. of less than one hour; (18) closure, changes, unavailability in operation of aerodrome(s)/heliport(s) other than aerodrome(s)/heliport(s) operation hours; and (19) other non-operational information of a similar temporary nature. Note.— Information which relates to an aerodrome and --- Not transposed. its vicinity and does not affect its operational status may be distributed locally during pre-flight or in-flight briefing or other local contact with flight crew members. 6.3.3 Data set updates AIS.OR.515 Digital data updates --- 6.3.3.1 Data sets shall be amended or reissued at such An aeronautical information services provider shall: Transposed. regular intervals as may be necessary to keep them up to (a) amend or reissue data sets at such regular date. intervals as may be necessary to keep them up to date. 6.3.3.2 Permanent changes and temporary changes of (b) issue permanent changes and temporary changes Transposed. long duration (three months or longer) made available as of long duration - three months or longer - made digital data shall be issued in the form of a complete data available as digital data in the form of a complete set and/or a sub-set that includes only the differences data set and/or a sub-set that includes only the differences from the previously issued complete European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) from the previously issued complete data set. data set. 6.3.3.3 Recommendation. - When made available as a AMC1 AIS.OR.515 Digital data updates Transposed. completely re-issued data set, the differences from the GENERAL previously issued complete data set should be indicated. (a) When made available as a completely re-issued data set, the differences from the previously issued complete data set should be indicated. 6.3.3.4 Recommendation. - When temporary changes of (b) When temporary changes of short duration are Transposed. short duration are made available as digital data (Digital made available as digital data, they should use the NOTAM), they should use the same aeronautical same aeronautical information model as the information model as the complete data set. complete data set. 6.3.3.5 Updates to AIP, Aeronautical (AIP) data sets and AIS.OR.515 Digital data updates Transposed. Instrument Flight Procedures data sets shall be (c) synchronise updates to AIP, AIP data sets and synchronised. instrument flight procedures data sets. APPENDIX 1. TERRAIN AND OBSTACLE DATA AIS.TR.350 Terrain and Obstacle data – general Transposed. REQUIREMENTS requirements The Note is not considered necessary. (see Chapter 5) The coverage areas for sets of electronic terrain and obstacle data shall be specified as: 1. The coverage areas for sets of terrain and obstacle data shall be specified as: (a) area 1: the entire territory of a State; — Area 1: the entire territory of a State; (b) area 2: within the vicinity of an aerodrome, European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) — Area 2: within the vicinity of an aerodrome, subdivided as follows: subdivided as follows; (1) area 2a: a rectangular area around a runway — Area 2a: a rectangular area around a runway that that comprises the runway strip plus any comprises the runway strip plus any clearway that exists. clearway that exists; Note.— See Annex 14, Volume I, Chapter 3, for (2) area 2b: an area extending from the ends of dimensions for runway strip. area 2a in the direction of departure, with a length of 10 km and a splay of 15 % to each — Area 2b: an area extending from the ends of Area 2a side; in the direction of departure, with a length of 10 km and a splay of 15 per cent to each side; (3) area 2c: an area extending outside areas 2a and 2b at a distance of not more than 10 km — Area 2c: an area extending outside Area 2a and Area from the boundary of area 2a; and 2b at a distance of not more than 10 km from the boundary of Area 2a; and (4) area 2d: an area outside areas 2a, 2b and 2c up to a distance of 45 km from the — Area 2d: an area outside the Areas 2a, 2b and 2c up to aerodrome reference point, or to an existing a distance of 45 km from the aerodrome reference point, TMA boundary, whichever is nearest; or to an existing TMA boundary, whichever is nearest; (c) area 3: the area bordering an aerodrome — Area 3: the area bordering an aerodrome movement movement area that extends horizontally from area that extends horizontally from the edge of a runway the edge of a runway to 90 m from the runway to 90 m from the runway centre line and 50 m from the centre line and 50 m from the edge of all other edge of all other parts of the aerodrome movement area. parts of the aerodrome movement area; and — Area 4: The area extending 900 m prior to the runway (d) area 4: the area extending 900 m prior to the threshold and 60 m each side of the extended runway runway threshold and 60 m each side of the centre line in the direction of the approach on a extended runway centre line in the direction of European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) precision approach runway, Category II or III. the approach on a precision approach runway, category II or III. Recommendation. — Where the terrain at a distance AMC1 AIS.TR.350 Terrain and Obstacle data – Transposed. greater than 900 m (3 000 ft) from the runway threshold general requirements is mountainous or otherwise significant, the length of Where the terrain at a distance greater than 900 m Area 4 should be extended to a distance not exceeding 2 (3 000 ft) from the runway threshold is mountainous 000 m (6 500 ft) from the runway threshold. or otherwise significant, the length of Area 4 should be extended to a distance not exceeding 2 000 m (6 500 ft) from the runway threshold. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) [This graphic has been reproduced in AIS.TR.355 Transposed. Terrain data sets] AREA 1 Flight operations prohibited AREA 2 (TMA or 45 km) ARP m 10 k km 45 TMA Terrain data collection surface 120 m 120 m ARP Terrain data collected with Area 1 numerical requirements Terrain data collected with Area 2 numerical requirements European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Figure A1-1. Terrain data collection surfaces — Area 1 AIS.TR.355 Terrain data sets Transposed. and Area 2 (g) Within the area covered by a 10-km radius from 1. Within the area covered by a 10-km radius from the ARP, terrain data shall comply with the area 2 the ARP, terrain data shall comply with the Area 2 numerical requirements. numerical requirements. (h) In the area between 10 km and the TMA 2. In the area between 10 km and the TMA boundary or 45-km radius (whichever is smaller), boundary or 45-km radius (whichever is smaller), data on data on terrain that penetrates the horizontal plane terrain that penetrates the horizontal plane 120 m above 120 m above the lowest runway elevation shall the lowest runway elevation shall comply with the Area 2 comply with the area 2 numerical requirements. numerical requirements. (i) In the area between 10 km and the TMA 3. In the area between 10 km and the TMA boundary or 45-km radius (whichever is smaller), boundary or 45-km radius (whichever is smaller), data on data on terrain that does not penetrate the terrain that does not penetrate the horizontal plane 120 horizontal plane 120 m above the lowest runway m above the lowest runway elevation shall comply with elevation shall comply with the area 1 numerical the Area 1 numerical requirements. requirements. 4. In those portions of Area 2 where flight (j) In those portions of area 2 where flight operations are prohibited due to very high terrain or operations are prohibited due to very high terrain or other local restrictions and/or regulations, terrain data other local restrictions and/or regulations, terrain shall comply with the Area 1 numerical requirements. data shall comply with the area 1 numerical requirements. Note.— Terrain data numerical requirements for Areas 1 and 2 are specified in PANS-AIM, Table A1-6. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) B [This graphic has been reproduced in AIS.TR.360 Transposed. Obstacle data sets] AREA 1 Area 2d TMA max to 45 km Flight operations prohibited 45 Area 2c k m Area 2a CWY CWY Area 2b Area 2b A ARP 10 km Area 2c TMA Section A-A′ B′ 100 m Obstacle data collection surface 3m 1.2 % % 100 m 1 .2 3m 3m CWY CWY Section B-B′ ARP 100 m Obstacle data collection surface 1.2 % % 1.2 100 m 15 m 3m 15 m ARP European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Figure A1-2. Obstacle data collection surfaces — Area 1 AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data sets and Area 2 1. Obstacle data shall be collected and recorded in (c) Obstacle data for area 2 and 3 shall be collected Transposed. accordance with the Area 2 numerical requirements in accordance with the following obstacle collection The deleted texts are already covered under specified in Table A8-2: surfaces: AIS.TR.350 Terrain and Obstacle data – general a) Area 2a: a rectangular area around a runway that (1) the area 2a obstacle collection surface has a requirements, and therefore not necessary to comprises the runway strip plus any clearway that exists. height of 3 m above the nearest runway duplicate. The Area 2a obstacle collection surface shall have height elevation measured along the runway centre of 3 m above the nearest runway elevation measured line, and for those portions related to a along the runway centre line, and for those portions clearway, if one exists, at the elevation of the related to a clearway, if one exists, at the elevation of nearest runway end; the nearest runway end; (2) the area 2b obstacle collection surface has a b) Area 2b: an area extending from the ends of Area 2a in 1.2% slope extending from the ends of area 2a the direction of departure, with a length of 10 km and a at the elevation of the runway end in the splay of 15% to each side. The Area 2b obstacle direction of departure, with a length of 10 km collection surface has a 1.2% slope extending from the and a splay of 15% to each side. Obstacles less ends of Area 2a at the elevation of the runway end in the than 3 m in height above ground need not be direction of departure, with a length of 10 km and a splay collected; of 15% to each side. Obstacles less than 3 m in height (3) the area 2c obstacle collection surface has a above ground need not be collected; 1.2% slope extending outside areas 2a and 2b at c) Area 2c: an area extending outside Area 2a and Area a distance of not more than 10 km from the 2b at a distance of not more than 10 km from the boundary of area 2a. The initial elevation of area boundary of Area 2a. The Area 2c obstacle collection 2c shall be the elevation of the point of area 2a European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) surface has a 1.2% slope extending outside Area 2a and at which it commences. Obstacles less than 15 m Area 2b at a distance of not more than 10 km from the in height above ground need not be collected; boundary of Area 2a. The initial elevation of Area 2c shall and be the elevation of the point of Area 2a at which it (4) the area 2d obstacle collection surface has a commences. Obstacles less than 15 m in height above height of 100 m above ground; and ground need not be collected; and d) Area 2d: an area outside the Areas 2a, 2b and 2c up to a distance of 45 km from the aerodrome reference point, or to an existing TMA boundary, whichever is nearest. The Area 2d obstacle collection surface has a height of 100 m above ground. 2. In those portions of Area 2 where flight operations are AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. prohibited due to very high terrain or other local (d) In those portions of area 2 where flight restrictions and/or regulations, obstacle data shall be operations are prohibited due to very high terrain or collected and recorded in accordance with the Area 1 other local restrictions and/or regulations, obstacle requirements. data shall be collected and recorded in accordance with the area 1 requirements. 3. Data on every obstacle within Area 1 whose height --- Covered in the data catalogue. above the ground is 100 m or higher shall be collected and recorded in the database in accordance with the Area 1 numerical requirements specified in PANS-AIM Table A1-8. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) --- This figure is not transposed as it is considered not required to understand the related requirements. 90 m R AREA 3 BOR 116.9 60 TWY 60 E TWY E AREA 3 TWY 50 m D Hangar TWY H ARP TWR Terminal H TWY and AIS C CUST MET ABN TWY FI W F TWY G TWY G TWY U/S TWY A F TWY TWY 27 F B L AREA 3 BOR 116.9 TWY A TWY A 27 R European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Figure A1-3. Terrain and obstacle data collection surface — Area 3 1. The data collection surface for terrain and AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. obstacles extends a half-metre (0.5 m) above the (c) (5) The area 3 obstacle collection surface extends horizontal plane passing through the nearest point on a half-metre (0.5 m) above the horizontal plane the aerodrome movement area. passing through the nearest point on the aerodrome movement area. 2. Terrain and obstacle data in Area 3 shall comply --- Covered by the data catalogue with the numerical requirements specified in PANS-AIM, Table A1-6 and PANS-AIM, Table A1-8, respectively. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) --- This figure is not transposed as it is considered not required to understand the related requirements. AREA 4 (120 x 900 m) R BOR 116.9 60 L TWY CAT II/III RWY E TWY E TWY D TWY Hangar H ARP TWR Terminal TWY and H C CUST AIS MET TWY ABN F FI W TWY G TWY G TWY U/S TWY A F TWY 27 TWY B F L BOR 116.9 TWY A TWY 27 A R European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO Annex 15 NPA Text Justification (upcoming proposed amendment) Figure A1-4. Terrain and obstacle data collection --- Covered by the data catalogue. surface — Area 4 Terrain and obstacle data in Area 4 shall comply with the numerical requirements specified in Table A8-1 and Table A8-2 respectively. Note.— Area 4 may be extended in accordance with 10.1.2. ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) ---- --- The term ‘transposed’ means that the substance of the ICAO provisions is not changed, although, in some cases, some editorial revisions may have been applied. ---- NOTE1: When reference is made to Annex III to Regulation ../.., it refers to Part-ATM/ANS.OR in draft Regulation laying down technical requirements and administrative procedures related to service providers and the oversight thereof, still to be adopted. NOTE 2: When reference is made to Appendix 1 to Article 3, it refers to the Appendix on requirements for aviation undertakings that is linked to Article 3.1 to Regulation laying down technical requirements and administrative procedures related to service providers and the oversight thereof, still to be adopted. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) CHAPTER 2. AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION --- --- MANAGEMENT 2.1 Information management requirements --- --- Management of aeronautical data and aeronautical Transposed as explanatory material to Article 3.1 of GM1 Article 3(1) Provision of services information shall be carried out to include the following draft Regulation laying down common handling processes: Management of aeronautical data and aeronautical requirements for service providers and the - collection information shall be carried out to include the oversight in air traffic management and air - processing following handling processes: navigation services and other air traffic - quality control - collection management network functions. - processing - quality control 2.1.1 Collection --- --- 2.1.1.1 The identification of the data originator (or of the GM1 Article 3(1) Provision of services Transposed as explanatory material to Article 3.1 of relevant intermediate entity responsible for delivering The identification of the data originator (or of the draft Regulation laying down common data to AIS) shall be documented taking into account the relevant intermediate entity responsible for requirements for service providers and the scope of aeronautical data and aeronautical information delivering data to AIS) shall be documented taking oversight in air traffic management and air to be collected. into account the scope of aeronautical data and navigation services and other air traffic aeronautical information to be collected. management network functions. 2.1.1.2 A record of data originators should be GM1 Article 3(1) Provision of services Transposed as explanatory material to Article 3.1 of maintained. A record of data originators should be maintained. draft Regulation laying down common requirements for service providers and the oversight in air traffic management and air navigation services and other air traffic management network functions. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note. — Metadata requirements in Chapter 4 specify --- Not transposed. which information is to be recorded for each originator 2.1.1.3 Each data element to be collected should be GM1 Article 3(1) Provision of services Transposed as explanatory material to Article 3.1 of mapped to an identified data originator, in accordance Each data element to be collected should be draft Regulation laying down common with the formal arrangements established between data mapped to an identified data originator, in requirements for service providers and the originators and AIS. accordance with the formal arrangements oversight in air traffic management and air established between data originators and AIS. navigation services and other air traffic management network functions. 2.1.1.4 The list of aeronautical information subjects and --- Not transposed. Formal arrangements their properties contained in Appendix 1 and Appendix 2 requirements are foresee between the relevant should be used for establishing the formal arrangements organisations involved in the origination and between originators and aeronautical information provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical services. information. 2.1.1.5 The valid codes for the properties or sub- --- Not transposed. properties of type code list should be defined in the formal arrangements between originator of the data and the aeronautical information service. 2.1.1.6 Appendix 1 and Appendix 2 shall be considered --- Not transposed. It is already mentioned in the data as a reference for aeronautical data and aeronautical catalogue information origination and publication requirements. Note 1. - Appendix 1 and Appendix 2 present the scope of The Data catalogue presents the scope of data that Transposed in: data and information that can be collected and can be collected and maintained by the aeronautical maintained by the Aeronautical Information Service information service providers and provides a  Appendix 1 to Article 3 European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note 2. - Appendix 1 and Appendix 2 provide a common common terminology that can be used by data  GM1 AIS.OR.200 language that can be used by data originators and AIS; originators and service providers.  GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(a) 2.1.2 Processing --- --- 2.1.2.1 Collected data shall be verified and validated for ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and Transposed. compliance with completeness, format, timeliness, aeronautical information traceability and data quality requirements. When originating, processing or transmitting data to the aeronautical information services provider, service providers shall: (h) ensure that validation and verification techniques are employed throughout the aeronautical data processing chain to ensure that the aeronautical data meets the associated data quality requirements, and […] AIS.OR.220 Verification and validation process An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that verification and validation techniques are employed so that the aeronautical data meets the data quality requirements specified in AIS.TR.200. Appendix 1 to Article 3 6. Data verification and validation European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) When using aeronautical data to derive or calculate new aeronautical data, the initial data shall be verified and validated, except when provided by an authoritative source. Note 1. — Appendix 1 contains aeronautical data --- This Note is not considered necessary to transpose. attributes, metadata, and accuracy requirements. Note 2. — Guidance material on the aeronautical data --- Guidance on WGS-84 is provided, based on the quality requirements (accuracy, resolution, integrity), EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of traceability and protection requirements may be foun Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material d in the World Geodetic System — 1984 (WGS- (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, edition 1.0 of 84) Manual (Doc 9674). 04/02/2013) Note 3. — --- Not transposed. The NPA makes reference to ED- Supporting data quality material in respect of data a 76A ‘Standards for processing aeronautical data’, ccuracy, publication resolution, and integrity of which contains sufficient material with regard to aeronautical data, together with guidance material in data quality. respect to the rounding convention for aeronautical data, is contained in RTCA Document DO-201A and European Organization for Civil Aviation Equipment (EUROCAE) Document ED-77 — Standards for Aeronautical Information (or equivalent). Note 4. — Guidance material on the management of --- Not transposed. aeronautical data quality is included in the Manual on ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 on management system the Quality Management System for Aeronautical contains sufficient guidance on the QMS. Information Services (Doc 9839). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note 5. — Verification activities may include: --- Not transposed. a) Comparison processes in which data and information are compared with an independant source; However, similar guidance material based on ED- b) Feedback processes in which data and information 76A on verification and validation processes are are compared between their input and output state; included in the NPA. c) Processing through multiple independent and different systems, comparing the output of each; this includes performing alternative calculations. d) Processes in which data and information are compared to the originator’s request; Note 6. — Validation activities may include: --- Not transposed. a) Application processes in which data and information are tested; However, similar guidance material based on ED- b) Processes in which data and information are 76A on verification and validation processes are compared between two different outputs, and; included in the NPA. c) Processes in which data and information are compared to an expected range, value or other business rules. 2.1.2.2 Automation systems implemented for processing AMC1 AIS.OR.200 General Transposed aeronautical data and aeronautical information should ensure traceability of the performed actions. (b) Automation systems implemented for processing aeronautical data and aeronautical information should ensure traceability of the performed actions. 2.1.3. Quality control --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note.— Error-producing faults in the entire process may --- Not transposed. be mitigated by additional data quality assurance techniques as may be required. These could include This paragraph is covered by the verification and application tests for critical data (for example, by flight validation processes. check); the use of security, logic, semantic, comparison, and redundancy checks; digital error detection; and the qualification of human resources and process tools such as hardware and software. 2.1.3.1 Quality checks should be implemented to ensure --- Not transposed. compliance with product specifications contained in Chapter 5 of PANS-AIM. This paragraph is covered by the verification and validation processes. 2.1.3.2 When the same data is duplicated in different AI --- Not transposed. products, coherency checks should be undertaken. This paragraph is covered by the verification and validation processes. 2.2 Data protection --- --- 2.2.1 Technical controls used to protect data integrity GM1 AIS.OR.220 Verification and validation Transposed. should be based on the use of systematic cycling codes process (e.g. cyclic redundancy check - CRC) or cryptographic technologies (e.g. hash functions, message (b) Digital error detection techniques can be used to authentication codes, symmetric and asymmetric detect errors during the transmission or storage of encryption, and digital certificates). data. An example of a digital error detection technique is the use of cyclic redundancy checks (CRCs). Coding techniques can be effective European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) regardless of the transmission media (e.g., computer disks, modem communication, or internet). GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(h) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information VALIDATION AND VERIFICATION […] (same text as above) Note.— Guidance material in respect of the processing of --- Not transposed. aeronautical data and aeronautical information is contained in RTCA Document DO-200B and European The guidance material on verification and Organization for Civil Aviation Equipment (EUROCAE) validation is based on the referred ED-76A. Document ED-76A — Standards for Processing Aeronautical Data. CHAPTER 3. QUALITY AND SAFETY MANAGEMENT --- --- 3.1 Quality management system --- --- In the framework of the quality management system, a --- Not transposed. user feedback system shall be defined and implemented. It is already covered by ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 Note 1. — Quality management may be provided by a --- Not transposed. single quality management system or a series of quality It is not considered relevant to specify this in the management systems. rules. Note 2. — International Organization for Standardization --- Transposed. (ISO) 9000 series of quality assurance standards provide It is already covered by AMC1 European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) a basic framework for the development of a quality ATM/ANS.OR.B.005(a) Management system. assurance programme. An ISO 9000 certificate issued by an accredited certification body is considered an acceptable means of compliance. Note 3. — Formal arrangements concerning data quality --- Not transposed. between originator and distributor and between It is already covered by the formal arrangements distributor and next intended user may be used to requirements throughout the NPA. manage the aeronautical information data chain. Note 4. — Guidance material concerning training GM1 AIS.OR.600 General requirements Transposed. methodology to ensure the competency of personnel is TRAINING contained in the Aeronautical Information Management Guidance material concerning training methodology Training Development Manual (Doc 9991). to ensure the competency of personnel is contained in the aeronautical information management training development manual (ICAO Doc 9991). 3.2 Safety management --- --- 3.2.1 Monitoring and measurement processes and --- Not transposed. procedures should be established in order to provide The safety policy is already covered by verification that safety performance complies with the ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 established safety policy and objectives. 3.2.2 Safety management activities --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 3.2.2.1 Assessment and mitigation of hazards and safety --- Not transposed. risks relating to AIM changes should include: The elements of the safety management are a) identifying potential and actual hazards as well as already covered by Appendix I of the AMC/GM associated safety risks related to AIM processes, related to Regulation (EU) No ../.. on ‘General procedures, resources and systems changes; guidance material related to changes to functional systems’ b) assessing and classifying the safety risks for acceptability; c) identifying and implementing mitigations to reduce safety risks to an acceptable level; and d) evaluating the mitigation measures to determine effectiveness in reducing the associated safety risk. 3.2.2.2 Voluntary confidential reporting procedures --- Not transposed. should be implemented where appropriate. Note 1.— Each State is encouraged to facilitate and --- Not transposed. promote the voluntary reporting of events that could Occurrence reporting requirements are put on affect aviation safety by adjusting their applicable laws, service providers in Annex III of Regulation (EU) ../.. regulations and policies. Note 2.— A non-punitive environment is fundamental to --- Not transposed. voluntary reporting. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 3.2.2.3 As a minimum, the following safety documents --- Not transposed. should be developed and maintained: The safety policy is already covered by a) The safety policy and objectives of the ATM/ANS.OR.B.005 organization; b) Responsibilities, authorities and accountabilities for safety related activities; and c) Records of identified safety risks, safety assessments performed and mitigations implemented. 3.3 Relationship between safety management and --- --- quality management Note 1.— The objective of quality management is to --- Not transposed. satisfy the needs of the users of a product or a service, whether they are expressed or implied. Safety is one of This Note is not considered necessary to the requirements relating to aeronautical information understand the requirements. management and aeronautical information services and products. Note 2.— Hence, safety management is that part of --- Not transposed. quality management that deals with the satisfaction of This Note is not considered necessary to the users’ requirement for safety. understand the requirements. Note 3.— Safety management activities can be --- Not transposed. embedded into a safety management system or exist as standalone activities. A safety management system can Guidance material on the relationship between European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) exist on its own or be part of a broader quality safety management system and quality management system which will then deal with all the management system are included in the related aspects of quality, including safety. AMC/GM to ATM/ANS.OR.B.005. Chapter 4 - AERONAUTICAL DATA REQUIREMENTS --- --- 4.1 Data Origination Requirements --- --- 4.1.1 Data shall be collected and transmitted to AIS in Appendix 1 to Article 3 Transposed. accordance with the accuracy requirements and integrity classification specified in Tables A1-1 to A1-8 of 4. Data catalogue Appendix 1. Aeronautical data shall be originated in accordance with the Data Catalogue specified in Appendix 1 of Subpart A of Annex III. 4.1.2 Positional data shall be classified as: surveyed --- Not transposed. points (e.g. navigation aids positions, runway threshold), calculated points (mathematical calculations from the This term is not used in the rules. known surveyed points of points in space, fixes) or declared points (e.g. flight information region boundary points). 4.1.3 Geographical coordinates indicating latitude and --- This paragraph is already covered in the rules longitude shall be determined and reported to the related to the common reference system. aeronautical information service in terms of the World Geodetic System — 1984 (WGS-84) geodetic reference datum. 4.1.4 Geographical coordinates which have been --- Already covered in AIS.TR.240 European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) transformed into WGS-84 coordinates by mathematical (An aeronautical information service provider shall means and whose accuracy of original field work does identify the aeronautical data and aeronautical not meet the applicable requirements contained in information that do not meet the data quality Appendix 1 shall be identified. requirements.) 4.2 Metadata Requirements --- --- 4.2.1 The metadata to be collected shall include, as a The metadata to be collected shall include, as a Transposed in: minimum: minimum: 1. the name of the organizations or entities performing (1) the identification of the organizations or entities — AIS.TR. 225 any action of originating, transmitting or manipulating performing any action of originating, transmitting or — ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 (e) the data; manipulating the data; — Appendix 1 to Article 3 (point 7) 2. the action performed; and (2) the action performed; and 3. the date and time the action was performed. (3) the date and time the action was performed. Note 1. — ISO standard 19115 specifies requirements for Further explanation on the schema required for Transposed in: Geographic information — metadata describing geographic information and services by — GM1 AIS.TR. 225 means of metadata may be found in the — GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(e) International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO — Appendix 1 to Article 3 (GM1 to point 7) 19115:2014 — Geographic information — Metadata, Part I. It provides information about the identification, the extent, the quality, the spatial and temporal aspects, the content, the spatial reference, the portrayal, distribution, and other properties of digital geographic data and services. CHAPTER 5 - AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION PRODUCTS --- --- AND SERVICES European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.1 General --- --- 5.1.1 Aeronautical data shall be provided in accordance --- Transposed. with the resolution requirements contained in Appendix The resolution requirements are covered in the 1. data catalogue. 5.1.2 The identification of geographical coordinates AIS.TR.240 Data limitations Transposed. whose accuracy does not meet the requirements may be The identification of data not meeting the data made either with an annotation or by explicitly providing quality requirements shall be made with an the actual accuracy value. annotation or by explicitly providing the quality value. 5.1.2.1 In aeronautical information products that are --- Not transposed a such as the identification of an distributed on paper, the identification should be done asterisk should not be ruled. Relevant guidance with an asterisk following the coordinate value material is proposed in GM1 AIS.TR.240 concerned. 5.2 Aeronautical information in a standardized --- --- presentation 5.2.1 Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP) --- --- 5.2.1.1 Contents --- --- 5.2.1.1.1 The AIP shall contain information relating to, AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication The first sentence is transposed. and arranged under, the subject headings listed in, (AIP) The second sentence is not transposed as Appendix 3. This facilitates both the locating of reference is made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already information under a specific heading and the (c) The AIP shall contain information relating to, covers this explanatory material. storage/retrieval of the information using automated and arranged under, the subject headings listed in European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) processing. Appendix 1 of this Annex. 5.2.1.1.2 If no facilities or services are provided or no --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is information is available for publication in respect of one made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this of the categories of information specified in Appendix 3, explanatory material. an indication should be given as to which of these circumstances applies (e.g. “NIL” or “Not AVBL”). 5.2.1.1.3 When the AIP Data Set (as specified in 5.3.2.1) GM1 AIS.TR.305(c) Aeronautical information Transposed. is provided, the following sections of the AIP may be left publication (AIP) blank and a reference to the data set availability shall be AIP DATA SET provided: When the AIP data set is provided, the following 1. ENR 2.1 FIR, UIR, TMA sections of the AIP may be left blank and a reference 2. ENR 3.1 Lower ATS Routes to the data set availability should be provided: 3. ENR 3.2 Upper ATS Routes (a) ENR 2.1 FIR, UIR, TMA; 4. ENR 3.3 Area Navigation (RNAV) Routes (b) ENR 3.1 Lower ATS routes; 5. ENR 3.4 Helicopter Routes (c) ENR 3.2 Upper ATS routes; 6. ENR 3.5 Other Routes (d) ENR 3.3 Area navigation (RNAV) routes; 7. ENR 3.6 En-route Holding (e) ENR 3.4 Helicopter routes; 8. ENR 4.1 Radio navigation aids — en-route (f) ENR 3.5 Other routes; 9. ENR 4.4 Name-code designators for significant (g) ENR 3.6 En route holding; points (h) ENR 4.1 Radio navigation aids — en route; 10. ENR 4.5 Aeronautical Ground Lights — En-route (i) ENR 4.4 Name-code designators for significant 11. ENR 5.1 Prohibited, Restricted and Danger Areas points; 12. ENR 5.2 Military exercise and training areas and air (j) ENR 4.5 Aeronautical ground lights — en route; defence identification zone (ADIZ) (k) ENR 5.1 Prohibited, restricted and danger areas; 13. ENR 5.3.1 Other activities of a dangerous nature (l) ENR 5.2 Military exercise and training areas and 14. ENR 5.5 Aerial sporting and recreational activities air defence identification zone (ADIZ); European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 15. **** AD 2.19 Radio navigation and landing aids (m) ENR 5.3.1 Other activities of a dangerous 16. **** AD 3.18 Radio navigation and landing aids nature; (n) ENR 5.5 Aerial sporting and recreational activities; (o) AD 2.19 Radio navigation and landing aids; and (p) AD 3.18 Radio navigation and landing aids. 5.2.1.1.4 When the Obstacle Data Set (as specified in GM1 AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data set Transposed. 5.3.2.3.2) is provided, the following sections of the AIP GENERAL may be left blank and a reference to the data set availability shall be provided: When the obstacle data set is provided, the 17. ENR 5.4 Air navigation obstacles following sections of the AIP may be left blank and a 18. ***AD 2.10 Aerodrome obstacles reference to the data set availability should be 19. ***AD 3.10 Heliport obstacles provided: (a) ENR 5.4 Air navigation obstacles ; (b) AD 2.10 Aerodrome obstacles; and (c) AD 3.10 Heliport obstacles. 5.2.1.2 General Specification --- --- 5.2.1.2.1 The issuing State and publishing authority shall AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. be clearly indicated. (AIP) (d) The issuing State and publishing authority shall be clearly indicated. 5.2.1.2.2 When two or more States jointly provide an AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. AIP, these States shall be clearly indicated. (AIP) (e) When two or more States jointly provide an AIP, these States shall be clearly indicated. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.2.1.2.3 Each AIP shall be self-contained and shall AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. include a table of contents. (AIP) (f) Each AIP shall be self-contained and shall include a table of contents. 5.2.1.2.4 An AIP shall be organised in three parts (GEN, AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. ENR and AD), sections and sub-sections, except when (AIP) the AIP, or a volume of the AIP, is designed to facilitate (g) An AIP shall be organised in three parts (GEN, operational use in flight, the precise format and ENR and AD), sections and sub-sections, except arrangement may be left to the discretion of the State when the AIP, or a volume of the AIP, is designed to provided that an adequate table of contents is included. facilitate operational use in flight, in which case the precise format and arrangement may be left to the discretion of the State provided that an adequate table of contents is included. 5.2.1.2.5 Each AIP shall be dated. AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. (AIP) (h) Each AIP shall be dated. 5.2.1.2.5.1 The date, consisting of the day, month (by AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. name) and year, shall be the publication date or the (AIP) effective date (AIRAC) of the information. (i) The date, consisting of the day, month (by name) and year, shall be the publication date and/or the effective date (AIRAC) of the information. 5.2.1.2.6 Charts, maps or diagrams shall be used, when GM1 AIS.TR.305(c) Aeronautical information Transposed. appropriate, to complement or as a substitute for the publication (AIP) tabulations or text of Aeronautical Information CHARTS, MAPS OR DIAGRAMS Publications. (a) Charts, maps or diagrams should be used, when European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) appropriate, to complement or as a substitute for the tabulations or text of the AIP. Note.— Where appropriate, charts produced in (b) Where appropriate, charts produced in Transposed. conformity with Annex 4 — Aeronautical Charts, may be conformity with AIS.OR.325 may be used to fulfil used to fulfil this requirement. Guidance material as to this requirement. Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the the specifications of index maps and diagrams included explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and in Aeronautical Information Publications is contained in applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. 8126). 5.2.1.2.7 When listing locations, the city or town should AMC1 AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information Transposed. be given in capital letters followed, where the facility is publication (AIP) an aerodrome/heliport or is located at an LOCATON FORMAT aerodrome/heliport, by an oblique stroke and the name When listing locations, the city or town should be of the aerodrome/heliport in smaller capital letters or given in capital letters followed, where the facility is lowercase type. Unless otherwise indicated, the list an aerodrome/heliport or is located at an should be in alphabetical order. aerodrome/heliport, by an oblique stroke and the name of the aerodrome/heliport in smaller capital letters or lower-case letters. Unless otherwise indicated, the list should be in alphabetical order. 5.2.1.2.8 The spelling of place names shall conform with AIS.TR.300 General Transposed. local usage, transliterated where necessary into the ISO (b) Place names shall be spelt in conformity with But based on Annex 15 3.1.3.2 Basic-Latin alphabet. local usage, transliterated, when necessary, into the ISO basic Latin alphabet. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.2.1.2.9 In the indication of the geographical AMC1 AIS.TR.305(c) Aeronautical information Transposed. coordinates of a location: publication (AIP) — the latitude should be given first; LOCATION — symbols for degrees, minutes or seconds should be In the indication of the geographical coordinates of omitted; a location: — two digits should always be used in expressing values (a) the latitude should be given first; of less than 10 degrees of latitude; and (b) symbols for degrees, minutes or seconds should — three digits should always be used in expressing be omitted; values of less than 100 degrees of longitude. (c) two digits should always be used in expressing values of less than 10 degrees of latitude; and (d) three digits should always be used in expressing values of less than 100 degrees of longitude. 5.2.1.2.10 When describing periods of activity, AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. availability or operation, the applicable days and times (AIP) shall be specified. (j) When describing periods of activity, availability or operation, the applicable days and times shall be specified. 5.2.1.2.11 The units of measurement selected for use in --- Not transposed. the AIP, e.g. dimensions on aerodromes, distances, The reference to the units of measurement is elevations or altitudes, should be consistently followed covered by the data catalogue (Appendix 1 to and should adhere to Annex 5. Annex III of Regulation ../…) 5.2.1.2.12 Index maps and diagrams included in the AIP AMC1 AIS.OR.325 Aeronautical Charts Transposed. should comply with the following specifications: GENERAL Aeronautical charts should be produced in accordance with the specifications contained in ICAO Annex 4, in its 11th edition of July 2009. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) a) Base map: The base map should be an outline map of --- Not transposed as such. the area adapted from existing material with general However, this paragraph is covered by AMC1 details. Graticules, topography and other details should AIS.OR.325 be as simple as possible Political subdivisions should be shown and identified. It should be produced in one colour. b) Sheet size and scale: The overall dimensions should be --- Not transposed as such. 210 mm × 297 mm. If a larger map is required, it should However, this paragraph is covered by AMC1 be folded to conform to this size. A uniform scale should AIS.OR.325 be used for all charts produced as a series and other charts where practicable. c) Title and marginal notes: The title should be shown on --- the top border and should be as short and simple as Not transposed as such. possible. However, this paragraph is covered by AMC1 AIS.OR.325 d) Colours: The number of colours used should be kept --- to a minimum. If more than one colour is used, the Not transposed as such. colours should offer adequate contrast. However, this paragraph is covered by AMC1 AIS.OR.325 e) Symbols: Symbols should conform, where practicable, --- to the ICAO Chart symbols shown in Annex 4, Appendix Not transposed as such. 2. The basic, general purpose symbols for AIP index However, this paragraph is covered by AMC1 maps are a filled circle ●and an empty circle ◯. Except European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) when the symbols used are self-explanatory, a legend AIS.OR.325 should be provided. For details for which no ICAO symbol has been provided, any appropriate symbol may be chosen provided it does not conflict with an ICAO symbol. 5.2.1.3 Specifications for AIP Amendments --- --- 5.2.1.3.1 The AIP shall be amended or re-issued at such AIS.OR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. regular intervals as necessary to ensure the information An aeronautical information services provider shall: But based on Annex 15 6.3.1.1 (it is duplicated in contained in the AIP is complete and up to date. (b) ensure that the AIP is amended or re-issued at the PANS-AIM) such regular intervals as necessary to ensure the information is complete and up to date. 5.2.1.3.2 Operationally significant changes to the AIP AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. shall be published in accordance with AIRAC procedures (a) Any operationally significant changes to the AIP and shall be clearly identified by the acronym — AIRAC. shall be issued under AIRAC and clearly identified as such. 5.2.1.3.2 When a State has established the regular --- Not transposed as it is already covered in interval or publication dates for its AIP Amendments, AIS.TR.310(g) transposing PANS-AIM 6.2.2.1) these intervals or publication dates shall be included in the AIP, Part 1 — General (GEN). 5.2.1.3.3 New or revised information contained in the --- This paragraph is covered by AIS.TR.310 (a) AIP shall be identified. 5.2.1.3.4 Each AIP Amendment shall be allocated a serial AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. number, which shall be consecutive. (b) Each AIP Amendment shall be allocated a serial European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) number, which shall be consecutive. 5.2.1.3.5 Each AIP Amendment shall contain a AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. publication date. (f) Each AIP Amendment page, including the cover sheet, shall: 5.2.1.3.6 Each AIRAC AIP Amendment shall contain an (2) contain a publication date and/or an effective effective date. date when applicable. 5.2.1.3.6.1 When an effective time other than 0000 UTC AMC1 AIS.TR.310(f)(2) AIP Amendments Transposed. is used, the effective time shall also be indicated. EFFECTIVE TIME When an effective time other than 0000 UTC is used, the effective time should also be indicated. 5.2.1.3.7 When an AIP Amendment is issued, it shall AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. include references to the serial number of the AIP (c) When an AIP Amendment is issued, it shall Supplement or NOTAM which have been incorporated include references to the serial number of the into the amendment. NOTAM which have been incorporated into the amendment. AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements (c) Each AIP Supplement shall be allocated a serial number which shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. 5.2.1.3.8 A brief indication of the subjects affected by --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is the amendment shall be given on the AIP Amendment made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this cover sheet. explanatory material. 5.2.1.3.9 Each amendment shall include a checklist AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) giving the current date of each loose-leaf page in the (e) Each AIP amendment shall: AIP, and shall provide a recapitulation of any (1) include a checklist giving the current date of outstanding manuscript corrections. The checklist shall each loose-leaf page in the AIP, and the carry both the page number and date. checklist shall carry both the page number and date; and (2) provide a recapitulation of any outstanding manuscript corrections. 5.2.1.4 Specifications for AIP Supplements --- --- Note.— Since the AIP is subject to frequent change, GM1 AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. provisions exist for its continual updating. In addition, TEMPORARY CHANGES changes of a temporary nature affecting the contents of (a) Since the AIP is subject to frequent change, an AIP are often required to cater for unexpected provisions exist for its continual updating. In circumstances or, in some cases, planned modifications addition, changes of a temporary nature affecting to a service/facility. The purpose of an AIP Supplement is the contents of an AIP are often required to cater to bring to the attention of users both temporary for unexpected circumstances or, in some cases, changes of long duration (three months or longer) and planned modifications to a service/facility. information of short duration containing extensive text (b) The purpose of an AIP Supplement is to bring to or graphics which affect one or more parts of the AIP. the attention of users both temporary changes of long duration (three months or longer) and information of short duration containing extensive text or graphics which affect one or more parts of the AIP. 5.2.1.4.1 Each AIP Supplement shall be allocated a serial AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. number which shall be consecutive and based on the (c) Each AIP supplement shall be allocated a serial calendar year (e.g. 2/13). number which shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note.— Guidance material on the use of AIP --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the Supplements together with examples of such use is explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and contained in the Aeronautical Information Services applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is Manual (Doc 8126). no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. 5.2.1.4.2 Whenever an AIP Supplement is issued as a AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. replacement of a NOTAM, a reference to the series and (d) Whenever an AIP supplement is issued as a number of the NOTAM shall be included. replacement of a NOTAM, a reference to the series and number of the NOTAM shall be included. 5.2.1.4.3 A checklist of valid AIP Supplements shall be AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. issued at intervals of not more than one month as part (e) A checklist of valid AIP supplements shall be of the checklist of NOTAM required at 5.1.4.2 and with issued at intervals of not more than one month as distribution as for the AIP Supplements. part of the checklist of NOTAM and with distribution as for the AIP supplements. 5.2.2 Aeronautical Information Circulars AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. 5.2.2.1 An AIC shall be provided whenever it is desirable (b) The AIC shall be provided whenever it is Transposed. to promulgate: desirable to promulgate: 1) forecasts of important changes in the air navigation (1) forecasts of important changes in the air Transposed. procedures, services and facilities provided; navigation procedures, services and facilities provided; 2) forecasts of implementation of new navigational (2) forecasts of implementation of new navigational Transposed. systems; systems; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 3) significant information arising from aircraft (3) significant information arising from aircraft Transposed. accident/incident investigation which has a bearing on accident/incident investigation which has a bearing flight safety; on flight safety; 4) information on regulations relating to the (4) information on regulations relating to the Transposed. safeguarding of international civil aviation against acts of safeguarding of international civil aviation against unlawful interference; acts of unlawful interference; 5) advice on medical matters of special interest to pilots; (5) advice on medical matters of special interest to Transposed. pilots; 6) warnings to pilots concerning the avoidance of (6) warnings to pilots concerning the avoidance of Transposed. physical hazards; physical hazards; 7) effect of certain weather phenomena on aircraft (7) effect of certain weather phenomena on aircraft Transposed. operations; operations; 8) information on new hazards affecting aircraft handling (8) information on new hazards affecting aircraft Transposed. techniques; handling techniques; 9) regulations relating to the carriage of restricted (9) regulations relating to the carriage of restricted Transposed. articles by air; articles by air; 10) reference to the requirements of, and publication of (10) reference to the requirements of, and Transposed. changes in, national legislation; publication of changes in, national legislation; 11) aircrew licensing arrangements; (11) aircrew licensing arrangements; Transposed. 12) training of aviation personnel; (12) training of aviation personnel; Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 13) application of, or exemption from, requirements in (13) application of, or exemption from, Transposed. national legislation; requirements in national legislation; 14) advice on the use and maintenance of specific types (14) advice on the use and maintenance of specific Transposed. of equipment; types of equipment; 15) actual or planned availability of new or revised (15) actual or planned availability of new or revised Transposed. editions of aeronautical charts; editions of aeronautical charts; 16) carriage of communication equipment; (16) carriage of communication equipment; Transposed. 17) explanatory information relating to noise (17) explanatory information relating to noise Transposed. abatement; abatement; 18) selected airworthiness directives; (18) selected airworthiness directives; Transposed. 19) changes in NOTAM series or distribution, new (19) changes in NOTAM series or distribution, new Transposed. editions of AIP or major changes in their contents, editions of AIP or major changes in their contents, coverage or format; coverage or format; 20) advance information on the snow plan (see 5.2.2.2); (20) advance information on the snow plan; Transposed. 21) other information of a similar nature. (21) other information of a similar nature. Transposed. 5.2.2.2 The snow plan issued under AD 1.2.2 of the AIP GM2 AIS.TR.320(d) AIC Transposed. shall be supplemented by seasonal information, to be The snow plan issued under AD 1.2.2 of the AIP may issued well in advance of the beginning of each winter — contain information such as that listed below: not less than one month before the normal onset of winter conditions and shall contain information such as European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) that listed below: a) a list of aerodromes/heliports where snow slush, ice (a) a list of aerodromes/heliports where snow Transposed. or frost clearance is expected to be performed during clearance is expected to be performed during the the coming winter: [text from AMDT 39] coming winter: *1) in accordance with the runway and taxiway systems; (1) in accordance with the runway and taxiway Transposed. or systems; or *2) planned snow clearing, deviating from the runway (2) planned snow clearing, deviating from the Transposed. system (length, width and number of runways, affected runway system (length, width and number of taxiways and aprons or portions thereof); runways, affected taxiways and aprons or portions thereof); *b) information concerning any centre designated to (b) information concerning any centre designated to Transposed. coordinate information on the current state of progress coordinate information on the current state of of clearance and on the current state of runways, progress of clearance and on the current state of taxiways and aprons; runways, taxiways and aprons; c) a division of the aerodromes/heliports into (c) a division of the aerodromes/heliports into Transposed. SNOWTAM distribution lists in order to avoid excessive SNOWTAM distribution lists in order to avoid NOTAM distribution; excessive NOTAM distribution; *d) an indication, as necessary, of minor changes to the (d) an indication, as necessary, of minor changes to Transposed. standing snow plan; the standing snow plan; *e) a descriptive list of clearance equipment; (e) a descriptive list of clearance equipment; and Transposed. *f) a listing of what will be considered as the minimum (f) a listing of what will be considered as the Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) critical snow bank to be reported at each minimum critical snow bank to be reported at each aerodrome/heliport at which reporting will commence. aerodrome/heliport at which reporting will commence. 5.2.2.3 The originating State shall select the AIC that are --- Not transposed. The requirement is put on the to be given international distribution. States. 5.2.2.4 States shall give AIC selected for international AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. distribution the same distribution as for the AIP. (e) When the AIC is selected by the originating State for international distribution, it shall have the same distribution as the AIP. 5.2.2.5 Distribution of AIC on a national basis is left to --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is the discretion of the originating State concerned. made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this explanatory material. 5.2.2.6 Each AIC shall be allocated a serial number which AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. (f) Each AIC shall be allocated a serial number which shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. Note 1.— Since AIC information is often effective for long --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is periods and requires little amendment, it will usually be made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this found that AIC can, if necessary, remain outstanding for explanatory material. several years without inconvenience. A review and re- issue on a yearly basis is however advisable. 5.2.2.7 In the event that AIC are provided in more than AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. one series, each series shall be separately identified by a (g) In the event that AIC are provided in more than European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) letter (A 2/02, B 4/02, etc.). one series, each series shall be separately identified by a letter. 5.2.2.8 A checklist of AIC currently in force shall be AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. issued at least once a year, with distribution as for the (h) A checklist of AIC currently in force shall be AIC. issued at least once a year, with distribution as for the AIC. 5.2.2.9 A checklist of AIC provided internationally shall AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) Transposed. be included in the NOTAM Checklist. (i) A checklist of AIC provided internationally shall be included in the NOTAM Checklist. 5.2.3 Printed products --- --- 5.2.3.1 Printed AIP --- --- 5.2.3.1.1 When the AIP is issued as a printed volume, it GM2 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information Transposed. should be published in looseleaf form unless the publication (AIP) complete publication is reissued at frequent intervals. FORM OF AIP When the AIP is issued as a printed volume, it is published in loose-leaf form unless the complete publication is reissued at frequent intervals. 5.2.3.1.2 Each AIP issued as a printed volume and each AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. page of an AIP issued in loose-leaf form shall be so (AIP) annotated as to indicate clearly: (k) Each AIP issued as a printed volume and each page of an AIP issued in loose-leaf form shall be annotated as to indicate clearly: European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) a) the identity of the Aeronautical Information --- Not transposed. It is not considered relevant. Publication; b) the territory covered and subdivisions when (1) the territory covered and subdivisions when Transposed. necessary; necessary; c) the identification of the issuing State and producing (2) the identification of the issuing State or the joint Transposed. organization (authority); issuing States and producing organization Amended to cover 5.2.3.1.3 below with ‘joint (authority); issuing States’ d) page numbers/chart titles; (3) page numbers/chart titles; Transposed. 5.2.3.1.3 The issuing State or the joint issuing States shall --- Transposed. be clearly indicated on the cover and in the table of This paragraph is covered by (k)(2) above. contents. 5.2.3.1.4 The normal method of amendment of the AIS.TR.305(m) Aeronautical information Transposed. printed volume AIP shall be by means of replacement publication (AIP) sheets. The method of amendment of the printed volume AIP is by means of replacement sheets. 5.2.3.1.5 New or revised information shall be identified. AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments The first sentence is transposed. by an annotation against it in the margin. A thick black (f) Each AIP Amendment page, including the cover The second sentence is not transposed as it is vertical line or, where the change incorporated covers sheet, shall: covered in Doc 8126 which already covers this one line only or a part of a line, a thick black horizontal (1) be identified by an annotation against it in the explanatory material. arrow, is sufficient to identify the change. margin. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.2.3.1.6 Each AIP amendment page, including the cover AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. sheet, shall contain a publication date and, when (f) Each AIP Amendment page, including the cover applicable, an effective date. sheet, shall: (2) contain a publication date and/or an effective date when applicable. 5.2.3.1.7 If it is necessary by reason of bulk or for GM1 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information Transposed. convenience, to publish an AIP in two or more parts or publication (AIP) volumes, each of them will indicate that the remainder PRINTED AIP of the information is to be found in the other part(s) or (a) If it is necessary by reason of bulk or for volume(s). convenience, to publish an AIP in two or more parts or volumes, each of them will indicate that the remainder of the information is to be found in the other part(s) or volume(s). 5.2.3.1.8 When the AIP is provided in more than one (b) When the AIP is provided in more than one Transposed. volume, each volume shall include: volume, each volume should include: (1) a preface; — Preface (2) a record of AIP amendments; — Record of AIP Amendments (3) a record of AIP supplements; (4) a checklist of AIP pages; and — Record of AIP Supplements (5) a list of current hand amendments. — Checklist of AIP pages — List of current hand amendments 5.2.3.1.9 When the AIP is published as one volume, the (c) When the AIP is published as one volume, the Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) above-mentioned subsections appear only in Part 1 — above-mentioned subsections should appear only in GEN and the annotation “not applicable” shall be Part 1 — GEN and the annotation ‘not applicable’ entered against each of these subsections in Parts 2 and should be entered against each of these subsections 3. in Parts 2 and 3. 5.2.3.1.10 A system of page numbering adaptable to the AMC1 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information Transposed. addition or deletion of sheets should be adopted. The publication (AIP) page number should include: PRINTED AIP A system of page numbering adaptable to the — an identification of the part of the AIP; addition or deletion of sheets should be adopted. The page number should include: — the section; and (a) an identification of the part of the AIP; (b) the section; and — subsection, as applicable; (c) subsection, as applicable, thus creating a separate set of numbers for each thus creating a separate set of numbers for each subject subject (e.g. GEN 2.1-3, ENR 4.1-1 or AD 2.2-3). (e.g. GEN 2.1-3, ENR 4.1-1 or AD 2.2-3). 5.2.3.1.11 A checklist giving the current date of each --- Not transposed as such, but reflected throughout page in the AIP shall be reissued frequently to assist the the relevant rules. user in maintaining a current publication. 5.2.3.1.12 The sheet size should be no larger than 210 × --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is 297 mm, except that larger sheets may be used provided made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this they are folded to the same size. explanatory material. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.2.3.1.13 When a small number of charts are to be AMC1 AIS.OR.325 Aeronautical Charts Transposed. included and chart size is not larger than 210 mm × 297 GENERAL mm or allows for folding to these dimensions, they Aeronautical charts should be produced in should be contained in the AIP. If, on the other hand, accordance with the specifications contained in there are many charts and they are frequently amended, ICAO Annex 4, in its 11th edition of July 2009. it may be convenient to place them in a separate volume with a separate subscription service. 5.2.3.1.14 Maps and charts included in the AIP should be Transposed. paginated in the same manner as other material. It is covered by AMC1 AIS.OR.325. 5.2.3.1.15 AIP Supplement pages should be coloured in --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is order to be conspicuous, preferably in yellow. made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this explanatory material. 5.2.3.1.16 AIP Supplement pages should be kept as the --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is first item in the AIP parts. made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this explanatory material. Note – As alternate to eliminate the need to continuously --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is refer to the front of the AIP for the required information, made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this the Supplements may be divided into specific parts (e.g. explanatory material. GEN, ENR, AD) for insertion in each AIP part, as necessary. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.2.3.1.17 Each AIP Supplement page shall show a AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. publication date. (f) Each AIP supplement page shall show a 5.2.3.1.18 Each AIRAC AIP Supplement page shall show a publication date. Each AIRAC AIP supplement page publication date and an effective date. shall show a publication date and an effective date. 5.2.3.2 Printed AIC --- --- 5.2.3.2.1 Differentiation and identification of AIC topics GM1 AIS.TR.320(a) AIC Transposed. according to subjects using colour coding should be PRINTED AIC practised where the numbers of AIC in force are (a) Differentiation and identification of AIC topics sufficient to make identification in this form necessary. according to subjects using colour coding should be practised where the numbers of AIC in force are sufficient to make identification in this form necessary. 5.2.3.2.2 It is recommended that AIC be colour coded by (b) It is recommended that AIC be colour coded by Transposed. subject where there are sufficient circulars in force to subject where there are sufficient circulars in force warrant such identification, e.g.: to warrant such identification, e.g.: a) white — administrative; (1) white — administrative; b) yellow — ATC; (2) yellow — ATC; c) pink — safety; (3) pink — safety; d) mauve — danger area map; and (4) mauve — danger area map; and e) green — maps/charts. (5) green — maps/charts. 5.2.4 Electronic AIP (eAIP) --- --- 5.2.4.1 The AIP, AIP Amendment, AIP Supplement and AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. AIC should also be published in a format that allows for (AIP) European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) displaying on a computer screen and printing on paper. (a) The AIP, AIP amendments and AIP supplements shall be provided on paper and/or as an electronic document ‘electronic AIP’ (eAIP) that allows for displaying on computer screen and printing on paper. AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical Information Circular (AIC) (a) The AIC shall be provided on paper and/or as part of the electronic document ‘electronic AIP’ (eAIP) that allows for displaying on computer screen and printing on paper. Note 1.— This composite electronic document is named --- Not transposed. “Electronic AIP” (eAIP) and may be based on a format It is considered to be self-explanatory. that allows for digital data exchange. Note 2.— Guidance material for the production and --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the provision of the eAIP is contained in Doc 8126. explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. 5.2.4.2 When provided, the information content of the AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication Transposed. eAIP and the structure of chapters, sections and sub- (AIP) sections shall follow the content and structure of the (l) When provided, the information content of the paper AIP. The eAIP shall include files that allow for eAIP and the structure of chapters, sections and printing a paper AIP. sub-sections shall follow the content and structure of the paper AIP. 5.2.4.3 New or revised information shall be identified AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) either by an annotation against it in the margin or by a (f) Each AIP amendment page, including the cover mechanism that allows comparing the new/revised sheet, shall: information with the previous one. (1) be identified by an annotation against it in the margin; and 5.2.4.4 When provided, the eAIP should be available on AMC2 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information Transposed. a physical distribution medium (CD, DVD, etc.) and/or publication (AIP) online on the Internet. ELECTRONIC AIP When provided, the eAIP should be available on a physical distribution medium, such as cd, dvd, etc. and/or online on the internet. Note.— Guidance material on the use of the Internet is Not transposed. It is not considered necessary in contained in Guidelines on the Use of the Public Internet the context of the rules. for Aeronautical Applications (Doc 9855). 5.2.5 NOTAM --- --- 5.2.5.1 General specifications --- --- 5.2.5.1.1 Except as otherwise provided in 5.2.5.1.5 and AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. 5.2.5.1.6, each NOTAM shall contain the information in (a) Except as provided for in AIS.TR.330(d) and the order shown in the NOTAM Format in Appendix 4. AIS.TR.330(e), each NOTAM shall contain the information in the order shown in the NOTAM Format in Appendix 2. Note.— Additional procedures covering the reporting of --- Not transposed. It is not considered necessary in runway surface conditions is contained in PANS- the context of the rules. Aerodromes (Doc 9981). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note.— Detailed guidance material covering NOTAM, --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the SNOWTAM, ASHTAM and PIB production is contained in explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and Doc 8126. applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. 5.2.5.1.2 NOTAM text shall be composed of the (b) NOTAM text shall be composed of the Transposed. significations/uniform abbreviated phraseology assigned significations/uniform abbreviated phraseology to the ICAO NOTAM Code complemented by ICAO assigned to the ICAO NOTAM Code complemented abbreviations, indicators, identifiers, designators, by ICAO abbreviations, indicators, identifiers, callsigns, frequencies, figures and plain language. designators, call signs, frequencies, figures and plain language. Note.— The ICAO NOTAM Code together with GM1 AIS.TR.330(b) NOTAM Transposed. significations/uniform abbreviated phraseology, and NOTAM CODE ICAO Abbreviations are those contained in the PANS-ABC The ICAO NOTAM Code together with (Doc 8400). significations/uniform abbreviated phraseology, and ICAO Abbreviations are those contained in the PANS-ABC (Doc 8400). 5.2.5.1.3 All NOTAM shall be issued in English language. AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. (c) All NOTAM shall be issued in English language. If 5.2.5.1.4 If necessary for domestic users, NOTAM may necessary for domestic users, NOTAM may additionally be issued in national language. additionally be issued in national language. 5.2.5.1.5 Information concerning snow, slush, ice, frost, AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. standing water, or water associated with snow, slush, ice (d) Information concerning snow, slush, ice, frost, or frost on the movement area shall be disseminated by standing water, or water associated with snow, means of SNOWTAM, and contain the information in the slush, ice or frost on the movement area shall be order shown in the SNOWTAM Format in Appendix 5. disseminated by means of SNOWTAM, and shall European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) [text from AMDT 39] contain the information in the order shown in the SNOWTAM Format in Appendix 3. Note.— The origin and order of the information is a --- Not transposed. result of assessment processes and procedures prescribed in PANS-Aerodromes (Doc 9981). [text from AMDT 39] 5.2.5.1.6 Information concerning an operationally AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. significant change in volcanic activity, a volcanic eruption (e) Information concerning an operationally and/or volcanic ash cloud shall, when reported by means significant change in volcanic activity, a volcanic of an ASHTAM, contain the information in the order eruption and/or volcanic ash cloud shall, when shown in the ASHTAM Format in Appendix 6. reported by means of an ASHTAM, contain the information in the order shown in the ASHTAM Format in Appendix 4. 5.2.5.1.7 When errors occur in a NOTAM, a NOTAM with AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. a new number to replace the erroneous NOTAM shall be (f) When errors occur in a NOTAM, a NOTAM with issued or the erroneous NOTAM shall be cancelled and a a new number to replace the erroneous NOTAM new NOTAM issued. shall be issued or the erroneous NOTAM shall be cancelled and a new NOTAM issued. 5.2.5.1.8 When a NOTAM is issued which cancels or AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. replaces a previous NOTAM, the series and number of (g) When a NOTAM is issued that cancels or the previous NOTAM shall be indicated. replaces a previous NOTAM: (1) the series and number of the previous NOTAM shall be indicated; and European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.2.5.1.8.1 The series, location indicator and subject of (2) the series, location indicator and subject of both Transposed. both NOTAM shall be the same. NOTAM shall be the same. 5.2.5.1.9 Only one NOTAM shall be cancelled or replaced AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. by a NOTAM. (h) Only one NOTAM shall be cancelled or replaced by a NOTAM. 5.2.5.1.10 Each NOTAM shall deal with only one subject AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. and one condition of the subject. (i) Each NOTAM shall deal with only one subject and one condition of the subject. Note.— Guidance concerning the combination of a --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the subject and a condition of the subject in accordance with explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and the NOTAM Selection Criteria is contained in the applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc 8126). no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. 5.2.5.1.11 Each NOTAM shall be as brief as possible and AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. so compiled that its meaning is clear without the need to (j) Each NOTAM shall be as brief as possible and refer to another document. compiled so that its meaning is clear without the need to refer to another document. 5.2.5.1.12 Each NOTAM shall be transmitted as a single AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. telecommunication message. (k) Each NOTAM shall be transmitted as a single telecommunication message. 5.2.5.1.13 A NOTAM containing permanent or AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. temporary information of long duration shall carry (l) A NOTAM containing permanent or temporary appropriate AIP or AIP Supplement references. information of long duration shall carry appropriate AIP or AIP Supplement references. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.2.5.1.14 Location indicators included in the text of a AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. NOTAM shall be those contained in Location Indicators (m) Location indicators included in the text of a (Doc 7910). NOTAM shall be those contained in ICAO Doc 7910 (Location Indicators). In no case shall a curtailed 5.2.5.1.14.1 In no case shall a curtailed form of such form of such indicators be used. indicators be used. 5.2.5.1.15 Where no ICAO location indicator is assigned AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. to the location, its place name shall be entered in plain (n) Where no ICAO location indicator is assigned to language, spelt in conformity with local usage, the location, its place name shall be entered in plain transliterated, when necessary, into the ISO Basic-Latin language, spelt in conformity with local usage, alphabet. transliterated, when necessary, into the ISO Basic- Latin alphabet. 5.2.5.2 NOTAM number and series allocation --- --- 5.2.5.2.1 The NOTAM Office shall allocate to each AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. NOTAM a series identified by a letter and a four-digit (o) To each NOTAM shall be allocated a series number followed by a stroke and a two-digit number for identified by a letter and a four-digit number the year. The four-digit number shall be consecutive and followed by a stroke and a two-digit number for the based on the calendar year. year. The four-digit number shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. 5.2.5.2.2 Letters A to Z, with the exception of T, should --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is be used to identify a NOTAM series. made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this explanatory material. 5.2.5.2.3 All NOTAM shall be divided in series based on AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. subject, traffic or location or a combination thereof, (p) All NOTAM shall be divided in series based on European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) depending on end-user needs. NOTAM for aerodromes subject, traffic or location or a combination thereof, allowing international air traffic shall be issued in depending on end-user needs. NOTAM for international NOTAM series. aerodromes allowing international air traffic shall be issued in international NOTAM series. 5.2.5.2.4 If NOTAM is issued in both English and national AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. language, the NOTAM series shall be organised so that (q) If NOTAM are issued in both English and the national language series are equivalents of the national language, the NOTAM series shall be English language series in terms of content and organised so that the national language series are numbering. equivalents of the English language series in terms of content and numbering. 5.2.5.2.5 The content and geographical coverage of each AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. NOTAM series shall be stated in detail in the AIP, GEN 3. (r) The content and geographical coverage of each NOTAM series shall be stated in detail in the AIP, GEN 3. 5.2.5.2.6 Series allocation shall be monitored and, if AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. required, appropriate measures shall be taken to assure (w) Series allocation shall be monitored and, if that no series reaches the maximum possible number of required, appropriate measures shall be taken to issued NOTAM before the end of a calendar year. assure that no series reaches the maximum possible number of issued NOTAM before the end of a calendar year. 5.2.5.3 NOTAM Checklist --- --- 5.2.5.3.1 A checklist of valid NOTAM shall be issued as a AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. checklist NOTAM at intervals of not more than one (s) A checklist of valid NOTAM shall be regularly month. provided. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note.— Omitting a NOTAM from the checklist does not --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is cancel a NOTAM. made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this explanatory material. 5.2.5.3.2 One checklist NOTAM shall be issued for each AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. series. (t) One checklist NOTAM shall be issued for each series. 5.2.5.3.3 A checklist NOTAM shall refer to the latest AIP AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. Amendments, AIP Supplements, data sets and at least (u) A checklist NOTAM shall also refer to the latest the internationally distributed AIC, and, when it is AIP Amendments, AIP Supplements, data sets and at selected, include the checklist of AIP Supplements. least the internationally distributed AIC. GM1 AIS.TR.330(v) NOTAM CHECKLIST The checklist NOTAM may include the checklist of AIP SUPP 5.2.5.3.4 A checklist NOTAM shall have the same AIS.TR.330 NOTAM Transposed. distribution as the actual message series to which they (v) A checklist NOTAM shall have the same refer and shall be clearly identified as checklist. distribution as the actual message series to which they refer and shall be clearly identified as checklist. 5.3 Digital Data --- --- 5.3.1 General provisions --- -- 5.3.1.1 The ISO 19100 series of standards for geographic GM1 AIS.TR.335(a) General Transposed information shall be used as a reference framework. ISO SERIES European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) (a) The ISO 19100 series of standards for geographic information may be used as a reference framework. Note.— This is intended to facilitate and support the use (b) […] This is intended to facilitate and support the Transposed. and exchange of digital data sets between data use and exchange of digital data sets between data providers and data users. providers and data users. 5.3.1.2 A description of the available digital data sets AIS.TR.335(a) General Transposed. shall be provided in the form of data product (b) A description of the available digital data sets specification on which basis air navigation users will be shall be provided in the form of data product able to evaluate the products and determine whether specification. they fulfil the requirements for their intended use (application). GM1 AIS.TR.335(b) General DESCRIPTION OF AVAILABLE DATA SET (a) The data product specification enables air navigation users to evaluate the products and determine whether they fulfil the requirements for their intended use (application). Note.— ISO Standard 19131 specifies the requirements AMC1 AIS.TR.335(a) General Transposed. and outline of data product specifications for geographic ISO SERIES information. GM1 AIS.TR.335(a) General ISO SERIES (b) ISO Standard 19131 specifies the requirements and outline of data product specifications for geographic information. […] Note.— This may include an overview, specification GM1 AIS.TR.335(b) General Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) scope, data product identification, data content and DESCRIPTION OF AVAILABLE DATA SET structure, reference system, data quality, data capture, (b) This may include an overview, specification data maintenance, data portrayal, data product delivery, scope, data product identification, data content and additional information, and metadata. structure, reference system, data quality, data capture, data maintenance, data portrayal, data product delivery, additional information, and metadata. 5.3.1.3 Globally interoperable aeronautical information --- This paragraph is covered under AIS.OR.205 and exchange models and data exchange models shall be applies to digital data set as well. used for the provision of data sets. Note.— --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the Guidance on the aeronautical information and data e explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and xchange models may be found in the Aeronautical applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is Information Services Manual (Doc 8126). no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. 5.3.1.4 The aeronautical information model used AMC1 AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data Transposed. should encompass the aeronautical data and and aeronautical information aeronautical information to be exchanged. EXCHANGE MODELS (a) The aeronautical information model used should encompass the aeronautical data and aeronautical information to be exchanged. 5.3.1.5 The aeronautical information model used (b) The aeronautical information model used Transposed. should: should: a) use the Unified Modelling Language (UML) to describe (1) use the Unified Modelling Language (UML) to Transposed. the aeronautical information features and their describe the aeronautical information features and European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) properties, associations and data types; their properties, associations and data types; b) include data value constraints and data verification (2) include data value constraints and data Transposed. rules; verification rules; c) include provisions for metadata as specified in 5.3.2; (3) include provisions for metadata; and Transposed. and d) include a temporality model to enable capturing the (4) include a temporality model to enable capturing Transposed. evolution of the properties of an aeronautical the evolution of the properties of an aeronautical information feature during its life cycle. information feature during its life cycle. 5.3.1.6 The aeronautical data exchange model used (c) The aeronautical data exchange model used Transposed. should: should: a) apply a commonly used data encoding format; (1) apply a commonly used data encoding format; Transposed. b) cover all the classes, attributes, data types and (2) cover all the classes, attributes, data types and Transposed. associations of the aeronautical information model associations of the aeronautical information model; detailed in 3.3.1.5; and and c) provide an extension mechanism by which groups of (3) provide an extension mechanism by which Transposed. users can extend the properties of existing features and groups of users can extend the properties of existing add new features which do not adversely affect global features and add new features which do not standardization. adversely affect global standardization. Note 1.—The intent of using a commonly used data GM1 AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data Transposed. encoding format is to ensure interoperability of and information aeronautical data exchange between agencies and EXCHANGE ENABLING European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) organizations involved in the data processing chain. (a) The intent of using a commonly used data encoding format is to ensure interoperability of aeronautical data exchange between agencies and organizations involved in the data processing chain. Note 2.—Examples of commonly used data encoding (b) Examples of commonly used data encoding Transposed. formats include Extensible Markup Language (XML), formats include Extensible Markup Language (XML), Geography Markup Language (GML), and JavaScript Geography Markup Language (GML), and JavaScript Object Notation (JSON). Object Notation (JSON). 5.3.2 Metadata --- --- 5.3.2.1 Each data set shall include the following minimal AIS.TR.340 Metadata requirements Transposed. set of metadata: The minimum metadata for each data set shall include: a) the name of the organizations or entities providing (a) the name of the organizations or entities Transposed. the data set; providing the data set; b) the date and time when the data set was provided (b) the date and time when the data set was Transposed. provided; c) validity of the data set (c) validity of the data set; Transposed. d) any limitations with regard to the use of the data set (d) any limitations with regard to the use of the Transposed. data set. 5.3.3 Data sets --- --- European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note.— A data subject may appear in multiple data sets. GM1 AIS.OR.335(a) General Transposed. DATA SET A data subject may appear in multiple data sets. 5.3.3.1 Aeronautical (AIP) data set --- --- Note. - The purpose of the Aeronautical (AIP) data set is GM1 AIS.OR.340 AIP data set Transposed. to support the initial transition of the ATM domain PURPOSE towards the use of digital data sets instead of paper The purpose of the AIP data set is to support the products. Therefore, its scope is defined considering the initial transition of the ATM domain towards the use likelihood that the data contained in this set is actually of digital data sets instead of paper products. being used in digital format by service providers, ATC Therefore, its scope is defined considering the and IFR/VFR airspace users. likelihood that the data contained in this set is actually being used in digital format by service providers, ATC and IFR/VFR airspace users. 5.3.3.1.1 The AIP Data sub-Set shall include data about AIS.TR.345 AIP data set Transposed. the following subjects, with the properties indicated in (a) The AIP data set shall include data about the The elements from a. to k. are transposed as such brackets being included as a minimum (if applicable): following subjects, with the properties indicated in a table for easy reading, but the table is not being included, if applicable: [table] reproduced here for purpose of format issue. a. ATS Airspace (type, name, lateral limits, vertical limits, class of airspace) b. Special Activity Airspace (type, name, lateral limits, vertical limits, restriction, activation) c. Route (identifier prefix, flight rules, designator, …) d. Route segment (navigation specification, startpoint, endpoint, track, distance, upper limit, lower limit, MEA, MOCA, direction of cruising level, reverse direction of cruising level, required navigation performance) European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) e. Waypoint - enroute (reporting requirement, identification, location, formation) f. Aerodrome/Heliport (location indicator, name, designator IATA, served city, certified ICAO, certification date, certification expiration date, control type, field elevation, reference temperature, magnetic variation, airport reference point) g. Runway (designator, nominal length, nominal width, surface type, strength) h. Runway Direction (designator, true bearing, threshold, TORA, TODA, ASDA, LDA, rejected TODA) i. FATO (designation, length, width, threshold point,...) j. TLOF (designator, centre point, length, width, surface type) k. Radio navigation Aid (type. identification, name, aerodrome served, hours of operation, magnetic variation, frequency/channel, position, elevation, magnetic bearing, true bearing, zero bearing direction, Note 1. - The description of the data subjects, their --- Transposed. It is now included in the introduction properties, data type and applicable data quality of the data catalogue. requirements is provided in Appendix 1 ). Note 2. – The Aeronautical (AIP) Data-set includes GM1 AIS.TR.345(a) AIP data set Transposed. relevant AIP Amendment and SUP information. CONTENT The AIP Data-set includes relevant AIP amendment and SUP information. 5.3.3.1.2 When a property is not defined for a particular AIS.TR.345 AIP data set Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) occurrence of the subjects listed in 5.3.3.1.1, the AIP (b) When a property is not defined for a particular data sub-set shall include an explicit “not applicable” occurrence of the subjects listed in (a), the AIP data indication. sub-set shall include an explicit “not applicable” indication. 5.3.3.2 Terrain and obstacle data sets GM2 to AIS.TR.350, AIS.TR.355, AIS.TR.360 Terrain and obstacle data NAVIGATION APPLICATIONS Note.— Terrain and obstacle data are intended to be (a) Terrain and obstacle data are intended to be Transposed. used in the following air navigation applications: used in the following air navigation applications: a) ground proximity warning system with forward (1) ground proximity warning system with looking terrain avoidance function and minimum safe forward looking terrain avoidance function altitude warning (MSAW) system; and minimum safe altitude warning (MSAW) b) determination of contingency procedures for use in system; the event of an emergency during a missed approach or (2) determination of contingency procedures take-off; for use in the event of an emergency during c) aircraft operating limitations analysis; a missed approach or take-off; d) instrument procedure design (including circling (3) aircraft operating limitations analysis; procedure); (4) instrument procedure design (including e) determination of en-route “drift-down” procedure circling procedure); and en-route emergency landing location; (5) determination of en-route “drift-down” f) advanced surface movement guidance and control procedure and en-route emergency landing system (A-SMGCS); and g) aeronautical chart location; production and on-board databases. (6) (f) advanced surface movement guidance and control system (A-SMGCS); and g) aeronautical chart production and on-board databases. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) The data may also be used in other applications such as (b) The data may also be used in other applications Transposed. flight simulator and synthetic vision systems, and may such as flight simulator and synthetic vision systems, assist in determining the height restriction or removal of and may assist in determining the height restriction obstacles that pose a hazard to air navigation. or removal of obstacles that pose a hazard to air navigation. 5.3.3.2.1 Terrain data set --- --- 5.3.3.2.1.1 A terrain grid shall be angular or linear and AIS.TR.355 Terrain data sets Transposed. shall be of regular or irregular shape. (b) A terrain grid shall be angular or linear and shall be of regular or irregular shape. Note.— In regions of higher latitudes, latitude grid --- This paragraph is not transposed as it is already spacing may be adjusted to maintain a constant linear covered by the ToD Manual and the ED-98 density of measurement points. documents. 5.3.3.2.1.2 Sets of terrain data shall include spatial (c) Sets of terrain data shall include spatial (position The first sentence is transposed. (position and elevation), thematic and temporal aspects and elevation), thematic and temporal aspects for for the surface of the Earth containing naturally the surface of the Earth containing naturally The rest of the paragraph is not transposed as it is occurring features such as mountains, hills, ridges, occurring features, excluding obstacles. already covered by the ToD Manual and the ED-98 valleys, bodies of water, permanent ice and snow, and documents. excluding obstacles. In practical terms, depending on the acquisition method used, this shall represent the continuous surface that exists at the bare Earth, the top of the canopy or something in-between, also known as “first reflective surface”. 5.3.3.2.1.3 In terrain data sets, only one feature type, (d) Only one feature type shall be provided. Transposed. i.e. terrain, shall be provided. Feature attributes The Table A7-1 in Appendix 7 is transposed as European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) describing terrain shall be those listed in Appendix 7, (e) The terrain feature attributes represent the AMC1 AIS.TR.355(d) Terrain data set. Table A7-1. The terrain feature attributes listed in Table minimum set of terrain attributes, and those A7-1 represent the minimum set of terrain attributes, annotated as mandatory shall be recorded in the and those annotated as mandatory shall be recorded in terrain data set. the terrain data set. 5.3.3.2.1.4 Terrain data for each area shall conform to Transposed. the applicable numerical requirements in Appendix 1. 5.3.3.2.2 Obstacle data set AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data sets Transposed. 5.3.3.2.2.1 Obstacle data elements are features that (a) Obstacle data elements are features that shall Transposed. shall be represented in the data sets by points, lines or be represented in the data sets by points, lines or polygons polygons. 5.3.3.2.2.2 In an obstacle data set, all defined obstacle (b) All defined obstacle feature types shall be Transposed. feature types shall be provided and each of them shall provided and each of them shall be described. be described according to the list of mandatory The Table A7-2 in Appendix 7 is transposed as attributes provided in Appendix 7, Table A7-2. AMC1 AIS.TR.360(b) Obstacle data set. Note.— By definition, obstacles can be fixed (permanent --- This paragraph is not transposed as it is already or temporary) or mobile. Specific attributes associated covered by the ToD Manual and the ED-98 with mobile (feature operations) and temporary types of documents. obstacles are annotated in Appendix 7, Table A7-4, as optional attributes. If these types of obstacles are to be provided in the data set, appropriate attributes describing such obstacles are also required. 5.3.3.2.2.3 Obstacle data for each area shall conform to --- Transposed. It is covered by the data catalogue. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) the applicable numerical requirements contained in Appendix 1. 5.3.3.2.2.4 The obstacle data product specification, (e) The obstacle data product specification, Transposed. supported by geographical coordinates for each supported by geographical coordinates for each aerodrome included within the dataset, shall describe aerodrome included within the dataset, shall the following areas: describe the following areas: — Areas 2a, 2b, 2c, 2d; (1) areas 2a, 2b, 2c and 2d; — the take-off flight path area; and (2) the take-off flight path area; and — the obstacle limitation surfaces. (3) the obstacle limitation surfaces. Note.— Area 4 terrain data and Area 2 obstacle data are --- Not transposed as it is already covered by the ToD normally sufficient to support the production of the Manual and ED-98 document. Precision Approach Terrain Chart — ICAO. When more detailed obstacle data are required for Area 4, these may be provided in accordance with the Area 4 obstacle data requirements specified in Appendix 7, Table A7-2. Guidance on appropriate obstacles for this chart is given in the Aeronautical Chart Manual (Doc 8697). 5.3.3.3 Aerodrome mapping data sets --- --- Note 1.— Aerodrome mapping data include aerodrome GM1 to AIS.TR.350, AIS.TR.355, AIS.TR.360 Terrain This paragraph is not transposed as such. This Note geographic information that supports applications which and obstacle data contains elements that are included in the ED-98 improve the user’s situational awareness or supplements REFERENCES documents, which is referred to in the related surface navigation, thereby increasing safety margins (b) In addition, the EUROCAE Document ED-98C guidance material. and operational efficiency. Aerodrome mapping data (October 2015) provides guidance for data gathering sets with appropriate data element accuracy support by data originators, for data processing by data European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) requirements for collaborative decision making, common integrators, for implementation by system situational awareness, and aerodrome guidance designers, and for end use by the aviation applications are intended to be used, among others, in community (e.g. air carriers, air traffic services, the following air navigation applications: procedure designers). a) position and route awareness including moving maps --- This paragraph is not transposed as such as it is with own ship position, surface guidance and navigation covered by the GM above. (such as A-SMGCS); This Note contains elements that are included in b) traffic awareness including surveillance and runway the ED-98 documents, which is referred to in the incursion detection and alerting; related guidance material. c) facilitation of aerodrome-related aeronautical information, including NOTAM; d) resource and aerodrome facility management; and e) aeronautical chart production. The data may also be used in other applications such as --- Same as above. training/flight simulator and synthetic vision systems. Note 1.— Aerodrome mapping data are organized and --- Same as above. arranged in aerodrome mapping databases (AMDBs) for ease of electronic storage and usage by appropriate applications. Note. 2 — The exact content of the aerodrome mapping --- Same as above. data sets is defined in EUROCAE ED99 / RTCA DO 272. Note 3. — Metadata elements applicable to aerodrome GM2 AIS.TR.365(a) Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) mapping data are contained in RTCA Document DO-291B METADATA and European Organization for Civil Aviation Equipment Metadata elements applicable to aerodrome (EUROCAE) Document ED-119B — Interchange Standards mapping data are contained in EUROCAE Document for Terrain, Obstacle, and Aerodrome Mapping Data. ED-119C ‘Interchange standards for terrain, obstacle and aerodrome mapping data’, October 2015. 5.3.3.3.1 Aerodrome mapping data — requirements for --- --- provision 5.3.3.3.1.1 Aerodrome mapping data should be GM1 AIS.TR.365(a) Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. supported by electronic terrain and obstacle data for ADDITIONAL DATA Area 3 in order to ensure consistency and quality of all (a) Aerodrome mapping data may be supported by geographical data related to the aerodrome. electronic terrain and obstacle data for area 3 in order to ensure consistency and quality of all geographical data related to the aerodrome. Note 1.— Accuracy and integrity requirements for --- This Note is not considered relevant to transpose. aerodrome mapping data are contained in Annex 14, The relevant reference is currently Regulation Volume I, Appendix 5. 139/2014. Note 2.— Electronic terrain and obstacle data pertaining GM2 AIS.TR.365(a) Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. to Area 3 and aerodrome mapping data may be COMMON ACQUISITION TECHNIQUES originated using common acquisition techniques and Electronic terrain and obstacle data pertaining to managed within a single geographic information system area 3 and aerodrome mapping data may be (GIS). originated using common acquisition techniques and managed within a single geographic information system (GIS). European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note 3.— Supporting material with respect to the GM1 AIS.TR.365 Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed with reference to Eurocae ED-99. processing of electronic terrain and obstacle data and COMPLEMENTARY GUIDANCE aerodrome mapping data is contained in RTCA Further information concerning minimum Document DO-200A and European Organization for Civil requirements and reference material applicable to Aviation Equipment (EUROCAE) Document ED-76 — the content, origination, publication, and updating Standards for Processing Aeronautical Data. of aerodrome mapping information may be found in EUROCAE Documents ED-99D ‘User requirement for aerodrome mapping information’, October 2015, and ED-119C ‘Interchange standards for terrain, obstacle and aerodrome mapping data’, October 2015. 5.3.3.3.2 Aerodrome mapping data product --- --- specification 5.3.3.3.2.1 The ISO 19100 series of standards for AIS.TR. 365 Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. geographic information shall be used as a reference (b) Standards for geographic information shall be The reference to the ISO number is contained in framework. used as a reference framework. AMC. Note.— This is intended to facilitate and support the use GM1 AIS.TR.335(a) General Transposed. and exchange of aerodrome mapping data between data ISO SERIES providers and data users. (b) […]This is intended to facilitate and support the use and exchange of digital data sets between data providers and data users. 5.3.3.3.2.2 Aerodrome mapping data products shall be AIS.TR. 365 Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. described following the ISO 19131 data product (c) Aerodrome mapping data products shall be The ISO number reference is contained in AMC. specification standard. described following the relevant data product specification standard. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note.— This includes an overview, specification scope, GM1 AIS.TR.335(b) General Transposed. data product identification, data content and structure, DESCRIPTION OF AVAILABLE DATA SET reference system, data quality, data capture, data (b) This may include an overview, specification maintenance, data portrayal, data product delivery, scope, data product identification, data content and additional information, and metadata. structure, reference system, data quality, data capture, data maintenance, data portrayal, data product delivery, additional information, and metadata. 5.3.3.3.3 Aerodrome mapping database — data set --- --- content and structure 5.3.3.3.2.1 The content and structure of aerodrome AIS.TR. 365 Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. mapping data sets shall be defined in terms of an (d) The content and structure of aerodrome application schema and a feature catalogue. mapping data sets shall be defined in terms of an application schema and a feature catalogue. Note.— ISO Standard 19109 contains rules for GM1 AIS.TR.365(d) Aerodrome mapping data sets Transposed. application schema while ISO Standard 19110 describes ISO REFERENCE the feature cataloguing methodology for geographic ISO Standard 19109 contains rules for application information. schema while ISO Standard 19110 describes the feature cataloguing methodology for geographic information. 5.3.3.4 Instrument flight procedure design data set --- --- Note - The purpose of the Instrument flight procedure GM1 AIS.OR.340 AIP data set Transposed. data set is to support the initial transition of the ATM PURPOSE domain towards the use of digital data sets instead of The purpose of the AIP data set is to support the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) paper products. Therefore, its scope is defined initial transition of the ATM domain towards the use considering the likelihood that the data contained in this of digital data sets instead of paper products. set is actually being used in digital format by service Therefore, its scope is defined considering the providers, ATC and IFR/VFR airspace users. likelihood that the data contained in this set is actually being used in digital format by service providers, air traffic control (ATC) and instrument flight rules (IFR)/visual flight rules (VFR) airspace users. 5.3.3.4.1 The Instrument flight procedure design data set AIS.TR.370 Instrument flight procedure data sets Transposed. shall include data about the following data subjects, with (b) The Instrument flight procedure design data set the properties indicated in brackets being included as a shall include data about the following subjects, minimum (if applicable): including all of their properties: a. Procedure (all properties) (1) Procedure b. Procedure Segment (all properties) (2) Procedure Segment c. Final Approach Segment (all properties) (3) Final Approach Segment d. Procedure Fix (all properties) (4) Procedure Fix e. Procedure Holding (all properties) (5) Procedure Holding f. Helicopter Procedure Specifics (all properties) (6) Helicopter Procedure Specifics Note1.— The description of the data subjects, their GM2 AIS.TR.345(a) AIP data set Transposed. properties, data type and applicable data quality CONTENT requirements is provided in Appendix 1. The description of the data subjects, their properties, data type and applicable data quality requirements is provided in the Data Catalogue contained in Appendix 1 to Annex III to the Regulation. Note2.— The Instrument Flight Procedure data set --- Not transposed. This Note is not considered European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) should also cover the data publication requirements necessary to transpose. contained in Doc 8168, PANS-OPS, etc. 5.4 Distribution Services --- --- 5.4.1 General --- --- 5.4.1.1 Distribution to the next intended user will differ GM1 AIS.OR.400(b) Distribution services Transposed. in the delivery method applied which may either be: DISTIBUTION OF AIP PRODUCTS (a) Distribution to the next intended user will differ in the delivery method applied which may either be: Physical distribution. The means by which aeronautical (1) physical distribution — the means by which Transposed. data and aeronautical information distribution is aeronautical data and aeronautical information achieved through the delivery of a physical package, distribution is achieved through the delivery of a such as postal services; or physical package, such as postal services; or Direct electronic distribution. The means by which (2) direct electronic distribution — the means by Transposed. aeronautical data and aeronautical information which aeronautical data and aeronautical distribution is achieved automatically through the use of information distribution is achieved automatically a direct electronic connection between the AIS and the through the use of a direct electronic connection next intended user. between the AIS and the next intended user. 5.4.1.2 Different delivery methods and data media may (b) Different delivery methods and data media may Transposed. require different procedures to ensure the required data require different procedures to ensure the required quality. data quality. Note.— Further guidance on digital dataset distribution (c) Further guidance on digital dataset distribution Transposed. can be found in the Document - ICAO SWIM Concept - can be found in the ICAO Doc 10039 (Manual on European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Doc 10039 system wide information management (SWIM) concept). 5.4.1.3. A checklist of the available data sets, including AIS.TR.335 General Transposed. their effective and publication dates, shall be made (c) A checklist of the available data sets, including available to allow the users to ensure that current data is their effective and publication dates, shall be made being used. available to allow the users to ensure that current data is being used. 5.4.1.4 The checklist of data sets shall be made available AIS.TR.335 General Transposed. through the same distribution mechanism as used for (d) The checklist of data sets shall be made the data sets. available through the same distribution mechanism as used for the data sets. 5.4.2 NOTAM distribution --- --- 5.4.2.1 An aeronautical information service shall AIS.OR.400 Distribution services Transposed. arrange, as necessary, to satisfy operational An aeronautical information services provider shall: requirements for the issuance and receipt of NOTAM […] distributed by telecommunication. (e) arrange, as necessary, the issuance and receipt of NOTAM distributed by telecommunication to satisfy operational requirements. 5.4.2.2 International exchange of NOTAM shall take AIS.OR.400 Distribution services Transposed. place only as mutually agreed between the international An aeronautical information services provider shall: NOTAM offices and/or multinational NOTAM Processing (d) ensure the exchange of NOTAM between Units concerned. international NOTAM offices and/or multinational NOTAM Processing Units concerned; and European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) Note.— Arrangements may be made for direct exchange GM1 AIS.OR.400(d) Distribution of services Transposed. of SNOWTAM (see Appendix 5) between SNOWTAM aerodromes/heliports. Arrangements may be made for direct exchange of SNOWTAM between aerodromes/heliports. 5.4.2.3 The international exchange of ASHTAM (see AIS.TR.400 Distribution services Transposed. 5.1.4.1.5), and NOTAM where States continue to use (a) The international exchange of ASHTAM, and NOTAM for distribution of information on volcanic NOTAM where States continue to use NOTAM for activity, shall include volcanic ash advisory centres and distribution of information on volcanic activity, shall the centres designated by regional air navigation include volcanic ash advisory centres and the world agreement for the operation of AFS satellite distribution area forecast centres, and shall take account of the systems (satellite distribution system for information requirements of long-range operations. relating to air navigation (SADIS) and international satellite communications system (ISCS)), and shall take account of the requirements of long-range operations. 5.4.2.4 The exchange of NOTAM between international AMC1 AIS.TR.400 Distribution services Transposed. NOTAM offices and/or multinational NOTAM Processing The exchange of NOTAM between international Units shall, as far as practicable, cover the needs of NOTAM offices and/or multinational NOTAM operations personnel including flight crew members. Processing Units should cover the needs of operations personnel including flight crew members. 5.4.2.5 A predetermined distribution system for NOTAM AIS.TR.400 Distribution services Transposed. transmitted on the AFS in accordance with Annex 15, (b) A predetermined distribution system for 6.3.2.3 shall be used whenever possible, subject to the NOTAM transmitted on the AFS shall be used requirements of 5.4.3.3. whenever possible. 5.4.2.6 The originating State shall upon request grant (c) Distribution of NOTAM series other than those Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) distribution of NOTAM series other than those distributed internationally shall be granted upon distributed internationally. request. 5.5 Pre-flight information services --- --- 5.5.1 Geographic coverage for pre-flight information GM1 AIS.OR.405(b) Pre-flight information services Transposed. services should be determined and periodically INFORMATION OF OPERATIONAL SIGNIFICANCE reviewed. In general the coverage zone should be (b) Geographic coverage for pre-flight information limited to the FIR within which the aerodrome/heliport services should be determined and periodically is located, the FIR(s) adjacent thereto, and all air route reviewed. In general, the coverage zone should be or portion of route flown without an intermediate limited to the flight information region (FIR) within landing, originating at the aerodrome/heliport and which the aerodrome/heliport is located, the FIR(s) extending beyond the FIR(s) mentioned. adjacent thereto, and all air route or portion of route flown without an intermediate landing, originating at the aerodrome/heliport and extending beyond the FIR(s) mentioned. 5.5.4 Although Miscellaneous NOTAM is regarded not AIS.TR.405 Pre-flight information services Transposed. subject for a briefing but available on request, all (e) All NOTAM shall be made available for briefing NOTAM shall be provided for briefing by default and that by default and content reduction filtering shall be at content reduction should be at user’s discretion. user’s discretion. 5.5.5 Automated pre-flight information systems shall be AIS.TR.405 Pre-flight information services Transposed. used to make aeronautical data and aeronautical (a) Automated pre-flight information systems shall The last sentence is not considered necessary. information available to operations personnel including be used to make aeronautical data and aeronautical flight crew members for self-briefing, flight planning and information available to operations personnel, flight information service purposes. The aeronautical including flight crew members, for self-briefing, data and aeronautical information made available shall flight planning and flight information service comply with the provisions of Annex 15. purposes. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.5.6 Self-briefing facilities of an automated pre-flight (b) The human–machine interface of such facilities Transposed. information system shall provide access to operations shall ensure easy access in a guided manner to all personnel, including flight crew members and other relevant information/data. aeronautical personnel concerned, for consultation as necessary with the aeronautical information service by (c) Self-briefing facilities of an automated pre-flight telephone or other suitable telecommunications means. information system shall provide access for The human/machine interface of such facilities shall consultation as necessary with the aeronautical ensure easy access in a guided manner to all relevant information service by telephone or other suitable information/data. telecommunications means. 5.5.7 Automated pre-flight information systems for the (d) Automated pre-flight information systems for Transposed. supply of aeronautical data and aeronautical information the supply of aeronautical data and aeronautical for self-briefing, flight planning and flight information information for self-briefing, flight planning and service shall: flight information service shall: a) provide for continuous and timely updating of the (1) provide for continuous and timely updating of Transposed. system database and monitoring of the validity and the system database and monitoring of the validity quality of the aeronautical data stored; and quality of the aeronautical data stored; b) permit access to the system by operations personnel (2) permit access to the system by operations Transposed. including flight crew members, aeronautical personnel personnel including flight crew members, concerned and other aeronautical users through suitable aeronautical personnel concerned and other telecommunications means; aeronautical users through suitable telecommunications means; c) ensure provision, in paper copy form, of the (3) ensure provision, in paper copy form, of the Transposed. aeronautical data and aeronautical information aeronautical data and aeronautical information accessed, as required; accessed, as required; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) d) use access and interrogation procedures based on (4) use access and interrogation procedures based Transposed. abbreviated plain language and ICAO location indicators, on abbreviated plain language and ICAO location as appropriate, or based on a menu-driven user indicators, as appropriate, or based on a menu- interface or other appropriate mechanism as agreed driven user interface or other appropriate between the civil aviation authority and operator mechanism as agreed between the civil aviation concerned; and authority and operator concerned; and e) provide for rapid response to a user request for (5) provide for rapid response to a user request for Transposed. information. information. Note.— ICAO abbreviations and codes and location --- Transposed. indicators are given respectively in the Procedures for Air Navigation Services — ICAO Abbreviations and Codes NOTE - Both ICAO Doc referred to in the PANS-AIM (PANS-ABC, Doc 8400) and Location Indicators (Doc are transposed in other provisions but are not 7910). reproduced here. For instance please see: GM1 AIS.TR.330(b) NOTAM 5.5.8 Automated pre-flight information systems GM1 AIS.TR.405(a) Pre-flight information services Transposed. providing a harmonized, common point of access by AUTOMATION operations personnel, including flight crew members (a) Automated pre-flight information systems and other aeronautical personnel concerned, to providing a harmonised, common point of access by aeronautical information in accordance with Annex 15 operations personnel, including flight crew and meteorological information in accordance with members and other aeronautical personnel Annex 3 — Meteorological Service for International Air concerned, to aeronautical information and Navigation, should be established by an agreement meteorological information should be established by between the civil aviation authority or the agency to an agreement between the competent authority for which the authority to provide service has been civil aviation or service provider and the competent delegated in accordance with Annex 15 2.1.1 c) and the authority for meteorological services or service relevant meteorological authority. provider. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 5.5.9 Where automated pre-flight information systems (b) Where automated pre-flight information systems Transposed. are used to provide the harmonized, common point of are used to provide the harmonised, common point access by operations personnel, including flight crew of access by operations personnel, including flight members and other aeronautical personnel concerned, crew members and other aeronautical personnel to aeronautical data, aeronautical information and concerned, to aeronautical data, aeronautical meteorological information, the civil aviation authority information and meteorological information, the or the agency to which the authority to provide service competent authority for civil aviation or the service has been delegated in accordance with Annex 15 2.1.1 c) provider to which the authority to provide service shall remain responsible for the quality and timeliness of has been delegated, remain responsible for the the aeronautical data and aeronautical information quality and timeliness of the aeronautical data and provided by means of such a system. aeronautical information provided by means of such a system. Note.— The meteorological authority concerned remains (c) The meteorological service provider concerned Transposed. responsible for the quality of the meteorological remains responsible for the quality of the information provided by means of such a system in meteorological information provided by means of accordance with Annex 3. such a system in accordance with Part-MET. CHAPTER 6 - AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION UPDATES --- --- 6.1 Aeronautical Information Regulation and Control --- --- (AIRAC) 6.1.1 Information provided under the AIRAC system and AIS.TR.505 AIRAC Transposed. published in paper copy or made available on physical (a) Information provided under the AIRAC system media shall be distributed by the AIS at least 42 days in and published in paper copy or made available advance of the effective date. on physical media shall be distributed at least 42 days in advance of the effective date. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 6.1.2 When information has not been submitted by the (b) When information has not been submitted by Transposed. AIRAC date, a NIL notification shall be distributed by the AIRAC date, a NIL notification shall be NOTAM or other suitable means, not later than one distributed by NOTAM or other suitable means, cycle before the AIRAC effective date concerned. not later than one cycle before the AIRAC effective date concerned. 6.2 Aeronautical Information Product updates --- --- 6.2.1 The same update cycle shall be applied to AIP AIS.TR.500 General Transposed. Amendments, the Aeronautical (AIP) data set and the The same update AIRAC cycle shall be applied to the Instrument Flight Procedures data set in order to ensure AIP, the AIP amendments, the AIP data set and the the coherence of the data items that appear in multiple instrument flight procedure data sets in order to aeronautical information products. ensure the coherence of the data that appear in multiple aeronautical information products. 6.2.2 Specifications for AIP updates --- --- 6.2.2.1 The AIP Amendment regular interval shall be AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. specified in the AIP, Part 1 — General (GEN). (g) The AIP Amendment regular interval shall be specified in the AIP, Part 1 — General (GEN). Note.— Guidance material on the establishment of --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the intervals between publication dates of AIP Amendments explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and is contained in the Aeronautical Information Services applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is Manual (Doc 8126). no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. 6.2.2.2 When an AIP Amendment will not be published --- This paragraph is already covered by AIS.TR.505(b) at the established regular interval or publication date, a above. NIL notification shall be originated and distributed by the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) NOTAM checklist. 6.2.2.3 Recourse to hand amendments or annotations AIS.TR.310 AIP Amendments Transposed. The second sentence is added from shall be kept to the minimum. (h) Recourse to hand amendments or hand the current ICAO Annex 15 in 4.2.9. annotations shall be kept to the minimum; the normal method of amendment shall be by re-issuing or by replacement of pages. 6.2.2.4 When the AIP is provided in more than one --- This paragraph is not transposed as reference is volume, each volume should include separate made to ICAO Doc 8126 which already covers this amendment services. explanatory material. 6.2.3 Specifications for AIP Supplements --- --- 6.2.3.1 When an error occurs in an AIP Supplement or AIS.TR.315 AIP Supplements Transposed. when the period of validity of an AIP Supplement is (g) When there is not sufficient time for the changed, a new AIP Supplement shall be published as a distribution of an AIP Supplement, a NOTAM shall replacement. be issued. Note 1.— The requirements for NOTAM apply when time --- Not transposed. constraints do not allow sufficient time for the distribution of an AIP Supplement. Note 2.— Guidance material on the use of AIP --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the Supplements together with examples of such use is explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and contained in the Aeronautical Information Services applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is Manual (Doc 8126). no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 6.2.4 Specifications for NOTAM --- --- 6.2.4.1 NOTAM should be published with sufficient lead AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. time for the affected parties to take any required action, (a) NOTAM shall be published with sufficient lead except in the case of unserviceability, volcanic activity, time for the affected parties to take any required release of radioactive material, toxic chemicals and action, except in the case of unserviceability, other events that cannot be foreseen. volcanic activity, release of radioactive material, toxic chemicals and other events that cannot be foreseen. 6.2.4.2 NOTAM notifying unserviceability of aids to air (b) NOTAM notifying unserviceability of aids to air Transposed. navigation, facilities or communication services shall give navigation, facilities or communication services shall an estimate of the period of unserviceability or the time give an estimate of the period of unserviceability or at which restoration of service is expected. the time at which restoration of service is expected. 6.2.4.3 At least seven days’ advance notice should be AMC1 AIS.TR.510(a) NOTAM Updates Transposed. given of the activation of established danger, restricted ADVANCE NOTICE or prohibited areas and of activities requiring temporary (a) At least seven days’ advance notice should be airspace restrictions other than for emergency given of the activation of established danger, operations. restricted or prohibited areas and of activities requiring temporary airspace restrictions other than for emergency operations. 6.2.4.4 Notice of any subsequent cancellation of the (b) Notice of any subsequent cancellation of the Transposed. activities or any reduction of the hours of activity or the activities or any reduction of the hours of activity or dimensions of the airspace should be given as soon as the dimensions of the airspace should be given as possible. soon as possible. Note.— Whenever possible, at least 24 hours’ advance GM1 AIS.TR.510(b) NOTAM Updates Transposed. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) notice is desirable, to permit timely completion of the ADVANCE NOTICE notification process and to facilitate airspace utilization Whenever possible, at least 24 hours’ advance planning. notice is desirable, to permit timely completion of the notification process and to facilitate airspace utilisation planning. 6.2.4.5 Within three months from the issuing of a AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. Permanent NOTAM, the information contained in the (c) Within three months from the issuing of a NOTAM shall be included in the Aeronautical permanent NOTAM, the information contained in Information Products affected. the NOTAM shall be included in the aeronautical information products affected. 6.2.4.6 Within three months from the issuing of a AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. temporary NOTAM of long duration, the information (d) Within three months from the issuing of a contained in the NOTAM shall be included in an AIP temporary NOTAM of long duration, the information Supplement. contained in the NOTAM shall be included in an AIP supplement. 6.2.4.7 When a NOTAM with estimated end of validity AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. unexpectedly exceeds the three-month period, a (e) When a NOTAM with estimated end of validity replacement NOTAM shall be issued, unless the unexpectedly exceeds the three-month period, a condition is expected to last for a further period of more replacement NOTAM shall be issued unless the than three months; in this case an AIP Supplement shall condition is expected to last for a further period of be issued. more than three months; in this case, an AIP supplement shall be issued. 6.2.4.8 A “Trigger” NOTAM shall give a brief description AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. of the content, the effective date and time, and the (f) A ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall give a brief description reference number of the amendment, datasets or of the content, the effective date and time, and the European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) supplement. reference number of the amendment, datasets or supplement. 6.2.4.9 A “Trigger” NOTAM shall come into force on the AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. same effective date and time as the AIP amendment or (g) A ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall come into force on the supplement. same effective date and time as the AIP amendment or supplement. 6.2.4.10 In the case of an AIP Amendment, a “Trigger” AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. NOTAM shall remain valid for a period of fourteen days. (h) In the case of an AIP Amendment, a “Trigger” NOTAM shall remain valid for a period of fourteen days. 6.2.4.11 In the case of an AIP Supplement that is valid AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. for less than fourteen days, the “Trigger” NOTAM shall (i) In the case of an AIP supplement that is valid for remain valid for the complete validity period of the AIP less than fourteen days, the ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall Supplement. remain valid for the complete validity period of the AIP supplement. 6.2.4.12 In the case of an AIP Supplement that is valid AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates Transposed. for fourteen days or more, the “Trigger” NOTAM shall (j) In the case of an AIP supplement that is valid for remain valid for at least fourteen days. fourteen days or more, the ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall remain valid for at least fourteen days. Note.— Guidance material for the origination of NOTAM --- Reference to ICAO Doc 8126 is made in the announcing the existence of AIRAC AIP Amendments or explanatory note to the AMC/GM document and AIP Supplements (“Trigger NOTAM”) is contained in the applies to the relevant paragraphs, so that there is Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc 8126). no need to repeat it for all the related provisions. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) 6.2.5 Specifications for digital data updates --- --- 6.2.5.1 The update interval for the Aeronautical (AIP) AIS.TR.515 Digital data updates Transposed. data set and Instrument Flight Procedures data sets shall (a) The update interval for the AIP data set and the be specified in data product specification. instrument flight procedure data sets shall be specified in data product specification. 6.2.5.2 Data sets that have been made available in (b) Data sets that have been made available in Transposed. advance (according to the AIRAC cycle) shall be updated advance, according to the AIRAC cycle, shall be with the non-AIRAC changes that occurred in between updated with the non-AIRAC changes that occurred the publication and the effective date. in between the publication and the effective date. APPENDIX 1. AERONAUTICAL DATA CATALOGUE Appendix 1 to Annex III (ATM/ANS.OR) Transposed. APPENDIX 2. INFORMATION ABOUT NATIONAL AND Appendix 1 to Annex III (ATM/ANS.OR) Transposed. LOCAL REGULATION, SERVICE AND PROCEDURES APPENDIX 3. CONTENTS OF THE AERONAUTICAL Appendix 1 to Annex VI (Part-AIS) Transposed. INFORMATION PUBLICATION (AIP) APPENDIX 4. NOTAM FORMAT Appendix 2 to Annex VI (Part-AIS) Transposed. APPENDIX 5. SNOWTAM FORMAT Appendix 3 to Annex VI (Part-AIS) Transposed. APPENDIX 6. ASHTAM FORMAT Appendix 4 to Annex VI (Part-AIS) Transposed. APPENDIX 7. TERRAIN AND OBSTACLE ATTRIBUTES AMC1 AIS.TR.355(d) Terrain data set Transposed. PROVISION REQUIREMENTS AMC1 AIS.TR.360(b) Obstacle data set European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 ICAO PANS-AIM NPA Text Justification (new proposed amendment) — END — European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management RMT.0477 — 27.4.2016 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This Notice of Proposed Amendment (NPA) addresses a safety issue related to the provision of aeronautical information services (AIS) and aeronautical information management (AIM). The main objective of this NPA is to maintain a high level of safety, increase efficiency and provide for greater cost- effectiveness of the air navigation system by achieving an uninterrupted aeronautical data chain with no loss or corruption in data and information and with guaranteed data quality. The role and importance of aeronautical data and aeronautical information has changed significantly with the implementation of area navigation (RNAV), performance-based navigation (PBN), airborne computer-based navigation systems and data link systems. Corrupt, erroneous, late, or missing aeronautical data and aeronautical information can potentially affect the safety of air navigation. The specific objectives of this NPA are to: 1) ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are originated, assembled, edited, formatted, published and finally provided at the required level of quality to the next intended user and for all phases of flight; the quality of the data shall be proportionate to the types of aeronautical actors involved; 2) ensure alignment in an efficient and effective way with the latest International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) Annex 15 amendment; and 3) ensure enough proportionality and flexibility to allow smooth implementation of AIS. This NPA proposes rules for: — ATM/ANS providers; and — organisations involved in the origination of aeronautical data. It amends Annexes I (Definitions), II (Part-ATM/ANS.AR), III (Part-ATM/ANS.OR) and VI (Part-AIS) to Regulation .../…. laying down common requirements for service providers and the oversight in air traffic management/air navigation services and other air traffic management network functions, as well as Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 of 12 February 2014 laying down requirements and administrative procedures related to aerodromes. Applicability Process map Affected Commission Implementing Regulation Concept paper: No regulations (EU) No 1035/2011; Commission Terms of reference: 11.10.2013 and decisions: Regulation (EU) No 73/2010; Decision Rulemaking group: Yes 2014/012/R RIA type: Light Affected AIS providers, service providers, Technical consultation stakeholders: competent authorities, aerodrome during NPA drafting: No operators, data originators and EASA Duration of NPA consultation: 4 months Driver/origin: Safety Review group: Yes Reference: Article 8b of Regulation (EC) Focused consultation: Yes No 216/2008 Publication date of the opinion: 2017/Q1 Publication date of the decision: 2017/Q4 TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 1 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 Table of contents Table of contents 1. Procedural information ........................................................................................................................ 4 1.1. The rule development procedure............................................................................................................ 4 1.2. The structure of this NPA and related documents .................................................................................. 4 1.3. How to comment on this NPA ................................................................................................................. 4 1.4. The next steps in the procedure.............................................................................................................. 5 2. Explanatory note .................................................................................................................................. 6 2.1. Overview of the subject to be addressed................................................................................................ 6 2.2. The overall context .................................................................................................................................. 7 2.3. Summary of the proposal ........................................................................................................................ 8 2.3.1. The aeronautical information products and services ......................................................................8 2.3.2. Aeronautical data quality ................................................................................................................9 2.3.3. Aerodrome operators ....................................................................................................................11 2.3.4. Aeronautical charts........................................................................................................................11 2.3.5. AIS certificate .................................................................................................................................11 2.4. Overview of the main changes compared to the ADQ Regulation ....................................................... 12 2.5. Proposal to move the ADQ requirements to the EASA regulatory framework ..................................... 13 2.6. Applicability of the new proposed rules................................................................................................ 14 2.7. Objectives .............................................................................................................................................. 15 2.8. Summary of the regulatory impact assessment (RIA) ........................................................................... 15 2.9. Overview of the proposed amendments .............................................................................................. 15 2.9.1. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) .../… ...........................................................................15 2.9.2. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 .............................................................16 2.9.3. Proposed amendments to AMC and GM to Authority, Organisation and Operations Requirements for Aerodromes ......................................................................................................................17 2.10. Overview of the proposed amendments in the ATM/ANS rule structure ............................................ 18 3. Proposed amendments....................................................................................................................... 19 3.1. Draft regulation (draft opinion) ............................................................................................................. 19 3.1.1. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) …/… ...........................................................................19 3.1.2. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 .............................................................55 3.2. Draft AMC and GM (draft decisions) ..................................................................................................... 56 3.2.1. Proposed amendments to AMC and GM to Regulation .../... .......................................................56 3.2.2. Proposed amendment to the AMC and GM to Authority, Organisation and Operations Requirements for Aerodromes ......................................................................................................................92 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) ................................................................................................... 94 4.1. Issues to be addressed .......................................................................................................................... 94 4.1.1. Safety risk assessment ...................................................................................................................96 4.1.2. Who is affected? ............................................................................................................................96 4.1.3. How could the issue/problem evolve? ..........................................................................................96 4.2. Objectives .............................................................................................................................................. 96 4.3. Policy options ........................................................................................................................................ 97 4.4. Analysis of impacts ................................................................................................................................ 97 4.4.1. Safety impact .................................................................................................................................97 4.4.2. Environmental impact ...................................................................................................................97 4.4.3. Social impact ..................................................................................................................................98 4.4.4. Economic impact ...........................................................................................................................98 4.4.5. General aviation and proportionality issues .................................................................................99 TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 2 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 Table of contents 4.4.6. Impact on ‘better regulation’ and harmonisation .......................................................................100 4.5. Comparison and conclusion ................................................................................................................ 101 4.5.1. Comparison of options ................................................................................................................101 4.5.2. Monitoring and evaluation ..........................................................................................................101 5. References ....................................................................................................................................... 103 5.1. Affected regulations ............................................................................................................................ 103 5.2. Affected AMC and GM ......................................................................................................................... 103 5.3. Reference documents.......................................................................................................................... 103 6. Appendices ...................................................................................................................................... 104 TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 3 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 1. Procedural information 1. Procedural information 1.1. The rule development procedure The European Aviation Safety Agency (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Agency’) developed this NPA in line with Regulation (EC) No 216/20081 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Basic Regulation’) and the Rulemaking Procedure2. This rulemaking activity is included in the Agency’s 5-year Rulemaking Programme under RMT.0477. The text of this NPA has been developed by the Agency based on the input of the Rulemaking Group RMT.0477. It is hereby submitted for consultation of all interested parties3. The process map on the title page contains the major milestones of this rulemaking activity to date and provides an outlook of the timescale of the next steps. 1.2. The structure of this NPA and related documents Chapter 1 of this NPA contains the procedural information related to this task. Chapter 2 explains the background, context, justification of the core technical content. Chapter 3 contains the proposed amendments. Chapter 4 contains the regulatory impact assessment showing which options were considered and what impacts were identified, thereby providing further detailed justification for this NPA. To facilitate the assessment and understanding, the Agency is providing 3 tables containing the comparisons between: — the definitions found in ICAO material and Regulation (EU) No 73/20104 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘ADQ Regulation’) with the proposed text; — the ICAO provisions and the proposed text; and — the provisions of ADQ Regulation and the proposed text. 1.3. How to comment on this NPA Please submit your comments using the automated comment-response tool (CRT) available at http://hub.easa.europa.eu/crt/. Furthermore, it is important to be noted that throughout Chapter 2 (explanatory note) and Chapter 4 (RIA) there is an matter on which the Agency explicitly invites stakeholders to answer to questions and express their opinion. The Agency is addressing said questions 1 Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 February 2008 on common rules in the field of civil aviation and establishing a European Aviation Safety Agency, and repealing Council Directive 91/670/EEC, Regulation (EC) No 1592/2002 and Directive 2004/36/EC (OJ L 79, 19.3.2008, p. 1). 2 The Agency is bound to follow a structured rulemaking process as required by Article 52(1) of the Basic Regulation. Such a process has been adopted by the Agency’s Management Board (MB) and is referred to as the ‘Rulemaking Procedure’. See MB Decision No 18-2015 of 15 December 2015 concerning the procedure to be applied by the Agency for the issuing of opinions, certification specifications and guidance material. 3 In accordance with Article 52 of Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 and Articles 6(3) and 7 of the Rulemaking Procedure. 4 Commission Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 of 26 January 2010 laying down requirements on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information for the single European sky (OJ L 23, 27.1.2010, p. 6). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 4 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 1. Procedural information to stakeholders in order to receive further guidance during the consultation of this NPA with a view to gaining additional information and the opinion of a wider audience. Although nominally the formal period for consultation is 3 months, the Agency proposes to extend that period by an additional month as it is the summer period; therefore the deadline for submission of comments is 31 August 2016. 1.4. The next steps in the procedure Following the closing of the NPA public consultation period, the Agency will review all comments and perform a focused consultation which will consist of involving relevant technical experts in the review of the comments and in the drafting of the revised rule text. The outcome of the NPA public consultation, as well as of the focused consultation, will be reflected in a comment-response document (CRD). The Agency will publish the CRD concurrently with the EASA Opinion. Based on the outcome of the consultation, the opinion will contain the proposed changes to Regulation (EU) …/…, and will be addressed to the European Commission (EC) to be used as a technical basis in order to prepare further steps within the institutions leading to the finalization of the regulatory changes. Following the adoption of the regulation, the Agency will issue a EASA Decision containing the related acceptable means of compliance (AMC) and guidance material (GM). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 5 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note 2. Explanatory note This NPA proposes a set of rules for the origination and the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. NOTE: When this document refers to ‘Regulation (EU) .../…’, it must be understood as the Regulation laying down common requirements for service providers and the oversight in air traffic management and air navigation services and other air traffic management network functions, which was voted at the Single Sky Committee on 25 February 2016 and which, at the time of the publication of this NPA, is still awaiting publication the EU Official Journal. Therefore, a reference number cannot be referred to at this stage. 2.1. Overview of the subject to be addressed AIS providers in Europe provide and manage aeronautical data and aeronautical information in a very complex data chain where aeronautical ‘service provision’ is still primarily focused on paper/electronic data management practices. These practices contribute to errors and inconsistencies in published aeronautical information. During the last years, the role and importance of aeronautical data and aeronautical information has changed significantly with the advent of the internet era, the implementation of RNAV, required navigation performance (RNP), air traffic management (ATM) requirements, and airborne computer- based navigation systems, which require some adaptation of the way aeronautical information is provided today. The provision and the management of aeronautical data and aeronautical information is expected to meet the operational demands in order to have the right information, in the right place, at the right time. One way of ensuring this is to shift to a broader concept of AIM, with a different method of information provision and management. AIM introduces new methods of distribution of aeronautical information and digital products and relies on the data-centric nature (as opposed to the product- centric nature of AIS) mainly based on the management of digital aeronautical information. Also, while one key enabler of the ATM system is interoperability, it is essential: — that aeronautical data and aeronautical information be provided in a format that ensures consistency, authenticity and appropriate coverage of the data; and — to provide accessibility to the data by all users of the ATM network, both on the ground and in the air. Most importantly, ATM is dependent on the provision of timely, relevant, accurate, and quality- assured information that allows the ATM community to ensure an efficient distribution method of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. This NPA intends to reflect the current developments occurring in the aeronautical data and aeronautical information environment in order to ensure the provision of quality aeronautical data and aeronautical information in a timely manner, with the accuracy and resolution appropriate for its intended use, and with the assurance that integrity levels are met and maintained throughout the management process in order to support all phases of flight. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 6 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note 2.2. The overall context This NPA proposes rules on aeronautical data quality and on aeronautical information services and products, based respectively on the upcoming ‘major’ amendment to ICAO Annex 15 and the new PANS-AIM, on ICAO Annex 4 including up to amendment 58 on aeronautical charts and on the ADQ Regulation. The proposed rules have taken into account: 1. The development of the upcoming ‘major’ amendment to ICAO Annex 15; and 2. The implementation of the ADQ Regulation. The upcoming ‘major’ amendment to ICAO Annex 15 Currently, ICAO Annex 15 ‘Aeronautical Information Services’ is the basis of the national regulatory framework for Member States and AIS providers. Since 2008, ICAO has set up the ICAO AIS/AIM Study Group to assist the ICAO Secretariat with the development of a global road map for the transition from AIS to AIM5 and the development of revised Standards And Recommended Practices (SARPs) and guidance material related to the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. As from 2012, this Study Group developed a new ICAO amendment proposing a revised Annex 15 that will contain the core requirements, and the new PANS-AIM containing the provisions on how to fulfil these requirements. This ICAO proposal is known as ‘the’ big amendment to the current SARPs of Annex 156. The work of the ICAO Study Group was conducted in parallel to that of the EASA Rulemaking Group. Hence, one challenge during the development of this NPA was to be able to align as closely as possible with the latest text of the ICAO proposed amendment. The major amendments already known during the rulemaking phase were the replacement of 1) the ‘Integrated aeronautical information publication (IAIP)’ with the concept of ‘aeronautical information products and services’ in order to include the different elements of the IAIP as well as the digital data sets, and 2) the definition of data quality that is expanded, to cover additional criteria to be met (data quality is not only about accuracy, resolution and integrity, but contains four additional criteria: traceability, timeliness, completeness and format). Another important element that was introduced by the ICAO proposal is the ICAO data catalogue which includes an exhaustive list of data elements that can be collected and maintained by the AIS providers. It thus provides a common terminology that can be used by data originators and service providers. The Rulemaking Group finished its drafting at the same time as the ICAO AIS/AIM Study Group. Therefore, all the changes anticipated within the ICAO material are reflected in this NPA. Any other important change to the proposed amendment that would occur at ICAO level before its final adoption can be considered during the subsequent Agency rulemaking process, and alignment can be assured until the publication of the associated Agency opinion. This NPA therefore reflects the current status of the ICAO proposed amendment but further alignment with the adopted ICAO amendment may be necessary at a later stage in order to ensure proper transposition of the ICAO SARPs. 5 Roadmap for the Transition from AIS to AIM, ICAO, first edition - 2009 6 At the time of publication of this NPA, the latest amendment adopted by ICAO (on 22 February 2016) is amendment 39. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 7 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note ADQ Regulation This Regulation entered into force on 16 February 2010 and has been applicable, for most of its articles, since 1 July 2013. The ADQ Regulation was developed to complement ICAO Annex 15 which provides the main baseline for the data quality requirements. The requirements on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information in terms of accuracy, resolution and integrity are meant to ensure and improve safety and support new concepts of operation within the European ATM network. The ADQ Regulation defines the implementation dates (1 July 2013, 1 July 2014, and 30 June 2017) as well as the main obligations for stakeholders. In 2013, the EC consulted the Member States on the implementation status of the ADQ Regulation. The consultation revealed delays in most Member States in the application of the ADQ Regulation and underlined a number of implementation issues. In 2015, the EC conducted a second survey7 on the status of implementation in the EASA Member States. The survey demonstrated that most of the parties concerned are still not compliant as regards the application dates of 1 July 2013 and of 1 July 2014. Furthermore, with regard to the application date of 30 June 2017, there is no certainty that stakeholders can comply with the ADQ Regulation. The reported reasons for the indicated delays included the lack or late availability of guidance material and specifications; the high cost of implementation and the lack of available resources; furthermore unclear legal provisions (requiring further clarification) and the complexity of addressing data originators (both technical and institutional). 2.3. Summary of the proposal The proposed rules are applicable to AIS providers, to organisations involved in the origination of aeronautical data, to service providers and to aerodrome operators. 2.3.1. The aeronautical information products and services Transposition of ICAO SARPs The rules related to aeronautical information products and services in this NPA are those stemming from the upcoming Amendment to ICAO Annex 15 and the new PANS-AIM provisions from chapters 2 to 6. In general, the provisions of (the new) Annex 15 have been transposed in the organisation requirements (AIS.OR) and those of the new PANS-AIM are reflected in the technical requirements (AIS.TR). A careful analysis of the ICAO provisions was made during the development of the rules in order to maintain the ICAO objectives. Therefore, this NPA is closely aligned with the relevant ICAO provisions. The ICAO common reference system for air navigation The horizontal, vertical and temporal systems used for air navigation are not only described in ICAO Annexes 4 (aeronautical charts) and 15 (AIS) but also in ICAO Annexes 11 (ATS) and 14 (Aerodromes). It 7 The first survey was conducted in 2013. Thereafter, the EC organised a workshop on 27 June 2014 where it summarised the current status of implementation by reporting on the Member States’ feedback collected in the autumn 2013. The second survey was conducted in October 2015, by EC letter of 10 July 2015, inviting the Member States to provide an accurate description of the situation in the countries as regards compliance with the ADQ Regulation. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 8 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note is an ICAO transverse provision and, therefore, it is not meant to be applied only by AIS providers but also by any other service provider that needs to use this common reference system for the performance of its duties. Therefore, this NPA introduces the common reference system for all relevant service providers. Data catalogue This NPA reproduces the data catalogue developed by ICAO. The data catalogue is a table presenting the scope of data that can be collected and maintained by the AIS providers and provides a common terminology that can be used by organisations involved in the origination of aeronautical data, and by service providers. It is the source of the accuracy and integrity requirements for determination and reporting of aeronautical data to AIS providers and also the source of the resolution and integrity requirements for publication and charting of products including aeronautical data. It details data elements in terms of field names, field types and field definitions and is used as a reference for aeronautical data origination and publication requirements, as applicable. The provision of aeronautical information and aeronautical data in accordance with data set specifications is ensured through the specifications contained in the data catalogue. The products and services All the elements of ICAO Annex 15 Chapter 5 on aeronautical information publication (AIP), AIP Supp, AIP amendments, aeronautical information circulars (AIC), aeronautical charts, notice to airmen (NOTAM), digital sets, distribution services and pre-flight information services, have been transposed, together with the related appendices as well as those of Chapter 6 on aeronautical information regulation and control (AIRAC), aeronautical information product updates. The provisions on post-flight information services have not been covered as this is not considered to be an AIS responsibility, as the AIS provider is only the recipient of such information. The responsibility is on either the aerodrome operators or the Member State to make arrangement to ensure that such information is made available to AIS. A detailed cross-reference table of draft ICAO Annex 15 and PANS-AIM is provided. 2.3.2. Aeronautical data quality Origination activities by aviation undertakings This NPA proposes that Member States be responsible for aviation undertakings when they are involved in the origination of aeronautical data. For this purpose, Appendix 1 to Article 3 (Provision of services) is proposed, containing origination requirements for aviation undertakings. These ‘data originators’ such as geodetic institutes and surveyors are essential actors involved at the very beginning of the aeronautical data chain. Aviation undertakings are entities, persons or organisations, other than the organisations regulated by Regulation (EU) No .../… that are affected by or affect a service delivered by a service provider. They can also be non-aviation entities. They create, modify or delete aeronautical information and aeronautical data for the purpose of aviation. They are not service providers and can therefore not be regulated as such. However, there is a need to ensure that when they originate aeronautical information and aeronautical data, they provide data of sufficient quality. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 9 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note Origination activities by service providers Origination activities can also be carried out by service providers. When this is the case, they need to comply with the requirements in ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Subpart A of Annex III. These requirements are similar to those for aviation undertakings as they are performing the same activity. The scope of ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 is limited to the activity performed by service providers from origination, processing and distribution to the aeronautical services provider. Therefore, this requirement is not applicable to aeronautical information services providers that are covered in Annex VI (Part-AIS). Data exchange This NPA proposes a performance-based approach. For the purpose of exchanging aeronautical data, the NPA leaves free the choice of the most suitable model to exchange data, as long as it is globally interoperable between the relevant parties. Practically, this means that the aeronautical information exchange model (AIXM) will have to be used, whilst not imposing a specific version of this model. This provides a more flexible approach compared to the ADQ Regulation which required the specific version 5.1 of the AIXM and is also in line with ICAO Annex 15. The format requirement is not applicable to aviation undertakings but they need to be able to exchange aeronautical data through electronic means. By electronic ‘means’ (instead of ‘connection’ in the ADQ Regulation), it is understood that the exchange of aeronautical data may be done by a number of electronic exchanges including email or pdf documents, without any manual interaction with the data itself. This approach is adopted to take into account other possibilities to exchange data than strictly automatic transfer system-to-system connection. Verification and validation process This NPA introduces requirements on service providers to ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are verified and validated. Through this mechanism, the protection against accidental or malicious alteration is ensured. The verification and validation processes sufficiently ensure the necessary data protection and that the quality of the aeronautical data is not degraded or, if it is, that there is a suitably high degree of assurance that the degradation will be identified and corrected. Hence, this NPA does not propose the application of a specific cyclic redundancy check (CRC) algorithm for the protection of data. The way how to ensure this data protection is explained in guidance material, underlining that an example of a digital error detection technique may be the use of CRCs. This pragmatic proposal provides a more objective-based approach than the one under the ADQ Regulation and is in line with ICAO Annex 15. Tools and software The proposal on ‘tools and software’ reflects a pragmatic approach, providing proportionality and therefore enabling easy implementation. This NPA proposes to not require aviation undertakings to comply with ‘tools and software’ requirements, contrary to the ADQ Regulation. This flexible approach reflects the need to focus on the objective rather than on the way each service provider organises itself to attain this objective. For service providers, it only requires, in a very general manner, that service providers must ensure that the tools and software they use do not adversely impact on the quality of such data. The requirement is applicable to service providers and not solely to AIS providers. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 10 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note 2.3.3. Aerodrome operators Regulation (EU) No 139/20148 only contains general provisions (based on ICAO Annex 14) on data quality requirements for aerodrome operators. Because many of the data originators are aerodrome operators, this NPA proposes to align the data quality requirements already included in said Regulation and the related AMC/GM with those developed under this NPA for service providers and organisations involved in data origination. The proposed requirements on data protection, data exchange, metadata are added to the ADR Regulation and are, therefore, a duplication of the requirements proposed by this NPA in order to directly address aerodrome operators. Also, a reference to the data catalogue is made to ensure that aerodrome operators will follow the applicable specifications. Question to stakeholders One issue is related to data protection and the reference to the CRC as a mean of protection. Whereas for service providers, the proposed rules limit the protection of the data through the validation and verification process and refer to the CRC mechanism at guidance material level only (in line with the draft ICAO Annex 15), for aerodrome operators, this NPA proposes to keep the reference to the CRC at AMC level in order to be aligned with ICAO Annex 14. The Agency would like to have the opinion of stakeholders whether they consider that both provisions on data protection should be fully aligned, meaning that for both service providers and aerodrome operators the CRC should be either included at AMC level or at GM level, or if a differential treatment could be kept. 2.3.4. Aeronautical charts This NPA only reproduces the key elements of ICAO Annex 4. Firstly, some charts have not been included in the proposal: the Electronic Aeronautical Chart Display, the Plotting Chart, the Aeronautical Navigation Chart — ICAO Small Scale, and the Aerodrome Terrain and Obstacle Chart — ICAO (Electronic), mainly because they are effectively not produced in Europe. Secondly, the proposed transposed requirements of ICAO Annex 4 are those limited to the obligation for service providers to make available all the necessary charts, meaning that only the two first paragraphs of each chapter of ICAO Annex 4 (function and availability) have been reproduced. As a mean to comply with the transposed requirements on aeronautical charts, this NPA proposes referring to ICAO Annex 4 as there are, in Europe, different ways to present information in aeronautical charts. 2.3.5. AIS certificate This NPA proposes modifying the certificate template for AIS services in the current Appendix 1 to Annex II of Regulation (EU).../…. It is now proposed to make the distinction between the different products/services provided under the scope of AIS, in the same way than for the other ATM/ANS services. The table in 3.1.1(3) shows the proposed changes to the current Appendix 1 to Annex II to said Regulation. 8 Commission Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 of 12 February 2014 laying down requirements and administrative procedures related to aerodromes pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ L 44, 14.2.2014). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 11 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note 2.4. Overview of the main changes compared to the ADQ Regulation In 2.3.2 above, some changes are proposed compared to what is required under the ADQ Regulation. These are due to several considerations: the different scope between the ADQ Regulation (SES framework) and the one in which this NPA has been developed (EASA framework); the necessity to take into account the changes at ICAO level (upcoming ‘major’ amendment to Annex 15 and PANS- AIM); the Regulation (EU).../…. which already covers some elements of the ADQ Regulation; safety considerations; and the necessity to take into account the current implementation challenges faced by the majority of European Member States and organisations affected by the ADQ Regulation. This table provides an overview of the main changes proposed: Subject ADQ Regulation EASA approach NPA Aviation undertakings Requirements on data to comply with Data originators are origination for: service minimum data quality Data originators regulated parties providers, aerodrome requirements. (Article 2(2)) operators, aviation Responsibility of undertakings. Member States Detailed common data The ICAO data catalogue set specifications in Data set specifications Data set covering data sets is Annex I not transposed reproduced in this NPA. (Article 4 and Annex I) Detailed technical Exchange model required specifications for the that is globally data exchange model interoperable. One mean is Performance-based Data exchange (practically equivalent to use an aeronautical approach to a given version of information exchange model AIXM) without requiring a given (Article 5 and Annex II) version. Requirement to Proportionality Cycling codes or protect data through approach. cryptographic techniques Protection of CRC32Q algorithm Use of the relevant required to ensure data data (Article 9 and algorithm according to protection. Annex VI) the AISPs capabilities. Algorithm not defined. Detailed requirements Not transposed. Not included Quality, safety for quality, safety and Sufficiently covered in It ensures consistency & security security management ATM/ANS.OR. throughout the upcoming management in (Article 10 and (management system) Regulation (EU) ../… Annex VII) in Regulation (EU) ../…) Not transposed The requirements on Not included. conformity & suitability Conformity & Detailed requirements It avoids duplication and of constituents are, at suitability of in (article 11 and ensure consistency with this stage, sufficiently constituents Annex VIII) existing European covered through regulations. Regulation (EC) No 552/2004. Detailed requirements The content of the formal Formal on the minimum Flexibility approach arrangements in Part C of arrangements content these formal Annex IV is moved to AMC TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 12 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note arrangements shall be level. This provides based on. proportionality and flexibility (Annex IV, Part C) to adapt the appropriate service level agreement depending on the data to be provided. Not applicable at origination Requirement level as it is seen as a means applicable to all the to reach the data quality. Tools and parties referred to in Pragmatic approach This eliminates burdensome software the Regulation. requirements on originators (Article 8 and Annex V) with no added value on safety. Defined in terms of accuracy, Defined in terms of Alignment with Data quality integrity, resolution, accuracy, integrity and upcoming new ICAO (Definition) traceability, timeliness, resolution. Annex 15 completeness and format. Requirements already All regulated parties to addressed in Security ensure this ATM/ANS.OR.D.010. of Not included. clearance of requirement Annex III (Part- Duplication is avoided. personnel (Article 13(a)) ATM/ANS.OR) to Regulation (EU) .../... 2.5. Proposal to move the ADQ requirements to the EASA regulatory framework The rules on aeronautical data quality proposed in this NPA have been developed with the objective of providing a proportionate approach and better understanding of the requirements to be met. The objective is to provide enough flexibility, taking into account the implementation difficulties experienced in complying with the ADQ Regulation. In addition, certain aspects of the Regulation can be better addressed through the AMC/GM material, which at the same time ensures that the investments made so far are not compromised. The rules are expected to ease the overall AIS-AIM implementation, not create any additional costs than those already engaged in the framework of the ADQ Regulation. Consequently, the Agency considers that it is not adequate to maintain two regulations with several overlapping provisions and therefore proposes the repeal of the ADQ Regulation. The following provides an overview of the remaining provisions of the ADQ Regulation: COMMISSION REGULATION (EU) No 73/2010 of 26 January 2010 laying down requirements on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information for the single European sky […] Article 1 Subject matter Article 2 Scope Article 3 Definitions Article 4 Data set ANNEX I Data set specifications referred to in Article 4 TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 13 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note PART A IAIP, aerodrome mapping and electronic obstacle data PART B Electronic terrain data sets PART C Metadata Article 5 Data exchange ANNEX II Aeronautical data exchange format requirements referred to in Article 5 PART A IAIP, aerodrome mapping and electronic obstacle data PART B Electronic terrain data Article 6 Data quality Article 7 Consistency, timeliness and personnel performance ANNEX IV Data quality requirements referred to in Articles 6 and 7 PART A Data quality requirements PART B Evidence requirements PART C Formal arrangements PART D Data origination PART E Data process requirements PART F Error reporting and rectification requirements Article 8 Tools and software requirements ANNEX V Tools and software requirements referred to in Article 8 Article 9 Data protection ANNEX VI Data protection requirements referred to in Article 9 Article 10 Management requirements ANNEX VII Quality, safety and security management requirements referred to in article 10 PART A Quality management system PART B Safety management objectives PART C Security management objectives Article 11 Conformity or suitability for use of constituents ANNEX VIII Requirements for the assessment of the conformity or suitability for use of constituents referred to in Article 11 Article 12 Verification of systems ANNEX IX Conditions referred to in Article 12 Article 13 Additional requirements Article 14 Transitional provisions ANNEX XI ICAO differences referred to in Article 14 Article 15 Entry into force and application ANNEX III Provisions referred to in articles and annexes ANNEX X PART A Requirements for the verification of systems referred to in Article 12(1) PART B Requirements for the verification of systems referred to in Article 12(2) A detailed cross-reference table of the ADQ Regulation is provided. 2.6. Applicability of the new proposed rules In accordance with Regulation …/.., the proposed rules with applicability date of 1 January 2019 would repeal the ADQ Regulation. Aeronautical data and aeronautical information that are demonstrated to be in compliance with Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 before 1 January 2019 are deemed to be in compliance with the new proposed rules. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 14 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note 2.7. Objectives The overall objectives of the EASA system are established in Article 2 of the Basic Regulation. This proposal will contribute to the achievement of the overall objectives by addressing the issues outlined in Chapter 2. The specific objectives of this proposal are to: — ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are originated, assembled, edited, formatted, published and finally provided at the required level of quality to the next intended user and for all phases of flight. The quality of the data shall be proportionate to the types of aeronautical actors involved; and — foster efficient and effective rules considering also the harmonisation with the latest ICAO Annex 15 amendment. 2.8. Summary of the regulatory impact assessment (RIA) The RIA considers the impact analysis of the below options. Option 0 — Take no action/baseline scenario. This leaves the situation at it is today and full compliance with the ADQ Regulation continues with the known implementation issues. Option 1 — The draft rules on data quality are based on a performance-based approach. The rules are adapted to allow for a pragmatic approach. Option 2 – The draft rules on data quality are founded on prescriptive and technical provisions. The rules are similar to Option 0 in terms of rules content and potential effects. The preferred option is Option 1 as it allows to maintain an acceptable level of safety while facilitating the implementation of the data quality rules. The analysis of the impacts of the options suggested above focused mainly on economic impacts. 2.9. Overview of the proposed amendments This NPA puts forward amendments to: — Regulation (EU) ../… laying down common requirements for service providers and the oversight in air traffic management and air navigation services and other air traffic management network functions; — Regulation (EU) No 139/2014; and — AMC and GM to Authority, Organisation and Operations Requirements for Aerodromes 2.9.1. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) .../… The following amendments are proposed: Article 3 In Article 3, a new paragraph introduces a requirement for Member States to ensure that aviation undertakings originating data comply with the necessary data origination requirements. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 15 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note Annex I — Definitions In Annex I: — the relevant definitions of ICAO Annex 15 and the ADQ Regulation are added; and — the definition of ‘aviation undertaking’ is amended to encompass aerodromes operators. Annex II — Authority requirements In Appendix 1 to Annex II (Service provider certificate), the ‘scope of service’ for the AIS in the certificate is amended to separate the different types of AIS. Annex III — Organisation requirements In ATM/ANS.OR.A (Subpart A – General requirements), the following requirements are added: — ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information to cover necessary data quality requirements for ATM/ANS providers when they originate, process and transmit aeronautical data and aeronautical information to the AIS provider. — ATM/ANS.OR.A.085 Common reference systems for air navigation The use of the horizontal, vertical and temporal reference systems for air navigation is transposed directly from the common reference system provisions in the different ICAO Annexes where they are referred to. Annex VI — Specific requirements for the provision of aeronautical information services (PART-AIS) Annex VI is amended to introduce the NPA requirements applicable to AIS providers. The current requirements in AIS.OR.100 (a) and (b) of Regulation (EU) .../… are reflected in the proposal and complemented by the proposed requirements addressed to AIS providers. The current AIS.TR.100 is replaced by the related technical requirements proposed in this NPA. There is, therefore, no need to make reference to relevant ICAO Annexes or to the ADQ Regulation anymore. Part-AIS is divided into the following categories of provisions: — General responsibilities of AIS providers, mostly based on draft ICAO Annex 15; — Data quality requirements, based on the ADQ Regulation and draft ICAO Annex 15; — Aeronautical information products and services, based on and aligned with draft ICAO Annex 15 and PANS-AIM; and — Personnel requirements, based on both draft ICAO Annex 15 and the ADQ Regulation. 2.9.2. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 The following amendments with regard to aerodrome operators are proposed: — ADR.OR.D.015 Personnel requirements This requirement is considered necessary to be applicable also for aerodrome operators in order for their personnel to be properly trained. It is ‘mirroring’ the similar proposed provision in Part-AIS. — ADR.OPS.A.011 Data error detection and authentication TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 16 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note Data error detection and authentication is not foreseen in Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 and is therefore included in a similar way as in the Regulation (EU) .../… . This requirement is complemented by an AMC. A specific question is addressed to stakeholders in 2.3.3. — ADR.OPS.A.012 Data catalogue The specifications of the data catalogue should be applicable for aerodrome operators. The necessary reference to the data catalogue is provided rather than repeating it in the aerodrome rules. Please refer to the data catalogue explanations in 2.3.1. — ADR.OPS.A.013 Metadata This requirement is considered necessary to be applicable also for aerodrome operators, in a way similar to that for service providers. — ADR.OPS.A.014 Data exchange This requirement is considered necessary to be applicable also for aerodrome operators, in a way similar to that for service providers. 2.9.3. Proposed amendments to AMC and GM to Authority, Organisation and Operations Requirements for Aerodromes The following amendment is proposed. AMC1.ADR.OPS.A.010 Data quality requirements This AMC is amended to add provisions related to error handling and corrective action as well as for formal arrangements. This is now aligned with the similar provisions for service providers. In addition, the paragraphs related to data protection and the reference to CRC32 are deleted to be replaced with the requirement ADR.OPS.A.011 Data error detection and authentication, referred to above. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 17 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 2. Explanatory note 2.10. Overview of the proposed amendments in the ATM/ANS rule structure Regulation (EU) …/… laying down common requirements for service providers and the oversight in air traffic management/air navigation services and other air traffic management network functions Annex I Annex III (Part- Article 3 Annex VI (Part-AIS) DEFINITIONS OF ATM/ANS.OR) Provision of Subpart A — OR TERMS USED IN Subpart A services Subpart B — TR ANNEXES II to XIII ATM/ANS.OR.A (General) [Member States For the purposes ATM/ANS.OR.A.075 Open Section 1 Section 2 Data shall…] of this Regulation, and transparent provision General quality the following of services requirements requirements [When Member definitions shall […] Section 2 Data States…] apply: quality Section 3 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 requirements Aeronautical Member States Identified Aeronautical data and Section 3 information shall ensure that definitions from aeronautical information Aeronautical products aviation ICAO and the information undertakings ADQ Regulation ATM/ANS.OR.A.085 products Section 4 originating data Common reference Section 4 Distribution and comply with systems for air navigation Distribution and pre-flight Appendix 1 to pre-flight information this article. information services APPENDIX 1 services Data Catalogue Section 5 Section 5 Aeronautical Aeronautical APPENDIX 1 Requirements information information for aviation products updates products updates undertakings Section 6 Personnel --- requirements APPENDIX 1 AIP Content APPENDIX 2 NOTAM format APPENDIX 3 SNOWTAM format APPENDIX 4 ASHTAM format TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 18 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments 3. Proposed amendments The text of the amendment is arranged to show deleted text, new or amended text as shown below: 1. deleted text is marked with strike through; 2. new or amended text is highlighted in grey; 3. an ellipsis […] indicates that the remaining text is unchanged in front of or following the reflected amendment. 3.1. Draft regulation (draft opinion) 3.1.1. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) …/… (1) Article 3 is amended as follows: Article 3 Provision of services 1. Member States shall (…) 2. Member States shall (…) 3. Member States shall ensure that aviation undertakings originating aeronautical data comply with Appendix 1 to this article. APPENDIX 1 TO ARTICLE 3 REQUIREMENTS FOR AVIATION UNDERTAKINGS 1. Scope This Appendix establishes the requirements to be met by aviation undertakings originating aeronautical information and data. 2. Common reference systems (a) The World Geodetic System WGS-84 shall be used as the horizontal reference system for data origination. (b) The mean sea level (MSL) datum shall be used as the vertical reference system for data origination. (c) The Gregorian calendar and coordinated universal time (UTC) shall be used as the temporal reference systems for data origination. 3. Formal arrangements (a) Organisations originating data shall establish formal arrangements with: (1) parties requesting the data; and (2) when different, those to which the data is delivered. (b) The formal arrangements shall include, as a minimum: (1) an unambiguous description of the data that is to be created, modified or deleted; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 19 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (2) confirmation of the entity to which the data is to be provided; (3) the date and time by which the data is to be provided; (4) the data origination report format to be used; and (5) the requirement to identify any limitations on the use of data. 4. Data catalogue Aeronautical data shall be originated in accordance with the data catalogue specified in Appendix 1 to Subpart A of Annex III. 5. Data quality requirements Data quality requirements shall be complied with at data origination and maintained through to publication to the next intended user. (a) The order of accuracy for aeronautical data shall be as specified in the data catalogue. (b) The integrity of aeronautical data shall be maintained throughout the data process from origination to distribution to the next intended user. Based on the integrity classification specified in the data catalogue, procedures shall be put in place so that: (1) for routine data, corruption is avoided throughout the processing of the data; (2) for essential data, it is assured that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and additional processes are included, as needed, to address potential risks in the overall system architecture to further assure data integrity at this level; and (3) for critical data, it is assured that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and additional integrity assurance processes are included to fully mitigate the effects of faults identified by thorough analysis of the overall system architecture as potential data integrity risks. (c) The resolution of aeronautical data shall be commensurate with the actual data accuracy. (d) Traceability of aeronautical data shall be ensured. (e) Timeliness shall be ensured by including any limits on the effective period with the data elements. (f) Completeness of the aeronautical data shall be ensured in order to support the intended use. (g) The format of delivered data shall be adequate to ensure that the data is interpreted in a manner that is consistent with the intent of the data. 6. Data verification and validation When using aeronautical data to derive or calculate new aeronautical data, the initial data shall be verified and validated, except when provided by an authoritative source. 7. Metadata (a) Metadata shall be collected and maintained up to the next intended user. (b) The metadata shall include, as a minimum: (1) the identification of the organisations or entities performing any action of originating, transmitting or manipulating the data; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 20 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (2) the action performed; and (3) the date and time the action was performed. 8. Data error detection and authentication (a) Digital data error detection techniques shall be used during the transmission and/or storage of aeronautical data and digital data sets. (b) Digital data error detection techniques shall apply to all integrity levels of data sets. (c) The transfer of aeronautical data shall be subject to a suitable authentication process such that recipients are able to confirm that the data or information has been transmitted by an authorised source. 9. Data exchange Aeronautical data shall be exchanged through electronic means. 10. Error handling requirements The error handling and corrective action mechanisms shall ensure that: (a) errors identified during data origination and after data delivery are addressed or resolved; (b) priority is given to errors in critical and essential aeronautical data. 11. Personnel requirements Personnel responsible for originating aeronautical data and aeronautical information shall be adequately trained, competent and authorised for the job they are required to do. (2) Annex I (Definitions) is amended as follows: ANNEX I DEFINITIONS FOR TERMS USED IN ANNEXES II TO XIII The following definitions are added: […] ’Aeronautical data’ means a representation of aeronautical facts, concepts or instructions in a formalised manner suitable for communication, interpretation or processing; ‘Aeronautical information circular (AIC)’ means a notice containing information that does not qualify for the origination of a NOTAM or for inclusion in the AIP, but which relates to flight safety, air navigation, technical, administrative or legislative matters; ‘Aeronautical information management (AIM)’ means the dynamic, integrated management of aeronautical information through the provision and exchange of quality-assured digital aeronautical data in collaboration with all parties; ‘Aeronautical information product’ means aeronautical data and aeronautical information provided either as digital data sets or as a standardised presentation in paper or electronic media. Aeronautical information products include: TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 21 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments — aeronautical information publication (AIP), including amendments and supplements; — aeronautical information circular (AIC); — aeronautical charts; — notice to airmen (NOTAM); and — digital data sets; ‘Aeronautical information publication (AIP)’ means a publication issued by or with the authority of a State and containing aeronautical information of a lasting character essential to air navigation; ‘Aeronautical information service’ means a service established by or on behalf of a Member State, within the defined area of coverage responsible for the provision of aeronautical information and data necessary for the safety, regularity, and efficiency of air navigation; ‘Aeronautical information services provider’ means an organisation responsible for the provision of an aeronautical information service; ‘AIP amendment’ means permanent changes to the information contained in the AIP; ‘AIP supplement’ means temporary changes to the information contained in the AIP which are provided by means of special pages; ‘Aeronautical information regulation and control’ (AIRAC) means a system aimed at advance notification, based on common effective dates, of circumstances that necessitate significant changes in operating practices; ‘Assemble’ means a process of merging data from multiple sources into a database and establishing a baseline for subsequent processing; ‘Cyclic redundancy check (CRC)’ means a mathematical algorithm applied to the digital expression of data that provides a level of assurance against loss or alteration of data; ‘Completeness (of data)’ means the degree of confidence that all of the data needed to support the intended use is provided; ’Data collection surface’ means a defined surface intended for the purpose of collecting obstacle or terrain data; ‘Data product specification’ means a detailed description of a data set or data set series together with additional information that will enable it to be created, supplied to and used by another party; ‘Data set’ means identifiable collection of data; ‘Data accuracy’ means a degree of conformance between the estimated or measured value and the true value; ‘Data integrity’ means a degree of assurance that aeronautical data and its value has not been lost or altered since the data origination or authorised amendment; ‘Data origination’ means the creation of a new data item with its associated value, the modification of the value of an existing data item or the deletion of an existing data item; ‘Datum’ means any quantity or set of quantities that may serve as a reference or basis for the calculation of other quantities; ’Feature’ means abstraction of real world phenomena; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 22 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments ‘Feature attribute’ means the characteristic of a feature having a name, a data type and a value domain associated with it; ’Feature type’ means a class of real world phenomena with common properties, forming the basic level of classification in a feature catalogue; ‘Format (of data)’ means a structure of data elements, records and files arranged to meet standards, specifications or data quality requirements; ‘Geoid’ means the equipotential surface in the gravity field of the Earth which coincides with the undisturbed mean sea level (MSL) extended continuously through the continents; ‘Geoid undulation’ means the distance of the geoid above (positive) or below (negative) the mathematical reference ellipsoid; ‘Heliport’ means an aerodrome or a defined area on a structure intended to be used wholly or in part for the arrival, departure and surface movement of helicopters; ‘Integrity classification (aeronautical data)’ means a classification based upon the potential risk resulting from the use of corrupted data, defining routine, essential and critical data; ‘International NOTAM office (NOF)’ means an office designated by a State for the exchange of NOTAM internationally; ‘Manoeuvring area’ means that part of an aerodrome to be used for the take-off, landing and taxiing of aircraft, excluding aprons; ‘Metadata’ means data about data; ‘Movement area’ means that part of an aerodrome to be used for the take-off, landing and taxiing of aircraft, consisting of the manoeuvring area and the apron; ‘Next intended user’ means the entity that receives the aeronautical information from the aeronautical information services provider; ‘Position (geographical)’ means a set of coordinates (latitude and longitude) referenced to the mathematical reference ellipsoid which define the position of a point on the surface of the Earth; ‘Route stage’ means a route or portion of a route flown without an intermediate landing; ‘Resolution (of data)’ means a number of units or digits to which a measured or calculated value is expressed and used; ‘Route stage’ means a route or portion of a route flown without an intermediate landing; ‘SNOWTAM’ means a special series NOTAM given in a standard format providing a surface condition report notifying the presence or cessation of hazardous conditions due to snow, ice, slush, frost or water associated with snow, slush, ice, or frost on the movement area; ‘Timeliness (of data)’ means the degree of confidence that the data is applicable to the period of its intended use; ‘Traceability of data’ means the degree that a system or a data product can provide a record of the changes made to that product and thereby enable an audit trail to be followed from the end-user to the data originator; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 23 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments ‘Validation’ means the process of ensuring that data meets the requirements for the specified application or intended use; ‘Verification’ means the evaluation of the output of an aeronautical data process to ensure correctness and consistency with respect to the inputs and applicable data standards, rules and conventions used in that process; […] The following definition is amended: 34. ‘Aviation undertaking’ means an entity, person or organisation, other than the service providers regulated by this Regulation or other than the aerodrome operators regulated by Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 that is affected by or affects a service delivered by a service provider or an aerodrome operator; (3) Annex II — Appendix 1 ‘SERVICE PROVIDER CERTIFICATE’ (Part-ATM/ANS.AR) is amended as follows: Services Type of Service Scope of Service Limitations* Aeronautical Provision of the whole AIS Aeronautical Information Services information publication (AIP) (AIS) Aeronautical information circular (AIC) Aeronautical charts NOTAM Aeronautical information products (including AIP data set distribution services) AIS Terrain data sets Obstacle data sets Aerodrome mapping data sets Instrument flight procedure data sets Pre-flight information n/a services Conditions** TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 24 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (4) Annex III (Part-ATM/ANS.OR) is amended as follows: In Annex III, the following points are added in Subpart A: […] ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 Aeronautical data and aeronautical information When originating, processing or transmitting data to the aeronautical information services provider, service providers shall: (a) ensure that aeronautical data is determined in accordance with the data catalogue specified in Appendix 1 to this Annex; (b) meet the following data quality requirements from origination and maintained through to publication to the next intended user: (1) The accuracy for aeronautical data shall be as specified in the data catalogue. (2) The integrity of aeronautical data shall be maintained throughout the data process from origination to distribution to the next intended user. (3) The resolution of aeronautical data shall be commensurate with the actual data accuracy. (4) Traceability of aeronautical data. (5) Timeliness of the data, by including any limits on the effective period with the data elements. (6) Completeness of the aeronautical data, in order to support the intended use. (7) The format of delivered data which shall be adequate to ensure that the data is interpreted in a manner that is consistent with the intent of the data; (c) exchange aeronautical data through electronic means; (d) establish formal arrangements between themselves when exchanging aeronautical data and aeronautical information; (e) collect metadata for aeronautical data processes and exchange points and maintain them up to the next intended user. The metadata to be collected shall include, as a minimum: (1) the identification of the organisations or entities performing any action of originating, transmitting or manipulating the data; (2) the action performed; and (3) the date and time the action was performed; (f) ensure that all tools and software used to support or automate aeronautical data and aeronautical information processes perform their functions without adversely impacting on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information; (g) when requesting a data origination activity, ensure, through formal arrangements, that: (1) the data is created, modified or deleted in compliance with their instructions; (2) their instructions contain, as a minimum: (i) an unambiguous description of the data that is to be created, modified or deleted; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 25 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (ii) confirmation of the entity to which the data is to be provided; (iii) the date and time by which the data is to be provided; (iv) the data origination report format to be used; and (v) the requirement to identify any limitation on the use of the data; (h) ensure that validation and verification techniques are employed throughout the aeronautical data processing chain to ensure that the aeronautical data meets the associated data quality requirements, and that: (1) the verification ensures that aeronautical data was received without corruption and that the aeronautical data process does not introduce corruption. Verification of received aeronautical data shall involve checks that ensure the integrity of the transmitted data; and (2) aeronautical data and aeronautical information entered manually are subject to independent verification to identify any errors that may have been introduced; (i) ensure that digital data error detection techniques are used during the transmission and/or storage of aeronautical data and digital data sets and apply to all integrity levels of data sets; (j) ensure that the transfer of aeronautical data is subject to a suitable authentication process such that recipients are able to confirm that the data or information has been transmitted by an authorised source; (k) ensure that errors identified during data origination and after data delivery are addressed or resolved and that priority is given to critical and essential aeronautical data. ATM/ANS.OR.A.085 Common reference systems for air navigation For the purpose of air navigation, service providers shall use: (a) the World Geodetic System — 1984 (WGS-84) as the horizontal reference system. (b) the mean sea level (MSL) datum as the vertical reference system. (c) the Gregorian calendar and coordinated universal time (UTC) as the temporal reference systems. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 26 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (5) Annex VI (Part-AIS) is amended as follows: ANNEX VI SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PROVISION OF AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES (Part-AIS) SUBPART A — ADDITIONAL ORGANISATION REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PROVISION OF AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES (AIS.OR) Section 1 — General requirements AIS.OR.100 Technical and operational competence and capability An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that information and data are available for operations in a form suitable for: flight operating personnel, including flight crew; flight planning, flight management systems and flight simulators; and air traffic services providers which are responsible for flight information services, aerodrome flight information services and the provision of pre-flight information. Aeronautical information services providers shall ensure the integrity of data and confirm the level of accuracy of the information distributed for operations, including the source of such information, before such information is distributed. Section 1 — General requirements AIS.OR.100 Aeronautical information management An aeronautical information services provider shall establish information management resources and processes that are adequate to ensure the timely collection, processing, storing, integration, exchange and delivery of quality-assured aeronautical data and aeronautical information within the ATM system. AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical information services providers (a) An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information necessary for the safety, regularity and efficiency of air navigation. (b) An aeronautical information services provider shall receive, collate or assemble, edit, format, publish, store and distribute aeronautical data and aeronautical information concerning the entire territory of a Member State as well as those areas over the high seas in which the Member State is responsible for the provision of air traffic services. (c) An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are available for: TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 27 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (1) personnel involved in flight operations, including flight crews, flight planning, and flight simulators; and (2) air traffic services providers responsible for flight information service, and the services responsible for pre-flight information. (d) An aeronautical information services provider shall provide 24-hour services for NOTAM origination and issuance in its area of responsibility and for pre-flight information needed in relation to route stages originating at the aerodrome/heliport in its area of responsibility. (e) An aeronautical information services provider shall make available to other aeronautical information services providers any aeronautical data and aeronautical information required by them. (f) An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that procedures are in place to assess and mitigate safety risks to aviation arising from data and information errors. (g) An aeronautical information services provider shall clearly indicate that aeronautical data and aeronautical information provided for and on behalf of a Member State are provided under the authority of that Member State, irrespective of the format in which it is provided. Section 2 — Data quality requirements AIS.OR.200 General An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that: (a) aeronautical data and aeronautical information are provided in accordance with the specifications laid down in the data catalogue, as specified in Appendix 1 to Annex III to Regulation EU …/…, and the applicable data quality requirements, as specified in AIS.TR.200; and (b) data quality requirements are maintained from reception through to distribution to the next intended user. AIS.OR.205 Formal arrangements An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that formal arrangements are established: (a) with all parties transmitting data to them; and (b) between themselves when exchanging aeronautical information and data. AIS.OR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that: (a) the format of aeronautical data is based on an aeronautical information exchange model designed to be globally interoperable; and (b) aeronautical data is exchanged through electronic means. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 28 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AIS.OR.215 Tools and software An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that all tools and software used to support or automate aeronautical data and aeronautical information processes perform their functions without adversely impacting on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. AIS.OR.220 Verification and validation process An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that verification and validation techniques are employed so that the aeronautical data meets the associated data quality requirements specified in AIS.TR.200. AIS.OR.225 Metadata requirements An aeronautical information services provider shall collect and retain metadata. AIS.OR.230 Authentication and data error detection (a) An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that: (1) digital data error detection techniques are used during the transmission and/or storage of aeronautical data and digital data sets; and (2) digital data error detection techniques apply to all integrity levels of data sets. (b) The transfer of aeronautical data shall be subject to a suitable authentication process such that recipients are able to confirm that the data or information has been transmitted by an authorised source. AIS.OR.235 Error reporting and corrective actions An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that error reporting, measurement and corrective mechanisms are established and maintained. AIS.OR.240 Data limitations An aeronautical information services provider shall identify the aeronautical data and aeronautical information that do not meet the data quality requirements. AIS.OR.250 Consistency requirement Where aeronautical data or aeronautical information is duplicated in the AIP of more than one Member State, the aeronautical information services providers responsible for those AIPs shall establish mechanisms to ensure consistency between the duplicated information. Section 3 — Aeronautical information products AIS.OR.300 General An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that, where aeronautical data and aeronautical information are provided in multiple formats, processes are implemented to ensure data and information consistency between those formats. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 29 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Chapter 1 — Aeronautical information in a standardised presentation AIS.OR.305 Aeronautical information publication (AIP) An aeronautical information services provider shall issue aeronautical information of lasting character, permanent information and long-duration temporary changes, essential to air navigation as AIP, including AIP amendments and AIP supplements. AIS.OR.310 AIP amendments An aeronautical information services provider shall: (a) provide permanent changes to the AIP as AIP amendments; and (b) ensure that the AIP is amended or re-issued at such regular intervals as necessary to ensure the information is complete and up to date. AIS.OR.315 AIP supplements An aeronautical information services provider shall: (a) issue temporary changes of long duration — three months or longer — and information of short duration that contains extensive text and/or graphics as AIP supplements; (b) regularly provide a checklist of the valid AIP supplements; (c) publish a new AIP supplement as a replacement when an error occurs in an AIP supplement or when the period of validity of an AIP supplement is changed; and (d) issue a NOTAM when there is not sufficient time for the distribution of an AIP supplement. AIS.OR.320 Aeronautical information circular (AIC) (a) An aeronautical information services provider shall issue the following as an AIC: (1) a long-term forecast of any major change in legislation, regulations, procedures or facilities; or (2) information of a purely explanatory or advisory nature that affect flight safety; or (3) information or notification of an explanatory or advisory nature concerning technical, legislative or purely administrative matters. (b) An aeronautical information services provider shall review the validity of AIC in force at least once a year. AIS.OR.325 Aeronautical charts (a) Aerodrome obstacle chart — type A (operating limitations) An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available an aerodrome obstacle chart — type A for all aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation, except for those aerodromes where there are no obstacles in the take- off flight path areas; and (2) ensure that the aerodrome obstacle chart, in combination with the relevant information published in the AIP, provides the data necessary to enable an operator to comply with the TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 30 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments operating limitations of Subpart C of Part-CAT, Part-NCC, Part-NCO and Part-SPO of Regulation (EU) No 965/2012. (b) Aerodrome obstacle chart — type B An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that when made available, the aerodrome obstacle chart — type B provides information to satisfy the following functions: (1) the determination of minimum safe altitudes/heights including those for circling procedures; (2) the determination of procedures for use in the event of an emergency during take-off or landing; (3) the application of obstacle clearing and marking criteria; and (4) the provision of source material for aeronautical charts. (c) Precision approach terrain chart An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available a precision approach terrain chart for all precision approach runway categories II and III at aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation; and (2) ensure that this chart provides detailed terrain profile information within a defined portion of the final approach, so as to enable aircraft operators to assess the effect of the terrain on decision height determination by the use of radio altimeters. (d) En route chart An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available an en route chart for all areas where flight information regions have been established; and (2) ensure that the en route chart provides flight crews with the information that will facilitate navigation along ATS routes in compliance with ATS procedures. (e) Area chart An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available an area chart where the ATS routes or position reporting requirements are complex and cannot be adequately shown on an en route chart; and (2) ensure that this chart provides flight crews with the information that will facilitate the following phases of flight: (i) the transition between the en route phase and approach to an aerodrome; (ii) the transition between take-off/missed approach and en route phase of flight; and (iii) flights through areas of complex ATS routes or airspace structure. (f) Standard departure chart — instrument (SID) An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available a SID chart wherever a SID route has been established and cannot be shown with sufficient clarity on the area chart; and TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 31 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (2) ensure that this chart provides flight crews with the information that will enable them to comply with the designated SID route from the take-off phase to the en route phase. (g) Standard arrival chart — instrument (STAR) An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available a STAR chart wherever a standard instrument arrival route has been established and cannot be shown with sufficient clarity on the area chart; and (2) ensure that this chart provides flight crews with the information that will enable them to comply with the designated standard instrument arrival route from the en route phase to the approach phase. (h) Instrument approach chart An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available instrument approach charts for all aerodromes used by international civil aviation where instrument approach procedures have been established; and (2) ensure that these charts provide flight crews with the information that will enable them to perform an approved instrument approach procedure to the runway of intended landing, including the missed approach procedure and, where applicable, associated holding patterns. (i) Visual approach chart An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available a visual approach chart for all aerodromes used by international civil aviation where: (i) only limited navigation facilities are available; or (ii) radio communication facilities are not available; or (iii) no adequate aeronautical charts of the aerodrome and it surroundings at 1:500 000 or greater scale are available; or (iv) visual approach procedures have been established; and (2) ensure that this chart provides flight crews with the information that will enable them to transit from the en route/descent phase to the approach phase of flight to the runway of intended landing by means of visual reference. (j) Aerodrome/heliport chart An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available an aerodrome/heliport chart for all aerodromes and heliports regularly used by international civil aviation; and (2) ensure that this chart provides flight crews with: (i) information that facilitates the ground movement of aircraft between the aircraft stand and the runway; (ii) information that facilitates helicopter movement: TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 32 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (A) between the final approach and take-off area, the touchdown and lift-off area and the helicopter stand; (B) along helicopter ground and air taxiways; and (C) along air transit routes; and (iii) essential operational information at the aerodrome or heliport. (k) Aerodrome ground movement chart Where an aerodrome ground movement chart is provided, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that it provides flight crews with detailed information to facilitate the ground movement of aircraft to and from the aircraft stands and the parking or docking of aircraft. (l) Aircraft parking/docking chart Where an aircraft parking/docking chart is provided, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that it provides flight crews with detailed information to facilitate the ground movement of aircraft between the taxiways and the aircraft stands and the parking or docking of aircraft. (m) World aeronautical chart 1:1 000 000 An aeronautical information services provider shall: (1) make available the world aeronautical chart 1:1 000 000 unless its operational requirements are effectively satisfied by the aeronautical chart 1:500 000; and (2) ensure that, when the world aeronautical Chart 1:1 000 000 is provided, that the chart provides the information to satisfy the requirements of visual air navigation. (n) Aeronautical chart 1:500 000 Where an aeronautical chart 1:500 000 is provided, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that it provides the information to satisfy the requirements of visual air navigation for low speed, short- or medium-range operations at low and intermediate altitudes. (o) Air traffic control (ATC) surveillance minimum altitude chart Where an ATC surveillance minimum altitude chart is provided, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that it provides the information that will enable flight crews to monitor and cross- check altitude assigned by an air traffic controller using an ATS surveillance system. (p) Chart distribution requirements An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that the following aeronautical charts, where made available: (1) form part of the AIP or are provided separately to recipients of the AIP: (i) aerodrome obstacle chart — type A; (ii) aerodrome/heliport chart; (iii) aerodrome ground movement chart; (iv) aircraft parking/docking chart; (v) precision approach terrain chart; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 33 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (vi) ATC surveillance minimum altitude chart; (vii) area chart; (viii) standard arrival chart — instrument (STAR); (ix) standard departure chart — instrument (SID); (x) instrument approach chart; (xi) visual approach chart; and (xii) en route chart; and (2) are provided as part of the aeronautical information products: (i) aerodrome obstacle chart — type B; (ii) world aeronautical chart 1:1 000 000; and (iii) world aeronautical chart 1:500 000. AIS.OR.330 NOTAM An aeronautical information services provider shall: (a) originate and issue promptly a NOTAM whenever the information to be distributed is of a temporary nature and of short duration or when operationally significant permanent changes, or temporary changes of long duration are made at short notice, except for extensive text and/or graphics; (b) issue information concerning the establishment, condition or change in any aeronautical facility, service, procedure or hazard, the timely knowledge of which is essential to personnel concerned with flight operations, as a NOTAM; (c) ensure that international exchange of NOTAM takes place only as mutually agreed between the international NOTAM offices and multinational NOTAM processing units concerned. Chapter 2 — Digital data sets AIS.OR.335 General (a) When provided, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that digital data is in the form of the following data sets: (1) AIP data set; (2) terrain data sets; (3) obstacle data sets; (4) aerodrome mapping data sets; and (5) instrument flight procedure data sets. (b) Each data set shall include a minimum set of metadata, as defined in AIS.TR.340 that needs to be provided to the next intended user. (c) A checklist of valid data sets shall be regularly provided. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 34 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AIS.OR.340 Metadata requirements Each data set shall include metadata. AIS.OR.345 AIP data set When provided, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that the AIP data set contains the digital representation of aeronautical information of lasting character, including permanent information and long-duration temporary changes, essential to air navigation. AIS.OR.350 Terrain and obstacle data — general requirements When made available, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that terrain and obstacle data are provided in accordance with AIS.TR.350. AIS.OR.355 Terrain data sets Where made available, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that terrain data are provided: (a) for Area 1; (b) for aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation, to cover: (1) Area 2a; (2) Areas 2b, 2c and 2d for terrain that penetrates the relevant terrain data collection surface; (3) the take-off flight path area; (4) an area bounded by the lateral extent of the aerodrome obstacle limitation surfaces; (5) Area 3; (6) Area 4 for all runways where precision approach category II or III operations have been established and where detailed terrain information is required by operators to enable them to assess the effect of terrain on decision height determination by use of radio altimeters; or parts thereof. AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets Where made available, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that obstacle data are provided: (a) for obstacles in Area 1 whose height is 100 m or higher above ground; (b) for aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation, for all obstacles within Area 2 that are assessed as being a hazard to air navigation; (c) for aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation, to cover: (1) Area 2a, for those obstacles that penetrate the relevant obstacle data collection surface; (2) objects in the take-off flight path area which project above a plane surface having a 1.2 % slope and having a common origin with the take-off flight path area; (3) penetrations of the aerodrome obstacle limitation surfaces; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 35 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (4) Areas 2b, 2c and 2d for obstacles that penetrate the relevant obstacle data collection surfaces; (5) Area 3 for obstacles that penetrate the relevant obstacle data collection surface; and (6) Area 4, for all runways where precision approach category II or III operations have been established, or parts thereof. AIS.OR.365 Aerodrome mapping data sets Where made available, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that aerodrome mapping data sets are provided in accordance with AIS.TR.365. AIS.OR.370 Instrument flight procedure data sets Where made available, an aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that instrument flight procedure data sets are provided in accordance with AIS.TR.370. Section 4 — Distribution and pre-flight information services AIS.OR.400 Distribution services An aeronautical information services provider shall: (a) distribute aeronautical information products to those users who requested them; (b) make available AIP, AIP amendments, AIP supplements, NOTAM and AIC by the most expeditious means; (c) ensure that NOTAM are distributed through the aeronautical fixed service (AFS), whenever practicable; (d) ensure the exchange of NOTAM between international NOTAM offices and/or multinational NOTAM processing units concerned; and (e) arrange, as necessary, the issuance and receipt of NOTAM distributed by telecommunication to satisfy operational requirements. AIS.OR.405 Pre-flight information services An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that: (a) for any aerodrome/heliport regularly used by international civil aviation, aeronautical information relative to the route stages originating at the aerodrome/heliport is made available to flight operations personnel, including flight crews and services responsible for pre-flight information; and (b) aeronautical information provided for pre-flight planning purposes includes information of operational significance from the elements of the aeronautical information products. Section 5 — Aeronautical information products updates AIS.OR.500 General An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are amended or reissued to keep them up to date. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 36 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AIS.OR.505 AIRAC (a) An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that information concerning the following circumstances is distributed under the AIRAC system, i.e. basing establishment, withdrawal of or significant changes upon a series of common effective dates at intervals of 28 days, including [XX/XX/2016]: (1) horizontal and vertical limits, regulations and procedures applicable to: (i) flight information regions; (ii) control areas; (iii) control zones; (iv) advisory areas; (v) ATS routes; (vi) permanent danger, prohibited and restricted areas (including type and periods of activity when known) and ADIZ; and (vii) permanent areas or routes, or portions thereof, where the possibility of interception exists; (2) positions, frequencies, call signs, identifiers, known irregularities and maintenance periods of radio navigation aids, and communication and surveillance facilities; (3) holding and approach procedures, arrival and departure procedures, noise abatement procedures and any other pertinent ATS procedures; (4) transition levels, transition altitudes and minimum sector altitudes; (5) meteorological facilities (including broadcasts) and procedures; (6) runways and stopways; (7) taxiways and aprons; (8) aerodrome ground operating procedures (including low visibility procedures); (9) approach and runway lighting; and (10) aerodrome operating minima if published by a State. (b) An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that: (1) the information notified under the AIRAC system is not changed further for at least another 28 days after the effective date unless the circumstance notified is of a temporary nature and would not persist for the full period; (2) the information provided under the AIRAC system is distributed/made available so as to reach recipients at least 28 days in advance of the AIRAC effective date; and (3) implementation dates other than AIRAC effective dates are not used for pre-planned operationally significant changes requiring cartographic work and/or for updating of navigation databases. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 37 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AIS.OR.510 NOTAM updates An aeronautical information services provider shall: (a) ensure that NOTAM updates are provided in accordance with AIS.TR.510; and (b) provide a ‘Trigger’ NOTAM when an AIP amendment or an AIP supplement is published in accordance with AIRAC procedures. AIS.OR.515 Digital data updates An aeronautical information services provider shall: (a) amend or reissue data sets at such regular intervals as may be necessary to keep them up to date; (b) issue permanent changes and temporary changes of long duration — three months or longer — made available as digital data in the form of a complete data set and/or a sub-set that includes only the differences from the previously issued complete data set. Section 6 — Personnel requirements AIS.OR.600 General requirements An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that personnel responsible for tasks in the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information is: (a) made aware of and applies: (1) the requirements for aeronautical information products and services, as specified in Sections 2 to 5; and (2) the update cycles applicable to the issue of AIP amendments and supplements for the areas for which they are providing aeronautical data or aeronautical information; and (b) adequately trained, competent and authorised for the job it is required to do. AIS.OR.605 Language proficiency An aeronautical information services provider shall ensure that its personnel is proficient in speaking, reading, writing and understanding English, as required for the functions that it is expected to perform. SUBPART B — TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PROVISION OF AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES (AIS.TR) An aeronautical information services provider shall be able to demonstrate that their working methods and operating procedures are compliant with the standards in the following Annexes to the Convention on International Civil Aviation as far as they are relevant to the provision of aeronautical information services in the airspace concerned: Annex 4 on aeronautical charts in its 11th edition of July 2009, including all amendments up to and including No 58; and TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 38 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments without prejudice to Regulation (EU) No 73/20109, Annex 15 on aeronautical information services in its 14th edition of July 2013, including all amendments up to and including No 38. The following sections are inserted: Section 2 — Data quality requirements AIS.TR.200 General (a) The accuracy for aeronautical data shall be as in the data catalogue, as specified in Appendix 1 to Annex III. (b) The resolution of aeronautical data shall be commensurate with the actual data accuracy. (c) The integrity of aeronautical data shall be maintained throughout the data process from reception to distribution to the next intended user. Based on the integrity classification specified in the data catalogue, procedures shall be put in place so that: (1) for routine data, corruption is avoided throughout the processing of the data; (2) for essential data, it is assured that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and additional processes are included as needed to address potential risks in the overall system architecture to further assure data integrity at this level; and (3) for critical data, it is assured that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and additional integrity assurance processes are included to fully mitigate the effects of faults identified by thorough analysis of the overall system architecture as potential data integrity risks. (d) Traceability of aeronautical data shall be ensured and retained. (e) Timeliness shall be ensured by including any limits on the effective period with the data elements. (f) Completeness of the aeronautical data shall be ensured in order to support the intended use. (g) The format of delivered data shall be adequate to ensure that the data is interpreted in a manner that is consistent with the intended use of the data. AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information Except for terrain data, the exchange format of aeronautical data shall: (a) enable the exchange of data for both individual features and feature collections; (b) enable the exchange of baseline information as a result of permanent changes; and (c) be in accordance with the subjects, properties and associations of the data catalogue, and be documented through mapping rules. 9 Commission Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 of 26 January 2010 laying down requirements on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information for the single European sky (OJ L 23, 27.1.2010, p. 6). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 39 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AIS.TR.220 Verification and validation process (a) The verification shall ensure: (1) that aeronautical data was received without corruption; (2) that the aeronautical data process does not introduce corruption; and (3) the integrity of the transmitted data. (b) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information entered manually shall be subject to independent verification to identify any errors that may have been introduced. AIS.TR.225 Metadata The metadata to be collected shall include, as a minimum: (a) the identification of the organisations or entities performing any action of originating, transmitting or manipulating the data; (b) the action performed; and (c) the date and time the action was performed. AIS.TR.235 Error reporting and corrective actions The error reporting, measurement and corrective mechanisms shall ensure that: (a) problems identified during origination, production, storage, handling and processing, or those reported by users after publication, are recorded; (b) all problems reported in relation to the aeronautical data and aeronautical information are analysed by the aeronautical information services provider and the necessary corrective actions are determined; (c) priority is given to resolution of all errors, inconsistencies and anomalies detected in critical and essential aeronautical data; (d) affected users are warned of errors by the most effective means, taking into account the integrity level of the aeronautical data and aeronautical information; and (e) error feedback is facilitated and encouraged. AIS.TR.240 Data limitations The identification of data not meeting the data quality requirements shall be made with an annotation or by explicitly providing the quality value. Section 3 — Aeronautical information products AIS.TR.300 General (a) Aeronautical information products intended for international distribution shall include English text for those parts expressed in plain language. (b) Place names shall be spelt in conformity with local usage, transliterated, when necessary, into the ISO basic Latin alphabet. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 40 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (c) ICAO abbreviations shall be used in the aeronautical information services whenever they are appropriate and their use will facilitate distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. Chapter 1 — Aeronautical information in a standardised presentation AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication (AIP) (a) The AIP, AIP amendments and AIP supplements shall be provided on paper and/or as an electronic document ‘electronic AIP’ (eAIP) that allows for displaying on computer screen and printing on paper. (b) The AIP shall include: (1) a statement of the competent authority responsible for the air navigation facilities, services or procedures covered by the AIP; (2) the general conditions under which the services or facilities are available for international use; (3) a list of significant differences between the national regulations and practices of the State and the related ICAO Standards, Recommended Practices and Procedures, given in a form that would enable a user to differentiate readily between the requirements of the State and the related ICAO provisions; and (4) the choice made by a State in each significant case where an alternative course of action is provided for in ICAO Standards, Recommended Practices and Procedures. (c) The AIP shall contain information relating to, and arranged under, the subject headings listed in Appendix 1 to this Annex. (d) The issuing State and publishing authority shall be clearly indicated. (e) When two or more States jointly provide an AIP, these States shall be clearly indicated. (f) Each AIP shall be self-contained and shall include a table of contents. (g) An AIP shall be organised in three parts (GEN, ENR and AD), sections and sub-sections, except when the AIP, or a volume of the AIP, is designed to facilitate operational use in flight, in which case the precise format and arrangement may be left to the discretion of the State provided that an adequate table of contents is included. (h) Each AIP shall be dated. (i) The date, consisting of the day, month (by name) and year, shall be the publication date and/or the effective date (AIRAC) of the information. (j) When describing periods of activity, availability or operation, the applicable days and times shall be specified. (k) Each AIP issued as a printed volume and each page of an AIP issued in loose-leaf form shall be annotated as to indicate clearly: (1) the territory covered and subdivisions when necessary; (2) the identification of the issuing State or the joint issuing States and producing organisation (authority); and (3) page numbers/chart titles. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 41 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (l) When provided, the information content of the eAIP and the structure of chapters, sections and sub- sections shall follow the content and structure of the paper AIP. (m) The method of amendment of the printed volume AIP shall be by means of replacement sheets. AIS.TR.310 AIP amendments (a) Any operationally significant changes to the AIP shall be issued under AIRAC and clearly identified as such. (b) Each AIP amendment shall be allocated a serial number, which shall be consecutive. (c) When an AIP amendment is issued, it shall include references to the serial number of the NOTAM which have been incorporated into the amendment. (d) The most current update cycles applicable to AIP amendments shall be made publicly available. (e) Each AIP amendment shall: (1) include a checklist giving the current date of each loose-leaf page in the AIP, and the checklist shall carry both the page number and date; and (2) provide a recapitulation of any outstanding manuscript corrections. (f) Each AIP amendment page, including the cover sheet, shall: (1) be identified by an annotation against it in the margin; and (2) contain a publication date and/or an effective date when applicable. (g) The AIP amendment regular interval shall be specified in the AIP, Part 1 — General (GEN). (h) Recourse to hand amendments or hand annotations shall be kept to the minimum; the normal method of amendment shall be by re-issuing or by replacement of pages. AIS.TR.315 AIP supplements (a) The AIP supplement shall be provided by means of distinctive pages. (b) The most current update cycles applicable to AIP supplements shall be made publicly available. (c) Each AIP supplement shall be allocated a serial number which shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. (d) Whenever an AIP supplement is issued as a replacement of a NOTAM, a reference to the series and number of the NOTAM shall be included. (e) A checklist of valid AIP supplements shall be issued at intervals of not more than one month as part of the checklist of NOTAM and with distribution as for the AIP supplements. (f) Each AIP supplement page shall show a publication date. Each AIRAC AIP supplement page shall show a publication date and an effective date. (g) When there is not sufficient time for the distribution of an AIP Supplement, a NOTAM shall be issued. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 42 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AIS.TR.320 Aeronautical information circular (AIC) (a) The AIC shall be provided on paper and/or as part of the electronic document ‘electronic AIP’ (eAIP) that allows for displaying on computer screen and printing on paper. (b) The AIC shall be provided whenever it is desirable to promulgate: (1) forecasts of important changes in the air navigation procedures, services and facilities provided; (2) forecasts of implementation of new navigational systems; (3) significant information arising from aircraft accident/incident investigation which has a bearing on flight safety; (4) information on regulations relating to the safeguarding of international civil aviation against acts of unlawful interference; (5) advice on medical matters of special interest to pilots; (6) warnings to pilots concerning the avoidance of physical hazards; (7) effect of certain weather phenomena on aircraft operations; (8) information on new hazards affecting aircraft handling techniques; (9) regulations relating to the carriage of restricted articles by air; (10) reference to the requirements of, and publication of changes in, national legislation; (11) aircrew licensing arrangements; (12) training of aviation personnel; (13) application of, or exemption from, requirements in national legislation; (14) advice on the use and maintenance of specific types of equipment; (15) actual or planned availability of new or revised editions of aeronautical charts; (16) carriage of communication equipment; (17) explanatory information relating to noise abatement; (18) selected airworthiness directives; (19) changes in NOTAM series or distribution, new editions of AIP or major changes in their contents, coverage or format; (20) advance information on the snow plan; and (21) other information of a similar nature. (c) The AIC shall not be used for information that qualifies for inclusion in AIP or NOTAM. (d) The snow plan issued under AD 1.2.2 of the AIP shall be supplemented by seasonal information, to be issued well in advance of the beginning of each winter — not less than one month before the normal onset of winter conditions. (e) When the AIC is selected by the originating State for international distribution, it shall have the same distribution as the AIP. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 43 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (f) Each AIC shall be allocated a serial number which shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. (g) In the event that AIC are provided in more than one series, each series shall be separately identified by a letter. (h) A checklist of AIC currently in force shall be issued at least once a year, with distribution as for the AIC. (i) A checklist of AIC provided internationally shall be included in the NOTAM checklist. AIS.TR.325 Aeronautical charts (a) Aerodrome obstacle chart — type A (operating limitations) Where a chart is not required because no obstacles exist in the take-off flight path area, a notification to this effect shall be published in the AIP. (b) En route chart Separate en route charts shall be made available where different ATS routes, position reporting requirements or lateral limits of flight information regions or control areas exist in different layers of airspace and cannot be shown with sufficient clarity on one chart. (c) Area chart Separate area charts shall be made available where the ATS routes or position reporting requirements are different for arrivals and for departures, and these cannot be shown with sufficient clarity on one chart. (d) Instrument approach chart Separate instrument approach charts shall be made available when the values for track, time or altitude differ between different categories of aircraft on other than the final approach segment of the instrument approach procedures and the listing of these differences on a single chart could cause clutter or confusion. AIS.TR.330 NOTAM (a) A NOTAM shall contain the following information: (1) establishment of, closure of, or significant changes in operation of aerodrome(s) or heliport(s) or runways; (2) establishment of, withdrawal of, and significant changes in operation of aeronautical services; (3) establishment of, withdrawal of, and significant changes in operational capability of radio navigation and air-ground communication services; (4) unavailability of back-up and secondary systems, having a direct operational impact; (5) establishment of, withdrawal of, or significant changes made to visual aids; (6) interruption of or return to operation of major components of aerodrome lighting systems; (7) establishment of, withdrawal of, or significant changes made to procedures for air navigation services; (8) occurrence or correction of major defects or impediments in the manoeuvring area; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 44 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (9) changes to and limitations on availability of fuel, oil and oxygen; (10) major changes to search and rescue facilities and services available; (11) establishment of, withdrawal of, or return to operation of hazard beacons marking obstacles to air navigation; (12) changes in regulations or EASA operational directives requiring immediate action; (13) presence of hazards which affect air navigation; (14) planned laser emissions, laser displays and search lights if pilots’ night vision is likely to be impaired; (15) erecting or removal of, or changes to, obstacles to air navigation in the take-off/climb, missed approach, approach areas and runway strip; (16) establishment or discontinuance of, including activation or deactivation, as applicable, or changes in the status of prohibited, restricted or danger areas; (17) establishment or discontinuance of areas or routes, or portions thereof, where the possibility of interception exists and where the maintenance of guard on the VHF emergency frequency 121.5 MHz is required; (18) allocation, cancellation or change of location indicators; (19) changes in aerodrome/heliport rescue and firefighting category; (20) presence or removal of, or significant changes in, hazardous conditions due to snow, slush, ice, radioactive material, toxic chemicals, volcanic ash deposition or water on the movement area; (21) outbreaks of epidemics necessitating changes in notified requirements for inoculations and quarantine measures; (22) forecasts of solar cosmic radiation, where provided; (23) an operationally significant change in volcanic activity, the location, date and time of volcanic eruptions and/or horizontal and vertical extent of volcanic ash cloud, including direction of movement, flight levels and routes or portions of routes which could be affected; (24) release into the atmosphere of radioactive materials or toxic chemicals following a nuclear or chemical incident, the location, date and time of the incident, the flight levels and routes, or portions thereof, that could be affected and the direction of movement; (25) establishment of operations of humanitarian relief missions, together with procedures and/or limitations that affect air navigation; (26) implementation of short-term contingency measures in cases of disruption, or partial disruption, of air traffic services and related supporting services; and (27) specific loss of satellite-based navigation systems integrity; (b) A NOTAM shall not contain the following information: (1) routine maintenance work on aprons and taxiways that does not affect the safe movement of aircraft; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 45 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (2) runway marking work, when aircraft operations can safely be conducted on other available runways, or the equipment used can be removed when necessary; (3) temporary obstructions in the vicinity of aerodromes/heliports that do not affect the safe operation of aircraft; (4) partial failure of aerodrome/heliport lighting facilities where such failure does not directly affect aircraft operations; (5) partial temporary failure of air-ground communications when suitable alternative frequencies are available and are operative; (6) the lack of apron marshalling services and road traffic closures, limitations and control; (7) the unserviceability of location, destination or other instruction signs on the aerodrome movement area; (8) parachuting when in uncontrolled airspace under VFR , when controlled, at promulgated sites or within danger or prohibited areas; (9) training activities by ground units; (10) unavailability of back-up and secondary systems if these do not have an operational impact; (11) limitations to airport facilities or general services with no operational impact; (12) national regulations not affecting general aviation; (13) announcement or warnings about possible/potential limitations, without any operational impact; (14) general reminders on already published information; (15) availability of equipment for ground units without containing information on the operational impact for airspace and facility users; (16) information about laser emissions without any operational impact and fireworks below minimum flying heights; (17) closure of movement area parts in connection with planned work locally coordinated of duration of less than one hour; (18) closure, changes, unavailability in operation of aerodrome(s)/heliport(s) other than aerodrome(s)/heliport(s) operation hours; and (19) other non-operational information of a similar temporary nature; (c) Except as provided for in AIS.TR.330(d) and AIS.TR.330(e), each NOTAM shall contain the information in the order shown in the NOTAM Format in Appendix 2. (d) NOTAM text shall be composed of the significations/uniform abbreviated phraseology assigned to the ICAO NOTAM Code complemented by ICAO abbreviations, indicators, identifiers, designators, call signs, frequencies, figures and plain language. (e) All NOTAM shall be issued in English language. If necessary for domestic users, NOTAM may additionally be issued in national language. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 46 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (f) Information concerning snow, slush, ice, frost, standing water, or water associated with snow, slush, ice or frost on the movement area shall be disseminated by means of SNOWTAM, and shall contain the information in the order shown in the SNOWTAM Format in Appendix 3. (g) Information concerning an operationally significant change in volcanic activity, a volcanic eruption and/or volcanic ash cloud shall, when reported by means of an ASHTAM, contain the information in the order shown in the ASHTAM Format in Appendix 4. (h) When errors occur in a NOTAM, a NOTAM with a new number to replace the erroneous NOTAM shall be issued or the erroneous NOTAM shall be cancelled and a new NOTAM issued. (i) When a NOTAM is issued that cancels or replaces a previous NOTAM: (1) the series and number of the previous NOTAM shall be indicated; and (2) the series, location indicator and subject of both NOTAM shall be the same. (j) Only one NOTAM shall be cancelled or replaced by a NOTAM. (k) Each NOTAM shall deal with only one subject and one condition of the subject. (l) Each NOTAM shall be as brief as possible and compiled so that its meaning is clear without the need to refer to another document. (m) Each NOTAM shall be transmitted as a single telecommunication message. (n) A NOTAM containing permanent or temporary information of long duration shall carry appropriate AIP or AIP supplement references. (o) Location indicators included in the text of a NOTAM shall be those contained in ICAO Doc 7910 (Location Indicators). In no case shall a curtailed form of such indicators be used. (p) Where no ICAO location indicator is assigned to the location, its place name shall be entered in plain language, spelt in conformity with local usage, transliterated, when necessary, into the ISO basic Latin alphabet. (q) To each NOTAM shall be allocated a series identified by a letter and a four-digit number followed by a stroke and a two-digit number for the year. The four-digit number shall be consecutive and based on the calendar year. (r) All NOTAM shall be divided in series based on subject, traffic or location or a combination thereof, depending on end-user needs. NOTAM for aerodromes allowing international air traffic shall be issued in international NOTAM series. (s) If NOTAM are issued in both English and national language, the NOTAM series shall be organised so that the national language series are equivalents of the English language series in terms of content and numbering. (t) The content and geographical coverage of each NOTAM series shall be stated in detail in the AIP, GEN 3. (u) A checklist of valid NOTAM shall be regularly provided. (v) One checklist NOTAM shall be issued for each series. (w) A checklist NOTAM shall also refer to the latest AIP amendments, AIP supplements, data sets and at least the internationally distributed AIC. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 47 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (x) A checklist NOTAM shall have the same distribution as the actual message series to which they refer and shall be clearly identified as checklist. (y) Series allocation shall be monitored and if required, appropriate measures shall be taken to assure that no series reaches the maximum possible number of issued NOTAM before the end of a calendar year. Chapter 2 — Digital data sets AIS.TR.335 General (a) A standard for geographic information shall be used as a reference framework. (b) A description of the available digital data sets shall be provided in the form of data product specification. (c) A checklist of the available data sets, including their effective and publication dates, shall be made available to allow the users to ensure that current data is being used. (d) The checklist of data sets shall be made available through the same distribution mechanism as used for the data sets. AIS.TR.340 Metadata requirements The minimum metadata for each data set shall include: (a) the name of the organisations or entities providing the data set; (b) the date and time when the data set was provided; (c) validity of the data set; and (d) any limitations with regard to the use of the data set. AIS.TR.345 AIP data set (a) The AIP data set shall include data about the following subjects, with the properties indicated being included, if applicable: Data subjects Associated properties as a minimum ATS airspace type, name, lateral limits, vertical limits, class of airspace Special activity airspace type, name, lateral limits, vertical limits, restriction, activation Route identifier prefix, flight rules, designator Route segment navigation specification, startpoint, endpoint, track, distance, upper limit, lower limit, minimum en route altitude (MEA), minimum obstruction clearance altitude (MOCA), direction of cruising level, reverse direction of cruising level, required navigation performance Waypoint — en route reporting requirement, identification, location, formation Aerodrome/heliport location indicator, name, designator IATA, served city, certified ICAO, certification date, certification expiration date, control type, field elevation, reference temperature, magnetic variation, airport reference point TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 48 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Runway designator, nominal length, nominal width, surface type, strength Runway direction designator, true bearing, threshold, take-off run available (TORA), take-off distance available (TODA), accelerate-stop distance available (ASDA), landing distance available (LDA), rejected TODA FATO designation, length, width, threshold point TLOF designator, centre point, length, width, surface type Radio navigation aid type identification, name, aerodrome served, hours of operation, magnetic variation, frequency/channel, position, elevation, magnetic bearing, true bearing, zero bearing direction (b) When a property is not defined for a particular occurrence of the subjects listed in (a), the AIP data sub- set shall include an explicit ‘not applicable’ indication. AIS.TR.350 Terrain and obstacle data — general requirements The coverage areas for sets of electronic terrain and obstacle data shall be specified as: (a) Area 1: the entire territory of a State; (b) Area 2: within the vicinity of an aerodrome, subdivided as follows: (1) Area 2a: a rectangular area around a runway that comprises the runway strip plus any clearway that exists; (2) Area 2b: an area extending from the ends of Area 2a in the direction of departure, with a length of 10 km and a splay of 15 % to each side; (3) Area 2c: an area extending outside Areas 2a and 2b at a distance of not more than 10 km from the boundary of Area 2a; and (4) Area 2d: an area outside the Areas 2a, 2b and 2c up to a distance of 45 km from the aerodrome reference point, or to an existing terminal manoeuvring area (TMA) boundary, whichever is nearest; (c) Area 3: the area bordering an aerodrome movement area that extends horizontally from the edge of a runway to 90 m from the runway centre line and 50 m from the edge of all other parts of the aerodrome movement area; and (d) Area 4: the area extending 900 m prior to the runway threshold and 60 m each side of the extended runway centre line in the direction of the approach on a precision approach runway, category II or III. [Annex 15, Appendix 1, Terrain and Obstacle data requirements] AIS.TR.355 Terrain data sets (a) Terrain data sets shall contain the digital representation of the terrain surface in the form of continuous elevation values at all intersections of a defined grid, referenced to common datum. (b) A terrain grid shall be angular or linear and shall be of regular or irregular shape. (c) Sets of terrain data shall include spatial (position and elevation), thematic and temporal aspects for the surface of the Earth containing naturally occurring features, excluding obstacles. (d) Only one feature type shall be provided. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 49 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (e) The terrain feature attributes represent the minimum set of terrain attributes, and those annotated as mandatory shall be recorded in the terrain data set. (f) Within Areas 2b, 2c and 2d, terrain data shall be collected: (1) within 10 km from the aerodrome reference point (ARP); (2) beyond 10 km from the ARP if terrain penetrates the horizontal plane 120 m above the lowest runway elevation. (g) Within the area covered by a 10-km radius from the ARP, terrain data shall comply with the Area 2 numerical requirements. (h) In the area between 10 km and the TMA boundary or 45-km radius (whichever is smaller), data on terrain that penetrates the horizontal plane 120 m above the lowest runway elevation shall comply with the Area 2 numerical requirements. (i) In the area between 10 km and the TMA boundary or 45-km radius (whichever is smaller), data on terrain that does not penetrate the horizontal plane 120 m above the lowest runway elevation shall comply with the Area 1 numerical requirements. (j) In those portions of Area 2 where flight operations are prohibited due to very high terrain or other local restrictions and/or regulations, terrain data shall comply with the Area 1 numerical requirements. (k) Within Area 3, terrain data shall be collected for terrain that extends half metre (0.5 m) above the horizontal plane passing through the nearest point on the aerodrome movement area. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 50 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data sets (a) Obstacle data elements are features that shall be represented in the data sets by points, lines or polygons. (b) All defined obstacle feature types shall be provided and each of them shall be described. (c) Obstacle data for Areas 2 and 3 shall be collected in accordance with the following obstacle collection surfaces: (1) the Area 2a obstacle collection surface has a height of 3 m above the nearest runway elevation measured along the runway centre line, and for those portions related to a clearway, if one exists, at the elevation of the nearest runway end; (2) the Area 2b obstacle collection surface has a 1.2% slope extending from the ends of Area 2a at the elevation of the runway end in the direction of departure, with a length of 10 km and a splay of 15% to each side. Obstacles less than 3 m in height above ground need not be collected; (3) the Area 2c obstacle collection surface has a 1.2% slope extending outside Areas 2a and 2b at a distance of not more than 10 km from the boundary of Area 2a. The initial elevation of Area 2c shall be the elevation of the point of Area 2a at which it commences. Obstacles less than 15 m in height above ground need not be collected; and (4) the Area 2d obstacle collection surface has a height of 100 m above ground; and (5) the Area 3 obstacle collection surface extends half-metre (0.5 m) above the horizontal plane passing through the nearest point on the aerodrome movement area. (d) In those portions of Area 2 where flight operations are prohibited due to very high terrain or other local restrictions and/or regulations, obstacle data shall be collected and recorded in accordance with the Area 1 numerical requirements. (e) The obstacle data product specification, supported by geographical coordinates for each aerodrome included within the dataset, shall describe the following areas: (1) Areas 2a, 2b, 2c and 2d; (2) the take-off flight path area; and (3) the obstacle limitation surfaces. (f) Obstacle data sets shall contain the digital representation of the vertical and horizontal extent of obstacles. (g) Obstacles shall not be included in terrain data sets. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 51 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments B AREA 1 Area 2d TMA max to 45 km Flight operations prohibited 45 Area 2c k m Area 2a A CWY CWY Area 2b Area 2b A ARP 10 km Area 2c TMA Section A-A B 100 m Obstacle data collection surface 3m 1.2 % % 100 m 1.2 3m 3m CWY CWY Section B-B ARP 100 m Obstacle data collection surface 1.2 % % 1.2 100 m 15 m 3m 15 m ARP AIS.TR.365 Aerodrome mapping data sets (a) Aerodrome mapping data sets shall contain the digital representation of aerodrome features. (b) Standards for geographic information shall be used as a reference framework. (c) Aerodrome mapping data products shall be described following the relevant data product specification standard. (d) The content and structure of aerodrome mapping data sets shall be defined in terms of an application schema and a feature catalogue. AIS.TR.370 Instrument flight procedure data sets (a) Instrument flight procedure data sets shall contain the digital representation of instrument flight procedures. (b) The instrument flight procedure data set shall include data about the following subjects, including all of their properties: (1) procedure; (2) procedure segment; (3) final approach segment; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 52 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (4) procedure fix; (5) procedure holding; and (6) helicopter procedure specifics. Section 4 — Distribution and pre-flight information services AIS.TR.400 Distribution services (a) The international exchange of ASHTAM, and NOTAM where States continue to use NOTAM for distribution of information on volcanic activity, shall include volcanic ash advisory centres and the world area forecast centres, and shall take account of the requirements of long-range operations. (b) A predetermined distribution system for NOTAM transmitted on the AFS shall be used whenever possible. (c) Distribution of NOTAM series other than those distributed internationally shall be granted upon request. (d) NOTAM shall be prepared in conformity with the relevant provisions of the ICAO communication procedures. AIS.TR.405 Pre-flight information services (a) Automated pre-flight information systems shall be used to make aeronautical data and aeronautical information available to operations personnel, including flight crew members, for self-briefing, flight planning and flight information service purposes. (b) The human–machine interface of such facilities shall ensure easy access in a guided manner to all relevant information/data. (c) Self-briefing facilities of an automated pre-flight information system shall provide access for consultation as necessary with the aeronautical information service by telephone or other suitable telecommunications means. (d) Automated pre-flight information systems for the supply of aeronautical data and aeronautical information for self-briefing, flight planning and flight information service shall: (1) provide for continuous and timely updating of the system database and monitoring of the validity and quality of the aeronautical data stored; (2) permit access to the system by operations personnel including flight crew members, aeronautical personnel concerned and other aeronautical users through suitable telecommunications means; (3) ensure provision, in paper copy form, of the aeronautical data and aeronautical information accessed, as required; (4) use access and interrogation procedures based on abbreviated plain language and ICAO location indicators, as appropriate, or based on a menu-driven user interface or other appropriate mechanism as agreed between the civil aviation authority and operator concerned; and (5) provide for rapid response to a user request for information. (e) All NOTAM shall be made available for briefing by default, and content reduction shall be at user’s discretion. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 53 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Section 5 — Aeronautical information products updates AIS.TR.500 General The same update AIRAC cycle shall be applied to the AIP, the AIP amendments, the AIP data set and the instrument flight procedure data sets in order to ensure the coherence of the data items that appear in multiple aeronautical information products. AIS.TR.505 AIRAC (a) Information provided under the AIRAC system and published in paper copy or made available on physical media shall be distributed at least 42 days in advance of the effective date. (b) When information has not been submitted by the AIRAC date, a NIL notification shall be distributed by NOTAM or other suitable means, not later than one cycle before the AIRAC effective date concerned. AIS.TR.510 NOTAM updates (a) NOTAM shall be published with sufficient lead time for the affected parties to take any required action, except in the case of unserviceability, volcanic activity, release of radioactive material, toxic chemicals and other events that cannot be foreseen. (b) NOTAM notifying unserviceability of aids to air navigation, facilities or communication services shall give an estimate of the period of unserviceability or the time at which restoration of service is expected. (c) Within three months from the issuing of a permanent NOTAM, the information contained in the NOTAM shall be included in the aeronautical information products affected. (d) Within three months from the issuing of a temporary NOTAM of long duration, the information contained in the NOTAM shall be included in an AIP supplement. (e) When a NOTAM with estimated end of validity unexpectedly exceeds the three-month period, a replacement NOTAM shall be issued unless the condition is expected to last for a further period of more than three months; in this case, an AIP supplement shall be issued. (f) A ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall give a brief description of the content, the effective date and time, and the reference number of the amendment, datasets or supplement. (g) A ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall come into force on the same effective date and time as the AIP amendment or supplement. (h) In the case of an AIP amendment, a ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall remain valid for a period of fourteen days. (i) In the case of an AIP supplement that is valid for less than fourteen days, the ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall remain valid for the complete validity period of the AIP supplement. (j) In the case of an AIP supplement that is valid for fourteen days or more, the ‘Trigger’ NOTAM shall remain valid for at least fourteen days. AIS.TR.515 Digital data updates (a) The update interval for the AIP data set and the instrument flight procedure data sets shall be specified in data product specification. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 54 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (b) Data sets that have been made available in advance, according to the AIRAC cycle, shall be updated with the non-AIRAC changes that occurred in between the publication and the effective date. 3.1.2. Proposed amendments to Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 The following points are added: ADR.OR.D.015 Personnel requirements The aerodrome operator shall ensure that the personnel responsible for tasks in the provision of aeronautical data or aeronautical information are adequately trained, competent and authorised for the job they are required to do. ADR.OPS.A.011 Data error detection and authentication (a) The aerodrome operator shall ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are protected in accordance with data error detection, security, and authentication techniques. (b) The aerodrome operator shall ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are protected against loss or alteration by the application of a data integrity protection mechanism. ADR.OPS.A.012 Data catalogue The aerodrome operator shall ensure that aeronautical data is originated in accordance with the data catalogue specified in Appendix 1 to Annex III to Regulation (EU) …/…. ADR.OPS.A.013 Metadata The metadata shall include, as a minimum, the following items: (a) the identification of the organisation performing data origination; (b) the action performed on the data; (c) the date and time the action was performed; and (d) details of any limitations on the data. ADR.OPS.A.014 Data exchange Aeronautical data shall be exchanged through electronic means. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 55 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments 3.2. Draft AMC and GM (draft decisions) 3.2.1. Proposed amendments to AMC and GM to Regulation .../... (1) In Annex I, the following new GM is introduced: GM ANNEX I DEFINITIONS OF TERMS USED IN ANNEXES II to XIII GM1 to Definition XX ‘Data product specification’ A data product specification provides a description of the universe of discourse and a specification for mapping the universe of discourse to a data set. It may be used for production, sales, end-use or other purpose. Data product specification provides a means by which the content of a data set is precisely specified. A data product specification supports the party generating a data set by providing information as to what exactly should be included within the data set. The content of the data product specification is closely related to the metadata model. The users of the data may determine, by comparing their data product specification with the metadata, how the data may be used in their application and what mitigations, if any, are needed as result of, for example, the quality/completeness of the data. GM1 to Definition XX ‘Integrity classification (aeronautical data)’ Aeronautical data are classified as: (a) routine data: there is a very low probability when using corrupted routine data that the continued safe flight and landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk with the potential for catastrophe; (b) essential data: there is a low probability when using corrupted essential data that the continued safe flight and landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk with the potential for catastrophe; and (c) critical data: there is a high probability when using corrupted critical data that the continued safe flight and landing of an aircraft would be severely at risk with the potential for catastrophe. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 56 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (2) In Appendix 1 to Article 3(3), the following new AMC and GM are introduced: AMC/GM TO APPENDIX 1 TO ARTICLE 3(3) REQUIREMENTS FOR AVIATION UNDERTAKINGS GM1 to 4. Data catalogue The data catalogue presents the scope of data that can be collected and maintained by the aeronautical information services providers and provides a common terminology that can be used by data originators and service providers. GM1 to 2(a) Common reference systems for air navigation HORIZONTAL REFERENCE SYSTEM — WGS-84 A reference system provides a definition of a co-ordinate system in terms of the position of an origin in space, the orientation of an orthogonal set of Cartesian axes, and a scale. A terrestrial reference system defines a spatial reference system in which positions of points anchored on the Earth’s solid surface have coordinates. Examples are: WGS-84, ITRS/European Terrestrial Reference System (ETRS) and national reference systems. WGS-84 defines, inter alia, a conventional terrestrial reference system, a reference frame and a reference ellipsoid. The system was developed by the United States Department of Defence, together with scientists of other States and institutions. WGS-84 is currently the reference system ICAO requires for geo-referencing aeronautical information. The WGS-84 co-ordinate system is a right-handed, Earth-fixed orthogonal coordinate system. In the National Imaging and Mapping Agency TR8350.2 — Department of Defense, WGS-84, [RD 30], WGS-84 is characterised as follows: (a) It is geocentric, the centre of mass being defined for the whole Earth, including oceans and atmosphere; (b) Its scale is that of the local Earth frame, in the sense of a relativistic theory of gravitation; (c) Its orientation was initially given by the Bureau International de l’Heure (BIH) orientation of 1984.0; and (d) Its time evolution in orientation will create no residual global rotation with regard to the crust. The set of definitions for WGS-84 not only includes a reference system, but also the practical realisation of a reference frame through a set of station co-ordinates. The latest available frame is called ‘WGS-84 (G873)’, where letter ‘G’ indicates that the station co-ordinates has been derived by global positioning system (GPS) techniques and the number following ‘G’ indicates the GPS week number in which these co-ordinates were implemented (January 29, 1997). The accuracy of the station co-ordinates is in the order of 5 cm (1 ). Part of the WGS-84 definition is the ellipsoid as a geometric (mathematical) reference surface. Geometric constants of the WGS-84 ellipsoid should be as described in the tables below. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 57 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Table on geometric constants Table on some of WGS-84 ellipsoid-derived geometric constants Further explanation and guidance may be found in Annex B (Horizontal reference systems) to EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material (EUROCONTROL-SPEC- 154, Edition 1.0 of 04/02/2013). GM2 to 2(a) Common reference systems for air navigation TEMPORARY NON-COMPLIANCE OF GEOGRAPHICAL CO-ORDINATES In those particular cases where geographical co-ordinates have been transformed into WGS-84 coordinates by mathematical means and whose accuracy of original field work does not meet the applicable requirements contained in the data catalogue, they should be identified until the time when they can be compliant. AMC1 to 2(b) Common reference systems for air navigation VERTICAL REFERENCE SYSTEM (a) A service provider should use the Earth Gravitational Model — 1996 (EGM-96), as the global gravity model. (b) At those geographical positions where the accuracy of EGM-96 does not meet the accuracy requirements for elevation and geoid undulation specified in Annex 14, Volumes I and II, on the basis of EGM-96 data, regional, national or local geoid models containing high resolution (short wavelength), gravity field data should be developed and used. When a geoid model other than the EGM-96 model is used, a description of the model used, including the parameters required for height transformation between the model and EGM-96, should be provided in the AIP. GM1 to 2(b) Common reference systems for air navigation VERTICAL REFERENCE SYSTEM Further explanation and guidance may be found in Annex C (Vertical reference systems) to EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of Aeronautical Data, Volume 2 (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, Edition 1.0 of 04/02/2013). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 58 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM1 to 2(b) Common reference systems for air navigation MEAN SEA LEVEL (a) The geoid globally most closely approximates MSL. It is defined as the equipotential surface in the gravity field of the Earth which coincides with the undisturbed MSL extended continuously through the continents. (b) Gravity-related heights (elevations) are also referred to as ‘orthometric heights’, while distances of points above the ellipsoid are referred to as ‘ellipsoidal heights’. (c) Global and local geoids differ in their origin: global geoids consider only the long- and middle-wave part of the Earth’s gravity field, whilst local geoids also consider the short-wave part of the gravity field. Global geoids are used when consistent orthometric heights, over long distances (continent or earth surveying), are required. Currently, the world’s best global geoid model is EGM 200846. It was determined using satellite tracking, gravity anomalies and satellite altimetry. Its accuracy is in the range of ± 0.05 m (oceans) and ± 0.5 m (on land). This accuracy is higher in flat regions than in topographically mountainous terrain, such as the Alps. (d) For local engineering applications and cadastre-surveying, global geoids are not as accurate as needed. For such applications, local geoid models are calculated. These can only be developed using local field measurements. They offer centimetre accuracy over several hundred kilometres, with a high resolution. Local geoids are not suitable for height comparison over large distances since they are based on different origins and reference heights (different equipotential levels). Further explanation and guidance may be found in Annex C (Vertical reference systems) to EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, Edition 1.0 of 04/02/2013). GM1 to 2(c) Common reference systems for air navigation TEMPORAL REFERENCE SYSTEM (a) A value in the time domain is a temporal position measured relative to a temporal reference system. (b) ISO Standard 8601 specifies the use of the Gregorian calendar and 24-hour local or UTC for information interchange, while ISO Standard 19108 prescribes the Gregorian calendar and UTC as the primary temporal reference system for use with geographic information. GM1 to 3. Formal arrangements DATA EXCHANGE The means for data exchange to be used and its related specifics should be defined by the respective parties in the formal arrangements. GM1 to 5. Data quality requirements CONCEPT Minimum requirements for the processing of aeronautical data may be found in the EUROCAE Document ED-76A, ‘Standards for processing aeronautical data’, June 2015, which aims to assist aeronautical data chain actors. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 59 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM1 to 5(e) Data quality requirements TRACEABILITY Traceability is supported by maintaining the metadata. GM1 to 6. Data verification and validation DATA PROCESSING (a) Validation (1) Validation is the activity where a data element is checked as having a value that is fully applicable to the identity ascribed to the data element, or where a set of data elements are checked as being acceptable for their intended use. (2) The application of validation techniques considers the entire aeronautical data chain. This includes the validation performed by prior data chain participants and any requirements levied on the data supplier. (3) Examples of validation methods include: (i) Validation by application One method of validation is to apply data under test conditions. In certain cases, this may not be practical. Validation by application is considered to be the most effective form of validation. For example, flight inspection of final approach segment data prior to publication can be used to ensure that the published data is acceptable. (ii) Logical consistency Logical consistency validates by comparing two different data sets or elements and identifying inconsistencies between values based on operative rules (e.g. business rules). (iii) Semantic consistency Semantic consistency validates by comparing data to an expected value or range of values for the data characteristics. (iv) Validation by sampling Validation by sampling evaluates a representative sample of data and applies statistical analysis to determine the confidence in the data quality. (b) Verification (1) Verification is a process for checking the integrity of a data element whereby the data element is compared to another source, either from a different process or from a different point in the same process. While verification cannot ensure that the data is correct, it can be effective to ensure that the data has not been corrupted by the data process. (2) The application of verification techniques considers only the portion of the aeronautical data chain controlled by the organisation. Yet, verification techniques may be applied at multiple phases of the data processing chain. (3) Examples of verification techniques include: (i) Digital error detection techniques TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 60 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Digital error detection techniques can be used to detect errors during the transmission or storage of data. An example of a digital error detection technique is the use of cyclic redundancy checks (CRCs). Coding techniques can be effective regardless of the transmission media (e.g. computer disks, modem communication, or internet). Digital data error detection techniques shall apply to all integrity levels of data sets. (ii) Feedback Feedback testing is the comparison between the output and input state of a data set. (iii) Independent redundancy Independent redundancy testing involves processing the same data through two or more independent processes and comparing the data output of each process. (iv) Update comparison Updated data can be compared to its previous version. This comparison can identify all data elements that have changed. The list of changed elements can then be compared to a similar list generated by the supplier. A problem can be detected if an element is identified as changed on one list and not on the other. GM2 to 6. Data verification and validation TECHNIQUES Validation and verification techniques are employed throughout the data processing chain to ensure that the data meets the associated data quality requirements. More explanatory material may be found in ED-76A ‘Standards for processing aeronautical data’, June 2015. GM1 to 8. Data error detection and authentication DEFINING DATA SECURITY REQUIREMENTS (a) Transmission of data via electronic/digital means (e.g. file transfer protocol (FTP) sites, web downloads, or email) may be subject to malicious attack that can corrupt the integrity of data for its intended use. Provision of means to mitigate the intentional corruption of digitally transmitted data may already exist within the organisational construct and operating procedures of participating entities. This section provides requirements to address data security. (b) The objective of data security is to ensure that data is received from a known source and that there is no intentional corruption during processing and exchange of data. (c) Records shall be maintained to show what data security provisions have been implemented. (d) Provisions supporting this objective may include: (1) implementation of technical data security measures to provide authentication and prevent intentional corruption during exchange of data (e.g. secure hashes, secure transmissions, digital signatures); and (2) Implementation of organisational data security measures to protect processing resources and prevent intentional corruption during processing of data. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 61 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM1 to 8. Data error detection and authentication DATA PROCESSING More explanation and guidance may be found in Appendix C (Guidance on compliance with data processing requirements) of EUROCAE ED-76A. GM1 to 9. Data exchange ELECTRONIC MEANS The exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information may be done by different means including email or pdf documents, without any manual interaction with the data itself. GM1 to 10. Error handling requirements GENERAL (a) The term ‘error’ is understood as being defective, degraded, lost, misplaced or corrupted data elements, or data elements not meeting stated quality requirements. (b) Guidance on how to detect, identify, report and address/resolve aeronautical data errors may be found in EUROCAE ED-76A, ‘Standards for processing aeronautical data’, June 2015. (3) In Subpart A of Annex III, the following new AMC and GM are introduced: (…) GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080 DATA EXCHANGE ELECTRONIC MEANS The exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information may be done by different means including email or pdf documents, without any manual interaction with the data itself. AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(b) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information PROCEDURES Based on the integrity classification specified in the data catalogue, procedures should be put in place so that: (a) for routine data, corruption is avoided throughout the processing of the data; (b) for essential data, it is assured that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and additional processes are included, as needed, to address potential risks in the overall system architecture to further assure data integrity at this level; and (c) for critical data, it is assured that corruption does not occur at any stage of the entire process and additional integrity assurance processes are included to fully mitigate the effects of faults identified by thorough analysis of the overall system architecture as potential data integrity risks. AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(d) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information FORMAL ARRANGEMENTS — CONTENT Formal arrangements should include the following minimum content: (a) the aeronautical data to be provided; (b) the data quality requirements for each data item supplied according to the data catalogue; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 62 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (c) the method(s) for demonstrating that the data provided conforms with the specified requirements; (d) the action to be taken in the event of discovery of a data error or inconsistency in any data provided; (e) the following minimum criteria for notification of data changes: (1) criteria for determining the timeliness of data provision based on the operational or safety significance of the change; (2) any prior notice of expected changes; and (3) the means to be adopted for notification; (f) the party responsible for documenting data changes; (g) data exchange details such as format or format change processes; (h) any limitations on the use of data; (i) requirements for the production of data origination quality reports; (j) metadata requirements; and (k) contingency requirements concerning the continuity of data provision. AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information TOOLS The tools used to support or automate aeronautical data and aeronautical information processes which are implemented fully or partially in software, should: (a) correctly state what is required by the software in order to satisfy the tool requirements; and (b) be traceable to the tool requirements referred to in point 2. AMC2 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information TOOLS AND SOFTWARE — EVIDENCE (a) In order to prove that software tools do not adversely impact on the quality of data, the potential software contribution to failure conditions should be analysed and a global analysis process of error cases should be chosen e.g. ‘Failure Modes and Effects Analysis’ (FMEA). (b) During the software requirements phase, system-level requirements dealing with error cases should be further developed, or detailed, as requirements. GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information SOFTWARE (a) A means by which ATM/ANS.OR.A.095 can be met, is through the validation and verification of software applied to a known executable version of the software in its target operating environment. (b) The validation of software is a process of ensuring that software meets the requirements for the specified application or intended use of the aeronautical data and aeronautical information. (c) The verification of software is an evaluation of the output of an aeronautical data and/or aeronautical information software development process to ensure correctness and consistency with respect to the inputs and applicable software standards, rules and conventions used in that process. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 63 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM2 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information TOOLS AND SOFTWARE — TOOL QUALIFICATION Tools (e.g. software) can be used to eliminate, reduce or automate the activities associated with aeronautical data processes. Tool qualification is the process by which assurance is achieved that tools employed will neither introduce errors into the data nor fail to detect an error. When required, tool qualification shall be performed within the context of the tool’s intended use, using EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 with adaptations provided in EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO-200B, Appendix D. The objectives of tool qualification are to: — demonstrate that the tool complies with its requirements; and — ensure that the tool provides equivalence to any activities that it automates and tool qualification is commensurate with the tool’s intended use or the data production process. (a) Determining requirement for tool qualification Tools shall be qualified when data processes are eliminated, reduced or automated by the use of the tool without the output being verified. Only tools that have the ability to insert or fail to detect an error in the aeronautical data process require qualification. The following requirements apply equally to tools obtained ‘off the shelf’ or developed by the data chain participants. — Each proposal for a new tool or for a modification of an existing tool, shall be reviewed to determine whether the tool is required to undergo qualification; and — Where a decision is made that qualification is not required, justification for that decision shall be documented. The tool qualification process may be applied to a single tool, a collection of tools, or one or more functions within a tool. For a tool with multiple functions, if protection between tool functions can be demonstrated, only those functions that are used to eliminate, reduce or automate data processes, and whose outputs are not verified, need to be qualified. Protection is the use of a mechanism to ensure that a tool function cannot adversely impact on another tool function. A tool is qualified where the intention to use the tool is stated in the data processing procedures. A tool is qualified to support data quality, as defined in the DQRs. If a tool is used to provide data compliance with additional or modified DQRs, the need for re-qualification shall be assessed. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 64 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Figure: Criteria for tool qualification The first question posed is whether or not the tool eliminates, reduces, or automates an activity associated with the aeronautical data chain, which includes any action that is performed to complete an aeronautical data chain functional link. If the answer is yes, the next question is posed, and if no, the tool does not need to be qualified. The second question is whether or not the activity or resultant output of the tool will be adequately verified by a different qualified tool or a manual process. If the answer is no, the next question is posed, and if yes, the tool does not need to be qualified. The third question is whether or not the tool has the ability to insert an error into the aeronautical data contained in the database being processed. If the answer is yes, the tool shall be qualified as a data processing tool. If the answer is no, the next question is posed. The final question posed, for tools that have not yet been identified as needing qualification, is whether or not the tool could theoretically fail to detect an error it was designed to identify. If the answer is yes, the tool shall be qualified as an error detection tool, and if no (which essentially means that the tool was not designed to directly perform modification or verification of any aeronautical data elements), the tool does not need to be qualified. It should be noted that the error detection tool does not need qualification to find any error that may exist in the data, but only errors in the data it is designed to find. NOTE: The decision to reference EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 for RTCA EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO- 200B’s tool qualification standard is made to specify an actionable set of objectives through which tool qualification rigor can be tied to data process assurance level (DPAL). Additionally, it brings tool qualification methods into alignment with related domains in the aviation software industry. (b) Determining tool qualification level When tool qualification is needed, the impact of the tool use in the aeronautical data chain should be assessed in order to determine its tool qualification level (TQL). The appropriate DPAL and TQL are indicated in the table below. Three levels of tool qualification, TQL-3 to TQL-5, are identified based on the tool use and its potential impact on the aeronautical data chain. TQL-3 is the most rigorous level and TQL-5 is the least rigorous level. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 65 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments The objectives, activities, and guidance required for each TQL are described in EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 with adaptations provided in Appendix D of this standard (TQL-1 and TQL-2 are not invoked). DPAL Data processing tool Error detection tool 1 TQL-3 TQL-5 2 TQL-4 TQL-5 3 Not required Not required (c) Tools previously qualified under EUROCAE ED-76/RTCA DO-200A If an organisation has tools that were previously qualified under EUROCAE ED-76/RTCA DO-200A and it desires to meet EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO-200B process standards, those tools can continue to be used without additional qualification activities taking place as long as the following conditions are met: — The tool has not changed since its previous qualification; — The tool environment has not changed since its previous qualification; and — The use of the tool to eliminate, reduce or automate activities associated with aeronautical data processes remains the same. Tools previously qualified under EUROCAE ED-76/RTCA DO-200A that have changed and require requalification after a data supplier has transitioned to meet EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO-200B process standards, shall perform that new qualification based on the following guidelines. First, the tool is classified as a data processing or error detection tool. Then, the RTCA DO- 200B/EUROCAE ED-76A TQL that the tool corresponds to is determined using Section 2.4.5.2. Based on this determination, one of the three following requirements applies: — For tools categorised as TQL-3, the new tool qualification process shall follow RTCA DO- 200B/EUROCAE ED-76A tool qualification standards. — For tools categorised as TQL-4, the tool qualification process approved under RTCA DO- 200A/EUROCAE ED-76 may continue to be used so long as concurrence from the authority granting recognition of compliance with this standard has been obtained/maintained. This concurrence may be granted based on an analysis of the tool addressing one or more of the following concepts:  configuration management of the tool;  effectiveness of problem reporting activity for the tool;  stability and maturity of the tool;  relevance of tool service history environment;  actual error rates and tool service history; and  impact of tool modifications. If concurrence cannot be achieved or is not desired, EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO-200B tool qualification standards shall be met. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 66 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments — For tools categorised as TQL-5, the tool qualification process shall follow either EUROCAE ED-76 / RTCA DO-200B tool qualification standards, or the supplier’s previous tool qualification process approved under EUROCAE ED-76/RTCA DO-200A. NOTE: The previous tool qualification data collected using EUROCAE ED-76/RTCA DO-200A tool qualification standards, or a tool’s service history, can be used as an alternate method of compliance with some RTCA DO-330/EUROCAE ED-215 objectives if qualification is being performed against EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO-200B standards. EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 provides additional information regarding alternative methods for tool qualification. GM3 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information TOOL AND SOFTWARE This GM provides guidance on the application of EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 to qualified tools in the aeronautical data processing domain. In the aeronautical data processing domain, EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 certification liaison objectives are not applicable. The following terms from EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 are changed to the aeronautical data processing domain. They are applicable to the intent of EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO-200B, Appendix D: — Certification credit — replaced by the general statement ‘satisfaction of the applicable RTCA DO- 200B/EUROCAE ED-76A objectives’; — Certification authority — should be understood as approval authority (See EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO- 200B, Section 2.5.1); — Applicant — identifies the entity seeking compliance with EUROCAE ED-76A/RTCA DO-200B requirements; and — Terms such as ‘software life cycle’, ‘software processes’, ‘software plans’, and ‘software’ are used. They refer to the product life cycle, processes, plans, and domain where the tool will be used in the software domain. In the context of this standard, the term ‘software” should be understood as ‘aeronautical databases’, and ‘software life cycle processes’ should be understood as ‘aeronautical data processes’. TQL-1 and TQL-2 are not invoked as they have been assessed as not applicable to the aeronautical data processing domain. Tool development standards (e.g. tool requirements standards, tool design standards, and tool coding standards), as defined in EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330, are not required under the aeronautical data processing domain. GM4 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(f) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information TOOL AND SOFTWARE — PROCESSING ADAPTATIONS Tables: — summarising the objectives adapted from EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 by showing the applicability of each objective by TQL; — whether the objective is to be implemented with independence; — the output which results from satisfying the objective; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 67 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments — and the control category for each tool life cycle data item, may be found in Appendix D.2 to ED-76A (EUROCAE ED-215/RTCA DO-330 OBJECTIVES AERONAUTICAL DATA PROCESSING ADAPTATIONS) GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(h) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information VALIDATION AND VERIFICATION (a) Validation (1) Validation is the activity where a data element is checked as having a value that is fully applicable to the identity ascribed to the data element, or where a set of data elements are checked as being acceptable for their intended use. (2) The application of validation techniques considers the entire aeronautical data chain. This includes the validation performed by prior data chain participants and any requirements levied on the data supplier. (3) Examples of validation methods include: (i) Validation by application One method of validation is to apply data under test conditions. In certain cases, this may not be practical. Validation by application is considered to be the most effective form of validation. For example, flight inspection of final approach segment data prior to publication can be used to ensure that the published data is acceptable. (ii) Logical consistency Logical consistency validates by comparing two different data sets or elements and identifying inconsistencies between values based on operative rules (e.g. business rules). (iii) Semantic consistency Semantic consistency validates by comparing data to an expected value or range of values for the data characteristics. (iv) Validation by sampling Validation by sampling evaluates a representative sample of data and applies statistical analysis to determine the confidence in the data quality. (b) Verification (1) Verification is a process for checking the integrity of a data element whereby the data element is compared to another source, either from a different process or from a different point in the same process. While verification cannot ensure that the data is correct, it can be effective to ensure that the data has not been corrupted by the data process. (2) The application of verification techniques considers only the portion of the aeronautical data chain controlled by the organisation. Yet, verification techniques may be applied at multiple phases of the data processing chain. (3) Examples of verification techniques include: (i) Digital error detection techniques TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 68 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Digital error detection techniques can be used to detect errors during the transmission or storage of data. An example of a digital error detection technique is the use of cyclic redundancy checks (CRCs). Coding techniques can be effective regardless of the transmission media (e.g. computer disks, modem communication, or internet). Digital data error detection techniques shall apply to all integrity levels of data sets. (ii) Feedback Feedback testing is the comparison between the output and input state of a data set. (iii) Independent redundancy Independent redundancy testing involves processing the same data through two or more independent processes and comparing the data output of each process. (iv) Update comparison Updated data can be compared to its previous version. This comparison can identify all data elements that have changed. The list of changed elements can then be compared to a similar list generated by the supplier. A problem can be detected if an element is identified as changed on one list and not on the other. GM2 ATM/ANS.OR.A.080(h) Aeronautical data and aeronautical information VALIDATION AND VERIFICATION TECHNIQUES Validation and verification techniques are employed throughout the data processing chain to ensure that the data meets the associated DQRs. More explanatory material may be found in ED-76A ‘Standards for processing aeronautical data’. GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(a) Common reference systems for air navigation HORIZONTAL REFERENCE SYSTEM — WGS-84 A reference system provides a definition of a co-ordinate system in terms of the position of an origin in space, the orientation of an orthogonal set of Cartesian axes, and a scale. A terrestrial reference system defines a spatial reference system in which positions of points anchored on the Earth’s solid surface have coordinates. Examples are WGS-84, ITRS/European Terrestrial Reference System (ETRS) and national reference systems. WGS-84 defines, inter alia, a conventional terrestrial reference system, a reference frame and a reference ellipsoid. The system was developed by the United States Department of Defence, together with scientists of other States and institutions. WGS-84 is currently the reference system ICAO requires for geo-referencing aeronautical information. The WGS-84 co-ordinate system is a right-handed, Earth-fixed orthogonal coordinate system. In the National Imaging and Mapping Agency TR8350.2 — Department of Defense, WGS-84, [RD 30], WGS-84 is characterised as follows: (a) It is geocentric, the centre of mass being defined for the whole Earth, including oceans and atmosphere; (b) Its scale is that of the local Earth frame, in the sense of a relativistic theory of gravitation; (c) Its orientation was initially given by the Bureau International de l’Heure (BIH) orientation of 1984.0; and (d) Its time evolution in orientation will create no residual global rotation with regards to the crust. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 69 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments The set of definitions for WGS-84 not only includes a reference system, but also the practical realisation of a reference frame through a set of station co-ordinates. The latest available frame is called ‘WGS-84 (G873)’, where letter ‘G’ indicates that the station co-ordinates has been derived by global positioning system (GPS) techniques and the number following ‘G’ indicates the GPS week number in which these co-ordinates were implemented (January 29, 1997). The accuracy of the station co-ordinates is in the order of 5 cm (1). Part of the WGS-84 definition is the ellipsoid as a geometric (mathematical) reference surface. Geometric constants of the WGS-84 ellipsoid should be as described in the tables below. Table on geometric constants Table on some of WGS-84 ellipsoid-derived geometric constants Further explanation and guidance may be found in Annex B (Horizontal reference systems) to EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material (EUROCONTROL-SPEC- 154, Edition 1.0 of 04/02/2013) GM2 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(a) Common reference systems for air navigation TEMPORARY NON-COMPLIANCE OF GEOGRAPHICAL COORDINATES In those particular cases where geographical coordinates have been transformed into WGS-84 coordinates by mathematical means and whose accuracy of original field work does not meet the applicable requirements contained in the data catalogue, they should be identified until the time when they can be compliant. AMC1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(b) Common reference systems for air navigation VERTICAL REFERENCE SYSTEM (a) A service provider should use the Earth Gravitational Model — 1996 (EGM-96), as the global gravity model. (b) At those geographical positions where the accuracy of EGM-96 does not meet the accuracy requirements for elevation and geoid undulation specified in Annex 14, Volumes I and II, on the basis of EGM-96 data, regional, national or local geoid models containing high resolution (short wavelength), gravity field data should be developed and used. When a geoid model other than the EGM-96 model is used, a description of the model used, including the parameters required for height transformation between the model and EGM-96, should be provided in the AIP. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 70 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(b) Common reference systems for air navigation MEAN SEA LEVEL (a) The geoid globally most closely approximates MSL. It is defined as the equipotential surface in the gravity field of the Earth which coincides with the undisturbed MSL extended continuously through the continents. (b) Gravity-related heights (elevations) are also referred to as ‘orthometric heights’, while distances of points above the ellipsoid are referred to as ‘ellipsoidal heights’. (c) Global and local geoids differ in their origin: global geoids consider only the long- and middle-wave part of the Earth’s gravity field, whilst local geoids also consider the short-wave part of the gravity field. Global geoids are used when consistent orthometric heights, over long distances (continent or earth surveying), are required. Currently, the world’s best global geoid model is EGM 200846. It was determined using satellite tracking, gravity anomalies and satellite altimetry. Its accuracy is in the range of ± 0.05 m (oceans) and ± 0.5 m (on land). This accuracy is higher in flat regions than in topographically mountainous terrain, such as the Alps. (d) For local engineering applications and cadastre-surveying, global geoids are not as accurate as needed. For such applications, local geoid models are calculated. These can only be developed using local field measurements. They offer centimetre accuracy over several hundred kilometres, with a high resolution. Local geoids are not suitable for height comparison over large distances since they are based on different origins and reference heights (different equipotential levels). Further explanation and guidance may be found in Annex C (Vertical reference systems) to EUROCONTROL Specifications for the Origination of Aeronautical Data, Volume 2: Guidance material (EUROCONTROL-SPEC-154, Edition 1.0 of 04/02/2013) GM1 ATM/ANS.OR.A.085(c) Common reference systems for air navigation TEMPORAL REFERENCE SYSTEM (a) A value in the time domain is a temporal position measured relative to a temporal reference system. (b) ISO Standard 8601 specifies the use of the Gregorian calendar and 24-hour local or UTC for information interchange, while ISO Standard 19108 prescribes the Gregorian calendar and UTC as the primary temporal reference system for use with geographic information. (4) In Annex VI, the following new AMC and GM are introduced: General introduction In ICAO Annex 15, as well as in the PANS-AIM, multiple references to ICAO Doc 8126 (Aeronautical Information Services Manual) are made. This ED Decision proposes a generic reference to ICAO Doc 8126 to support the material contained in Part-AIS of Regulation (EU) …./…. This is to avoid duplicating several instances of guidance material (GM) referring to ICAO Doc 8126. GM1 to Annex VI — Part-AIS ICAO DOC 8126 Guidance material on the organisation and operation of aeronautical information services is contained in ICAO Doc 8126 (Aeronautical Information Services Manual). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 71 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments SUBPART A — ADDITIONAL ORGANISATION REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PROVISION OF AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES (AIS.OR) Section 1 —Data quality requirements GM1 AIS.OR.105 Responsibilities of aeronautical information services providers GENERAL An aeronautical information services provider obtains aeronautical data and aeronautical information to enable it to provide pre-flight information service and to meet the need for in-flight information from: (a) the aeronautical information services of other States; (b) other sources that may be available. Section 2 —Data quality requirements AMC1 AIS.OR.200 General AUTOMATION (a) In order to meet the data quality requirements, automation should enable digital aeronautical data exchange between aeronautical information services providers. (b) Automation systems implemented for processing aeronautical data and aeronautical information should ensure traceability of the performed actions. AMC1 AIS.OR.200 General AUTOMATED DATA PROCESS Where processes or parts of processes used in the origination, production, storage, handling, processing, transfer and distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical information are subject to automation they should be: (a) automated to a level commensurate with the context of the data process; (b) automated to optimise the allocation and interaction of human and machine to achieve a high degree of safety and quality benefits of the process; (c) designed to avoid the introduction of data errors; and (d) designed to detect errors in received/input data. GM1 AIS.OR.200 General DATA CATALOGUE The data catalogue presents the scope of data that can be collected and maintained by the aeronautical information services providers and provides a common terminology that can be used by data originators and service providers. AMC1 AIS.OR.205 Formal arrangements CONTENT Formal arrangements should include the following minimum content: TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 72 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (a) the aeronautical data to be provided; (b) the data quality requirements for each data item supplied according to the data catalogue; (c) the method(s) for demonstrating that the data provided conforms with the specified requirements; (d) the action to be taken in the event of discovery of a data error or inconsistency in any data provided; (e) the following minimum criteria for notification of data changes: (1) criteria for determining the timeliness of data provision based on the operational or safety significance of the change; (2) any prior notice of expected changes; and (3) the means to be adopted for notification; (f) the party responsible for documenting data changes; (g) data exchange details such as format or format change processes; (h) any limitations on the use of data; (i) requirements for the production of data origination quality reports ; (j) metadata requirements; and (k) contingency requirements concerning the continuity of data provision. AMC1 AIS.OR.210(a) Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information EXCHANGE MODEL An aeronautical information services provider should use an aeronautical information exchange model that describes the features and their properties (attributes and associations) within the AIM domain and includes an XML schema. GM1 AIS.OR.210(b) Exchange of aeronautical data and information ELECTRONIC MEANS The exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information may be done by a number of electronic exchanges including email or pdf documents, without any manual interaction with the data itself. GM1 AIS.OR.225 Metadata PERSONAL DATA When collecting metadata, the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data apply, in accordance with Directive 95/46/EC on Data protection. AMC1 AIS.OR.235 Error reporting and corrective action ISO 9001 CERTIFICATE FOR AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES PROVIDERS AN EN ISO 9001 certificate, issued by an appropriately accredited organisation, addressing all the elements required in this Part should be considered as a sufficient means of compliance for aeronautical information services providers. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 73 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AMC1 AIS.OR.250 Consistency requirement The aeronautical information services provider should establish mechanisms to ensure that: (a) previous coordination and explicit agreement with the service providers responsible for the AIPs of the Member States concerned is reached before introducing changes in published border or cross-border data and information (e.g. designated points used in route segments, cross-border areas/airspaces, cross-border entities); and (b) periodic reviews are performed to detect inconsistencies between the AIPs of the Member States concerned. GM1 AIS.OR.250 Consistency requirement (a) In order on one hand to facilitate the identification of the need and the previous coordination and agreement and on the other hand to define the scope of the periodic review, the service provider might identify and maintain a list of the data items and information which should be subject to coordination, for the reference and use by its operational staff. (b) For the purpose of establishing periodic reviews, the service provider might rely on agreements established with other aeronautical information services providers. Section 3 — Aeronautical information products GM1 to Section 3 — Aeronautical information products OPERATING PROCEDURE FOR AIS STATIC DATA Further detailed explanation with regard to aeronautical information products can be found in the ‘Operating Procedure for AIS Static Data - Procedure for the Provision of Originated Data to the AIS’ developed by EUROCONTROL, Edition 2.0 of 17 July 2009. AMC1 AIS.OR.325 Aeronautical charts GENERAL Aeronautical charts should be produced in accordance with the specifications contained in ICAO Annex 4, in its 11th edition of July 2009. AMC2 AIS.OR.325(a), (b) and (c) Aeronautical charts AERODROME OBSTACLE CHART — ELECTRONIC (a) As an alternative to aerodrome obstacle chart type A, aerodrome obstacle chart type B and precision approach terrain chart, aeronautical information services provider may make available an electronic aerodrome obstacle chart for all aerodromes regularly used by international civil aviation. (b) If provided, the electronic aerodrome obstacle chart should provide the data necessary to: (1) enable an aircraft operator to comply with the operating limitations of Subpart C of Part-CAT, Part-NCC, Part-NCO and Part-SPO of Regulation (EU) No 965/2012, by developing contingency procedures for use in the event of an emergency during a missed approach or take-off, and by developing aircraft operating limitations analysis; (2) support instrument procedure design (including circling procedures); TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 74 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (3) support aerodrome obstacle restriction and removal; and (4) produce other aeronautical charts. (c) An aeronautical information services provider should make available the electronic aerodrome obstacle charts it provides in hard-copy format upon request. AMC1 AIS.OR.330 NOTAM USE OF OPADD An aeronautical information services provider should originate and issue NOTAM in accordance with the ‘EUROCONTROL Guidelines — Operating Procedures for AIS Dynamic Data (OPADD), Edition 4.0, 17 April 2015. GM1 AIS.OR.335(a) General DATA SET A data subject may appear in multiple data sets. Chapter 2 — Digital data GM1 AIS.OR.340 AIP data set PURPOSE The purpose of the AIP data set is to support the initial transition of the ATM domain towards the use of digital data sets instead of paper products. Therefore, its scope is defined considering the likelihood that the data contained in this set is actually being used in digital format by service providers, air traffic control (ATC) and instrument flight rules (IFR)/visual flight rules (VFR) airspace users. GM2 AIS.OR.340 AIP data set CONTENT The aeronautical AIP data set includes relevant AIP amendment and AIP supplement information. GM1 to AIS.OR.350, AIS.OR.355, AIS.OR.360 Terrain and obstacle data GENERAL Useful information for those organisations involved in the origination, processing and provision of electronic terrain and obstacle data, from the point at which the need for origination is identified through to the point when the State makes it available in accordance with the requirements of ICAO Annex 15, can be found in the EUROCONTROL ‘Terrain and Obstacle Data Manual’ (November 2015, Edition 2.1). In addition, the EUROCAE Document ED-98C ‘User Requirements For Terrain And Obstacle Data’ (October 2015) provides guidance for data gathering by data originators, for data processing by data integrators, for implementation by system designers, and for end use by the aviation community (e.g. air carriers, air traffic services, procedure designers). AMC1 AIS.TR.350 Terrain and Obstacle data — general requirements Where the terrain at a distance greater than 900 m (3 000 ft) from the runway threshold is mountainous or otherwise significant, the length of area 4 should be extended to a distance not exceeding 2 000 m (6 500 ft) from the runway threshold. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 75 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AMC1 AIS.OR.355 Terrain data sets ADDITIONAL TERRAIN DATA Where additional terrain data is collected to meet other aeronautical requirements, the terrain data sets should be expanded to include this additional data. AMC1 AIS.OR.360 Obstacle data sets ADDITIONAL OBSTACLE DATA Where additional obstacle data are collected to meet other aeronautical requirements, the obstacle data sets should be expanded to include these additional data. GM1 AIS.TR.365 Aerodrome mapping data sets AERODROME FEATURES Aerodrome features consist of attributes and geometries, which are characterised as points, lines or polygons. Examples include runway thresholds, taxiway guidance lines and parking stand areas. Section 4 — Distribution and pre-flight information services AMC1 AIS.TR.400 Distribution services GENERAL The exchange of NOTAM between international NOTAM offices and/or multinational NOTAM processing units should cover the needs of operations personnel including flight crew members. GM1 AIS.OR.400(a) Distribution services DISTRIBUTION OF NOTAM Global communication networks and web services may be employed for the provision of aeronautical information products. GM1 AIS.OR.400(b) Distribution services DISTRIBUTION OF AIP PRODUCTS (a) Distribution to the next intended user differs in the delivery method applied which may either be: (1) physical distribution — the means by which aeronautical data and aeronautical information distribution is achieved through the delivery of a physical package, such as postal services; or (2) direct electronic distribution — the means by which aeronautical data and aeronautical information distribution is achieved automatically through the use of a direct electronic connection between the AIS and the next intended user. (b) Different delivery methods and data media may require different procedures to ensure the required data quality. (c) Further guidance on digital dataset distribution can be found in the ICAO Doc 10039 (Manual on system wide information management (SWIM) concept). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 76 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM1 AIS.OR.400(c) Distribution services DISTRIBUTION OF NOTAM Further information on the distribution of NOTAM by an aeronautical information services provider may be found in the ‘EUROCONTROL Guidelines — Operating Procedures for AIS Dynamic Data (OPADD)’, Edition 4.0, 17 April 2015. GM1 AIS.OR.400(d) Distribution services DISTRIBUTION OF NOTAM A selective distribution list should be used when practicable. GM1 AIS.OR.400(d) Distribution of services SNOWTAM Arrangements may be made for direct exchange of SNOWTAM between aerodromes/heliports. GM1 AIS.OR.405(b) Pre-flight information services INFORMATION OF OPERATIONAL SIGNIFICANCE (a) Pre-flight information may be provided as a verbal briefing or a self-briefing. (b) Geographic coverage for pre-flight information services should be determined and periodically reviewed. In general, the coverage zone should be limited to the flight information region (FIR) within which the aerodrome/heliport is located, the FIR(s) adjacent thereto, and all air route or portion of route flown without an intermediate landing, originating at the aerodrome/heliport and extending beyond the FIR(s) mentioned. (c) The elements of the aeronautical information products may be limited to national publications and when practicable, those of immediately adjacent States, provided a complete library of aeronautical information is available at a central location and means of direct communications are available with that library. (d) A recapitulation of valid NOTAM of operational significance and other information of urgent character can be made available to flight crews in the form of plain-language pre-flight information bulletins (PIB). (e) Guidance on the preparation of pre-flight information services and PIB may be found in Chapter 8 of ICAO Doc 8126 (Aeronautical Information Services Manual) and in Chapter 7 of the ‘EUROCONTROL Guidelines — Operating Procedures for AIS Dynamic Data (OPADD)’, Edition 4.0, 17 April 2015. Section 5 — Aeronautical information products updates GM1 AIS.OR.505(a) AIRAC STATIC DATA PROCEDURES (SDP) Further explanations with regard to the application of the AIRAC system can be found in the ‘Operating procedure for AIS static data — procedure for the provision of originated data to the AIS’ developed by the European organisation for the safety of air navigation – EUROCONTROL, Edition 2.0, 17 July 2009. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 77 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM2 AIS.OR.505(a) AIRAC USE OF AIRAC SYSTEM The AIRAC may be used for the provision of information relating to the establishment and withdrawal of, and premeditated significant changes in, the circumstances listed below: (a) Position, height and lighting of navigational obstacles. (b) Hours of service of aerodromes, facilities and services. (c) Customs, immigration and health services. (d) Temporary danger, prohibited and restricted areas and navigational hazards, military exercises and mass movements of aircraft. (e) Temporary areas or routes or portions thereof where the possibility of interception exists. GM3 AIS.OR.505(a) AIRAC ADVANCE NOTIFICATION OF MAJOR CHANGES Whenever major changes are planned and where advance notice is desirable and possible, information may be distributed and/or made available by the aeronautical information services provider, whenever practicable, so as to reach recipients at least 56 days in advance of the AIRAC effective date. This may apply to the establishment of, and premeditated major changes in the circumstances listed below, as well as to other major changes if deemed necessary: (a) New aerodromes for international IFR operations; (b) New runways for IFR operations at international aerodromes; (c) Design and structure of the ATS route network; (d) Design and structure of a set of terminal procedures (including change of procedure bearings due to magnetic variation change); (e) Circumstances listed in AIS.OR.505(a)(10) if the entire State or any significant portion thereof is affected or if cross-border coordination is required. AMC1 AIS.OR.515 Digital data updates GENERAL (a) When made available as a completely re-issued data set, the differences from the previously issued complete data set should be indicated. (b) When temporary changes of short duration are made available as digital data (Digital NOTAM), they should use the same aeronautical information model as the complete data set. Section 6 —Personnel requirements GM1 AIS.OR.600 General requirements TRAINING Guidance material concerning training methodology to ensure the competency of personnel is contained in the aeronautical information management training development manual (ICAO Doc 9991). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 78 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments SUBPART B — TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS FOR THE PROVISION OF AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION SERVICES (AIS.TR) Section 2 — General requirements GM1 to Section 2 — General requirements ED-76A The quality of data is a degree or level of confidence that the data provided meets the requirements of the user. Minimum requirements for the processing of aeronautical data may be found in the EUROCAE Document ED-76A, which aims to assist aeronautical data chain actors and authorities in meeting their responsibilities. It is intended to be used by organisations seeking approval of the method(s) they use to process or manipulate data. Reference is made to EUROCAE Document ED-76A (Standards for Processing Aeronautical Data), June 2015. GM1 AIS.TR.200(b) General RESOLUTION The resolution of the data contained in the database may be the same or finer than the publication resolution. AMC1 AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information EXCHANGE MODELS (a) The aeronautical information model used should encompass the aeronautical data and aeronautical information to be exchanged. (b) The aeronautical information model used should: (1) use the unified modelling language (UML) to describe the aeronautical information features and their properties, associations and data types; (2) include data value constraints and data verification rules; (3) include provisions for metadata; and (4) include a temporality model to enable capturing the evolution of the properties of an aeronautical information feature during its life cycle. (c) The aeronautical data exchange model used should: (1) apply a commonly used data encoding format; (2) cover all the classes, attributes, data types and associations of the aeronautical information model; and (3) provide an extension mechanism by which groups of users can extend the properties of existing features and add new features which do not adversely affect global standardisation. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 79 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AMC2 AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information ELECTRONIC TERRAIN DATA Electronic terrain data should be provided in a common format compliant with ISO 19107:2003 — Geographic information — Spatial schema (Edition 1 — 8.5.2003) and 19136:2007 — Geographic information — Geography Mark-up Language (GML) (Edition 1 — 23.8.2007). GM1 AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information ENABLING EXCHANGE The intent of using a commonly used data encoding format is to ensure interoperability of aeronautical data exchange between agencies and organisations involved in the data processing chain. Examples of commonly used data encoding formats include extensible markup language (XML), geography markup language (GML), and JavaScript object notation (JSON). GM2 AIS.TR.210 Exchange of aeronautical data and aeronautical information AIXM The aeronautical information exchange model (AIXM) is designed to enable the management and distribution of aeronautical information services data in digital format. More information on the AIXM may be found under http://www.aixm.aero. AMC1 AIS.TR.220 Verification and validation process GENERAL (a) The process should define the means used to: (1) confirm that the data has been received without corruption; (2) ensure that stored data is protected from corruption; and (3) confirm that originated data has not been corrupted prior to being stored. (b) The process should define the: (1) action to be taken when data fails a verification or validation check; (2) tools required for the verification and validation process; (3) methods used to verify received data; (4) methods by which data quality is preserved; (5) method by which the user is assured that delivered data meets the data quality requirements; and (6) methods to be used to provide the user with the ability to verify that the data received by the user has not been corrupted. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 80 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM1 AIS.TR.220 Verification and validation process GENERAL (a) Validation Validation is the activity where a data element is checked as having a value that is fully applicable to the identity ascribed to the data element, or a set of data elements is checked as being acceptable for their intended use. The application of validation techniques considers the entire aeronautical data chain. This includes the validation performed by prior data chain participants and any requirements levied on the data supplier. Examples of validation methods include: (1) Validation by Application: one method of validation is to apply data under test conditions. In certain cases, this may not be practical. Validation by application is considered to be the most effective form of validation. For example, flight inspection of final approach segment data prior to publication can be used to ensure that the published data is acceptable. (2) Logical Consistency: validates by comparing two different data sets or elements and identifying inconsistencies between values based on operative rules (e.g. business rules). (3) Semantic Consistency: validates by comparing data to an expected value or range of values for the data characteristics. (4) Validation by Sampling: evaluates a representative sample of data and applies statistical analysis to determine the confidence in the data quality. (b) Verification Verification is a process for checking the integrity of a data element whereby the data element is compared to another source, either from a different process or from a different point in the same process. While verification cannot ensure that the data is correct, it can be effective to ensure the data has not been corrupted by the data process. The application of verification techniques considers only the portion of the aeronautical data chain controlled by the organisation. Yet, verification techniques may be applied at multiple phases of the data processing chain. Examples of verification techniques include: (1) Digital Error Detection Techniques can be used to detect errors during the transmission or storage of data. An example of a digital error detection technique is the use of cyclic redundancy checks (CRCs). Coding techniques can be effective regardless of the transmission media (e.g. computer disks, modem communication, or internet). (2) Feedback testing is the comparison of a data set between its output and input state. (3) Independent Redundancy testing involves processing the same data through two or more independent processes and comparing the data output of each process. (4) Update Comparison: updated data can be compared to its previous version. This comparison can identify all data elements that have changed. The list of changed elements can then be compared TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 81 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments to a similar list generated by the supplier. A problem can be detected if an element is identified as changed on one list and not on the other. GM1 AIS.TR.225 Metadata ISO Further explanation on the schema required for describing geographic information and services by means of metadata may be found in the International Organisation for Standardisation, ISO 19115:2014 — Geographic information — Metadata, Part I. It provides information about the identification, the extent, the quality, the spatial and temporal aspects, the content, the spatial reference, the portrayal, distribution, and other properties of digital geographic data and services. GM1 AIS.TR.240 Data limitations ANNOTATION (a) The objective of such an annotation is to notify the users of the AIP including its data that specific quality requirements are not met and may, therefore, compel limitations in the operational use of the relevant data. (b) More explanation and guidance may be found in the EUROCONTROL ‘Guidelines for the Annotation of data not compliant with Commission Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 (ADQ)’, Edition 1.0, 11 November 2014. Section 3 — Aeronautical information products AMC1 AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication (AIP) ELECTRONIC FORM The eAIP, eAIP amendments and eAIP supplements should be provided according to the ‘EUROCONTROL Specification for the Electronic Aeronautical Information Publication (eAIP)’, Edition 2.1, 6 October 2015. AMC1 AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication (AIP) LOCATION FORMAT When listing locations, the city or town should be given in capital letters followed, where the facility is an aerodrome/heliport or is located at an aerodrome/heliport, by an oblique stroke and the name of the aerodrome/heliport in smaller capital letters or lower-case letters. Unless otherwise indicated, the list should be in alphabetical order. GM1 AIS.TR.305 Aeronautical information publication (AIP) LANGUAGE If an AIP is issued in more than one language, a bilingual or multilingual edition may assist in the interpretation of questionable text. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 82 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments AMC1 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information publication (AIP) PRINTED AIP A system of page numbering adaptable to the addition or deletion of sheets should be adopted. The page number should include: (a) an identification of the part of the AIP; (b) the section; and (c) subsection, as applicable, (d) thus creating a separate set of numbers for each subject (e.g. GEN 2.1-3, ENR 4.1-1 or AD 2.2-3). AMC2 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information publication (AIP) ELECTRONIC AIP When provided, the eAIP should be available on a physical distribution medium, such as cd, dvd, etc. and/or online on the internet. GM1 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information publication (AIP) PRINTED AIP (a) If it is necessary by reason of bulk or for convenience, to publish an AIP in two or more parts or volumes, each of them will indicate that the remainder of the information is to be found in the other part(s) or volume(s). (b) When the AIP is provided in more than one volume, each volume should include: (1) a preface; (2) a record of AIP amendments; (3) a record of AIP supplements; (4) a checklist of AIP pages; and (5) a list of current hand amendments. (c) When the AIP is published as one volume, the above-mentioned subsections should appear only in Part 1 — GEN and the annotation ‘not applicable’ should be entered against each of these subsections in Parts 2 and 3. GM2 AIS.TR.305(a) Aeronautical information publication (AIP) FORM OF AIP When the AIP is issued as a printed volume, it may be published in loose-leaf form unless the complete publication is reissued at frequent intervals. AMC1 AIS.TR.305(c) Aeronautical information publication (AIP) LOCATION In the indication of the geographical coordinates of a location: (a) the latitude should be given first; (b) symbols for degrees, minutes or seconds should be omitted; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 83 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (c) two digits should always be used in expressing values of less than 10 degrees of latitude; and (d) three digits should always be used in expressing values of less than 100 degrees of longitude. GM1 AIS.TR.305(c) Aeronautical information publication (AIP) CHARTS, MAPS OR DIAGRAMS (a) Charts, maps or diagrams should be used, when appropriate, to complement or as a substitute for the tabulations or text of the AIP. (b) Where appropriate, charts produced in conformity with AIS.OR.325 may be used to fulfil this requirement. GM2 AIS.TR.305(c) Aeronautical information publication (AIP) AIP DATA SET When the AIP data set is provided, the following sections of the AIP may be left blank and a reference to the data set availability shall be provided: (a) ENR 2.1 FIR, UIR, TMA; (b) ENR 3.1 Lower ATS routes; (c) ENR 3.2 Upper ATS routes; (d) ENR 3.3 Area navigation (RNAV) routes; (e) ENR 3.4 Helicopter routes; (f) ENR 3.5 Other routes; (g) ENR 3.6 En route holding; (h) ENR 4.1 Radio navigation aids — en route; (i) ENR 4.4 Name-code designators for significant points; (j) ENR 4.5 Aeronautical ground lights — en route; (k) ENR 5.1 Prohibited, restricted and danger areas; (l) ENR 5.2 Military exercise and training areas and air defence identification zone (ADIZ); (m) ENR 5.3.1 Other activities of a dangerous nature; (n) ENR 5.5 Aerial sporting and recreational activities; (o) AD 2.19 Radio navigation and landing aids; and (p) AD 3.18 Radio navigation and landing aids. AMC1 AIS.TR.310(f) AIP amendments EFFECTIVE TIME When an effective time other than 0000 UTC is used, the effective time should also be indicated. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 84 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM1 AIS.TR.315 AIP supplements TEMPORARY CHANGES (a) Since the AIP is subject to frequent change, provisions exist for its continual updating. In addition, changes of a temporary nature affecting the contents of an AIP are often required to cater for unexpected circumstances or, in some cases, planned modifications to a service/facility. (b) The purpose of an AIP supplement is to bring to the attention of users both temporary changes of long duration (three months or longer) and information of short duration containing extensive text or graphics which affect one or more parts of the AIP. AMC1 AIS.TR.320 AIC ELECTRONIC FORM When AIC are provided as part of the ‘electronic AIP”, they should comply with the ‘EUROCONTROL Specification for the Electronic Aeronautical Information Publication (eAIP)’, Edition 2.1, 6 October 2015. GM1 AIS.TR.320(a) AIC PRINTED AIC (a) Differentiation and identification of AIC topics according to subjects using colour coding should be practised where the numbers of AIC in force are sufficient to make identification in this form necessary. (b) It is recommended that AIC be colour-coded by subject where there are sufficient circulars in force to warrant such identification, e.g.: (1) white — administrative; (2) yellow — ATC; (3) pink — safety; (4) mauve — danger area map; and (5) green — maps/charts. GM2 AIS.TR.320(d) AIC SNOW PLAN INFORMATION The snow plan issued under AD 1.2.2 of the AIP may contain information such as that listed below: (a) a list of aerodromes/heliports where snow clearance is expected to be performed during the coming winter: (1) in accordance with the runway and taxiway systems; or (2) planned snow clearing, deviating from the runway system (length, width and number of runways, affected taxiways and aprons or portions thereof); (b) information concerning any centre designated to coordinate information on the current state of progress of clearance and on the current state of runways, taxiways and aprons; (c) a division of the aerodromes/heliports into SNOWTAM distribution lists in order to avoid excessive NOTAM distribution; (d) an indication, as necessary, of minor changes to the standing snow plan; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 85 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (e) a descriptive list of clearance equipment; and (f) a listing of what will be considered as the minimum critical snow bank to be reported at each aerodrome/heliport at which reporting will commence. AMC1 AIS.TR.330 NOTAM USE OF OPADD The origination and issuing of NOTAM should be in accordance with the ‘EUROCONTROL Guidelines — Operating Procedures for AIS Dynamic Data (OPADD)’, Edition 4.0, 17 April 2015. GM1 AIS.TR.330(b) NOTAM NOTAM CODE The ICAO NOTAM Code together with significations/uniform abbreviated phraseology, and ICAO Abbreviations are those contained in ICAO Doc 8400 (PANS-ABC). GM1 AIS.TR.330(u) NOTAM CHECKLIST The checklist NOTAM may include the checklist of SUP. Chapter 2 — Digital data sets GM1 AIS.TR.335(a) General ISO SERIES (a) The ISO 19100 series of standards for geographic information may be used as a reference framework. (b) ISO Standard 19131 specifies the requirements and outline of data product specifications for geographic information. This is intended to facilitate and support the use and exchange of digital data sets between data providers and data users. GM1 AIS.TR.335(b) General DESCRIPTION OF AVAILABLE DATA SET (a) The data product specification enables air navigation users to evaluate the products and determine whether they fulfil the requirements for their intended use (application). (b) This may include an overview, specification scope, data product identification, data content and structure, reference system, data quality, data capture, data maintenance, data portrayal, data product delivery, additional information, and metadata. GM1 AIS.TR.345(a) AIP data set CONTENT The AIP data set includes the relevant AIP amendment and SUP information. GM1 to AIS.TR.350, AIS.TR.355, AIS.TR.360 Terrain and obstacle data REFERENCES Useful information for those organisations involved in the origination, processing and provision of electronic terrain and obstacle data, from the point at which the need for origination is identified through to the point TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 86 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments when the State makes it available in accordance with the requirements of ICAO Annex 15, can be found in the EUROCONTROL ‘Terrain and Obstacle Data Manual’ (November 2015, Edition 2.1). In addition, the EUROCAE Document ED-98C (October 2015) provides guidance for data gathering by data originators, for data processing by data integrators, for implementation by system designers, and for end use by the aviation community (e.g. air carriers, air traffic services, procedure designers). GM1 to AIS.TR.350, AIS.TR.355, AIS.TR.360 Terrain and obstacle data NAVIGATION APPLICATIONS (a) Terrain and obstacle data are intended to be used in the following air navigation applications: (1) ground proximity warning system with forward-looking terrain avoidance function and minimum safe altitude warning (MSAW) system; (2) determination of contingency procedures for use in the event of an emergency during a missed approach or take-off; (3) aircraft operating limitations analysis; (4) instrument procedure design (including circling procedure); (5) determination of en route ‘drift-down’ procedure and en route emergency landing location; (6) advanced surface movement guidance and control system (A-SMGCS); and (7) aeronautical chart production and on-board databases. (b) The data may also be used in other applications such as flight simulator and synthetic vision systems, and may assist in determining the height restriction or removal of obstacles that pose a hazard to air navigation. AMC1 AIS.TR.355(d) Terrain data set ATTRIBUTES Each of defined obstacle feature types should be described according to the following list of mandatory attributes: Terrain attribute Mandatory/optional Area of coverage Mandatory Data originator identifier Mandatory Data source identifier Mandatory Acquisition method Mandatory Post spacing Mandatory Horizontal reference system Mandatory Horizontal resolution Mandatory Horizontal accuracy Mandatory Horizontal confidence level Mandatory TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 87 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Horizontal position Mandatory Elevation Mandatory Elevation reference Mandatory Vertical reference system Mandatory Vertical resolution Mandatory Vertical accuracy Mandatory Vertical confidence level Mandatory Surface type Optional Recorded surface Mandatory Penetration level Optional Known variations Optional Integrity Mandatory Date and time stamp Mandatory Unit of measurement used Mandatory GM2 AIS.TR.360 Obstacle data set GENERAL When the obstacle data set is provided, the following sections of the AIP may be left blank and a reference to the data set availability should be provided: (a) ENR 5.4 Air navigation obstacles ; (b) AD 2.10 Aerodrome obstacles; and (c) AD 3.10 Heliport obstacles. AMC1 AIS.TR.360(b) Obstacle data set ATTRIBUTES Each of the defined obstacle feature types should be described according to the following list of mandatory attributes: Obstacle attribute Mandatory/optional Area of coverage Mandatory Data originator identifier Mandatory Data source identifier Mandatory Obstacle identifier Mandatory Horizontal accuracy Mandatory TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 88 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments Horizontal confidence level Mandatory Horizontal position Mandatory Horizontal resolution Mandatory Horizontal extent Mandatory Horizontal reference system Mandatory Elevation Mandatory Height Optional Vertical accuracy Mandatory Vertical confidence level Mandatory Vertical resolution Mandatory Vertical reference system Mandatory Obstacle type Mandatory Geometry type Mandatory Integrity Mandatory Date and time stamp Mandatory Unit of measurement used Mandatory Operations Optional Effectivity Optional Lighting Mandatory Marking Mandatory GM1 AIS.TR.365 Aerodrome mapping data sets COMPLEMENTARY GUIDANCE Further information concerning minimum requirements and reference material applicable to the content, origination, publication, and updating of aerodrome mapping information may be found in EUROCAE Documents ED-99D ‘User requirement for aerodrome mapping information’, October 2015, and ED-119C ‘Interchange standards for terrain, obstacle and aerodrome mapping data’, October 2015. GM1 AIS.TR.365(a) Aerodrome mapping data sets ADDITIONAL DATA Aerodrome mapping data may be supported by electronic terrain and obstacle data for Area 3 in order to ensure consistency and quality of all geographical data related to the aerodrome. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 89 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments GM2 AIS.TR.365(a) Aerodrome mapping data sets COMMON ACQUISITION TECHNIQUES Electronic terrain and obstacle data pertaining to Area 3 and aerodrome mapping data may be originated using common acquisition techniques and managed within a single geographic information system (GIS). METADATA Metadata elements applicable to aerodrome mapping data are contained in EUROCAE Document ED-119C ‘Interchange standards for terrain, obstacle and aerodrome mapping data’, October 2015. GM1 AIS.TR.365(d) Aerodrome mapping data sets ISO REFERENCE ISO Standard 19109 contains rules for application schema, while ISO Standard 19110 describes the feature cataloguing methodology for geographic information. Section 4 — Distribution and pre-flight information services GM1 AIS.TR.400(b) Distribution services NOTAM (a) The predetermined distribution system provides for incoming NOTAM (including SNOWTAM and ASHTAM) to be channelled through the AFS direct to designated addressees predetermined by the receiving country concerned while concurrently being routed to the international NOTAM office for checking and control purposes. (b) The addressee indicators for those designated addressees are constituted as follows: (1) First and second letters: The first two letters of the location indicator for the AFS communication centre associated with the relevant international NOTAM office of the receiving country. (2) Third and fourth letters: The letters ‘ZZ’ indicating a requirement for special distribution. (3) Fifth letter: The fifth letter differentiating between NOTAM (letter ‘N’), SNOWTAM (letter ‘S’), and ASHTAM (letter ‘V’). (4) Sixth and seventh letters: The sixth and seventh letters, each taken from the series A to Z, denoting the national and/or international distribution list(s) to be used by the receiving AFS centre. The fifth, sixth and seventh letters replace the three-letter designator YNY which, in the normal distribution system, denotes an international NOTAM office. (5) Eighth letter: The eighth position letter shall be the filler letter ‘X’ to complete the eight-letter addressee indicator. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 90 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (c) States are to inform the States from which they receive NOTAM of the sixth and seventh letters to be used under different circumstances to ensure proper routing. GM1 AIS.TR.405(a) Pre-flight information services AUTOMATION (a) Automated pre-flight information systems providing a harmonised, common point of access by operations personnel, including flight crew members and other aeronautical personnel concerned, to aeronautical information and meteorological information should be established by an agreement between the competent authority for civil aviation or service provider and the competent authority for meteorological services or service provider. (b) Where automated pre-flight information systems are used to provide the harmonised, common point of access by operations personnel, including flight crew members and other aeronautical personnel concerned, to aeronautical data, aeronautical information and meteorological information, the competent authority for civil aviation or the service provider to which the authority to provide service has been delegated, remain responsible for the quality and timeliness of the aeronautical data and aeronautical information provided by means of such a system. (c) The meteorological service provider concerned remains responsible for the quality of the meteorological information provided by means of such a system in accordance with Part-MET. GM1 AIS.TR.405(e) Pre-flight information services NOTAM Although miscellaneous NOTAM is regarded not subject for a briefing but available on request, all NOTAM are to be provided for briefing by default and content reduction should be at user’s discretion. Section 5 — Aeronautical information products updates AMC1 AIS.TR.510(a) NOTAM updates ADVANCE NOTICE (a) At least seven days’ advance notice should be given of the activation of established danger, restricted or prohibited areas and of activities requiring temporary airspace restrictions other than for emergency operations. (b) Notice of any subsequent cancellation of the activities or any reduction of the hours of activity or the dimensions of the airspace should be given as soon as possible. GM1 AIS.TR.510(a) NOTAM updates ADVANCE NOTICE Whenever possible, at least 24 hours’ advance notice is desirable, to permit timely completion of the notification process and to facilitate airspace utilisation planning. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 91 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments 3.2.2. Proposed amendment to the AMC and GM to Authority, Organisation and Operations Requirements for Aerodromes AMC1 ADR.OPS.A.010 Data quality requirements GENERAL REQUIREMENTS (…) (g) Protection of electronic aeronautical data while stored or in transit, should be totally monitored by the cyclic redundancy check (CRC). To achieve protection of the integrity level of critical, and essential aeronautical data as classified in (a)(1) and (a)(2) above, a 32- or 24-bit CRC algorithm should apply respectively. (h) To achieve protection of the integrity level of routine aeronautical data as classified in (a)(3) above, a 16-bit CRC algorithm should apply. (g) Where processes or parts of processes used in the origination, production, storage, handling, processing, transfer and distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical information are subject to automation they should be: (1) automated to a level commensurate with the context of the data process; (2) automated to optimise the allocation and interaction of human and machine to achieve a high degree of safety and quality benefits of the process; (3) designed to avoid the introduction of data errors; and (4) designed to detect errors in received/input data. (h) The error handling and corrective action mechanisms should ensure that: (1) errors identified during data origination and after data delivery are addressed or resolved; and (2) priority and urgency are given to errors in critical and essential aeronautical data. (…) NOTE: The following tables are deleted: Table 1 – Latitude and longitude Table 2 – Elevation/Altitude/Height Table 3 – Declination and magnetic variation Table 4 – Bearing Table 5 – Length/distance/dimension AMC2 ADR.OPS.A.010 Data quality requirements FORMAL ARRANGEMENTS (…) (c) Content of formal arrangements Such formal arrangements should include the following minimum content: (1) the scope of aeronautical data or aeronautical information to be provided; (2) the quality accuracy, resolution, and integrity requirements for each data item supplied according to the data catalogue; TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 92 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 3. Proposed amendments (3) the required methods for demonstrating that the data provided conforms with the specified requirements; (4) the nature of action to be taken in the event of discovery of a data error or inconsistency in any data provided; (5) the following minimum criteria for notification of data changes: (i) criteria for determining the timeliness of data provision based on the operational or safety significance of the change; (ii) any prior notice of expected changes; (iii) the means to be adopted for notification; (6) the party responsible for documenting data changes; (7) the means to resolve any potential ambiguities caused where different formats are used to data exchange details such as format or format change processes aeronautical data or aeronautical information; (8) any limitations on the use of data; (9) requirements for the production of quality reports by data providers to facilitate verification of data quality by the data users; (10) metadata requirements; and (11) contingency requirements concerning the continuity of data provision. (…) AMC1.OPS.A.011 Data error detection and authentication CRC The data protection mechanism for digital data sets shall offer, at the minimum, an equivalent level of protection as a 32-bit cyclic redundancy check (CRC). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 93 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) This RIA focuses only on the issues related to aeronautical data quality. With regard to the transposed provisions of ICAO Annex 15 and PANS-AIM, no significant controversial issues were raised and the impact of said provisions is very low. 4.1. Issues to be addressed Since 2013, the implementation of the ADQ Regulation has been subject to significant delays in most of the Member States because of two main factors: the high cost of implementation and the many regulatory requirements which are open to interpretation, or are even unachievable (e.g. addressing data originators and aerodromes). The EC’s latest survey, conducted in October 2015, showed that for a very large majority of the Member States, full compliance with the requirements to be met by the implementation dates of respectively 1 July 2013 and 1 July 2014 have not been met. Issues related to the cost of implementation One significant obstacle to meeting the requirements of the ADQ Regulation relates to the implementation costs. Said Regulation requires the implementation of two detailed technical means: the use of an aeronautical information exchange model prescribing its technical characteristics, and the use of a specific CRC (32Q) for data protection. These technical means represent high costs. The results of the October 2015 survey launched by the EC highlighted the costs to implement the ADQ Regulation in relation to the obligation to acquire new or other necessary systems or equipment to exchange data and to protect them. The following general challenges were pointed out in the result of the survey: — ‘The compliance with the full ADQ requirements with all data to a specified deadline is very costly and demanding’; — ‘The implementation of this Regulation is financially demanding for all parties involved’; — ‘Data exchange format is delayed because of the need to purchase and implement new technical system’; — ‘Costly and time consuming implementation’; — ‘Budget constraints to meet some requirements of the ADQ Regulation, mainly in terms of acquisition of the appropriate tools, upgrades to the existing ones and their constituents, new field surveys and training’; — ‘Financial implication of ADQ implementation difficult to anticipate’; — ‘Call for an increase of the awareness and knowledge of ADQ with a flexible management of implementation cost/timeline’. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 94 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) Overview of the ADQ implementation cost/burden issues Issues Description Investment/costs  Implementation is time-consuming  Lack of available resources  Anticipation of costs  Budget constraints  Cost of implementation Aeronautical information exchange model  Implementation/upgrade costs with detailed prescriptions Data protection  cost  Lack of industry solution (off-the-shelf) Personnel  Lack of sufficient personnel (source: ADQ compliance table — European Commission, October 2015 survey outcome) Issues related to regulatory aspects Since the entry into force of the ADQ Regulation, the affected organisations pointed out the complexity of the rule and the detailed technical provisions. Also, Member States, AIS providers and data originators, such as aerodrome operators, surveyors and geodetic institutes(including some outside the scope of the aeronautical information regulatory framework), are affected by requirements that are considered challenging to comply with or disproportionate for them. The survey pointed out the risk of such stakeholders no longer wishing to participate in AIS-related tasks, thus creating gaps in the data coverage or service provision (e.g. geodetic institutes). These entities need to be supported and encouraged in the ADQ Regulation implementation, in particular when the ADQ Regulation extends the data quality management to such entities (surveyors, instrument flight procedure designers, digital terrain or digital obstacle data owners). The scope is very wide, and partly goes beyond the scope of the national supervisory authorities (NSAs), casting thus doubt on the effectiveness of the Regulation as the NSAs cannot perform effective oversight unless they establish additional legal instruments in order to expand the oversight competences to those parties. Overview of the regulatory ADQ implementation issues Issues Description Data originators  Difficulty to deal with the high number of originators  Difficulty to identify originators outside aviation  Compliance of data originators with the rules Lack of legal clarity  Unavailability of guidance  Data scope of ADQ  National legislation needed  Complexity of regulation  Legal interpretation Processes  Formal arrangements  Difficult compliance with management system for small providers TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 95 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) 4.1.1. Safety risk assessment This rulemaking task is not directly driven by safety events occurred in the past. However, the criticality of the aeronautical data and aeronautical information is considered as an essential element to ensuring safe flight operations. Aeronautical data integrity requirements are based upon the potential risk resulting from the corruption of data and upon the use to which the data element is provided up to the end-user. Furthermore, lack of harmonisation of aeronautical data quality in Europe contributes to the risk resulting from aeronautical data and aeronautical information errors. The provisions of the ADQ Regulation are to be implemented to ensure the provision of quality-assured aeronautical data and aeronautical information. With the expected growth of the number of aircraft flying in Europe, it is recognised that the ADQ Regulation provides a means of achieving demonstrable levels of quality for aeronautical data and information and provides the ability to determine the origin, verification, validation, validity, accuracy, and integrity, at all stages from origination through to publication in the AIP and beyond. The support for data quality in the provision of aeronautical information is considered as an absolute necessity by the aviation community in order to meet the required level of safety and the user requirements, as well as in order to enable key modern ATM applications (PBN, airspace management, etc.) and to support interoperability. There is a need for the rules in order to achieve quality-assured aeronautical data and aeronautical information and data of a demonstrable level of quality that can be readily exchanged between EU States and user/stakeholder systems. It is unlikely that the SES objectives can be realised without quality aeronautical data and aeronautical information that are needed to support new concepts of ATM in the future. 4.1.2. Who is affected? — ATM/ANS providers; — Member States; — competent authorities; — data originators; — aerodrome operators. 4.1.3. How could the issue/problem evolve? In case no further action is taken, the risks described in 4.1.1 may continue. The issues identified in the ToR and in the present RIA would remain unaddressed. There would be no improvement in the current rules regarding the implementation due to issues addressed in 4.1. Opportunities for the overall improvements in this area in terms of enhanced data quality would be missed. The possibilities to improve the efficiency and the effectiveness of the provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information would remain limited. More and more organisations would be tempted to not keep up with the evolution of the new technologies seeking ways to delay the implementation of the ADQ Regulation, thus formally not complying with said Regulation. 4.2. Objectives The overall objectives of the EASA system are defined in Article 2 of the Basic Regulation. This proposal will contribute to the achievement of the overall objectives by addressing the issues outlined in Section 4.1. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 96 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) The specific objectives of this proposal are to: — ensure that aeronautical data and aeronautical information are originated, assembled, edited, formatted, published and finally provided at the required level of quality to the next intended user and for all phases of flight. The quality of the data shall be proportionate to the types of aeronautical actors involved; and — foster efficient and effective rules considering also the harmonisation with the latest ICAO Annex 15 amendment. 4.3. Policy options Table 1: Selected policy options Option No Short title Description Baseline option (no change in rules; risks remain as outlined in 0 No rulemaking the issue analysis). Performance-based The draft rules on data quality are founded on a performance- 1 rulemaking based approach. Prescriptive Rules on data quality founded on prescriptive and technical 2 rulemaking provisions. The policy option 2 on ‘prescriptive rulemaking’ was discarded at an early stage of the analysis. This option proposed draft rules on data quality founded on prescriptive and technical provisions. It entailed the transposition of the ADQ Regulation into the EASA regulatory framework. It was, therefore, very similar to Option 0 in terms of rules content and potential effects. Option 2 is thus not subject to an impact analysis in 4.4 below. 4.4. Analysis of impacts 4.4.1. Safety impact Option 0 — No rulemaking The current situation remains. The support for the aeronautical data quality is considered as an absolute necessity by the aviation community in order to reach the required level of safety. Therefore, without guaranteeing effective implementation of the current rules on data quality, this option has a potential impact on safety. Option 1 — Performance-based rules on data quality Under this option, the provisions of the ADQ Regulation are transposed into the EASA regulatory framework and alleviations to requirements are provided in several areas based on compensating and mitigating factors, which aim at ensuring an acceptable level of safety, whereas on some other areas, it is believed that safety could be improved by common understanding and clarity to all stakeholders. Therefore, this option is considered to have a positive impact in terms of safety. 4.4.2. Environmental impact All three options are neutral from the environmental perspective. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 97 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) 4.4.3. Social impact From a social perspective, no major impacts are expected. 4.4.4. Economic impact When assessing the economic impacts of the options, the outcome of the October 2015 survey of the EC was taken into consideration (see section 4.1). Option 0 — No rulemaking The economic impact is highly negative for all the parties affected by the ADQ Regulation. Investments. For some ANSPs, the financial impact of the ADQ Regulation is estimated at costs of EUR 10–20 million10. For many, these requirements are difficult to implement because of the costs that cannot be covered. The constraints on the exchange model imposed by the ADQ Regulation have a negative economic impact because they entail the development or the purchase of new software/hardware and the maintenance of it. The requirement to use the Air CRC32Q for data protection has a significant impact on the ANSPs’ budget as they navigation will need to change or adapt their existing data protection system. service providers Processes. ANSPs have to identify within their operational procedures the list of (ANSPs) data originators and the data they are responsible for, and establish working arrangements with them to define and establish the evidence needed to guarantee the compliance with the quality requirements. Staff resources. Manpower, technicians, contractor (or sub-contractor) personnel will be needed to install and maintain new technologies. ANSPs have to put in place dedicated training programmes. Investments. The obligation related to a specific aeronautical information exchange model to be used as well as the CRC32Q algorithm is highly problematic as data originators have limited financial and resources capabilities. Their budgets are often not in line with the necessary activities required by the Regulation and their resources are very tight. Processes. Data originators have to establish formal arrangements with whomever they exchange data with and need to do this according to a long list of Data requirements that could be met. To do this though, time and process efforts not originators always adapted to their business are required. They have to implement requirements that are not always necessary and this has a negative impact on costs for such organisations. In addition, for many data originators, the requirement to establish and maintain a quite rigid management system constitutes a very burdensome obligation. Some data originators are not always deeply involved in AIS-AIM but are still required to comply with a detailed set of technical provisions. The impact is related to human, financial and technical resources for the oversight Member of the organisations affected by the ADQ Regulation: States — Need to put in place a national legal framework for the origination of aeronautical data, e.g. formal arrangements, method to use the reference 10 Source: Summary Report of the European Commission — Workshop on the Implementation of Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 (Quality of Aeronautical Data and Aeronautical Information – ADQ) – 23 June 2014 TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 98 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) systems, obstacle data input. — Need to ensure that all stakeholders, including data originators, such as obstacle owners, surveyors, geodetic institutes, are aware of and apply the Regulation. Option 1 — Performance-based rules on data quality This option would greatly limit the costs of implementing new technologies since the provisions of exchange model and data protection are performance-based. This option ensures that the objectives of the ADQ Regulation are maintained, thus securing the investments done so far. Investments. ATM/ANS service providers are not required to exchange data using a specific version of an aeronautical information exchange model as long as the exchange of data is globally interoperable between the relevant parties. This option mitigates the economic impact as it allows AISPs to adapt and smoothly prepare for the future. With regard to the protection of data, AISPs have the possibility not to use the CRC32Q algorithm for the protection AISPs& but to choose another protection mechanism that suitably meets the required service protection performance. providers Processes. ATM/ANS service providers have to identify within their operational procedures the list of data originators and the data they are responsible for and establish working arrangements with them to define and establish the evidence needed to guarantee the compliance with the quality requirements. Staff resources. Manpower, technicians, contractor (or sub-contractor) personnel will be needed. ATM/ANS service providers have to put in place dedicated training programmes. CRC32Q is not mandatory. Data Tools and software requirements are not mandatory. For aviation originators undertakings, the principle is to have objective-based rules. The requirements are more adapted to their origination activities. Member States will still need to be aware of the number and kind of aviation Member undertakings that are active. However, clearer rules and proportionate States requirements are expected to make the Member States’ oversight tasks more effective. Open question to stakeholders Additionally, stakeholders are kindly invited to provide data on administrative cost impacts introduced by these draft rules and any other quantitative information they may find necessary to bring to the attention of the Agency. As a result, the relevant parts of the RIA might be adjusted on a case-by-case basis. 4.4.5. General aviation and proportionality issues General aviation impacts are not relevant in the framework of this RIA. Option 0 — No rulemaking TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 99 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) The implementation of the ADQ Regulation requires significant efforts, both in terms of finance and personnel. This option requires all the affected parties to follow common stringent rules without taking into consideration their specific needs. The data quality requirements are the same regardless of the size and the contribution of the affected organisations, i.e. small contributors to the AIS/AIM domain must comply with the ‘full package’ of the ADQ Regulation. It generates administrative, technological and thus financial burden on all those involved in the origination and provision of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. The implementation of the ADQ Regulation is affected by the efforts needed from the involvement of numerous interdependent stakeholders. In addition, the burden remains on the affected organisations. It is perceived as more restrictive than necessary to produce the desired result, which is to ensure interoperability of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. Option 1 — Performance-based rules on data quality The proposal is considered to be adapted to all the actors involved in the data chain (up to publication) and would give the relief needed while maintaining an adequate level of safety. This option ensures that the requirements are suitable to achieve the desired objective and that they do not go beyond what is necessary in order to achieve this objective. Contrary to the current detailed requirements, the proposal is now objective-based while giving the necessary flexibility through the developed means of compliance. 4.4.6. Impact on ‘better regulation’ and harmonisation Option 0 — No rulemaking One of the objectives of the ADQ Regulation is to support the interoperability of aeronautical data and aeronautical information. Consequently, a harmonised implementation of said Regulation across Europe is recognised as being necessary. Nevertheless, many affected organisations have highlighted the lack of clarity and the risk of different and misleading interpretations of the ADQ Regulation. Its complexity has led to multiple interpretations. Furthermore, significant delays in implementation could continue if no additional means of compliance with the Regulation are developed, thus maintaining the difficulty in the harmonised implementation of the data quality provisions. The ADQ Regulation therefore contains complex requirements that are difficult to understand for those who need to implement it. Option 1 — Performance-based rules on data quality The proposed data quality requirements are expected to have a positive impact on and improve the harmonised rule application, in particular to bring further clarity in implementation The right balance between implementing rules and AMCs has been determined and the Agency opted for including detailed provisions on most of the data quality requirements methods and techniques at the level of AMCs, complemented with the necessary guidance material to support implementation. In particular, this proposal aims at ensuring ‘resilience’ of the new rules in times where progress in digital data provisions and exchange open the way to a wide range of technical alternatives. This flexibility provided to the organisations concerned to meet or exceed the safety objectives defined at implementing rule level, depending on their particular organisation, business model and type of infrastructure (but still guaranteeing an high level of data quality) supports the objectives of ‘better regulation’. Specific safeguards, determined in line with performance-based principles, have been TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 100 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) defined to ensure that the adoption of new technologies will not lower the standards as required by the ADQ Regulation. Furthermore, the interface between Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 on aerodrome operators — who are data originators — is ensured with the inclusion of similar data quality requirements in said Regulation related to origination purposes. This alignment between both Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 and this proposal eliminates the gap between the ADQ Regulation and the EASA AMC for the ADR Regulation. Therefore, harmonisation is properly ensured. 4.5. Comparison and conclusion 4.5.1. Comparison of options Table 3 — Final scores of the qualitative impact Option 0 Option 1 Baseline Propose data quality requirements SAFETY 0 + ENVIRONMENTAL Not applicable Not applicable SOCIAL Not applicable Not applicable ECONOMIC - + GA & PROPORTIONALITY - + BETTER REGULATION & - + HARMONISATION TOTAL -/0 + Reviewing each of the options proposed, the following conclusions can be drawn: the impact of the regulatory proposal is positive and has no negative impact either on safety or on economic issues. Taking into account the implementation of the ADQ Regulation on data quality requirements, the benefit of the proposal is seen as positive in the sense that the draft set of rules propose better regulation, simplification of the regulatory approach and regulatory coherence. The implementation of aeronautical data quality requirements will be easier to manage with the proposed rules. The implementation of the proposed rules on aeronautical data quality does not incur any additional costs to those required under the ADQ Regulation. Therefore, Option 1 ensures fulfilling the necessary safety objectives at a minimum cost and administrative burden while making sure it delivers tangible and sustainable benefits for all those organisations that will be affected by the proposal. The proposal builds on the ADQ Regulation implementation experience whilst being easier to implement. 4.5.2. Monitoring and evaluation Monitoring is a continuous and systematic process of data collection and analysis about the implementation/application of a rule/activity. It generates factual information for future possible evaluations and impact assessments and helps identifying actual implementation problems. With respect to this proposal, the Agency would suggest to monitor: TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 101 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) — the extent to which data originator comply with minimum data quality including the new requirements ; — the extent to which the data set specifications from the ICAO data catalogue have been transposed; — the interoperability of aeronautical information exchange model and costs involvement by affected stakeholders The monitoring could occur in terms collecting and analysing data from different available sources via several tools e.g. conducting surveys. The responsible actors for collecting and providing the data could be further specified in the implementation phase. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 102 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 5. References 5. References 5.1. Affected regulations — Regulation (EU) No …/… laying down common requirements for service providers and the oversight in air traffic management and air navigation services and other air traffic management network functions. — Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 1034/2011 of 17 October 2011 on safety oversight in air traffic management and air navigation services and amending Regulation (EU) No 691/2010 (OJ L 271, 18.10.2011, p. 15). — Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 1035/2011 of 17 October 2011 laying down common requirements for the provision of air navigation services and amending Regulations (EC) No 482/2008 and (EU) No 691/2010 (OJ L 271, 18.10.2011, p. 23). — Commission Regulation (EU) No 73/2010 of 26 January 2010 laying down requirements on the quality of aeronautical data and aeronautical information for the single European sky (OJ L 23, 27.1.2010, p. 6). 5.2. Affected AMC and GM Decision 2014/012/R of the Executive Director of the Agency of 27 February 2014 adopting Acceptable Means of Compliance and Guidance Material to Regulation (EU) No 139/2014 ‘AMC/GM for Aerodromes – Initial Issue’ 5.3. Reference documents — ICAO Annex 15 — Aeronautical Information Services (latest amendment still to be adopted) — Doc 9674 - WGS 84 Manual — ICAO Annex 4 — Aeronautical charts — ICAO Doc 8126 — Aeronautical Information Services Manual — Pans-AIM (still to be adopted) — Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 February 2008 on common rules in the field of civil aviation and establishing a European Aviation Safety Agency, and repealing Council Directive 91/670/EEC, Regulation (EC) No 1592/2002 and Directive 2004/36/EC (OJ L 79, 19.3.2008, p. 1). TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 103 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-02 6. Appendices 6. Appendices The following appendices are introduced: — In Annex VI (Part-AIS):  Appendix 1 — CONTENTS OF THE AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION PUBLICATION (AIP)  Appendix 2 — NOTAM FORMAT  Appendix 3 — SNOWTAM FORMAT  Appendix 4 — ASHTAM FORMAT — In Annex III (Part-ATM/ANS.OR):  Appendix 1 — Data catalogue These appendices are not reproduced in this document as they would hinder readability of this NPA given that they contain numerous pages. However, the reader may consult them on the EASA webpage. TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO9001 certified. Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 104 of 104 An agency of the European Union European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management RMT.0477 — 27.4.2016 APPENDIX 4 TO ANNEX VI (PART-AIS) AIS.TR.330(e) ASHTAM FORMAT (PRIORITY (ADDRESSEE INDICATOR(S))1 INDICATOR) (COM heading) (DATE AND TIME (ORIGINATOR’S ( OF FILING) ( INDICATOR) (VA*2 SERIAL NUMBER) (LOCATION DATE/TIME OF ISSUANCE (OPTIONAL GROUP) (Abbreviated INDICATOR) heading) V A *2 *2 ASHTAM (SERIAL NUMBER) (FLIGHT INFORMATION REGION AFFECTED) A) (DATE/TIME (UTC) OF ERUPTION) B) (VOLCANO NAME AND NUMBER) C) (VOLCANO LATITUDE/LONGITUDE OR VOLCANO RADIAL AND DISTANCE FROM NAVAID) D) (VOLCANO LEVEL OF ALERT COLOUR CODE, INCLUDING ANY PRIOR LEVEL OF ALERT COLOUR CODE)3 E) (EXISTENCE AND HORIZONTAL/VERTICAL EXTENT OF VOLCANIC ASH CLOUD)4 F) (DIRECTION OF MOVEMENT OF ASH CLOUD)4 G) (AIR ROUTES OR PORTIONS OF AIR ROUTES AND FLIGHT LEVELS AFFECTED) H) (CLOSURE OF AIRSPACE AND/OR AIR ROUTES OR PORTIONS OF AIR ROUTES, AND ALTERNATIVE AIR ROUTES I) AVAILABLE) (SOURCE OF INFORMATION) J) (PLAIN-LANGUAGE REMARKS) K) NOTES: 1. See also Appendix 5 regarding addressee indicators used in predetermined distribution systems. 2. *Enter ICAO nationality letter as given in ICAO Doc 7910, Part 2. 3. See paragraph 3.5 below. 4. Advice on the existence, extent and movement of volcanic ash cloud G) and H) may be obtained from the Volcanic Ash Advisory Centre(s) responsible for the FIR concerned. 5. Item titles in brackets ( ) not to be transmitted. SIGNATURE OF ORIGINATOR (not for transmission) INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE COMPLETION OF THE ASHTAM FORMAT 1. General 1.1 The ASHTAM provides information on the status of activity of a volcano when a change in its activity is, or is expected to be of operational significance. This information is provided using the volcano level of alert colour code given in 3.5 below. 1.2 In the event of a volcanic eruption producing ash cloud of operational significance, the ASHTAM also provides information on the location, extent and movement of the ash cloud and the air routes and flight levels affected. 1.3 Issuance of an ASHTAM giving information on a volcanic eruption, in accordance with section 3 below, should not be delayed until complete information A) to K) is available but should be issued immediately following receipt of notification that an eruption has occurred or is expected to occur, or a change in the status of activity of a volcano of operational significance has occurred or is expected to occur, or an ash cloud is reported. In the case of an expected eruption, and hence no ash cloud evident at that time, items A) to E) should be completed and items F) to I) indicated as “not applicable”. Similarly, if a volcanic ash cloud is reported, e.g. by special air-report, but the source volcano is not known at that time, the ASHTAM should be issued initially with items A) to E) indicated as “unknown”, and items F) to K) completed, as necessary, based on the special air-report, pending receipt of further information. In other circumstances, if information for a specific field A) to K) is not available indicate “NIL”. 1.4 The maximum period of validity of ASHTAM is 24 hours. New ASHTAM must be issued whenever there is a change in the level of alert. 2. Abbreviated heading 2.1 Following the usual AFTN communications header, the abbreviated heading “TT AAiiii CCCC MMYYGGgg (BBB)” is included to facilitate the automatic processing of ASHTAM messages in computer data banks. The explanation of these symbols is: TT = data designator for ASHTAM = VA; AA = geographical designator for States, e.g. NZ = New Zealand (see Location Indicators (Doc 7910), Part 2, Index to Nationality Letters for Location Indicators); iiii = ASHTAM serial number in a four-figure group; CCCC = four-letter location indicator of the flight information region concerned (see Location Indicators (Doc 7910), Part 5, addresses of centres in charge of FIR/UIR); MMYYGGgg = date/time of report, whereby: MM = month, e.g. January = 01, December = 12 YY = day of the month GGgg = time in hours (GG) and minutes (gg) UTC; (BBB) = Optional group for correction to an ASHTAM message previously disseminated with the same serial number = COR. Note.— Brackets in (BBB) are used to indicate that this group is optional. Example: Abbreviated heading of ASHTAM for Auckland Oceanic FIR, report on 7 November at 0620 UTC: VANZ0001 NZZO 11070620 3. Content of ASHTAM 3.1 Item A — Flight information region affected, plain-language equivalent of the location indicator given in the abbreviated heading, in this example “Auckland Oceanic FIR”. 3.2 Item B — Date and time (UTC) of first eruption. 3.3 Item C — Name of volcano, and number of volcano as listed in the ICAO Manual on Volcanic Ash, Radioactive Material and Toxic Chemical Clouds (Doc 9691), Appendix H, and on the World Map of Volcanoes and Principal Aeronautical Features. 3.4 Item D — Latitude/Longitude of the volcano in whole degrees or radial and distance of volcano from NAVAID (as listed in the ICAO Manual on Volcanic Ash, Radioactive Material and Toxic Chemical Clouds (Doc 9691), Appendix H, and on the World Map of Volcanoes and Principal Aeronautical Features). 3.5 Item E — Colour code for level of alert indicating volcanic activity, including any previous level of alert colour code as follows: Level of alert colour code Status of activity of volcano GREEN Volcano is in normal, non-eruptive state. ALERT or, after a change from a higher alert level: Volcanic activity considered to have ceased, and volcano reverted to its normal, non-eruptive state. YELLOW Volcano is experiencing signs of elevated unrest above known background levels. ALERT or, after a change from higher alert level: Volcanic activity has decreased significantly but continues to be closely monitored for possible renewed increase. ORANGE Volcano is exhibiting heightened unrest with increased likelihood of eruption. ALERT or, Volcanic eruption is underway with no or minor ash emission [specify ash-plume height if possible]. RED Eruption is forecasted to be imminent with significant emission of ash into the atmosphere likely. ALERT or, Eruption is underway with significant emission of ash into the atmosphere [specify ash-plume height if possible]. Note.— The colour code for the level of alert indicating the status of activity of the volcano and any change from a previous status of activity should be provided to the area control centre by the responsible vulcanological agency in the State concerned, e.g. “RED ALERT FOLLOWING YELLOW” OR “GREEN ALERT FOLLOWING ORANGE”. 3.6 Item F — If volcanic ash cloud of operational significance is reported, indicate the horizontal extent and base/top of the ash cloud using latitude/longitude (in whole degrees) and altitudes in thousands of metres (feet) and/or radial and distance from source volcano. Information initially may be based only on special air-report, but subsequent information may be more detailed based on advice from the responsible meteorological watch office and/or volcanic ash advisory centre. 3.7 Item G — Indicate forecast direction of movement of the ash cloud at selected levels based on advice from the responsible meteorological watch office and/or volcanic ash advisory centre. 3.8 Item H — Indicate air routes and portions of air routes and flight levels affected, or expected to become affected. 3.9 Item I — Indicate closure of airspace, air routes or portions of air routes, and availability of alternative routes. 3.10 Item J — Source of the information, e.g. “special air-report” or “vulcanological agency”, etc. The source of information should always be indicated, whether an eruption has actually occurred or ash cloud reported, or not. 3.11 Item K — Include in plain language any operationally significant information additional to the foregoing. ______________________ European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management RMT.0477 — 27.4.2016 APPENDIX 3 TO ANNEX VI (PART-AIS) AIS.TR.330(d) SNOWTAM FORMAT (PRIORITY (ADDRESSES) ≪≡( (COM INDICATOR) heading) (DATE AND TIME (ORIGINATOR’S (OF FILING) ≪≡( ( INDICATOR) (SWAA* SERIAL NUMBER) (LOCATION INDICATOR) DATE-TIME OF ASSESSMENT (OPTIONAL GROUP) (Abbreviated heading) S W * * ≪≡( SNOWTAM (Serial number) <<≡ Aeroplane performance section (AERODROME LOCATION INDICATOR) M A) (DATE/TIME OF ASSESSMENT (Time of completion of assessment in UTC)) M B) (LOWER RUNWAY DESIGNATORS) M C) RUNWAY CONDITION CODE ON EACH THIRD OF RUNWAY (From Runway Condition Assessment D) M Matrix (RCAM) 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 or 6 / / E) PER CENT COVERAGE CONTAMINANT FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD C / / F) DEPTH (mm) OF LOOSE CONTAMINANT FOR EACH THIRD OF RUNWAY) C / / (CONDITION DESCRIPTION OVER TOTAL RUNWAY LENGTH M G) (Observed on each third of the runway, starting from threshold having the lower runway designation / / number) DRY WET ICE WATER ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW DRY SNOW DRY SNOW ON TOP OF ICE WET SNOW ON TOP OF ICE ICE SLUSH STANDING WATER COMPACTED SNOW WET SNOW DRY SNOW ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW WET SNOW ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW WET FROST (WIDTH OF RUNWAY TO WHICH THE RWYCCs APPLY, IF LESS THAN PUBLISHED WIDTH) O H) <≡ Situational awareness section (REDUCED RUNWAY LENGTH, IF LESS THAN PUBLISHED LENGTH (m)) O I) DRIFTING SNOW ON THE RUNWAYT O J) LOOSE SAND ON THE RUNWAY O K) CHEMICAL TREATMENT ON RUNWAY O L) (SNOWBANKS ON THE RUNWAY (If present, distance from runway centreline (m) followed by “L”, “R” or “LR” O M) as applicable)) (SNOWBANKS ON A TAXIWAY(If present, distance from the edge of runway (m) followed by “L”, “R” or “LR” as O N) applicable)) SNOWBANKS ADJACENT TO THE RUNWAY O O) (TAXIWAY CONDITIONS) O P) (APRON CONDITIONS) O R) (STATE APPROVED AND PUBLISHED USE OF MEASURED FRICTION COEFFICIENT) O S) (PLAIN-LANGUAGE REMARKS (Including contaminant coverage and other operationally significant information, O T) ) <≡ e.g. sanding, de-icing)) NOTES: 1. *Enter ICAO nationality letters as given in ICAO Doc 7910, Part 2. 2. *Information on other runways, repeat from B to P. 3. *Words in brackets ( ) not to be transmitted. SIGNATURE OF ORIGINATOR (not for transmission) INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE COMPLETION OF THE SNOWTAM FORMAT Note.— Origin of data, assessment process and the procedures linked to the surface conditions reporting system are prescribed in the PANS-Aerodromes (Doc 9981). 1. General a) When reporting on more than one runway, repeat Items B to H (the Aeroplane performance section). b) The letters used to indicate items are only used for reference purpose and should not be included in the messages. The letters, M (mandatory) C (conditional) and O (optional) mark the usage and information shall be included as explained below. c) Metric units shall be used and the unit of measurement not reported. d) The maximum validity of SNOWTAM is 8 hours. New SNOWTAM shall be issued whenever a new runway condition report is received. e) A SNOWTAM cancels the previous SNOWTAM. f) The abbreviated heading “TTAAiiii CCCC MMYYGGgg (BBB)” is included to facilitate the automatic processing of SNOWTAM messages in computer data banks. The explanation of these symbols is: TT = data designator for SNOWTAM = SW; AA = geographical designator for States, e.g. LF = FRANCE, EG = United Kingdom (see Location Indicators (Doc 7910), Part 2, Index to Nationality Letters for Location Indicators); iiii = SNOWTAM serial number in a four-digit group; CCCC = four-letter location indicator of the aerodrome to which the SNOWTAM refers (see Location Indicators (Doc 7910)); MMYYGGgg = date/time of observation/measurement, whereby: MM = month, e.g. January = 01, December = 12 YY = day of the month GGgg = time in hours (GG) and minutes (gg) UTC; (BBB) = optional group for: Correction to SNOWTAM message previously disseminated with the same serial number = COR. Note 1.— Brackets in (BBB) are used to indicate that this group is optional. Note 2.— When reporting on more than one runway and individual dates/times of observation/measurement are indicated by repeated Item B, the latest date/time of observation/measuring is inserted in the abbreviated heading (MMYYGGgg). Example: Abbreviated heading of SNOWTAM No. 149 from Zurich, measurement/observation of 7 November at 0620 UTC: SWLS0149 LSZH 11070620 Note.— The information groups are separated by a space, as illustrated above. g) For readability purposes for the SNOWTAM message, include a line feed after the SNOWTAM serial number and after the aeroplane performance section. h) When reporting on more than one runway, repeat the information in the Aeroplane performance calculation section from the Date and Time of Assessment for each runway before the information in the Situational awareness section. i) Mandatory information is: i) AERODROME LOCATION INDICATOR ii) DATE AND TIME OF ASSESSMENT iii) LOWER RUNWAY DESIGNATOR NUMBER iv) RUNWAY CONDITION CODE FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD v) CONDITION DESCRIPTION FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD (when runway condition code is reported 1- 5) 2. Aeroplane performance calculation section Item A — Aerodrome location indicator (Location Indicators, Doc 7910). Item B — Date and time of assessment eight-figure date/time group giving time of observation as month, day, hour and minute in UTC. Item C — Lower runway designator number ( nn[L] or nn[C] or nn[R]) 1) Only one runway designator shall be inserted for each runway and always the lowest number. Item D — Runway condition code for each runway third 1) Only one digit (0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 or 6) shall be inserted for each runway third, separated by an oblique stroke (n/n/n) 2) When RUNWAY CONDITION CODE FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD contains any code other than 6 (DRY) then the PER CENT COVERAGE FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD becomes mandatory for the affected runway thirds. 3) When the CONDITION DESCRIPTION FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD contains any of the following information: WET ICE WATER ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW DRY SNOW DRY SNOW ON TOP OF ICE WET SNOW ON TOP OF ICE ICE SLUSH STANDING WATER COMPACTED SNOW WET SNOW DRY SNOW ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW WET SNOW ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW FROST then the following information becomes mandatory and shall be provided for the respective runway thirds. Item E — Per cent coverage for each runway third Insert 25, 50, 75 or 100 for each runway third separated by an oblique stroke ([n]nn/[n]nn/[n]nn). Item F — Depth of loose contaminant for each runway third in millimetre for each runway third separated by an oblique stroke (nn/nn/nn). 1) This information shall only be reported for the following contamination types: Standing water, values to be reported03, then assessed value. Significant changes 3 mm up to and including 15 mm. Slush, values to be reported 02, then assessed value. Significant changes 3 mm up to and including 15 mm. Wet snow, values to be reported 02, then assessed value. Significant changes 5 mm. Dry snow, values to be reported 02, then assessed value. Significant changes 20 mm. 2) For contaminants other than the ones above, the depth is not reported. 3) For the information elements “PER CENT COVERAGE FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD and DEPTH OF LOOSE CONTAMINANT FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD, sometimes no information exists to be reported (see above for which contaminant types and conditions these elements shall be reported). Even when there is nothing to report, the oblique strokes shall be included at their relevant position in the message, to indicate to the user that no information exists ( // ). 4) For the information element reporting on “PER CENT COVERAGE FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD” and “DEPTH OF LOOSE CONTAMINANT FOR EACH RUNWAY THIRD”, one or two thirds may be left blank, and only one third may be reported, depending on which contamination type and runway condition codes that is reported. For example 25// , /15/15 Item G — Condition description for each third Insert any of the condition description for each runway third separated by an oblique stroke WET ICE WATER ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW DRY SNOW DRY SNOW ON TOP OF ICE WET SNOW ON TOP OF ICE ICE SLUSH STANDING WATER COMPACTED SNOW WET SNOW DRY SNOW ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW WET SNOW ON TOP OF COMPACTED SNOW FROST DRY shall be reported when there is no contaminant. Item H — Width of RWY to which the RWYCCs apply if less than published width, insert width in metres. 3. Situational awareness section 1) Elements in the situational awareness section shall end with a full stop. 2) Elements in the situational awareness section for which no information exists, or where the conditional circumstances for publication is not fulfilled, shall be left out completely. Item I — Reduced runway length If the runway length available is reduced due to reported conditions, insert available length in meters.([nn]nn) Item J — Drifting snow on the runway If snow is drifting on the runway, report “DRIFTING SNOW” Item K — Loose sand on the runway If loose sand is present on the runway, insert lowest runway designator and with a space “LOOSE SAND”, for example (RWY nn[L] or nn[C] or nn[R] LOOSE SAND). Item L — Chemical treatment on RWY If chemical treatment has been applied, insert the lowest runway designator and with a space “CHEMICALLY TREATED” (RWY nn[L] or nn[C] or nn[R] CHEMICALLY TREATED). Item M — Snowbanks on the runway If critical snowbanks are present on the runway, insert the runway designator and with a space “SNOWBANK” and with a space left “L” or right “R” or both sides “LR”, followed by the distance in metres from centreline separated by a space FM CL (RWY nn[L] or nn[C] or nn[R] SNOWBANK Lnn or Rnn or LRnn FM CL). Item N — Snowbanks on the taxiway If critical snow banks are present on a taxiway, insert the taxiway designator and with a space “SNOW BANK” and with a space left “L” or right “R” or both sides “LR”, followed by the distance in metres from centreline separated by a space FM CL (TWY [nn]n) SNOWBANK Lnn or Rnn or LRnn FM CL). Item O — Snowbanks adjacent to the runway If snow banks are present penetrating the height profile in the aerodrome snow plan, insert lowest runway designator and “ADJ SNOWBANKS” (RWY nn[L] or nn[C] or nn[R] ADJ SNOWBANKS.) Item P — Taxiway conditions If taxiway conditions are slippery or poor insert taxiway designator followed by a space “POOR”. ( TWY [nn]n POOR.) Item R — Apron conditions If apron conditions are slippery or poor insert taxiway designator followed by a space “POOR” ( APRON [nnnn] POOR.) Item S — State approved and published use of measured friction coefficient According to a standard set or agreed by the State. Item T — Plain language remarks Plain language text, insert characters in accordance with aeronautical fixed services provisions. EXAMPLE OF COMPLETED SNOWTAM FORMAT Example SNOWTAM 1 ENZH 02170055 09L 5/5/5 100/100/100 // WET/WET/WET Example SNOWTAM 2 ENZH 02170055 09L 5/5/5 100/100/100 // WET/WET/WET ENZH 02170135 09R 5/4/3 100/50/75 /06/06 WET/SLUSH/SLUSH Example SNOWTAM 3 ENZH 02170055 09L 5/5/5 100/100/100 // WET/WET/WET ENZH 02170135 09R 5/4/3 100/50/75 /06/06 WET/SLUSH/SLUSH ENZH 02170225 09C 3/2/1 75/100/100 06/12/12 SLUSH/WET SNOW/WET SNOW RWY 09L SNOWBANK R20 FM CL. RWY 09R ADJ SNOWBANKS. TWY B POOR. APRON NORTH POOR Example SNOWTAM 4 ENZH 02170345 09L 5/5/5 100/100/100 // WET/WET/WET ENZH 02170134 09R 5/4/3 100/50/75 /06/06 WET/SLUSH/SLUSH ENZH 02170225 09C 3/2/1 75/100/100 06/12/12 SLUSH/WET SNOW/WET SNOW 35 DRIFTING SNOW. RWY 09L LOOSE SAND. RWY 09R CHEMICALLY TREATED. RWY 09C CHEMICALLY TREATED. Note.— See the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc 8126) for additional SNOWTAM examples incorporating different runway conditions. ____________________ European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management RMT.0477 — 27.4.2016 APPENDIX 1 TO ANNEX VI (PART-AIS) (AIS.TR.305(c)) CONTENTS OF THE AERONAUTICAL INFORMATION PUBLICATION (AIP) PART 1 — GENERAL (GEN) When the AIP is produced as one volume, the preface, record of AIP Amendments, record of AIP Supplements, checklist of AIP pages and list of current hand amendments appear only in Part 1 — GEN, and the annotation “not applicable” must be entered against each of these subsections in Parts 2 and 3. If an AIP is produced and made available in more than one volume with each having a separate amendment and supplement service, a separate preface, record of AIP Amendments, record of AIP Supplements, checklist of AIP pages and list of current hand amendments must be included in each volume. GEN 0.1 Preface Brief description of the AIP, including: 1) name of the publishing authority; 2) applicable ICAO documents; 3) publication media (i.e. printed, online or other electronic media); 4) the AIP structure and established regular amendment interval; 5) copyright policy, if applicable; and 6) service to contact in case of detected AIP errors or omissions. GEN 0.2 Record of AIP Amendments A record of AIP Amendments and AIRAC AIP Amendments (published in accordance with the AIRAC system) containing: 1) amendment number; 2) publication date; 3) date inserted (for the AIRAC AIP Amendments, effective date); and 4) initials of officer who inserted the amendment. GEN 0.3 Record of AIP Supplements A record of issued AIP Supplements containing: 1) Supplement number; 2) Supplement subject; 3) AIP section(s) affected; 4) period of validity; and 5) cancellation record. GEN 0.4 Checklist of AIP pages A checklist of AIP pages containing: 1) page number/chart title; and 2) publication or effective date (day, month by name and year) of the aeronautical information. GEN 0.5 List of hand amendments to the AIP A list of current hand amendments to the AIP containing: 1) AIP page(s) affected; 2) amendment text; and 3) AIP Amendment number by which a hand amendment was introduced. GEN 0.6 Table of contents to Part 1 A list of sections and sub-sections contained in Part 1 — General (GEN). Note.— Subsections may be listed alphabetically. GEN 1. NATIONAL REGULATIONS AND REQUIREMENTS GEN 1.1 Designated authorities The addresses of designated authorities concerned with the facilitation of international air navigation (civil aviation, meteorology, customs, immigration, health, en-route and aerodrome/heliport charges, agricultural quarantine and aircraft accident investigation) containing, for each authority: 1) designated authority; 2) name of the authority; 3) postal address; 4) telephone number; 5) telefax number; 6) e-mail address; 7) aeronautical fixed service (AFS) address; and 8) website address, if available. GEN 1.2 Entry, transit and departure of aircraft Regulations and requirements for advance notification and applications for permission concerning entry, transit and departure of aircraft on international flights. GEN 1.3 Entry, transit and departure of passengers and crew Regulations (including customs, immigration and quarantine, and requirements for advance notification and applications for permission) concerning entry, transit and departure of non-immigrant passengers and crew. GEN 1.4 Entry, transit and departure of cargo Regulations (including customs, and requirements for advance notification and applications for permission) concerning entry, transit and departure of cargo. Note.— Provisions for facilitating entry and departure for search, rescue, salvage, investigation, repair or salvage in connection with lost or damaged aircraft are detailed in section GEN 3.6, Search and rescue. GEN 1.5 Aircraft instruments, equipment and flight documents Brief description of aircraft instruments, equipment and flight documents, including: 1) instruments, equipment (including aircraft communication, navigation and surveillance equipment) and flight documents to be carried on aircraft, including any special requirement in addition to the provisions specified in Annex 6, Part I, Chapters 6 and 7; and 2) emergency locator transmitter (ELT), signalling devices and life-saving equipment as presented in Annex 6, Part I, 6.6 and Part II, 2.4.5, where so determined by regional air navigation meetings, for flights over designated land areas. GEN 1.6 Summary of national regulations and international agreements/conventions A list of titles and references and, where applicable, summaries of national regulations affecting air navigation, together with a list of international agreements/conventions ratified by Member State. GEN 1.7 Differences from ICAO Standards, Recommended Practices and Procedures A list of significant differences between national regulations and practices of the Member State and related ICAO provisions, including: 1) provision affected (Annex and edition number, paragraph); and 2) difference in full text. All significant differences must be listed under this sub-section. All Annexes must be listed in numerical order even if there is no difference to an ICAO Annex, in which case a NIL notification must be provided. National differences or the degree of non-application of the regional supplementary procedures (SUPPs) must be notified immediately following the Annex to which the supplementary procedure relates. GEN 2. TABLES AND CODES GEN 2.1 Measuring system, aircraft markings, holidays GEN 2.1.1 Units of measurement Description of units of measurement used including table of units of measurement. GEN 2.1.2 Temporal reference system Description of the temporal reference system (calendar and time system) employed, together with an indication of whether or not daylight saving hours are employed and how the temporal reference system is presented throughout the AIP. GEN 2.1.3 Horizontal reference system Brief description of the horizontal (geodetic) reference system used, including: 1) name/designation of the reference system; 2) identification and parameters of the projection; 3) identification of the ellipsoid used; 4) identification of the datum used; 5) area(s) of application; and 6) an explanation, if applicable, of the asterisk used to identify those coordinates that do not meet ICAO Annex 11 and 14 accuracy requirements. GEN 2.1.4 Vertical reference system Brief description of the vertical reference system used, including: 1) name/designation of the reference system; 2) description of the geoid model used including the parameters required for height transformation between the model used and EGM-96; and 3) an explanation, if applicable, of the asterisk used to identify those elevations/geoid undulations that do not meet ICAO Annex 14 accuracy requirements. GEN 2.1.5 Aircraft nationality and registration marks Indication of aircraft nationality and registration marks adopted by the Member State. GEN 2.1.6 Public holidays A list of public holidays with indication of services being affected. GEN 2.2 Abbreviations used in AIS publications A list of alphabetically arranged abbreviations and their respective significations used by the Member State in its AIP and in the distribution of aeronautical data and aeronautical information with appropriate annotation for those national abbreviations that are different from those contained in the Procedures for Air Navigation Services — ICAO Abbreviations and Codes (PANS-ABC, ICAO Doc 8400). Note.— A list of alphabetically arranged definitions/glossary of terms may also be added. GEN 2.3 Chart symbols A list of chart symbols arranged according to the chart series where symbols are applied. GEN 2.4 Location indicators A list of alphabetically arranged ICAO location indicators assigned to the locations of aeronautical fixed stations to be used for encoding and decoding purposes. An annotation to locations not connected to the aeronautical fixed service (AFS) must be provided. GEN 2.5 List of radio navigation aids A list of radio navigation aids arranged alphabetically, containing: 1) identifier; 2) name of the station; 3) type of facility/aid; and 4) indication whether aid serves en-route (E), aerodrome (A) or dual (AE) purposes. GEN 2.6 Conversion of units of measurement Tables for conversion or, alternatively, conversion formulae between: 1) nautical miles and kilometres and vice versa; 2) feet and metres and vice versa; 3) decimal minutes of arc and seconds of arc and vice versa; and 4) other conversions as appropriate. GEN 2.7 Sunrise/sunset Information on the time of sunrise and sunset including a brief description of criteria used for determination of the times given and either a simple formulae or table from which times may be calculated for any location within its territory/area of responsibility, or an alphabetical list of locations for which the times are given in a table with a reference to the related page in the table and the sunrise/sunset tables for the selected stations/locations, including: 1) station name; 2) ICAO location indicator; 3) geographical coordinates in degrees and minutes; 4) date(s) for which times are given; 5) time for the beginning of morning civil twilight; 6) time for sunrise; 7) time for sunset; and 8) time for the end of evening civil twilight. GEN 3. SERVICES GEN 3.1 Aeronautical information services GEN 3.1.1 Responsible service Description of the Aeronautical Information Service (AIS) provided and its major components, including: 1) service/unit name; 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; 7) website address, if available; 8) a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the service is based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed; and 9) an indication if service is not H24. GEN 3.1.2 Area of responsibility The area of responsibility for the AIS . GEN 3.1.3 Aeronautical publications Description of the elements of the aeronautical information products, including: 1) AIP and related amendment service; 2) AIP Supplements; 3) AIC; 4) NOTAM and pre-flight information bulletins (PIB); 5) checklists and lists of valid NOTAM; and 6) how they may be obtained. When an AIC is used to promulgate publication prices, that must be indicated in this section of the AIP. GEN 3.1.4 AIRAC system Brief description of the AIRAC system provided including a table of present and near future AIRAC dates. GEN 3.1.5 Pre-flight information service at aerodromes/heliports A list of aerodromes/heliports at which pre-flight information is routinely available, including an indication of relevant: 1) elements of the aeronautical information products held; 2) maps and charts held; and 3) general area of coverage of such data. GEN 3.1.6 Electronic terrain and obstacle data Details of how electronic terrain and obstacle data may be obtained, containing: 1) name of the individual, service or organisation responsible; 2) street address and e-mail address of the individual, service or organisation responsible; 3) telefax number of the individual, service or organisation responsible; 4) contact telephone number of the individual, service or organisation responsible; 5) hours of service (time period including time zone when contact can be made); 6) online information that can be used to contact the individual, service or organisation; and 7) supplemental information, if necessary, on how and when to contact the individual, service or organisation. GEN 3.2 Aeronautical charts GEN 3.2.1 Responsible service(s) Description of service(s) responsible for the production of aeronautical charts, including: 1) service name; 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; 7) website address, if available; 8) a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the service is based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed; and 9) an indication if service is not H24. GEN 3.2.2 Maintenance of charts Brief description of how aeronautical charts are revised and amended. GEN 3.2.3 Purchase arrangements Details of how charts may be obtained, containing: 1) service/sales agency(ies); 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; and 7) website address, if available. GEN 3.2.4 Aeronautical chart series available A list of aeronautical chart series available followed by a general description of each series and an indication of the intended use. GEN 3.2.5 List of aeronautical charts available A list of aeronautical charts available, including: 1) title of series; 2) scale of series; 3) name and/or number of each chart or each sheet in a series; 4) price per sheet; and 5) date of latest revision. GEN 3.2.6 Index to the World Aeronautical Chart (WAC) — ICAO 1:1 000 000 An index chart showing coverage and sheet layout for the WAC 1:1 000 000 produced by a State. If Aeronautical Chart — ICAO 1:500 000 is produced instead of WAC 1:1 000 000, index charts must be used to indicate coverage and sheet layout for the Aeronautical Chart — ICAO 1:500 000. GEN 3.2.7 Topographical charts Details of how topographical charts may be obtained, containing: 1) name of service/agency(ies); 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; and 7) website address, if available. GEN 3.2.8 Corrections to charts not contained in the AIP A list of corrections to aeronautical charts not contained in the AIP, or an indication where such information can be obtained. GEN 3.3 Air traffic services (ATS) GEN 3.3.1 Responsible service Description of the air traffic service and its major components, including: 1) service name; 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; 7) website address, if available; 8) a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the service is based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed; and 9) an indication if service is not H24. GEN 3.3.2 Area of responsibility Brief description of area of responsibility for which air traffic services are provided. GEN 3.3.3 Types of services Brief description of main types of air traffic services provided. GEN 3.3.4 Coordination between the operator and ATS General conditions under which coordination between the operator and air traffic services is affected. GEN 3.3.5 Minimum flight altitude The criteria used to determine minimum flight altitudes. GEN 3.3.6 ATS units address list A list of ATS units and their addresses arranged alphabetically, containing: 1) unit name; 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; and 7) website address, if available. GEN 3.4 Communication services GEN 3.4.1 Responsible service Description of the service responsible for the provision of telecommunication and navigation facilities, including: 1) service name; 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; 7) website address, if available; 8) a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the service is based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed; and 9) an indication if service is not H24. GEN 3.4.2 Area of responsibility Brief description of area of responsibility for which telecommunication service is provided. GEN 3.4.3 Types of service Brief description of the main types of service and facilities provided, including: 1) radio navigation services; 2) voice and/or data link services; 3) broadcasting service; 4) language(s) used; and 5) an indication of where detailed information can be obtained. GEN 3.4.4 Requirements and conditions Brief description concerning the requirements and conditions under which the communication service is available. GEN 3.4.5 Miscellaneous Any additional information (e.g. selected radio broadcasting stations, telecommunications diagram). GEN 3.5 Meteorological services GEN 3.5.1 Responsible service Brief description of the meteorological service responsible for the provision of meteorological information, including: 1) service name; 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; 7) website address, if available; 8) a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the service is based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed; and 9) an indication if service is not H24. GEN 3.5.2 Area of responsibility Brief description of area and/or air routes for which meteorological service is provided. GEN 3.5.3 Meteorological observations and reports Detailed description of the meteorological observations and reports provided for international air navigation, including: 1) name of the station and the ICAO location indicator; 2) type and frequency of observation including an indication of automatic observing equipment; 3) types of meteorological reports (e.g. METAR) and availability of a TREND forecast; 4) specific type of observation system and number of observation sites used to observe and report surface wind, visibility, runway visual range, cloud base, temperature and, where applicable, wind shear (e.g. anemometer at intersection of runways, transmissometers next to touchdown zone, etc.); 5) hours of operation; and 6) indication of aeronautical climatological information available. GEN 3.5.4 Types of services Brief description of the main types of service provided, including details of briefing, consultation, display of meteorological information, flight documentation available for operators and flight crew members, and of the methods and means used for supplying the meteorological information. GEN 3.5.5 Notification required from operators Minimum amount of advance notice required by the meteorological service provider from operators in respect of briefing, consultation and flight documentation and other meteorological information they require or change. GEN 3.5.6 Aircraft reports As necessary, requirements of the meteorological service provider for the making and transmission of aircraft reports. GEN 3.5.7 VOLMET service Description of VOLMET and/or D-VOLMET service, including: 1) name of transmitting station; 2) call sign or identification and abbreviation for the radio communication emission; 3) frequency or frequencies used for broadcast; 4) broadcasting period; 5) hours of service; 6) list of aerodromes/heliports for which reports and/or forecasts are included; and 7) reports, forecasts and SIGMET information included and remarks. GEN 3.5.8 SIGMET and AIRMET service Description of the meteorological watch provided within flight information regions or control areas for which air traffic services are provided, including a list of the meteorological watch offices with: 1) name of the meteorological watch office, ICAO location indicator; 2) hours of service; 3) flight information region(s) or control area(s) served; 4) SIGMET validity periods; 5) specific procedures applied to SIGMET information (e.g. for volcanic ash and tropical cyclones); 6) procedures applied to AIRMET information (in accordance with relevant regional air navigation agreements); 7) the ATS unit(s) provided with SIGMET and AIRMET information; and 8) additional information (e.g. concerning any limitation of service, etc.). GEN 3.5.9 Other automated meteorological services Description of available automated services for the provision of meteorological information (e.g. automated pre- flight information service accessible by telephone and/or computer modem) including: 1) service name; 2) information available; 3) areas, routes and aerodromes covered; and 4) telephone and telefax number(s), e-mail address, and, if available, website address. GEN 3.6 Search and rescue (SAR) GEN 3.6.1 Responsible service(s) Brief description of service(s) responsible for the provision of search and rescue (SAR), including: 1) service/unit name; 2) postal address; 3) telephone number; 4) telefax number; 5) e-mail address; 6) AFS address; 7) website address, if available; and 8) a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the service is based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed. GEN 3.6.2 Area of responsibility Brief description of area of responsibility within which SAR services are provided. Note.— A chart may be included to supplement the description of the area. GEN 3.6.3 Types of service Brief description and geographical portrayal, where appropriate, of the type of service and facilities provided including indications where SAR aerial coverage is dependent upon significant deployment of aircraft. GEN 3.6.4 SAR agreements Brief description of SAR agreements in force, including provisions for facilitating entry and departure of other States’ aircraft for search, rescue, salvage, repair or salvage in connection with lost or damaged aircraft, either with airborne notification only or after flight plan notification. GEN 3.6.5 Conditions of availability Brief description of provisions for SAR, including the general conditions under which the service and facilities are available for international use, including an indication of whether a facility available for SAR is specialized in SAR techniques and functions, or is specially used for other purposes but adapted for SAR purposes by training and equipment, or is only occasionally available and has no particular training or preparation for SAR work. GEN 3.6.6 Procedures and signals used Brief description of the procedures and signals employed by rescue aircraft and a table showing the signals to be used by survivors. GEN 4. CHARGES FOR AERODROMES/HELIPORTS AND AIR NAVIGATION SERVICES (ANS) Reference may be made to where details of actual charges may be found, if not itemized in this chapter. GEN 4.1 Aerodrome/heliport charges Brief description of type of charges which may be applicable at aerodromes/heliports available for international use, including: 1) landing of aircraft; 2) parking, hangarage and long-term storage of aircraft; 3) passenger service; 4) security; 5) noise-related items; 6) other (customs, health, immigration, etc.); 7) exemptions/reductions; and 8) methods of payment. GEN 4.2 Air navigation services charges Brief description of charges which may be applicable to ANS provided for international use, including: 1) approach control; 2) route ANS; 3) cost basis for ANS and exemptions/reductions; and 4) methods of payment. PART 2 — EN-ROUTE (ENR) If an AIP is produced and made available in more than one volume with each having a separate amendment and supplement service, a separate preface, record of AIP Amendments, record of AIP Supplements, checklist of AIP pages and list of current hand amendments must be included in each volume. In the case of an AIP being published as one volume, the annotation “not applicable” must be entered against each of the above subsections. ENR 0.6 Table of contents to Part 2 A list of sections and subsections contained in Part 2 — En-route. Note.— Subsections may be listed alphabetically. ENR 1. GENERAL RULES AND PROCEDURES ENR 1.1 General rules The requirement is for publication of the general rules as applied within the Member State. ENR 1.2 Visual flight rules The requirement is for publication of the visual flight rules as applied within the Member State. ENR 1.3 Instrument flight rules The requirement is for publication of the instrument flight rules as applied within the Member State. ENR 1.4 ATS airspace classification and description ENR 1.4.1 ATS airspace classification The description of ATS airspace classes in the form of the ATS airspace classification table in Appendix 4 to SERA.6001, appropriately annotated to indicate those airspace classes not used by the Member State. ENR 1.4.2 ATS airspace description Other ATS airspace descriptions as applicable, including general textual descriptions. ENR 1.5 Holding, approach and departure procedures ENR 1.5.1 General The requirement is for a statement concerning the criteria on which holding, approach and departure procedures are established. If different from ICAO provisions, the requirement is for presentation of criteria used in a tabular form. ENR 1.5.2 Arriving flights The requirement is to present procedures (conventional or area navigation or both) for arriving flights which are common to flights into or within the same type of airspace. If different procedures apply within a terminal airspace, a note to this effect must be given together with a reference to where the specific procedures can be found. ENR 1.5.3 Departing flights The requirement is to present procedures (conventional or area navigation or both) for departing flights which are common to flights departing from any aerodrome/heliport. ENR 1.5.4 Other relevant information and procedures Brief description of additional information, e.g. entry procedures, final approach alignment, holding procedures and patterns. ENR 1.6 ATS surveillance services and procedures ENR 1.6.1 Primary radar Description of primary radar services and procedures, including: 1) supplementary services; 2) the application of radar control service; 3) radar and air-ground communication failure procedures; 4) voice and CPDLC position reporting requirements; and 5) graphic portrayal of area of radar coverage. ENR 1.6.2 Secondary surveillance radar (SSR) Description of secondary surveillance radar (SSR) operating procedures, including: 1) emergency procedures; 2) air-ground communication failure and unlawful interference procedures; 3) the system of SSR code assignment; 4) voice and CPDLC position reporting requirements; and 5) graphic portrayal of area of SSR coverage. Note.— The SSR description is of particular importance in areas or routes where the possibility of interception exists. ENR 1.6.3 Automatic dependent surveillance — broadcast (ADS-B) Description of automatic dependent surveillance — broadcast (ADS-B) operating procedures, including: 1) emergency procedures; 2) air-ground communication failure and unlawful interference procedures; 3) aircraft identification requirements; 4) voice and CPDLC position reporting requirements; and 5) graphic portrayal of area of ADS-B coverage. Note.— The ADS-B description is of particular importance in areas or routes where the possibility of interception exists. ENR 1.6.4 Other relevant information and procedures Brief description of additional information and procedures, e.g. radar failure procedures and transponder failure procedures. ENR 1.7 Altimeter setting procedures The requirement is for a statement of altimeter setting procedures in use, containing: 1) brief introduction with a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the procedures are based together with differences to ICAO provisions, if any; 2) basic altimeter setting procedures; 3) description of altimeter setting region(s); 4) procedures applicable to operators (including pilots); and 5) table of cruising levels. ENR 1.8 Regional supplementary procedures The requirement is for presentation of regional supplementary procedures (SUPPs) affecting the entire area of responsibility. ENR 1.9 Air traffic flow management and airspace management Brief description of air traffic flow management (ATFM) system and airspace management, including: 1) ATFM structure, service area, service provided, location of unit(s) and hours of operation; 2) types of flow messages and descriptions of the formats; and 3) procedures applicable for departing flights, containing: a) service responsible for provision of information on applied ATFM measures; b) flight plan requirements; and c) slot allocations. 4) information on overall responsibility regarding airspace management within FIR(s), details of civil/military airspace allocation and management coordination, structure of manageable airspace (allocation and changes to allocation) and general operating procedures. ENR 1.10 Flight planning The requirement is to indicate any restriction, limitation or advisory information related to the flight planning stage which may assist the user in the presentation of the intended flight operation, including: 1) procedures for the submission of a flight plan; 2) repetitive flight plan system; and 3) changes to the submitted flight plan. ENR 1.11 Addressing of flight plan messages The requirement is for an indication, in tabular form, of the addresses allocated to flight plans, showing: 1) category of flight (IFR, VFR or both); 2) route (into or via FIR and/or TMA); and 3) message address. ENR 1.12 Interception of civil aircraft The requirement is for a complete statement of interception procedures and visual signals to be used with a clear indication of whether ICAO provisions are applied and, if not, that differences exist. Note.— A list of significant differences between national regulations and practices of the Member State and related ICAO provisions is found in Gen 1.7. ENR 1.13 Unlawful interference The requirement is for presentation of appropriate procedures to be applied in case of unlawful interference. ENR 1.14 Air traffic incidents Description of air traffic incidents reporting system, including: 1) definition of air traffic incidents; 2) use of the “Air Traffic Incident Reporting Form”; 3) reporting procedures (including in-flight procedures); and 4) purpose of reporting and handling of the form. Note.— A copy of the “Air Traffic Incident Report Form” (PANS ATM, Doc 4444, Appendix 4) may be included for reference. ENR 2. AIR TRAFFIC SERVICES AIRSPACE ENR 2.1 FIR, UIR, TMA AND CTA Detailed description of flight information regions (FIR), upper flight information regions (UIR), and control areas (CTA) (including specific CTA such as TMA), including: 1) name, geographical coordinates in degrees and minutes of the FIR/UIR lateral limits and in degrees, minutes and seconds of the CTA lateral limits, vertical limits and class of airspace; 2) identification of unit providing the service; 3) call sign of aeronautical station serving the unit and language(s) used, specifying the area and conditions, when and where to be used, if applicable; 4) frequencies, and if applicable SATVOICE number, supplemented by indications for specific purposes; and 5) remarks. Control zones around military air bases not otherwise described in the AIP must be included in this subsection. Where the requirements of Annex 2 concerning flight plans, two-way communications and position reporting apply to all flights in order to eliminate or reduce the need for interceptions and/or where the possibility of interception exists and the maintenance of guard on the VHF emergency channel 121.5 MHz is required, a statement to this effect must be included for the relevant area(s) or portion(s) thereof. A description of designated areas over which the carriage of an emergency locator transmitter (ELT) is required and where aircraft shall continuously guard the VHF emergency frequency 121.5 MHz, except for those periods when aircraft are carrying out communications on other VHF channels or when airborne equipment limitations or cockpit duties do not permit simultaneous guarding of two channels. Note.— Other types of airspace around civil aerodromes/heliports such as control zones and aerodrome traffic zones are described in the relevant aerodrome or heliport section. ENR 2.2 Other regulated airspace Where established, a detailed description of other types of regulated airspace and airspace classification. ENR 3. ATS ROUTES Note 1.— Bearings, tracks and radials are normally magnetic. In areas of high latitude, where it is determined by the appropriate authority that reference to Magnetic North is impractical, another suitable reference, i.e. True North or Grid North, may be used. Note 2.— Changeover points established at the midpoint between two radio navigation aids, or at the intersection of the two radials in the case of a route which changes direction between the navigation aids, need not be shown for each route segment if a general statement regarding their existence is made. Note 3.— Guidance material on the organisation of ATS Route publication is contained in the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc 8126). ENR 3.1 Lower ATS routes Detailed description of lower ATS routes, including: 1) route designator, designation of the required communication performance (RCP) specification(s), navigation specification(s) and/or required surveillance performance (RSP) specification(s) applicable to a specified segment(s), names, coded designators or name-codes and the geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of all significant points defining the route including “compulsory” or “on-request” reporting points; 2) tracks or VOR radials to the nearest degree, geodesic distance to the nearest tenth of a kilometre or tenth of a nautical mile between each successive designated significant point and, in the case of VOR radials, changeover points; 3) upper and lower limits or minimum en-route altitudes, to the nearest higher 50 m or 100 ft, and airspace classification; 4) lateral limits and minimum obstacle clearance altitudes; 5) direction of cruising levels; 6) the navigation accuracy requirement for each PBN (RNAV or RNP) route segment; and 7) remarks, including an indication of the controlling unit, its operating channel and, if applicable, its logon address, SATVOICE number, and any navigation, RCP and RSP specification(s) limitations. Note.— In relation to Annex 11, Appendix 1, and for flight planning purposes, the defined navigation specification is not considered to be an integral part of the route designator. ENR 3.2 Upper ATS routes Detailed description of upper ATS routes, including: 1) route designator, designation of the required communication performance (RCP) specification(s), navigation specification(s) and/or required surveillance performance (RSP) specification(s) applicable to a specified segment(s), names, coded designators or name-codes and the geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of all significant points defining the route including “compulsory” or “on-request” reporting points; 2) tracks or VOR radials to the nearest degree, geodesic distance to the nearest tenth of a kilometre or tenth of a nautical mile between each successive designated significant point and, in the case of VOR radials, changeover points; 3) upper and lower limits and airspace classification; 4) lateral limits; 5) direction of cruising levels; 6) the navigation accuracy requirement for each PBN (RNAV or RNP) route segment; and 7) remarks, including an indication of the controlling unit, its operating channel and, if applicable, its logon address, SATVOICE number, and any navigation, RCP and RSP specification(s) limitations. Note.— In relation to Annex 11, Appendix 1, and for flight planning purposes, defined navigation specification is not considered to be an integral part of the route designator. ENR 3.3 Area navigation routes Detailed description of PBN (RNAV and RNP) routes, including: 1) route designator, designation of the required communication performance (RCP) specification(s), navigation specification(s) and/or required surveillance performance (RSP) specification(s) applicable to a specified segment(s), names, coded designators or name-codes and the geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of all significant points defining the route including “compulsory” or “on-request” reporting points; 2) in respect of waypoints defining an area navigation route, additionally as applicable: a) station identification of the reference VOR/DME; b) bearing to the nearest degree and the distance to the nearest tenth of a kilometre or tenth of a nautical mile from the reference VOR/DME, if the waypoint is not collocated with it; and c) elevation of the transmitting antenna of DME to the nearest 30 m (100 ft); 3) magnetic bearing to the nearest degree, geodesic distance to the nearest tenth of a kilometre or tenth of a nautical mile between defined end-points and distance between each successive designated significant point; 4) upper and lower limits and airspace classification; 5) direction of cruising levels; 6) the navigation accuracy requirement for each PBN (RNAV or RNP) route segment; and 7) remarks, including an indication of the controlling unit, its operating channel and, if applicable, its logon address, SATVOICE number and any navigation, RCP and RSP specification(s) limitations. Note.— In relation to Annex 11, Appendix 1, and for flight planning purposes, defined navigation specification is not considered to be an integral part of the route designator. ENR 3.4 Helicopter routes Detailed description of helicopter routes, including: 1) route designator, designation of the required communication performance (RCP) specification(s), navigation specification(s) and/or required surveillance performance (RSP) specification(s) applicable to a specified segment(s), names, coded designators or name-codes and the geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of all significant points defining the route including “compulsory” or “on-request” reporting points; 2) tracks or VOR radials to the nearest degree, geodesic distance to the nearest tenth of a kilometre or tenth of a nautical mile between each successive designated significant point and, in the case of VOR radials, changeover points; 3) upper and lower limits and airspace classification; 13/11/14 No. 38 4) minimum flight altitudes to the nearest higher 50 m or 100 ft; 5) the navigation accuracy requirement for each PBN (RNAV or RNP) route segment; and 6) remarks, including an indication of the controlling unit, its operating channel, and, if applicable, its logon address, SATVOICE number, and any navigation, RCP and RSP specification(s) limitations. Note.— In relation to Annex 11, Appendix 1, and for flight planning purposes, defined navigation specification is not considered to be an integral part of the route designator. ENR 3.5 Other routes The requirement is to describe other specifically designated routes which are compulsory within specified area(s). Note.— Arrival, transit and departure routes which are specified in connection with procedures for traffic to and from aerodromes/heliports need not be described since they are described in the relevant section of Part 3 — Aerodromes. ENR 3.6 En-route holding The requirement is for a detailed description of en-route holding procedures, containing: 1) holding identification (if any) and holding fix (navigation aid) or waypoint with geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds; 2) inbound track; 3) direction of the procedure turn; 4) maximum indicated airspeed; 5) minimum and maximum holding level; 6) time/distance outbound; and 7) indication of the controlling unit and its operating frequency. Note.— Obstacle clearance criteria related to holding procedures are contained in Procedures for Air Navigation Services — Aircraft Operations (PANS-OPS, Doc 8168), Volumes I and II. ENR 4. RADIO NAVIGATION AIDS/SYSTEMS ENR 4.1 Radio navigation aids — en-route A list of stations providing radio navigation services established for en-route purposes and arranged alphabetically by name of the station, including: 1) name of the station and magnetic variation to the nearest degree and for VOR, station declination to the nearest degree used for technical line-up of the aid; 2) identification; 3) frequency/channel for each element; 4) hours of operation; 5) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of the position of the transmitting antenna; 6) elevation of the transmitting antenna of DME to the nearest 30 m (100 ft); and 7) remarks. If the operating authority of the facility is other than the designated governmental agency, the name of the operating authority must be indicated in the remarks column. Facility coverage must be indicated in the remarks column. ENR 4.2 Special navigation systems Description of stations associated with special navigation systems (DECCA, LORAN, etc.), including: 1) name of station or chain; 2) type of service available (master signal, slave signal, colour); 3) frequency (channel number, basic pulse rate, recurrence rate, as applicable); 4) hours of operation; 5) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of the position of the transmitting station; and 6) remarks. If the operating authority of the facility is other than the designated governmental agency, the name of the operating authority must be indicated in the remarks column. Facility coverage must be indicated in the remarks column. ENR 4.3 Global navigation satellite system (GNSS) A list and description of elements of the global navigation satellite system (GNSS) providing the navigation service established for en-route purposes and arranged alphabetically by name of the element, including: 1) the name of the GNSS element (GPS, GLONASS, EGNOS, MSAS, WAAS, etc.); 2) frequency(ies), as appropriate; 3) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of the nominal service area and coverage area; and 4) remarks. If the operating authority of the facility is other than the designated governmental agency, the name of the operating authority must be indicated in the remarks column. ENR 4.4 Name-code designators for significant points An alphabetically arranged list of name-code designators (five-letter pronounceable “name-code”) established for significant points at positions not marked by the site of radio navigation aids, including: 1) name-code designator; 2) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of the position; 3) reference to ATS or other routes where the point is located; and 4) remarks, including supplementary definition of positions where required. ENR 4.5 Aeronautical ground lights — en-route A list of aeronautical ground lights and other light beacons designating geographical positions which are selected by the Member State as being significant, including: 1) name of the city or town or other identification of the beacon; 2) type of beacon and intensity of the light in thousands of candelas; 3) characteristics of the signal; 4) operational hours; and 5) remarks. ENR 5. NAVIGATION WARNINGS ENR 5.1 Prohibited, restricted and danger areas Description, supplemented by graphic portrayal where appropriate, of prohibited, restricted and danger areas together with information regarding their establishment and activation, including: 1) identification, name and geographical coordinates of the lateral limits in degrees, minutes and seconds if inside and in degrees and minutes if outside control area/control zone boundaries; 2) upper and lower limits; and 3) remarks, including time of activity. Type of restriction or nature of hazard and risk of interception in the event of penetration must be indicated in the remarks column. ENR 5.2 Military exercise and training areas and air defence identification zone (ADIZ) Description, supplemented by graphic portrayal where appropriate, of established military training areas and military exercises taking place at regular intervals, and established air defence identification zone (ADIZ), including: 1) geographical coordinates of the lateral limits in degrees, minutes and seconds if inside and in degrees and minutes if outside control area/control zone boundaries; 2) upper and lower limits and system and means of activation announcements together with information pertinent to civil flights and applicable ADIZ procedures; and 3) remarks, including time of activity and risk of interception in the event of penetration of ADIZ. ENR 5.3 Other activities of a dangerous nature and other potential hazards ENR 5.3.1 Other activities of a dangerous nature Description, supplemented by charts where appropriate, of activities that constitute a specific or obvious danger to aircraft operation and could affect flights including: 1) geographical coordinates in degrees and minutes of centre of area and range of influence; 2) vertical limits; 3) advisory measures; 4) authority responsible for the provision of information; and 5) remarks, including time of activity. ENR 5.3.2 Other potential hazards Description, supplemented by charts where appropriate, of other potential hazards that could affect flights (e.g. active volcanoes, nuclear power stations, etc.) including: 1) geographical coordinates in degrees and minutes of location of potential hazard; 2) vertical limits; 3) advisory measures; 4) authority responsible for the provision of information; and 5) remarks. ENR 5.4 Air navigation obstacles The list of obstacles affecting air navigation in Area 1 (the entire State territory), including: 1) obstacle identification or designation; 2) type of obstacle; 3) obstacle position, represented by geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds; 4) obstacle elevation and height to the nearest metre or foot; 5) type and colour of obstacle lighting (if any); and 6) if appropriate, an indication that the list of obstacles is available in electronic form, and a reference to GEN 3.1.6. Note 1.— An obstacle whose height above the ground is 100 m and higher is considered an obstacle for Area 1. Note 2.— Specifications governing the determination and reporting (accuracy of field work and data integrity) of positions (latitude and longitude) and elevations/heights for obstacles in Area 1 are given in Annex 11, Appendix 5, Tables 1 and 2, respectively. ENR 5.5 Aerial sporting and recreational activities Brief description, supplemented by graphic portrayal where appropriate, of intensive aerial sporting and recreational activities together with conditions under which they are carried out, including: 1) designation and geographical coordinates of the lateral limits in degrees, minutes and seconds if inside and in degrees and minutes if outside control area/control zone boundaries; 2) vertical limits; 3) operator/user telephone number; and 4) remarks, including time of activity. Note.— This paragraph may be subdivided into different sections for each different category of activity, giving the indicated details in each case. ENR 5.6 Bird migration and areas with sensitive fauna Description, supplemented by charts where practicable, of movements of birds associated with migration, including migration routes and permanent resting areas and areas with sensitive fauna. ENR 6. EN-ROUTE CHARTS The requirement is for the En-route Chart — ICAO and index charts to be included in this section. PART 3 — AERODROMES (AD) If an AIP is produced and made available in more than one volume with each having a separate amendment and supplement service, a separate preface, record of AIP Amendments, record of AIP Supplements, checklist of AIP pages and list of current hand amendments must be included in each volume. In the case of an AIP being published as one volume, the annotation “not applicable” must be entered against each of the above subsections. AD 0.6 Table of contents to Part 3 A list of sections and subsections contained in Part 3 — Aerodromes (AD). Note.— Subsections may be listed alphabetically. AD 1. AERODROMES/HELIPORTS — INTRODUCTION AD 1.1 Aerodrome/heliport availability and conditions of use AD 1.1.1 General conditions Brief description of the Member State’s designated authority responsible for aerodromes and heliports, including: 1) the general conditions under which aerodromes/heliports and associated facilities are available for use; and 2) a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the services are based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed. AD 1.1.2 Use of military air bases Regulations and procedures, if any, concerning civil use of military air bases. AD 1.1.3 Low visibility procedures (LVP) The general conditions under which the low visibility procedures applicable to Cat II/III operations at aerodromes, if any, are applied. AD 1.1.4 Aerodrome operating minima Details of aerodrome operating minima applied by the Member State. AD 1.1.5 Other information If applicable, other information of a similar nature. AD 1.2 Rescue and firefighting services and snow plan AD 1.2.1 Rescue and firefighting services Brief description of rules governing the establishment of rescue and firefighting services at aerodromes/ heliports available for public use together with an indication of rescue and firefighting categories established by a Member State. AD 1.2.2 Snow plan Brief description of general snow plan considerations for aerodromes/heliports available for public use at which snow conditions are normally liable to occur, including: 1) organisation of the winter service; 2) surveillance of movement areas; 3) measuring methods and measurements taken; 4) actions taken to maintain the usability of movement areas; 5) system and means of reporting; 6) the cases of runway closure; and 7) distribution of information about snow conditions. Note.— Where different snow plan considerations apply at aerodromes/heliports, this subparagraph may be subdivided accordingly. AD 1.3 Index to aerodromes and heliports A list, supplemented by graphic portrayal, of aerodromes/heliports within a Member State, including: 1) aerodrome/heliport name and ICAO location indicator; 2) type of traffic permitted to use the aerodrome/heliport (international/national, IFR/VFR, scheduled/non- scheduled, general aviation, military and other); and 3) reference to AIP, Part 3 subsection in which aerodrome/heliport details are presented. AD 1.4 Grouping of aerodromes/heliports Brief description of the criteria applied by the Member State in grouping aerodromes/heliports for production/distribution/provision of information purposes (e.g. international/national; primary/secondary; major/other; civil/military; etc.). AD 1.5 Status of certification of aerodromes A list of aerodromes in the Member State, indicating the status of certification, including: 1) aerodrome name and ICAO location indicator; 2) date and, if applicable, validity of certification; and 3) remarks, if any. AD 2. AERODROMES Note.— **** is to be replaced by the relevant ICAO location indicator. **** AD 2.1 Aerodrome location indicator and name The requirement is for the ICAO location indicator allocated to the aerodrome and the name of aerodrome. An ICAO location indicator must be an integral part of the referencing system applicable to all subsections in section AD 2. **** AD 2.2 Aerodrome geographical and administrative data The requirement is for aerodrome geographical and administrative data including: 1) aerodrome reference point (geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds) and its site; 2) direction and distance of aerodrome reference point from centre of the city or town which the aerodrome serves; 3) aerodrome elevation to the nearest metre or foot, and reference temperature; 4) where appropriate, geoid undulation at the aerodrome elevation position to the nearest metre or foot; 5) magnetic variation to the nearest degree, date of information and annual change; 6) name of aerodrome operator, address, telephone and telefax numbers, e-mail address, AFS address and, if available, website address; 7) types of traffic permitted to use the aerodrome (IFR/VFR); and 8) remarks. **** AD 2.3 Operational hours Detailed description of the hours of operation of services at the aerodrome, including: 1) aerodrome operator; 2) customs and immigration; 3) health and sanitation; 4) AIS briefing office; 5) ATS reporting office (ARO); 6) MET briefing office; 7) ATS; 8) fuelling; 9) handling; 10) security; 11) de-icing; and 12) remarks. **** AD 2.4 Handling services and facilities Detailed description of the handling services and facilities available at the aerodrome, including: 1) cargo-handling facilities; 2) fuel and oil types; 3) fuelling facilities and capacity; 4) de-icing facilities; 5) hangar space for visiting aircraft; 6) repair facilities for visiting aircraft; and 7) remarks. **** AD 2.5 Passenger facilities Passenger facilities available at the aerodrome, provided as a brief description or a reference to other information sources such as a website including: 1) hotel(s) at or in the vicinity of aerodrome; 2) restaurant(s) at or in the vicinity of aerodrome; 3) transportation possibilities; 4) medical facilities; 5) bank and post office at or in the vicinity of aerodrome; 6) tourist office; and 7) remarks. **** AD 2.6 Rescue and firefighting services Detailed description of the rescue and firefighting services and equipment available at the aerodrome, including: 1) aerodrome category for firefighting; 2) rescue equipment; 3) capability for removal of disabled aircraft; and 4) remarks. **** AD 2.7 Seasonal availability — clearing Detailed description of the equipment and operational priorities established for the clearance of aerodrome movement areas, including: 1) type(s) of clearing equipment; 2) clearance priorities; and 3) remarks. **** AD 2.8 Aprons, taxiways and check locations/positions data Details related to the physical characteristics of aprons, taxiways and locations/positions of designated checkpoints, including: 1) designation, surface and strength of aprons; 2) designation, width, surface and strength of taxiways; 3) location and elevation to the nearest metre or foot of altimeter checkpoints; 4) location of VOR checkpoints; 5) position of INS checkpoints in degrees, minutes, seconds and hundredths of seconds; and 6) remarks. If check locations/positions are presented on an aerodrome chart, a note to that effect must be provided under this subsection. **** AD 2.9 Surface movement guidance and control system and markings Brief description of the surface movement guidance and control system and runway and taxiway markings, including: 1) use of aircraft stand identification signs, taxiway guide lines and visual docking/parking guidance system at aircraft stands; 2) runway and taxiway markings and lights; 3) stop bars (if any); and 4) remarks. **** AD 2.10 Aerodrome obstacles Detailed description of obstacles, including: 1) obstacles in Area 2: a) obstacle identification or designation; b) type of obstacle; c) obstacle position, represented by geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and tenths of seconds; d) obstacle elevation and height to the nearest metre or foot; e) obstacle marking, and type and colour of obstacle lighting (if any); f) if appropriate, an indication that the list of obstacles is available in electronic form, and a reference to GEN 3.1.6; and g) NIL indication, if appropriate. Note 1.— Chapter 10, 10.1.1, provides a description of Area 2 while Appendix 8, Figure A8-2, contains graphical illustrations of obstacle data collection surfaces and criteria used to identify obstacles in Area 2. Note 2.— Specifications governing the determination and reporting (accuracy of field work and data integrity) of positions (latitude and longitude) and elevations for obstacles in Area 2 are given in Annex 11, Appendix 5, Tables 1 and 2, and in Annex 14, Volume I, Appendix 5, Tables A5-1 and A5-2, respectively. 2) the absence of an Area 2 data set for the aerodrome is to be clearly stated and obstacle data are to be provided for: a) obstacles that penetrate the obstacle limitation surfaces; b) obstacles that penetrate the take-off flight path area obstacle identification surface; and c) other obstacles assessed as being hazardous to air navigation. 3) indication that information on obstacles in Area 3 is not provided, or if provided: a) obstacle identification or designation; b) type of obstacle; c) obstacle position, represented by geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and tenths of seconds; d) obstacle elevation and height to the nearest tenth of a metre or tenth of a foot; e) obstacle marking, and type and colour of obstacle lighting (if any); f) if appropriate, an indication that the list of obstacles is available in electronic form, and a reference to GEN 3.1.6; and g) NIL indication, if appropriate. Note 1.— Chapter 10, 10.1.1, provides a description of Area 3 while Appendix 8, Figure A8-3, contains graphical illustrations of obstacle data collection surfaces and criteria used to identify obstacles in Area 3. Note 2.— Specifications governing the determination and reporting (accuracy of field work and data integrity) of positions (latitude and longitude) and elevations for obstacles in Area 3 are given in Annex 14, Volume I, Appendix 5, Tables A5-1 and A5-2, respectively. **** AD 2.11 Meteorological information provided Detailed description of meteorological information provided at the aerodrome and an indication of which meteorological office is responsible for the service enumerated, including: 1) name of the associated meteorological office; 2) hours of service and, where applicable, the designation of the responsible meteorological office outside these hours; 3) office responsible for preparation of TAFs and periods of validity and interval of issuance of the forecasts; 4) availability of the TREND forecasts for the aerodrome, and interval of issuance; 5) information on how briefing and/or consultation is provided; 6) types of flight documentation supplied and language(s) used in flight documentation; 7) charts and other information displayed or available for briefing or consultation; 8) supplementary equipment available for providing information on meteorological conditions, e.g. weather radar and receiver for satellite images; 9) the ATS unit(s) provided with meteorological information; and 10) additional information (e.g. concerning any limitation of service, etc.). **** AD 2.12 Runway physical characteristics Detailed description of runway physical characteristics, for each runway, including: 1) designations; 2) true bearings to one-hundredth of a degree; 4) dimensions of runways to the nearest metre or foot; 4) strength of pavement (PCN and associated data) and surface of each runway and associated stopways; 5) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and hundredths of seconds for each threshold and runway end and, where appropriate, geoid undulation of: — thresholds of a non-precision approach runway to the nearest metre or foot; and — thresholds of a precision approach runway to the nearest tenth of a metre or tenth of a foot; 6) elevations of: — thresholds of a non-precision approach runway to the nearest metre or foot; and — thresholds and the highest elevation of the touchdown zone of a precision approach runway to the nearest tenth of a metre or tenth of a foot; 7) slope of each runway and associated stopways; 8) dimensions of stopway (if any) to the nearest metre or foot; 9) dimensions of clearway (if any) to the nearest metre or foot; 10) dimensions of strips; 11) dimensions of runway end safety areas; 12) location (which runway end) and description of arresting system (if any); 13) the existence of an obstacle-free zone; and 14) remarks. **** AD 2.13 Declared distances Detailed description of declared distances to the nearest metre or foot for each direction of each runway, including: 1) runway designator; 2) take-off run available; 3) take-off distance available, and if applicable, alternative reduced declared distances; 4) accelerate-stop distance available; 5) landing distance available; and 6) remarks, including runway entry or start point where alternative reduced declared distances have been declared. If a runway direction cannot be used for take-off or landing, or both, because it is operationally forbidden, then this must be declared and the words “not usable” or the abbreviation “NU” entered. **** AD 2.14 Approach and runway lighting Detailed description of approach and runway lighting, including: 1) runway designator; 2) type, length and intensity of approach lighting system; 3) runway threshold lights, colour and wing bars; 4) type of visual approach slope indicator system; 5) length of runway touchdown zone lights; 6) length, spacing, colour and intensity of runway centre line lights; 7) length, spacing, colour and intensity of runway edge lights; 8) colour of runway end lights and wing bars; 9) length and colour of stopway lights; and 10) remarks. **** AD 2.15 Other lighting, secondary power supply Description of other lighting and secondary power supply, including: 1) location, characteristics and hours of operation of aerodrome beacon/identification beacon (if any); 2) location and lighting (if any) of anemometer/landing direction indicator; 3) taxiway edge and taxiway centre line lights; 4) secondary power supply including switch-over time; and 5) remarks. **** AD 2.16 Helicopter landing area Detailed description of helicopter landing area provided at the aerodrome, including: 1) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and hundredths of seconds and, where appropriate, geoid undulation of the geometric centre of touchdown and lift-off (TLOF) or of each threshold of final approach and take-off (FATO) area: — for non-precision approaches, to the nearest metre or foot; and — for precision approaches, to the nearest tenth of a metre or tenth of a foot; 2) TLOF and/or FATO area elevation: — for non-precision approaches, to the nearest metre or foot; and — for precision approaches, to the nearest tenth of a metre or tenth of a foot; 3) TLOF and FATO area dimensions to the nearest metre or foot, surface type, bearing strength and marking; 4) true bearings to one-hundredth of a degree of FATO; 5) declared distances available, to the nearest metre or foot; 6) approach and FATO lighting; and 7) remarks. **** AD 2.17 Air traffic services airspace Detailed description of ATS airspace organised at the aerodrome, including: 1) airspace designation and geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of the lateral limits; 2) vertical limits; 3) airspace classification; 4) call sign and language(s) of the ATS unit providing service; 5) transition altitude; 6) hours of applicability; and 7) remarks. **** AD 2.18 Air traffic services communication facilities Detailed description of ATS communication facilities established at the aerodrome, including: 1) service designation; 2) call sign; 3) channel(s); 4) SATVOICE number(s), if available; 5) logon address, as appropriate; 6) hours of operation; and 7) remarks. **** AD 2.19 Radio navigation and landing aids Detailed description of radio navigation and landing aids associated with the instrument approach and the terminal area procedures at the aerodrome, including: 1) type of aids, magnetic variation to the nearest degree, as appropriate, and type of supported operation for ILS/MLS, basic GNSS, SBAS, and GBAS and for VOR/ILS/MLS also station declination to the nearest degree used for technical line-up of the aid; 2) identification, if required; 3) frequency(ies), channel number(s), service provider, and reference path identifier(s) (RPI), as appropriate; 4) hours of operation, as appropriate; 5) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and tenths of seconds of the position of the transmitting antenna, as appropriate; 6) elevation of the transmitting antenna of DME to the nearest 30 m (100 ft) and of DME/P to the nearest 3 m (10 ft), elevation of GBAS reference point to the nearest metre or foot, and the ellipsoid height of the point to the nearest metre or foot. For SBAS, the ellipsoid height of the landing threshold point (LTP) or the fictitious threshold point (FTP) to the nearest metre or foot; 7) service volume radius from the GBAS reference point to the nearest kilometre or nautical mile; and 8) remarks. When the same aid is used for both en-route and aerodrome purposes, a description must also be given in section ENR 4. If the ground-based augmentation system (GBAS) serves more than one aerodrome, description of the aid must be provided under each aerodrome. If the operating authority of the facility is other than the designated governmental agency, the name of the operating authority must be indicated in the remarks column. Facility coverage must be indicated in the remarks column. **** AD 2.20 Local aerodrome regulations Detailed description of regulations applicable to the use of the aerodrome including the acceptability of training flights, non-radio and microlight aircraft and similar, and to ground manoeuvring and parking but excluding flight procedures. **** AD 2.21 Noise abatement procedures Detailed description of noise abatement procedures established at the aerodrome. **** AD 2.22 Flight procedures Detailed description of the conditions and flight procedures, including radar and/or ADS-B procedures, established on the basis of airspace organisation at the aerodrome. When established, detailed description of the low visibility procedures at the aerodrome, including: 1) runway(s) and associated equipment authorised for use under low visibility procedures; 2) defined meteorological conditions under which initiation, use and termination of low visibility procedures would be made; 3) description of ground marking/lighting for use under low visibility procedures; and 4) remarks. **** AD 2.23 Additional information Additional information at the aerodrome, such as an indication of bird concentrations at the aerodrome, together with an indication of significant daily movement between resting and feeding areas, to the extent practicable. **** AD 2.24 Aeronautical charts related to an aerodrome The requirement is for aeronautical charts related to an aerodrome to be included in the following order: 1) Aerodrome/Heliport Chart — ICAO; 2) Aircraft Parking/Docking Chart — ICAO; 3) Aerodrome Ground Movement Chart — ICAO; 4) Aerodrome Obstacle Chart — ICAO Type A (for each runway); 5) Aerodrome Terrain and Obstacle Chart — ICAO (Electronic); 6) Precision Approach Terrain Chart — ICAO (precision approach Cat II and III runways); 7) Area Chart — ICAO (departure and transit routes); 8) Standard Departure Chart — Instrument — ICAO; 9) Area Chart — ICAO (arrival and transit routes); 10) Standard Arrival Chart — Instrument — ICAO; 11) ATC Surveillance Minimum Altitude Chart — ICAO; 12) Instrument Approach Chart — ICAO (for each runway and procedure type); 13) Visual Approach Chart — ICAO; and 14) bird concentrations in the vicinity of the aerodrome. If some of the aeronautical charts are not produced, a statement to this effect must be given in section GEN 3.2, Aeronautical charts. Note.— A page pocket may be used in the AIP to include the Aerodrome Terrain and Obstacle Chart — ICAO (Electronic) on appropriate electronic media. AD 3. HELIPORTS When a helicopter landing area is provided at the aerodrome, associated data must be listed only under **** AD 2.16. Note.— **** is to be replaced by the relevant ICAO location indicator. **** AD 3.1 Heliport location indicator and name The requirement is for the ICAO location indicator assigned to the heliport and the name of heliport. An ICAO location indicator must be an integral part of the referencing system applicable to all subsections in section AD 3. **** AD 3.2 Heliport geographical and administrative data The requirement is for heliport geographical and administrative data, including: 1) heliport reference point (geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds) and its site; 2) direction and distance of heliport reference point from centre of the city or town which the heliport serves; 3) heliport elevation to the nearest metre or foot, and reference temperature; 4) where appropriate, geoid undulation at the heliport elevation position to the nearest metre or foot; 5) magnetic variation to the nearest degree, date of information and annual change; 6) name of heliport operator, address, telephone and telefax numbers, e-mail address, AFS address and, if available, website address; 7) types of traffic permitted to use the heliport (IFR/VFR); and 8) remarks. **** AD 3.3 Operational hours Detailed description of the hours of operation of services at the heliport, including: 1) heliport operator; 2) customs and immigration; 3) health and sanitation; 4) AIS briefing office; 5) ATS reporting office (ARO); 6) MET briefing office; 7) ATS; 8) fuelling; 9) handling; 10) security; 11) de-icing; and 12) remarks. **** AD 3.4 Handling services and facilities Detailed description of the handling services and facilities available at the heliport, including: 1) cargo-handling facilities; 2) fuel and oil types; 3) fuelling facilities and capacity; 4) de-icing facilities; 5) hangar space for visiting helicopter; 6) repair facilities for visiting helicopter; and 7) remarks. **** AD 3.5 Passenger facilities Passenger facilities available at the heliport, provided as a brief description or as a reference to other information sources such as a website, including: 1) hotel(s) at or in the vicinity of the heliport; 2) restaurant(s) at or in the vicinity of the heliport; 3) transportation possibilities; 4) medical facilities; 5) bank and post office at or in the vicinity of the heliport; 6) tourist office; and 7) remarks. **** AD 3.6 Rescue and firefighting services Detailed description of the rescue and firefighting services and equipment available at the heliport, including: 1) heliport category for firefighting; 2) rescue equipment; 3) capability for removal of disabled helicopter; and 4) remarks. **** AD 3.7 Seasonal availability — clearing Detailed description of the equipment and operational priorities established for the clearance of heliport movement areas, including: 1) type(s) of clearing equipment; 2) clearance priorities; and 3) remarks. **** AD 3.8 Aprons, taxiways and check locations/positions data Details related to the physical characteristics of aprons, taxiways and locations/positions of designated checkpoints, including: 1) designation, surface and strength of aprons, helicopter stands; 2) designation, width, and surface type of helicopter ground taxiways; 3) width and designation of helicopter air taxiway and air transit route; 4) location and elevation to the nearest metre or foot of altimeter checkpoints; 5) location of VOR checkpoints; 6) position of INS checkpoints in degrees, minutes, seconds and hundredths of seconds; and 7) remarks. If check locations/positions are presented on a heliport chart, a note to that effect must be provided under this subsection. **** AD 3.9 Markings and markers Brief description of final approach and take-off area and taxiway markings and markers, including: 1) final approach and take-off markings; 2) taxiway markings, air taxiway markers and air transit route markers; and 3) remarks. **** AD 3.10 Heliport obstacles Detailed description of obstacles, including: 1) obstacle identification or designation; 2) type of obstacle; 3) obstacle position, represented by geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and tenths of seconds; 4) obstacle elevation and height to the nearest metre or foot; 5) obstacle marking, and type and colour of obstacle lighting (if any); 6) if appropriate, an indication that the list of obstacles is available in electronic form, and a reference to GEN 3.1.6; and 7) NIL indication, if appropriate. **** AD 3.11 Meteorological information provided Detailed description of meteorological information provided at the heliport and an indication of which meteorological office is responsible for the service enumerated, including: 1) name of the associated meteorological office; 2) hours of service and, where applicable, the designation of the responsible meteorological office outside these hours; 3) office responsible for preparation of TAFs, and periods of validity of the forecasts; 4) availability of the TREND forecasts for the heliport, and interval of issuance; 5) information on how briefing and/or consultation is provided; 6) type of flight documentation supplied and language(s) used in flight documentation; 7) charts and other information displayed or available for briefing or consultation; 8) supplementary equipment available for providing information on meteorological conditions, e.g. weather radar and receiver for satellite images; 9) the ATS unit(s) provided with meteorological information; and 10) additional information (e.g. concerning any limitation of service, etc.). **** AD 3.12 Heliport data Detailed description of heliport dimensions and related information, including: 1) heliport type — surface-level, elevated or helideck; 2) touchdown and lift-off (TLOF) area dimensions to the nearest metre or foot; 3) true bearings to one-hundredth of a degree of final approach and take-off (FATO) area; 4) dimensions to the nearest metre or foot of FATO, and surface type; 5) surface and bearing strength in tonnes (1 000 kg) of TLOF; 6) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and hundredths of seconds and, where appropriate, geoid undulation of the geometric centre of TLOF or of each threshold of FATO: — for non-precision approaches, to the nearest metre or foot; and — for precision approaches, to the nearest tenth of a metre or tenth of a foot; 7) TLOF and/or FATO slope and elevation: — for non-precision approaches, to the nearest metre or foot; and — for precision approaches, to the nearest tenth of a metre or tenth of a foot; 8) dimensions of safety area; 9) dimensions, to the nearest metre or foot, of helicopter clearway; 10) the existence of an obstacle-free sector; and 11) remarks. **** AD 3.13 Declared distances Detailed description of declared distances to the nearest metre or foot, where relevant for a heliport, including: 1) take-off distance available, and if applicable, alternative reduced declared distances; 2) rejected take-off distance available; 3) landing distance available; and 4) remarks, including entry or start point where alternative reduced declared distances have been declared. **** AD 3.14 Approach and FATO lighting Detailed description of approach and FATO lighting, including: 1) type, length and intensity of approach lighting system; 2) type of visual approach slope indicator system; 3) characteristics and location of FATO area lights; 4) characteristics and location of aiming point lights; 5) characteristics and location of TLOF lighting system; and 6) remarks. **** AD 3.15 Other lighting, secondary power supply Description of other lighting and secondary power supply, including: 1) location, characteristics and hours of operation of heliport beacon; 2) location and lighting of wind direction indicator (WDI); 3) taxiway edge and taxiway centre line lights; 4) secondary power supply including switch-over time; and 5) remarks. **** AD 3.16 Air traffic services airspace Detailed description of ATS airspace organised at the heliport, including: 1) airspace designation and geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes and seconds of the lateral limits; 2) vertical limits; 3) airspace classification; 4) call sign and language(s) of ATS unit providing service; 5) transition altitude; 6) hours of applicability; and 7) remarks. **** AD 3.17 Air traffic services communication facilities Detailed description of ATS communication facilities established at the heliport, including: 1) service designation; 2) call sign; 3) frequency(ies); 4) hours of operation; and 5) remarks. **** AD 3.18 Radio navigation and landing aids Detailed description of radio navigation and landing aids associated with the instrument approach and the terminal area procedures at the heliport, including: 1) type of aids, magnetic variation (for VOR, station declination used for technical line-up of the aid) to the nearest degree, and type of operation for ILS, MLS, basic GNSS, SBAS and GBAS; 2) identification, if required; 3) frequency(ies), as appropriate; 4) hours of operation, as appropriate; 5) geographical coordinates in degrees, minutes, seconds and tenths of seconds of the position of the transmitting antenna, as appropriate; 6) elevation of the transmitting antenna of DME to the nearest 30 m (100 ft) and of DME/P to the nearest 3 m (10 ft); and 7) remarks. When the same aid is used for both en-route and heliport purposes, a description must also be given in section ENR 4. If the ground-based augmentation system (GBAS) serves more than one heliport, description of the aid must be provided under each heliport. If the operating authority of the facility is other than the designated governmental agency, the name of the operating authority must be indicated in the remarks column. Facility coverage must be indicated in the remarks column. **** AD 3.19 Local heliport regulations Detailed description of regulations applicable to the use of the heliport, including the acceptability of training flights, non-radio and microlight aircraft and similar, and to ground manoeuvring and parking but excluding flight procedures. **** AD 3.20 Noise abatement procedures Detailed description of noise abatement procedures established at the heliport. **** AD 3.21 Flight procedures Detailed description of the conditions and flight procedures, including radar and/or ADS-B procedures, established on the basis of airspace organisation established at the heliport. When established, detailed description of the low visibility procedures at the heliport, including: 1) touchdown and lift-off (TLOF) area(s) and associated equipment authorised for use under low visibility procedures; 2) defined meteorological conditions under which initiation, use and termination of low visibility procedures would be made; 3) description of ground marking/lighting for use under low visibility procedures; and 4) remarks. **** AD 3.22 Additional information Additional information about the heliport, such as an indication of bird concentrations at the heliport together with an indication of significant daily movement between resting and feeding areas, to the extent practicable. **** AD 3.23 Charts related to a heliport The requirement is for aeronautical charts related to a heliport to be included in the following order: 1) Aerodrome/Heliport Chart — ICAO; 2) Area Chart — ICAO (departure and transit routes); 3) Standard Departure Chart — Instrument — ICAO; 4) Area Chart — ICAO (arrival and transit routes); 5) Standard Arrival Chart — Instrument — ICAO; 6) ATC Surveillance Minimum Altitude Chart — ICAO; 7) Instrument Approach Chart — ICAO (for each procedure type); 8) Visual Approach Chart — ICAO; and 9) bird concentrations in the vicinity of heliport. If some of the aeronautical charts are not produced, a statement to this effect must be given in section GEN 3.2, Aeronautical charts. ___________________ European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management RMT.0477 — 27.4.2016 APPENDIX 2 TO ANNEX VI (PART-AIS) AIS.TR.330(a) NOTAM FORMAT Priority Indicator Address ≪≡ Date and time of filing Originator’s Indicator ≪≡( Message Series, Number and Identifier NOTAM containing new information ........................................... NOTAMN (series and number/year) NOTAMN NOTAM replacing a previous NOTAM ........................................... NOTAMR....................................................................................... (series and number/year) NOTAMR (series and number/year of NOTAM to be replaced) NOTAM cancelling a previous NOTAM ........................................... NOTAMC....................................................................................... ≪≡ (series and number/year) NOTAMC (series and number/year of NOTAM to be cancelled) Qualifiers Lower Upper FIR NOTAM Code Traffic Purpose Scope Coordinates, Radius Limit Limit Q) Q ≪≡ Identification of ICAO location indicator in which the facility, airspace A) or condition reported on is located Period of Validity From (date-time group) B) EST* To (PERM or date-time group) C) ≪≡ PERM* Time Schedule (if applicable) D) ≪≡ Text of NOTAM; Plain-language Entry (using ICAO Abbreviations) E) ≪≡ Lower Limit F) Upper Limit G) ) ≪≡ Signature *Delete as appropriate INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE COMPLETION OF THE NOTAM FORMAT 1. General The qualifier line (Item Q) and all identifiers (Items A) to G) inclusive) each followed by a closing parenthesis, as shown in the format, shall be transmitted unless there is no entry to be made against a particular identifier. 2. NOTAM numbering Each NOTAM shall be allocated a series identified by a letter and a four-digit number followed by a stroke and a two-digit number for the year (e.g. A0023/03). Each series shall start on 1 January with number 0001. 3. Qualifiers (Item Q) Item Q) is divided into eight fields, each separated by a stroke. An entry shall be made in each field. Examples of how fields are to be filled are shown in the Aeronautical Information Services Manual (Doc 8126). The definition of the field is as follows: 1) FIR a) If the subject of the information is located geographically within one FIR, the ICAO location indicator shall be that of the FIR concerned. When an aerodrome is situated within the overlying FIR of another State, the first field of Item Q) shall contain the code for that overlying FIR (e.g. Q) LFRR/…A) EGJJ); or, if the subject of the information is located geographically within more than one FIR, the FIR field shall be composed of the ICAO nationality letters of the State originating the NOTAM followed by “XX”. (The location indicator of the overlying UIR shall not be used). The ICAO location indicators of the FIRs concerned shall then be listed in Item A) or indicator of State or non-governmental agency which is responsible for provision of a navigation service in more than one State. b) If one State issues a NOTAM affecting FIRs in a group of States, the first two letters of the ICAO location indicator of the issuing State plus “XX” shall be included. The location indicators of the FIRs concerned shall then be listed in Item A) or indicator of State or non-governmental agency which is responsible for provision of a navigation service in more than one State. 2) NOTAM CODE All NOTAM Code groups contain a total of five letters and the first letter is always the letter Q. The second and third letters identify the subject, and the fourth and fifth letters denote the status or condition of the subject reported upon. The two-letter codes for subjects and conditions are those contained in the PANS-ABC (Doc 8400). For combinations of second and third, and fourth and fifth letters, refer to the NOTAM Selection Criteria contained in Doc 8126 or insert one of the following combinations, as appropriate: a) If the subject is not listed in the NOTAM Code (Doc 8400) or in the NOTAM Selection Criteria (Doc 8126), insert “XX” as the second and third letters (e.g. QXXAK); b) If the condition of the subject is not listed in the NOTAM Code (Doc 8400) or in the NOTAM Selection Criteria (Doc 8126), insert “XX” as the fourth and fifth letters (e.g. QFAXX); c) When a NOTAM containing operationally significant information is issued in accordance with Appendix 4 and Chapter 6 and when it is used to announce the existence of AIRAC AIP Amendments or Supplements, insert “TT” as the fourth and fifth letters of the NOTAM Code; d) When a NOTAM is issued containing a checklist of valid NOTAM, insert “KKKK” as the second, third, fourth and fifth letters; and e) The following fourth and fifth letters of the NOTAM Code shall be used in NOTAM cancellations: AK = RESUMED NORMAL OPERATION AL = OPERATIVE (OR RE-OPERATIVE) SUBJECT TO PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED LIMITATIONS/CONDITIONS AO = OPERATIONAL CC = COMPLETED CN = CANCELLED HV = WORK COMPLETED XX = PLAIN LANGUAGE Note 1.— As Q - - AO = Operational is used for NOTAM cancellation, NOTAM promulgating new equipment or services use the following fourth and fifth letters Q - - CS = Installed. Note 2.— Q - - CN = CANCELLED shall be used to cancel planned activities, e.g. navigation warnings; Q - - HV = WORK COMPLETED is used to cancel work in progress. 3) TRAFFIC I = IFR V = VFR K = NOTAM is a checklist Note.— Depending on the NOTAM subject and content, the qualifier field TRAFFIC may contain combined qualifiers. Guidance concerning the combination of TRAFFIC qualifiers with subject and conditions in accordance with the NOTAM Selection Criteria is contained in Doc 8126. 4) PURPOSE N = NOTAM selected for the immediate attention of flight crew members B = NOTAM of operational significance selected for PIB entry O = NOTAM concerning flight operations M = Miscellaneous NOTAM; not subject for a briefing, but it is available on request K = NOTAM is a checklist Note.— Depending on the NOTAM subject and content, the qualifier field PURPOSE may contain the combined qualifiers BO or NBO. Guidance concerning the combination of PURPOSE qualifiers with subject and conditions in accordance with the NOTAM Selection Criteria is contained in Doc 8126. 5) SCOPE A = Aerodrome E = En-route W = Nav Warning K = NOTAM is a checklist Note.— Depending on the NOTAM subject and content, the qualifier field SCOPE may contain combined qualifiers. Guidance concerning the combination of SCOPE qualifiers with subject and conditions in accordance with the NOTAM Selection Criteria is contained in Doc 8126. If the subject is qualified AE, the aerodrome location indicator must be reported in Item A). 6) and 7) LOWER/UPPER LOWER and UPPER limits shall only be expressed in flight levels (FL) and shall express the actual vertical limits of the area of influence without the addition of buffers. In the case of navigation warnings and airspace restrictions, values entered shall be consistent with those provided under Items F) and G). If the subject does not contain specific height information, insert “000” for LOWER and “999” for UPPER as default values. 8) COORDINATES, RADIUS The latitude and longitude accurate to one minute, as well as a three-digit distance figure giving the radius of influence in NM (e.g. 4700N01140E043). Coordinates present approximate centre of circle whose radius encompasses the whole area of influence, and if the NOTAM affects the entire FIR/UIR or more than one FIR/UIR, enter the default value “999” for radius. 4. Item A) Insert the ICAO location indicator as contained in ICAO Doc 7910 of the aerodrome or FIR in which the facility, airspace, or condition being reported on is located. More than one FIR/UIR may be indicated when appropriate. If there is no available ICAO location indicator, use the ICAO nationality letter as given in ICAO Doc 7910, Part 2, plus “XX” and followed up in Item E) by the name, in plain language. If information concerns GNSS, insert the appropriate ICAO location indicator allocated for a GNSS element or the common location indicator allocated for all elements of GNSS (except GBAS). Note.— In the case of GNSS, the location indicator may be used when identifying a GNSS element outage (e.g. KNMH for a GPS satellite outage). 5. Item B) For date-time group use a ten-figure group, giving year, month, day, hours and minutes in UTC. This entry is the date-time at which the NOTAMN comes into force. In the cases of NOTAMR and NOTAMC, the date-time group is the actual date and time of the NOTAM origination. The start of a day shall be indicated by “0000”. 6. Item C) With the exception of NOTAMC, a date-time group (a ten-figure group giving year, month, day, hours and minutes in UTC) indicating duration of information shall be used unless the information is of a permanent nature in which case the abbreviation “PERM” is inserted instead. The end of a day shall be indicated by “2359” (i.e. do not use “2400”). If the information on timing is uncertain, the approximate duration shall be indicated using a date-time group followed by the abbreviation “EST”. Any NOTAM which includes an “EST” shall be cancelled or replaced before the date-time specified in Item C). 7. Item D) If the hazard, status of operation or condition of facilities being reported on will be active in accordance with a specific time and date schedule between the dates-times indicated in Items B) and C), insert such information under Item D). If Item D) exceeds 200 characters, consideration shall be given to providing such information in a separate, consecutive NOTAM. Note.— Guidance concerning a harmonized definition of Item D) content is provided in Doc 8126. 8. Item E) Use decoded NOTAM Code, complemented where necessary by ICAO abbreviations, indicators, identifiers, designators, call signs, frequencies, figures and plain language. When NOTAM is selected for international distribution, English text shall be included for those parts expressed in plain language. This entry shall be clear and concise in order to provide a suitable PIB entry. In the case of NOTAMC, a subject reference and status message shall be included to enable accurate plausibility checks. 9. Items F) and G) These items are normally applicable to navigation warnings or airspace restrictions and are usually part of the PIB entry. Insert both lower and upper height limits of activities or restrictions, clearly indicating only one reference datum and unit of measurement. The abbreviations GND or SFC shall be used in Item F) to designate ground and surface respectively. The abbreviation UNL shall be used in Item G) to designate unlimited. Note.— For NOTAM examples see Doc 8126 and the PANS-ABC (Doc 8400). ______________________ European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Technical requirements and operational procedures for aeronautical information services and aeronautical information management RMT.0477 — 27.4.2016 Appendix 1 to Annex III (ATM/ANS.OR) of ‘Regulation (EU) .../…’ laying down common requirements for service providers and the oversight in air traffic management and air navigation services and other air traffic management network functions AERONAUTICAL DATA CATALOGUE European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Introduction (a) The Data Catalogue is a reference of the aeronautical data subjects, properties and sub-properties organized in: 1. Aerodrome data; 2. Airspace data; 3. ATS and other routes data; 4. Instrument flight procedure data; 5. Radio navigation aids/systems data; 6. Obstacle data; and 7. Geographic data. (b) The tables of the Data Catalogue are composed of the following columns: (1) Subject for which data can be collected; (2) & (3) Property: an identifiable characteristic of a subject which can be further defined into sub-properties; (4) Types: the data is classified in different types; (5) Description: a description of the data element; (6) Notes: containing additional information or conditions of the provision; (7) Accuracy: requirements for aeronautical data, are based upon a 95 per cent confidence level; (8) Integrity classification; (9) Origination type: positional data is identified as surveyed, calculated or declared; (10) Publication resolution; (11) Chart resolution. Note for (2) & (3): the classification of a catalogue element as subject, property or sub-property does not impose a certain data model; European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Note for (7): for those fixes and points that are serving a dual purpose, e.g. holding point and missed approach point, the higher accuracy applies. Accuracy requirements for obstacle and terrain data are based upon a 90 per cent confidence level. Note for (10): the publication resolutions for geographical position data (latitude and longitude) are applicable to coordinates formatted in degrees, minutes, seconds. When a different format is used (such as degrees with decimals for digital data sets) or when the location is significantly further to the North/South, the publication resolution needs to be commensurate with the accuracy requirements. 1. Aerodrome data Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accurac Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart y Res. Aerodrome / A defined area on land or water (including any Heliport buildings, installations and equipment) intended to be used either wholly or in part for the arrival, departure and surface movement of aircraft. Designator Designator of the aerodrome / heliport ICAO location Text The four letter ICAO location indicator of the if any indicator aerodrome/heliport, as listed in ICAO DOC 7910 (Location Indicators). Designator IATA Text The identifier that is assigned to a location in if any accordance with rules (resolution 767) governed by the International Air Transport Association (IATA). Other Text A locally defined airport identifier, if other than an ICAO Location Indicator Name Text The primary official name of an aerodrome as designated by an appropriate authority. Served city Text The full name ( free text) of the city or town the aerodrome/heliport is serving European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accurac Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart y Res. Type of traffic permitted International_national Code list Indication if international and/or national flights are permitted at the aerodrome/heliport IFR_VFR Code list Indication if IFR and/or VFR flights are permitted at the aerodrome/heliport Sched_nonsched Code list Indication if scheduled and/or nonscheduled flights are permitted at the aerodrome/heliport Civil_military Code list Indication if civil commercial aviation and/or general aviation and/or military flights are permitted at the aerodrome/heliport Restricted_use Text Indication if an aerodrome or heliport not open for the public (Only for the use of the owners). Heliport type Text The type of the heliport as mention in Annex 14 Volume II (Surface-level, elevated, shipboard or helideck) Control type Text Indication if an aerodrome is under civil control, military control or joint control Certified ICAO Text Indication if airport is/is not certified according to the ICAO rules Certification date Date The date when the airport certification has been issued by the supervising authority. Certification Date The date when the airport certification will become expiration date invalid. Field elevation Elevation Elevation The vertical distance above Mean Sea Level 0.5 m essential surveyed 1m or 1 ft 1 m or 1 (MSL) of the highest point of the landing area. ft Geoid undulation Height Geoid undulation at the aerodrome/ heliport where 0.5 m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1 m or 1 elevation position appropriate ft European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accurac Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart y Res. Reference Value The monthly mean of the daily maximum temperature temperatures for the hottest month of the year at an aerodrome. This temperature should be averaged over a period of years. (ICAO recommendation) Mean low Value The mean lowest temperature of the coldest month 5 degrees temperature of the year, for the last five years of data at the aerodrome elevation. Magnetic The angular difference between True North and variation Magnetic North. Angle Angle The magnetic variation angle value 1 degree essential surveyed 1 degree 1 degree Date Date The date on which the magnetic variation had the coresponding value. Annual change Value The annual rate of change of the magnetic variation. Reference point The designated geographical location of an aerodrome. Position Point Geographical location of aerodrome reference 30 m routine surveyed/ 1 sec 1 sec point. calculated Site Text The location of the reference point on the aerodrome. Direction Text Direction of aerodrome reference point from centre of the city or town which the aerodrome serves Distance Distance Distance of aerodrome reference point from centre of the city or town which the aerodrome serves Landing direction A device to indicate visually the direction currently indicator designated for landing and for take-off. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accurac Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart y Res. Location Text Location of landing direction indicator Lighting Text Lighting of landing direction indicator if any Secondary Power Supply Characteristics Text The description of the secondary power supply Switch-over time Value Secondary power supply switch-over time Anemometer Device used for measuring wind speed Location Text Location of anemometer Lighting Text Lighting of anemometer if any ABN / IBN Aerodrome beacon / identification beacon used to indicate the location of an aerodrome from the air. Location Text Location of aerodrome beacon/identification if any beacon Characteristics Text Description of aerodrome beacon/identification beacon European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accurac Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart y Res. Hours of Schedule Hours of operation of aerodrome operation beacon/identification beacon Wind Direction Indicator Location Text Location of Wind direction indicator Lighting Text Lighting of Wind direction indicator RVR observation The observation site of Runway Visual Range. site Position Point Geographical location of runway visual range (RVR) observation sites Frequency Area Designated part of a surface movement area where a specific frequency is required by air traffic control or ground control. Station Text Name of the station providing the service Frequency Value Frequency of the station providing the service Boundary Polygon Area boundary of the frequency area Hot spot A location on an aerodrome movement area with a history or potential risk of collision or runway incursion, and where heightened attention by pilots/drivers is necessary. Identifier Text The indentifier of the hot spot Annotation Text Additional information about the hot spot Geometry Polygon The geographical area of the hot spot European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Runway A defined rectangular area on a land aerodrome prepared for the landing and take-off of aircraft. (Annex 14) Designator Text The full textual designator of the runway, used to uniquely identify it at an aerodrome/heliport. E.g. 09/27, 02R/20L, RWY 1. Nominal length Distanc The declared longitudinal extent of the runway for 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e operational (performance) calculations. Nominal width Distanc The declared transversal extent of the runway for 1m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e operational (performance) calculations. Geometry Polygon Geometries of RunwayElement, RunwayDisplacedArea and RunwayIntersection Centre line points Position Point The geographical location of runway centre line at Definition 1m critical surveyed each end of the runway, at the stopway and at the from origin of each take-off flight path area, and at each Annex 4 significant change in slope of runway and stopway 3.8.4.2 Elevation Elevatio The elevation of the corresponding centre line point. 0.25m critical surveyed n (See Annex 14 I 2.3.2: ---- for non-precision approaches … any significant high and low intermediate points along the runway shall be measured to the accuracy of one-half metre or foot…) Geoid undulation Height The geoid undulation at the correspoding centre line point RWY exit line Exit guidance line Line The geographical location of the runway exit line 0.5m essential surveyed 1/100 sec 1 sec Colour Text Colour of runway exit line Style Text Style of runway exit line Directionality Code Directionality of RWY exit line (one-way or two-way) List Surface type Text The surface type of the runway defined as specified in Annex 14 Volume I European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Strength PCN Text Pavement classification number Pavement type Text Pavement type for aircraft classification number — pavement classification number (ACN-PCN) determination Subgrade category Text Subgrade strength category Allowable pressure Text Maximum allowable tire pressure category or maximum allowable tire pressure value Evaluation method Text The evaluation method used Strip A defined area including the runway and the stop- way if provided a) to reduce the risk of damage to aircraft running off a runway; and b) to protect aircraft flying over it during take-off or landing operations Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of the runway strip. e Width Distanc The transversal extent of the runway strip e Surface type Text The surface type of the runway strip Shoulder An area adjacent to the edge of a pavement so prepared as to provide a transition between the pavement and the adjacent surface. Geometry Polygon The geographical location of the shoulders Surface type Text The surface type of the shoulder Width Distanc The width of the runway shoulder 1m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft e Blastpad Specially prepared surface placed adjacent to the end of a runway to eliminate the erosive effect of the high wind forces produced by airplanes at the beginning of their take-off roll. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Geometry Polygon The geographical location of the blastpad Obstacle free Text Existence of an obstacle-free zone for a precision when zone approach runway category I provided RWYmarking Type Text Type of runway marking Description Text Description of the runway markings Geometry Polygon The geographical location of the runway marking RWY center line LGT Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of the runway centre line e lights Spacing Distanc Spacing of runway centre line lights e Colour Text Colour of runway centre line lights Intensity Text Intensity of runway centre line lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the runway center line lights RWY Edge LGT Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of the runway edge lights e Spacing Distanc Spacing of the runway edge lights e Colour Text Colour of runway edge lights European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Intensity Text Intensity of runway edge lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the runway edge lights Reference Code The intent of the reference code is to provide a simple method for interrelating the numerous specifications concerning the characteristics of aerodromes so as to provide a series of aerodrome facilities that are suitable for the aeroplanes that are intended to operate at the aerodrome Number Code A number based on the aeroplane reference field list length Letter Code A letter based on the aeroplane wingspan and outer list main gear wheel span Restriction Text Description of restrictions imposed on runway Runway Direction Designator Text The full textual designator of the landing and take- off direction. Examples: 27, 35L, 01R. True bearing Bearing The true bearing of the runway. 1/100 deg Routine surveyed 1/100 1 degree degree Type Text Type of runway: precision (CAT I, II, III) / non- precision / non-instrument Threshold The beginning of that portion of the runway usable for landing. Position Point Geographical location for runway threshold 1m critical surveyed 1/100 sec 1 sec Elevation Elevatio Elevation of the runway threshold n See Note 1) Geoid undulation Height WGS-84 Geoid undulation at runway threshold position See Note 2) Type Text The indication if the threshold is displaced/ not displaced. A displaced threshold is not located at the extremity of a runway. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Displacement Distanc Distance of displaced threshold If 1m routine surveyed e displaced threshold Runway end Runway end (flight path alignment point) Position Point Location of the runway end in the direction of 1m critical surveyed 1/100 sec 1 sec departure Elevation Elevatio Elevation of the end postion of the runway see RWY n centre line points Departure end of Departure end of the runway (DER), which is the Beginning runway end of the area declared suitable for take-off (i.e. of the end of the runway or, where a clearway is departure provided, the end of the clearway). procedure Position Point Geographical location of DER Elevation Elevatio The elevation of DER is the elevation of the end of n the runway or the elevation of the end of the clearway, whichever is higher. Touchdown zone The portion of a runway, beyond the threshold, where it is intended landing aeroplanes first contact the runway. Elevation Elevatio Highest elevation of the touchdown zone of a precision 0.25 m or n precision approach runway approach 0.25 ft RWY Slope Value The slope of the runway touchdown zone Slope Value Slope of the runway LAHSO Land and Hold Short Operations Geometry Line Geographical location of Land and Hold Short Operations (LAHSO) Protected element Text Name of runway or taxiway being protected Displaced area That portion of a runway between the beginning of the runway and the displaced threshold. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the displaced area PCN Text Pavement classification number of the displaced area Surface type Text The surface type of the displaced area Aircraft restriction Text Usage restriction for specific aircraft type Stopway A defined rectangular area on the ground at the end of take-off run available prepared as a suitable area in which an aircraft can be stopped in the case of an abandoned take-off. Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of stopway if any 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e Width Distanc Width of the stopway 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the stopway Slope Value Slope of stopway Surface type Text The surface type of the stopway Clearway A defined rectangular area on the ground or water under the control of the appropriate authority, selected or prepared as a suitable area over which an aeroplane may make a portion of its initial climb to a specified height. Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of the clearway 1m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft e Width Distanc The transversal extent of the clearway 1m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft e Ground profile The vertical profile (or slope) of the clearway if any European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. RESA An area symmetrical about the extended runway centre line and adjacent to the end of the strip primarily intended to reduce the risk of damage to an aeroplane undershooting or overrunning the runway. Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of Runway End Safety Area e Width Distanc The transversal extent of the Runway End Safety e Area Longitudinal slope Value Longitudinal slope of Runway End Safety Area Transverse slope Value Tranverse slope Runway End Safety Area Declared distances TORA Distanc Take-off run available - The length of runway 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e declared available and suitable for the ground run of an aeroplane taking off. TODA Distanc Take-off distance available - The length of the take- 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e off run available plus the length of the clearway, if provided. ASDA Distanc Accelerate-stop distance available - The length of 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e the take-off run available plus the length of the stopway, if provided. LDA Distanc Landing distance available - The length of runway 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m e which is declared available and suitable for the ground run of an aeroplane landing. Remarks Text Remarks including runway entry or start point where alternative reduced declared distances have been declared RWY End LGT Colour Text Colour of runway end lights European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the runway end lights SWY LGT Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of stopway lights e Colour Text Colour of stopway lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the stopway lights Approach lighting system Type Text Classification of the approach lighting system using as criteria the ICAO Annex 14 standards Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of approach lighting system. e Intensity Text A code indicating the relative intensity of the lighting system. Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the approach lighting system RWY threshold lights Colour Text Colour of runway threshold lights Wing bar color Text Colour of runway threshold wing bars Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the threshold and wing bar lights Touchdown zone lights Lenght Distanc The longitudinal extent of the runway touchdown e zone lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the touchdown zone lights European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Visual approach slope indicator system MEHT Height Minimum Eye Height over the Threshold Location Point Geographical location of Visual approach slope indicator system Angle Angle Nominal approach slope angle(s) Type Text Type of VGSI (VASI, PAPI etc.) Displacement angle Angle Where the axis of the system is not parallel to the runway centre line, the angle of displacement and the direction of displacement, i.e. left or right Displacement Text Where the axis of the system is not parallel to the direction runway centre line, the angle of displacement and the direction of displacement, i.e. left or right Arresting gear Line Geographical location of the aresting gear cable across the runway Arresting system High energy absorbing material located at the end of a runway or stopway designed to crush under the weight of an aircraft as the material exerts deceleration forces on the aircraft landing gear. Geometry Polygon The geographical location of the arresting system Setback Distanc Setback of the arresting system e Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of arresting system e Width Distanc The transverse extent of arresting system e Radio altimeter area Length Distanc The longitudinal extent of radio altimeter area e Width Distanc The transverse extent of radio altimeter area e Geometry Polygon Geographical location of radio altimeter area European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Note 1) Threshold elevation for runways with non-precision 0.5m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1 m or 1 approaches ft Threshold elevation for runways with precision 0.25m critical surveyed 0.1 m or 0.5 m or approaches 0.1 ft 1 ft Note 2) WGS-84 geoid undulation at runway threshold, non- 0.5m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1 m or 1 precision approaches ft WGS-84 geoid undulation at runway threshold, 0.25m critical surveyed 0.1 m or 0.5 m or precision approaches 0.1 ft 1 ft Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. FATO Final approach and take-off area. A defined area over which the final phase of the approach manoeuvre to hover or landing is completed and from which the take-off manoeuvre is commenced. Where the FATO is to be used by helicopters operated in performance class 1, the defined area includes the rejected take- off area available. Threshold point The beginning of that portion of the FATO usable for landing. Position Point Geographical location of FATO threshold point 1m critical surveyed 1/100 sec 1 sec Elevation Elevation Elevation of the FATO threshold See Note 1) Geoid undulation Height WGS-84 Geoid undulation at FATO threshold position See Note 2) Departure end of Departure end of the runway (DER), which is the end runway of the area declared suitable for take-off (i.e. the end of the runway or, where a clearway is provided, the end of the clearway or the end of the final approach and take-off (FATO) area). Position Point Geographical location of DER 1m critical surveyed 1/100 sec 1 sec European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Elevation Elevation The elevation of the DER is the higher of the elevations of the beginning and end of the runway/FATO. Type Text Type of FATO according to ICAO Heliport Manual (Doc 9261) Designation Text The full textual designator of the landing and take-off area. Length Distance The longitudinal extent of FATO 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m Width Distance The transversal extent of FATO Geometry Polygon Geographical location of FATO element Slope Value The slope of FATO Surface type Text The surface type of FATO True bearing Bearing The true bearing of the runway 1/100 deg routine surveyed 1/100 degree Declared distances TODAH Distance Take-off distance available - The length of the FATO and if 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft plus the length of helicopter clearway (if provided) applicable, alternative reduced declared distances; RTODAH Distance Rejected Take-off distance available - The length of 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft the FATO declared available and suitable for helicopters operated in performance class 1 to complete a rejected take-off. LDAH Distance Landing distance available - The length of the FATO 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft plus any additional area declared available and suitable for helicopters to complete the landing manoeuvre from a defined height. Remarks Text Remarks including entry or start point where alternative reduced declared distances have been declared European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. FATO marking Description Text Description of FATO markings Approach lighting system Type Text Classification of the approach lighting system using as criteria the ICAO Annex 14 standards Length Distance The longitudinal extent of approach lighting system. Intensity Text A code indicating the relative intensity of the lighting system. Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the approach lighting system Area lights Description Text Description of area lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the area lights Aiming point lights Description Text Description of aiming point lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the aiming point lights TLOF Touchdown and lift-off area. An area on which a helicopter may touch down or lift off. Designator Text The full textual designator of TLOF Centre point Position Point Geographical location of TLOF threshold point 1m critical surveyed 1/100 sec 1 sec European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Elevation Elevation Elevation of the TLOF threshold See Note 1) Geoid undulation Height WGS-84 Geoid undulation TLOF centre point position See Note 2) Length Distance The longitudinal extent of TLOF 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m Width Distance The transversal extent of TLOF 1m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1m Geometry Polygon Geographical location of TLOF element Slope Value The slope of TLOF Surface type Text The surface type of TLOF Bearing strength Value The bearing strength of TLOF 1 tone Visual approach Text Type of visual approach slope indicator system slope indicator system type Marking Description Text Description of TLOF markings Safety area A defined area on a heliport surrounding the FATO which is free of obstacles, other than those required for air navigation purposes, and intended to reduce the risk of damage to helicopters accidentally diverging from the FATO. Length Distance The longitudinal extent of safety area Width Distance The transversal extent of safety area Surface type Text The surface type of safety area European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Helicopter clearway A defined area on the ground or water, selected and/or prepared as a suitable area over which a helicopter operated in performance class 1 may accelerate and achieve a specific height. Length Distance The longitudinal extent of the helicopter clearway Ground profile Value Vertical profile (or slope) of helicopter clearway Note 1) FATO threshold, for heliports with or without a PinS 0.5m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft approach FATO threshold, for heliports intended to be operated 0.25m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft in accordance with ICAO Annex 14, Appendix 2 (non- precision) 0.1 m or 0.1 ft (precision) Note 2) WGS–84 geoid undulation at FATO threshold, TLOF 0.5m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft geometric centre, for heliports with or without a PinS approach WGS–84 geoid undulation at FATO threshold, TLOF 0.25m critical surveyed 1 m or 1 ft geometric centre, for heliports intended to be (non- operated in accordance with ICAO Annex 14, precision) Appendix 2 0.1 m or 0.1 ft (precision) Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Apron A defined area, on a land aerodrome, intended to accommodate aircraft for purposes of loading or unloading passengers, mail or cargo, fuelling, parking or maintenance. Designator Text The full textual name or designator used to identify an apron at an aerodrome/heliport. Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the apron element 1m routine surveye 1/10 sec 1 sec d Type Text Classification of the primary use for the apron European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Aircraft Text Usage restriction (prohibition) for specified aircraft type restriction Surface type Text The surface type of the apron Strength PCN Text Pavement classification number of apron Pavement type Text Pavement type for aircraft classification number — pavement classification number (ACN-PCN) determination Subgrade Text Subgrade strength category of apron category Allowable Text Maximum allowable tire pressure category or maximum pressure allowable tire pressure value Evaluation Text The evaluation method used to determine the apron method strength Elevation Elevation The elevation of the apron Taxiway A defined path on a land aerodrome established for the taxiing of aircraft and intended to provide a link between one part of the aerodrome and another, Designator Text The full textual designator of the taxiway. Width Distance The transversal extent of the taxiway. 1m essential surveye 1 m or 1 ft d Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the taxiway element Bridge Text Type of bridge (none, overpass, underpass) Surface type Text Surface type of taxiway Strength European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. PCN Text Pavement classification number of taxiway Pavement type Text Pavement type for aircraft classification number — pavement classification number (ACN-PCN) determination Subgrade Text Subgrade strength category of taxiway category Allowable Text Maximum allowable tire pressure category or maximum pressure allowable tire pressure value Evaluation Text The evaluation method used to determine the taxiway method strength Aircraft Text Usage restriction (prohibition) for specified aircraft type restrictions Reference code Code list A letter based on the aeroplane wingspan and outer main letter gear wheel span Center line points Position Point Geographical coordinates of taxiway center line points 0.5m essential surveye 1/100 sec 1/100 d sec Elevation Elevation Elevation of taxiway center line points 1m essential surveye d Shoulder An area adjacent to the edge of a pavement so prepared as to provide a transition between the pavement and the adjacent surface. Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the taxiway shoulder Surface type Text Surface type of taxiway shoulder Width Distance The width of the taxiway shoulder 1m essential surveye 1 m or 1 ft d Guidance lines Geometry Line Geoghraphical location of guidance lines 0.5 m essential surveye 1/100 sec 1/100 d sec Colour Text Colour of taxiway guidance lines European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Style Text Style of taxiway guidance lines Wingspan Value Wingspan Maxspeed Value Maximum speed Direction Text Direction Intermediate Line Intermediate holding position marking line 0.5 m essential surveye 1/100 sec 1 sec holding position d marking line Taxiway marking Description Text Description of taxiway marking Taxiway edge lights Description Text Description of taxiway edge lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the taxiway edge lights Taxiway centre line lights Description Text Description of taxiway centre line lights Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the taxiway center line lights Stop bars Description Text Description of the stop bars if any Location Line Location of the stop bar Runway guard lights Description Text Description of the runway guard lights and other runway if any protection measures Location Point Location of the stop bar Configu ration A European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Location Line Location of the stop bar Configu ration B Runway holding A designated position intended to protect a runway, an position obstacle limitation surface, or an ILS/ MLS critical/sensitive area at which taxiing aircraft and vehicles shall stop and hold, unless otherwise authorized by the aerodrome control tower. Geometry Line Geoghraphical location of runwany holding position n 0.5m essential surveye 1/100 sec 1 sec d Protected Text Designator of the runway protected runway Catstop Code list CAT of runway (0, I, II, III) RWY ahead text Text Actual text as it exists in the marking. For example, RWY AHEAD or RUNWAY AHEAD. Intermediate Geometry Line Geographical location of intermediate holding position - A holding position designated position intended for traffic control at which taxiing aircraft and vehicles shall stop and hold until further cleared to proceed, when so instructed by the aerodrome control tower. Helicopter ground A ground taxiway intended for the ground movement of taxiway wheeled undercarriage helicopters. (Annex 14) Designator Text The full textual designator of helicopter ground taxiway Center line Point Geographical location of helicopter ground center line 0.5m essential surveye points taxiway points d/ calculat ed Elevation Elevation Elevantion of helicopter ground taxiway 1m essential surveye d Width Distance The transversal extent of the helicopter ground taxiway 1m essential surveye d Surface type Text The surface type of the helicopter ground taxiway European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Intersection Line Helicopter ground taxiway intersection marking line 0.5 m essential surveye 1/100 sec 1 sec marking line d Lighting Description Text Description of helicopter ground taxiway light Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the helicopter ground taxiway lights Marking Description Text Description of helicopter ground taxiway marking Helicopter air A defined path on the surface established for the air taxiing taxiway of helicopters. (Annex 14) Designator The full textual designator of helicopter air taxiway Center line Point Geographical location of helicopter air taxiway center line 0.5m essential surveye points points d/ calculat ed Elevation Elevation Elevation of helicopter air taxiway 1m essential surveye d Width Distance The transversal extent of the helicopter air taxiway 1m essential surveye d Surface type Text Surface type of helicopter air taxiway Lighting Description Text Description of helicopter air taxiway lighting Position Point Geographical location of each individual light of the helicopter air taxiway lights Marking Description Text Description of helicopter air taxiway marking Helicopter air A defined path established for the movement of helicopters transit routes from one part of a heliport to another. A taxi-route includes a helicopter air or ground taxiway which is centred on the taxi-route. Designator Text Designator of helicopter air transit route Geometry Line Geographical location of helicopter air transit route European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Width Distance The transversal extent of the helicopter air transit route 1m essential Surveye d INS checkpoint Location Point Geographical location of the INS check point where 0.5m routine surveye 1/100 sec 1/100 availabl d sec e VOR checkpoint Location Point Geographical location of the VOR check point where availabl e Frequency Value Frequency of the VOR check point Altimeter checkpoint Location Point Geographical location of altimeter checkpoints Elevation Elevation Elevation of altimeter checkpoints Aircraft stand A designated area on an apron intended to be used for parking an aircraft Name Text Name of the aircraft stand point Acft stand points Location Point Geographical location of aircraft stand point 0.5m routine surveye 1/100 sec 1/100 d sec Aircraft types Code list Aircraft types Identification Text Description of aircraft stand identification sign sign Visual docking Text Description of visual docking/parking guidance system at parking guidance the aircraft stand system Parking stand Polygon Geographical location of parking stand area area Jetway Code list Jetway available at aircraft stand Fuel Code list Fuel available at aircraft stand Ground power Code list Ground power available at aircraft stand European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Towing Code list Towing available at aicraft stand Terminal Text Terminal building reference Surface type Text Surface type of the aircraft stand Aircraft Text Usage restriction (prohibition) for specified aircraft type restriction PCN Text Pavement classification number of aircraft stand Stand guidance line Geometry Line Geographical location of stand guidance line 0.5m essential surveye d 1/100 sec Elevation Elevation Parking guidance line points elevation 1m essential surveye d Direction Text Direction of stand guidance line Wingspan Value Wingspan Colour Code list Colour of stand guidance line Style Code list Style of stand guidance line Helicopter stand An aircraft stand which provides for parking a helicopter and where ground taxi operations are completed or where the helicopter touches down and lifts off for air taxi operations. (Annex 14) Name Text Name of helicopter stand Location Point Geographical location of helicopter stand point/ INS 0.5m essential surveye 1/100 sec checkpoints d De-icing area A facility where frost, ice or snow is removed (de-icing) from the aeroplane to provide clean surfaces, and/or where clean surfaces of the aeroplane receive protection (anti-icing) against the formation of frost or ice and accumulation of snow or slush for a limited period of time. Identifier Text Identifier of de-icing area Geometry Polygon Geographical location of de-icing area 1m routine surveye d 1/10 sec 1 sec Surface type Text The surface type of the deicing area European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Pub. Res. Chart Type Res. Idbase Text Name of underlying Taxiway, Parkingstand or Apron Element Aircraft Text Usage restriction (prohibition) for specified aircraft type restriction Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Communication facility Service Text Designation of the service provided designation Call sign Text Call sign of the communication facility Channel Text Channel/Frequency of the communication facility Logon address Text The logon address of the facility as approria te Hours of Schedule Operational hours of the station serving the unit operation 2. Airspace data Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. ATS Airspace Airspaces of defined dimensions, alphabetically designated, within which specific types of flights may operate and for which air traffic services and rules of operation are specified. Type Text Type of ATS airspace according to ICAO Annex 11. Designation Text The designator given to an airspace by a responsible authority European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Lateral limits Polygon The surface defining the horizontal shape of the see Note 1) Airspace Vertical limits Upper limit Altitude The upper limit of the airspace Lower limit Altitude The lower limit of the airspace 50 m routine calculated 50 m or 50 m or 100 ft 100 ft Class of airspace Code A categorisation of airspace which determines the list operating rules, flight requirements, and services provided. Transition altitude Altitude The altitude at or below which the vertical position of an aircraft is controlled by reference to altitudes. Hours of Schedul The hours of applicability of the airspace applicability e ATS Unit Unit providing service Name Text The name of the unit providing the service Call sign Text The call sign of the aeronautical station serving the unit Language Code Information on the language(s) used, specifying area list and conditions, when and where to be used, if applicable Applicability Text Information on the area and conditions when to be used Hours of service Schedul Operational hours of the station serving the unit e Frequency Value Value The frequency of the ATS aispace European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Purpose Text Indications for specific purposes of the frequency Note 1) FIR, UIR 2 km routine declared 1 min as plotted TMA, CTA 100 m essential calculated 1 sec as plotted CTR 100 m essential calculated 1 sec as plotted Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Special activity airspace Type Code list Type of special activity airspace (See Note 1) Identification Text The identification assigned to uniquely identify the airspace Name Text The name given to the airspace by a responsible authority Lateral limits Polygon The surface defining the horizontal shape of the See Note 2) for P,R,D Areas only airspace Vertical limits Upper limit Altitude The upper limit of the airspace Lower limit Altitude The lower limit of the airspace Restriction Text Type of restriction or nature of hazard Activation Text Information on system and means of activation announcements together with information pertinent to civil flights and applicable ADIZ procedures; Time of activity Schedule Time interval when the special activity takes place Risk of Text Risk of interception in the event of penetration interception European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Note 1) Prohibited Area Note 2) 100 m essential calculated type: 1 sec as plotted Restricted Area 2 km routine declared 1 min as plotted Danger Area Military Execise Area Military Training Area Air Defence Identification Zone (ADIZ) Other Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Other regulated airspace Type Text Type of airspace (RVSM, ELT etc.) Identification Text The identification assigned to uniquely identify the airspace Name Text The name given to the airspace by a responsible authority Lateral limits Polygon The surface defining the horizontal shape of the airspace Vertical limits Upper limit Altitude The upper limit of the airspace Lower limit Altitude The lower limit of the airspace Restriction Text Type of restriction if any Activation Text Information on system and means of activation announcements together with information pertinent to civil flights and applicable ADIZ procedures; Time of activity Schedule Time interval when the special activity takes place European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. ATS control sector Identification Text The identification given to the sector Lateral limits Polygon The surface defining the horizontal shape of the ATC-sector Vertical limits Upper limit Altitude The upper limit of the sector Lower limit Altitude The lower limit of the sector European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 3. ATS and other routes data Sub- Chart Subject Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Property Res. ATS Route A specified route designed for channelling the flow of traffic as necessary for the provision of air traffic services Designator Text Designators for ATS routes according to Annex 11 Appendix 1 (or Appendix 3 for standard departure and arrival routes) Designator Text The prefix of the route designator as specified in Note 1) prefix Other Route A specified route designed for channelling the flow of traffic as necessary without provision of air traffic services Designator Text Designator of the route Type Text Type of route (e.g. VFR uncontrolled navigation routes) Flight rules Code list Information on the flight rules that apply on the route (IFR / VFR) Route segment Navigation Text Designation of the navigation specification(s) applicable to a specification specified segment(s) - There are two kinds of navigation specifications: Required navigation performance (RNP) specification. A navigation specification based on area navigation that includes the requirement for performance monitoring and alerting, designated by the prefix RNP, e.g. RNP 4, RNP APCH. Area navigation (RNAV) specification. A navigation specification based on area navigation that does not include the requirement for performance monitoring and alerting, designated by the prefix RNAV, e.g. RNAV 5, RNAV 1. From point Reference to the first point of a route segment Name Text The coded designators or name-codes of significant point Reporting Code list Indication of ATS / MET reporting requirement “compulsory” or“on- request” To point Reference to the second point of a route segment Name Text The coded designators or name-codes of significant point European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Sub- Chart Subject Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Property Res. Reporting Code list Indication of the ATS / MET reporting requirement “compulsory” or “on-request” Track Bearing Track, VOR radial or magnetic bearing of a route segment 1/10 routine calculated 1 degree 1 degree degree (terminal (terminal (terminal (terminal (terminal arrival arrival arrival arrival arrival departure) departure) departure) departure) departure) Change over Point The point at which an aircraft navigating on an ATS route segment in case of point defined by reference to very high frequency omnidirectional radio VOR radial ranges is expected to transfer its primary navigational reference from the facility behind the aircraft to the next facility ahead of the aircraft. Length Distance The geodesic distance between from point and to point See Note 2) Upper limit Altitude The upper limit of the route segment Lower limit Altitude The lower limit of the route segment MEA Altitude Minimum en-route altitude (MEA). The altitude for an en-route Lower ATS 50 m routine calculate 50 m or 50 m or segment that provides adequate reception of relevant navigation Routes d 100 ft 100 ft facilities and ATS communications, complies with the airspace structure and provides the required obstacle clearance. MOCA Altitude Minimum obstacle clearance altitude (MOCA). The minimum 50 m routine calculate 50 m or 50 m or altitude for a defined segment of flight that provides the required d 100 ft 100 ft obstacle clearance. Minimum flight Altitude Minimum flight altitude Helicopter 50 m routine calculate 50 m or 50 m or altitude route d 100 ft 100 ft Lateral Limits Distance Lateral limits of route AMA Altitude Area Minimum Altitude (AMA) - The minimum altitude to be used under instrument meteorological conditions (IMC), that provides a minimum obstacle clearance within a specified area, normally formed by parallels and meridians. MVA Altitude Minimum Vectoring Altitude European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Sub- Chart Subject Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Property Res. Restrictions Text Indication on any area speed and level/altitude restrictions where established; Direction of Indication on the direction of the cruising level (even, odd, NIL) cruise levels Foward Code list Indication on the direction of the cruising level (even, odd, NIL) from first point to second point of route segment Backward Code list Indication on the direction of the cruising level (even, odd, NIL) from second point to first point of route segment Availability Text Information on the route availability Class of Text Classification of airspace (A, B, … G) which determines the airspace operating rules, flight requirements, and services provided. According to Annex 11, Appendix 4 PBN Area navigation based on performance requirements for aircraft PBN only requirements operating along an ATS route, on an instrument approach procedure or in a designated airspace requirements Navigation Text The navigation accuracy requirement for each PBN (RNAV or RNP) performance route segment requirements Sensor Text Indication on the sensor requirements including any navigation requirements specification limitations Controlling unit Name Text Name of the unit providing the service Channel Text Operating channel / frequency of controlling unit Logon Text A specified code used for data link logon to the controlling ATS unit if applicable address Note 1) U) Upper Note 2) 1/10 km routine calculated 1/10 km 1 km or 1 or 1/10 NM NM K) Helicopter 1/100 km essential calculated 1/100 km 1 km or 1 or 1/100 NM NM European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Sub- Chart Subject Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Property Res. S) Supersonic T) Tacan Other Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Waypoint Identification Text Names, coded designators or name-codes assigned to the significant point. ATC Reporting Code list Indication of ATS / MET reporting requirement requirement “compulsory” or “on-request” Position Point Geographical location of the waypoint 100 m essential surveyed 1 sec 1 sec calculated Formation Navaid Text The station identification of the reference VOR/DME Bearing Bearing The bearing from the reference VOR/DME, if the waypoint is not collocated with it; See Note 1. Distance Distance The distance from the reference VOR/DME, if the waypoint is not collocated with it; See Note 2. Note 1. 1/10 routine calculated 1/10 1/10 degree degree degree 1/100 essential calculated 1/100 1/10 degree degree degree Note 2. 1/10 km routine calculated 1/10 km 2/10 km or 1/10 (1/10 NM) NM European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. 1/100 km essential calculated 1/100 km 2/10 km or 1/100 (1/10 NM) NM Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. A predetermined manoeuvre which keeps an aircraft within a specified airspace while awaiting further En-route Holding clearance. Identification Text Identification of the holding procedure Identification of the holding procedure fix 100m essential surveyed 1 sec 1 sec Fix Text calculated Waypoint Point Geographical location of the holding waypoint Inbound track Bearing The inbound track of the holding procedure Turn Direction Text Direction of the procedure turn Speed Value Maximum indicated airspeed Level Minimum holding Altitude Minimum holding level of the holding procedure level Maximum holding Altitude Maximum holding level of the holding procedure level Time/distance Value Time/distance value of the holding procedure outbound Controlling unit Name Text Indication of the controlling unit Frequency Value The operating frequency/channel of the controlling unit European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Chart Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Res. Special Text Textual description of the Special VOR/DME entry In case an holding entry procedure entry radial procedure to a secondary fix at the end of the outbound leg has been established for a VOR/DME holding pattern 4. Instrument flight procedure data Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Procedure Identification FAS Guidance Code The name describing the type of radio navigation aid APCH list providing the final approach lateral guidance. This could be: ILS, VOR, RNAV, etc Runway Text The runway designator of the landing and take-off direction. Examples: 27, 35L, 01R. Circling Code Indication if a procedure is/ is not a circling approach APCH list Multiple Code Text A single letter suffix, starting with the letter z following APCH the radio navigation aid type shall be used if two or more procedures to the same runway cannot be distinguished by the radio navigation aid type only. For example: VOR y Rwy 20 VOR z Rwy 20 NS Limiter Text Sensor specific information in case of a limitation of use PBN only Name Text Name of the instrument flight procedure European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Plain Language Designation Basic Indicator Text The basic indicator shall be the name or name-code of SID, STAR the significvant point where the standard deparutre route terminates. Validity Indicator Text The validity indicator shall be a number from 1 to 9. SID, STAR Route Indicator Text The route indicator shall be one letter of the alphabet. SID, STAR The letters "I" and "O" shall not be used. Visual Indication Text Indication if the route has been established for use by VFR only aircraft operating in accordance with the visual flight rules (VFR) Coded Designation Significant Point Text The coded designator or name-code of the significant SID, STAR point Validity Indicator Text The Validity Indicator of the procedure SID, STAR Route Indicator Text The Route Indicator of the procedure SID, STAR Procedure Code Indication of the type of procedure (departure, arrival, Type list approach, other) PBN or Code Indication if the procedure is PBN or Conventional IFR only Conventional list Precision Type Text The instrument procedure type. Instrument approach APCH procedures are classified as follows: Non-precision approach (NPA) procedure. - An instrument approach procedure which utilizes lateral guidance but does not utilize vertical guidance. Approach procedure with vertical guidance (APV). - An instrument procedure which utilizes lateral and vertical guidance but does not meet the requirements established for precision approach and landing operations. Precision approach (PA) procedure. - An instrument approach procedure using precision lateral and vertical guidance with minima as determined by the category of operation. Aircraft Code Indication of which aircraft categories the procedure is Category list intended for European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Magnetic Value The magnetic variation considered for the procedure variation design OCA/H Obstacle clearance Altitude (Height) APCH as specified in Doc 8168 Aircraft category Code Aircraft category according to ICAO Doc 8168 Vol I or II APCH list Approach type Code Approach type (e.g. Straight-in Cat I, Cat II, LLZ, Circling APCH list ...) or specific navigation aid (e.g. stepdown fixes), or a specific navigation specification Altitude Altitude The lowest altitude used in establishing compliance with APCH as essential appropriate obstacle clearance criteria. specified in Doc 8168 Height Height The lowest height above the elevation of the relevant APCH as essential runway threshold or the aerodrome elevation as specified applicable, used in establishing compliance with in Doc appropriate obstacle clearance criteria. 8168 DA/H Decision Altitude (Height) APCH Aircraft category Code Aircraft category according to ICAO Doc 8168 Vol I or II APCH list Approach type Code Approach type (e.g. Straight-in, Circling ...) or specific APCH list navigation aid (e.g. stepdown fixes), or a specific navigation specification Altitude Altitude A specified altitude in a 3D instrument approach APCH operation at which a missed approach must be initiated if the required visual reference to continue the approach has not been established European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Height Height A specified height in a 3D instrument approach APCH operation at which a missed approach must be initiated if the required visual reference to continue the approach has not been established MDA/H Minimum Descent Altitude (Height) APCH Aircraft category Code Aircraft category according to ICAO Doc 8168 Vol I or II APCH list Approach type Code Approach type (e.g. Straight-in, Circling ...) or specific APCH list navigation aid (e.g. stepdown fixes), or a specific navigation specification Altitude Altitude A specified altitude in a 2D instrument approach APCH operation or circling approach operation below which descent must not be made without the required visual reference. Height Height A specified height in a 2D instrument approach operation APCH or circling approach operation below which descent must not be made without the required visual reference. MSA Minimum sector altitude - The lowest altitude which may IFR only be used which will provide a minimum clearance of 300 m (1 000 ft) above all objects located in an area contained within a sector of a circle of 46 km (25 NM) radius centred on a radio aid to navigation. Sector start angle Angle Start angle of a sector Sector end angle Angle End angle of a sector Based on Fix Text Center of the MSA Altitude Altitude The minimum altitude for each sector Restrictions Text Minimum sector altitude - The lowest altitude which may be used which will provide a minimum clearance of 300 m (1 000 ft) above all objects located in an area contained within a sector of a circle of 46 km (25 NM) radius centred on a radio aid to navigation. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Radius Value The radius of each sector TAA Terminal arrival altitude - The lowest altitude that will APCH, PBN provide a minimum clearance of 300 m (1 000 ft) above only all objects located in an arc of a circle defined by a 46 km (25 NM) radius centred on the initial approach fix (IAF), or where there is no IAF on the intermediate approach fix (IF), delimited by straight lines joining the extremity of the arc to the IF. The combined TAAs associated with an approach procedure shall account for an area of 360 degrees around the IF. Reference point Text TAA reference point (IAF or IF) IAF Text TAA Initial Approach Fix reference point IF Text TAA Intermediate Fix reference point Dist To IAF Distanc The distance of the TAA area boundary from the IAF e Altitude Altitude The terminal arrival altitude value Sector start angle Angle Start angle of a sector (bearing to TAA reference point Sector end angle Angle End angle of a sector (bearing to TAA reference point) Stepdown arc Distanc Radius of inner area with lower altitude. e Nav Spec Text A set of aircraft and flight crew requirements needed to PBN only Name support performance-based navigation operations within a defined airspace. There are two kinds of navigation specifications: Required navigation performance (RNP) specification. A navigation specification based on area navigation that includes the requirement for performance monitoring and alerting, designated by the prefix RNP, e.g. RNP 4, RNP APCH. Area navigation (RNAV) specification. A navigation specification based on area navigation that does not include the requirement for performance monitoring and alerting, designated by the prefix RNAV, e.g. RNAV 5, RNAV 1. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Operating Text Aerodrome Operating Minima - The limits of usability of APCH, DEP minima an aerodrome for: a) take-off, expressed in terms of runway visual range and/or visibility and, if necessary, cloud conditions; b) landing in precision approach and landing operations, expressed in terms of visibility and/or runway visual range and decision altitude/height (DA/H) as appropriate to the category of the operation; c) landing in approach and landing operations with vertical guidance, expressed in terms of visibility and/or runway visual range and decision altitude/height (DA/H); and d) landing in non-precision approach and landing operations, expressed in terms of visibility and/or runway visual range, minimum descent altitude/height (MDA/H) and, if necessary, cloud conditions Temperatue Minimum Value Minimum temperature reference APCH, PBN temperature only Maximum Value Maximum temperature reference APCH, PBN temperature only Remote Text Cautionary note indicating the altimetry source APCH Altimeter Source Proc Ref Text Airport or landing threshold APCH Datum PBN Specific requirements related to a PBN procedure PBN Requirements Code Identification of the navigation specification (RNAV 5, list PBN 0.3 …) Navigation Text Any navigation sensor limitations (GNSS required …) specification Functional Text Any required functionalities that are described as options requirements in the navigation specification, that is, not included in the core navigation specification (RF required …) Procedure SID, STAR, Segment APCH European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Start Text Identification of the start point of the segment End Text Identification of the end point or a description of the end of the segment End fix Code Indication if the end fix is a fly-by point (A waypoint PBN functionality list which requires turn anticipation to allow tangential interception of the next segment of a route or procedure) or fly-over point (A waypoint at which a turn is initiated in order to join the next segment of a route or procedure) End fix role Code Indication of the role of the end fix (MAPt, IF, IAF, FAF, list MAHF…) Procedure Altitude/ A specified altitude/height flown operationally a tor above SID, STAR, as essential altitude/height Height the minimum altitude/height and established to APCH specified accommodate a stabilized descent ata prescribed certain in Doc descent gradient/angle in the intermediate/final approach segments 8168 segment. only MOCA Altitude The minimum altitude for a defined segment that SID, STAR, provides the required obstacle clearance. APCH Distance Distanc Geodesic distance to the nearest tenth of a kilometer or 1/100 km essential calculated 1/100 km 1 km or 1 e tenth of a nautical mile between each successive or 1/100 NM designated significant point; NM True bearing Bearing True track to the nearest tenth of a degree to the nearest SID, STAR, 1/10 routine calculated 1/10 degree between each successive APCH degree degree significant point; Magnetic Bearing Magnetic track to the nearest tenth of a degree to the SID, STAR, 1/10 routine calculated 1 degree 1 degree bearing nearest degree between each successive APCH degree significant point; Gradient Value APCH, DEP Speed Value speed limit at a significant point, expressed in units of 10 knots applicable Controlling APCH, DEP obstacle Type Text indication if the obstacle is lit/unlit, type of obstacle (church/windturbine,…) European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Position Point coordinates of the controlling obstacle see obstacles Elevation: Elevatio elevation of the top of the controlling obstacle see n obstacles Final Approach That segment of an instrument approach procedure in SBAS APCH Segment which alignment and descent for landing are GBAS APCH accomplished. Operation type Text A number that indicates the type of the final approach segment (e.g "0" is coded for a straight-in approach procedure including offset procedures.) Approach Text A number that identifies the type of an approach. ( “0” is performance used to identify an LPV approach procedure and a “1” designator indicates a Category I approach procedure) SBAS provider Text Identifier of a particular satellite-based approach system SBAS only service provider RPDS Text Reference path data selector (RPDS) - A numerical GBAS only identifier that is unique on a frequency in the broadcast region and used to select the FAS data block. RPI Text Reference Path Identifier - A four-character identifier that is used to confirm selection of the correct approach procedure. LTP/FTP Landing threshold point (LTP) or fictitious threshold point (FTP) Position Point Latidude and Longitude of the LTP/FTP 0.3 m (1 critical 0.0005" ft) (0.01") Ellipsoid height Elevatio The height of the LTP/FTP above the WGS-84 ellipsoid 0.25 m critical 0.1 m n Orthometric Elevatio The height of the LTP/FTP as related to the geoid and height n presented as an MSL elevation FPAP Flight path alignment point (FPAP) Position Point Latidude and Longitude of the FPAP 0.3 m (1 critical 0.0005" ft) (0.01") Orthometric Elevatio The height of the FPAP as related to the geoid and height n presented as an MSL elevation European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. TCH Height Approach Threshold Crossing Height (TCH) - The 0.5 m critical calculated 0.05 m designated crossing height of the flight path angle above the LTP (or FTP). GPA Value Glide Path Angle (GPA) - The angle of the approach 0.01° N/A 0.01° path (glide path) with respect to the horizontal plane defined according to WGS-84 at the LTP/FTP. Course Width Value The semi-width of the lateral course width at the N/A critical 25 m at threshold LTP/FTP, defining the lateral offset at which the receiver will achieve full-scale deflection. Delta Length Distanc The distance from the stop end of the runway to the N/A N/A 8m Offset e FPAP.It defines the location where lateral sensitivity changes to the missed approach sensitivity. HAL Value Horizontal Alert Limit SBAS only VAL Value Vertical Alert Limit SBAS only FAS Data Text Binary string describing the Final Approach Segment Block (FAS) data block generated with an appropriate software tool. The FAS data block is set of parameters to identify a single precision approach or APV and define its associated approach CRC Text An 8-character hexadecimal representation of the Remainder calculated remainder bits used to determine the integrity of the FAS data block data during transmission and storage. Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property Procedure Fix Identification Text Names, coded designators or name-codes assigned to the significant point. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property ATC Reporting Text Indication of ATS / MET reporting requirement requirements “compulsory”, “on-request” or "nil" VFR Reporting point Text Bridge, Church Name VFR Position Point Geographical location of the fix See Note 1. Type Text Indication of the type of fix, such as: Navaid, Int, WPT Formations Navaid Text The station identification of the reference VOR/DME Bearing Bearing The bearing from the reference VOR/DME, if the waypoint is not collocated with it; See Note 2. Distance Distance The distance from the reference VOR/DME, if the 1/100 km essential calculated 1/100 km 2/10 km waypoint is not collocated with it; or 1/100 NM (1/10 NM) Note 1. 100 m essential surveyed / 1 sec 1 sec calculated 3m essential surveyed / 1/10 sec 1 sec calculated Note 2. 1/10 routine calculated 1/10 degree 1/10 degree degree 1/100 essential calculated 1/100 degree 1/10 degree degree European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Req. Chart Res. Property A predetermined manoeuvre which keeps an aircraft within a Procedure Holding specified airspace while awaiting further clearance. Identification Text Identification of the holding procedure Fix Point Geographical location that serves as a reference for a same as holding procedure. proc fix Inbound course Course Inbound true course 1/10 degree Outboundcourse Course Outbound true course 1/10 degree Leg distance Distance Outbound dIstance of the leg 1/10 km or 1/10 NM Leg time Value Outbound time of the leg Limiting radial Angle Limiting radial from the VOR/DME on which the holding is based Turn direction Value Direction of the procedure turn Minimum Altitude Minimum holding level to the nearest higher 50 m or 100 50 m routine calculated 50 m or 100 altitude ft/flight level ft/flight level Maximum Altitude Maximum holding level to the nearest higher 50 m or 100 50 m or 100 altitude ft/flight level ft/flight level Speed Value Maximum indicated air speed 10 kts Magnetic variation Angle Angle The magnetic variation of the radio navigation aid of the procedure Date Date The date on which the magnetic variation had the coresponding value. European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Propoerty Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Req. Chart Res. Property Nav Spec Name Text Name of the Navigation Specification - set of aircraft and RNAV/RNP aircrew requirements needed to support a navigation application within a defined airspace concept Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Publ. Res. Chart Res Property Helicopter Procedure Specifics Helicopter Text Identification of the helicopter procedure Procedure Title (RNAV 263) HCH Height Heliport crossing height essential 1 m or 1 ft 1 m or 1 ft IDF Point Initial departure fix DEP MAPt Point Missed Approach Point APCH Direct Visual For PinS APP: the portion of flight that connects directly the Segment PinS to the landing location. For PinS DEP: the portion of flight that connects directly the landing location to the IDF Track Line Distance Distance Bearing Angle Crossing Height height Manoeuvring Maneuvering Visual Segment - PinS visual segment APCH VS protected for the following manoeuvres: DEP For PinS APCH: Visual manoeuvre from the MAPt around the heliport or landing location to land from a direction other than directly from the MAPt. For PinS DEP: Take-off in a direction other than directly to the IDF followed by visual manoeuvre to join the instrument segment at the IDF. Center line Angle Centre line of take-off climb surface DEP European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Publ. Res. Chart Res Property Manoeuvring Polygon Area where the pilot is expected to manoeuvre visually APCH Area DEP No Polygon Area where manoeuvring is prohibited APCH Manoeuvring DEP Area Ingress Line Maneuvering Visual Segment - PinS visual segment APCH Tracks protected for the following manoeuvres: For PinS APCH: DEP Visual manoeuvre from the MAPt around the heliport or landing location to land from a direction other than directly from the MAPt. For PinS DEP: Take-off in a direction other than directly to the IDF followed by visual manoeuvre to join the instrument segment at the IDF. HAS Height above surface diagram APCH Radius Distance Height Height above Surface Proceed Text Text indicating that the procedure has Proceeed Visually Visually Text instruction Proceed VFR Text Text indicating that the procedure has Proceeed VFR Text instruction VSDA Value Visual segment descent angle Ingress Tracks Length Distance Width Distance Bearing Angle Subject Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Property Property AITF Notes on charts (Aeronautical Information in Textual Format) European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Property Property Non-align between Text Instrument and Visual Slope Indications Missed Approach Text Missed approach description for the procedure Description SID/STAR Route Text Textual description of the SID or STAR procedure Description Missed Apch Value the value of the missed apprach climb gradient for the Climb Gradient approach procedure CAT H Note Text CAT D Large Text Authorization Text Indication that RNP AR Required Units of Measure Text GNSS In-Lieu-Of Comm Failure Text Communication failure description Surveillance/Radar Required SID Close-in Text Indication Obstacle Note wherever close-in obstacles exist which were not considered in the determination of the published procedure design gradient Off-Set Alignment PDG greater then 3% 5. Radio navigation aids/systems data Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property Radio navigation aid European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property Type Text Type of radio navigation aid Identification Text The code assigned to uniquely identify the navaid Name Text The textual name assigned to the navaid Area of operation Text Indication whether navigation aid serves en-route (E), aerodrome (A) or dual (AE) purposes. Aerodrome Text The ICAO location indicator or name of the aerodromes served served Runway served Text Designator of the runway served Operating Text Name of the operating authority of the facility authority Type of supported Code list Indication of the type of supported operation for ILS/MLS and ops GBAS Co-location Text Information that a navaid is co-located with another navaid Hours of Schedule The hours of operation of the radio navigation aid operation Magnetic The angular difference between True North and Magnetic variation North Angle Angle The magnetic variation at the radio navigation aid ILS/ND See Note 1) B Date Date The date on which the magnetic variation had the coresponding value. Station Angle An alignment variation of the navaid between the zero degree VOR/IL declination radial and true north, determined at the time the station is S/MLS calibrated. Zero bearing Text Direction of the 'zero bearing' provided by the station. For VOR direction example: magnetic north, true north Frequency Value Frequency or tuning frequency of the radio navigation aid European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property Channel Text The channel number of the radio navigation aid DME Position Point Geographical location of the radio navigation aid See Note 2) Elevation Elevation The elevation of the transmitting antenna of DME DME The elevation of GBAS reference point GBAS See Note 3) Ellipsoidal height Height The ellipsoid height of the GBAS reference point, GBAS Localizer alignment Bearing Bearing The localizer course ILS 1/100 deg essential surveyed 1/100 Localize degree (if r true) 1 degree Type Text Type of localizer alligment, true or magnetic ILS Localize r Zero azimuth Bearing MLS zero azimuth alignment MLS 1/100 deg essential surveyed 1/100 alignment degree (if true) 1 degree Angle Angle The angle of the glide path of an ILS or the normal glide path ILS GP angle for the MLS installation /MLS RDH Value The value of the ILS Reference Datum Height (ILS RDH). ILS GP 0.5m critical calculated Localizer antenna Distance ILS localizer runway/FATO end distance ILS 3m routine calculated 1 m or 1 ft as plotted rwy end distance Localize r ILS glideslope Distance ILS glideslope antenna - threshold distance along centerline ILS GP 3m routine calculated 1 m or 1 ft as plotted antenna TRSH distance ILS marker TRSH Distance ILS marker - threshold distance ILS 3m essentail calculated 1 m or 1 ft 2/10 km distance (1/10 NM) ILS DME antenna Distance ILS DME antenna - threshold distance along centerline ILS 3m essential calculated 1 m or 1 ft as plotted TRSH distance European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property MLS azimuth Distance MLS azimuth antenna - runway/FATO end distance MLS 3m routine calculated 1 m or 1 ft as plotted antenna rwy end distance MLS elevation Distance MLS elevation antenna - threshold distance along centre line MLS 3m routine calculated 1 m or 1 ft as plotted antenna TRHS distance MLS DME Distance MLS DME/P antenna - threshold distance along centre line MLS 3m essential calculated 1 m or 1 ft as plotted antenna TRHS distance Signal Code list GBAS signal polarization (GBAS/H or GBAS/E) GBAS polarization DOC Text Designated operational coverage (DOC or stadard service volume SSV) as range or service volume radius from the navaid / GBAS reference point, height and sectors if required Note 1) ILS 1 degree essential surveyed 1 degree Localize r NDB 1 degree routine surveyed 1 degree Note 2) Aerodro 3m essential surveyed 1/10 sec as plotted me Navaid GBAS 1m Ref Point Enroute 100 m essential surveyed 1 sec Note 3) DME 30m essential surveyed 30 m (100 30 m (100 ft) (100ft) ft) DME/P 3m essential surveyed 3 m (10 ft) European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub- Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property GBAS 0.25 m essential 1 m or 1 ft Ref Point Sub- Subject Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property GNSS A worldwide position and time determination system that includes one or more satellite constellations, aircraft receivers and system integrity monitoring, augmented as necessary to support the required navigation performance for the intended operation. Name Text The name of the GNSS element (GPS, GBAS, GLONASS, EGNOS, MSAS, WAAS, etc.) Frequency Value Frequency of the GNSS as apprioriate Service area Polygon Geographical location of the GNSS service area Coverage Polygon Geographical location of the GNSS coverage area area Operating Text Name of the operating authority of the facility authority Sub- Subject Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property Aeronautical Ground lights and other light beacons designating ground lights geographical positions which are selected by the State as being significant Type Text Type of beacon Designator Text The code assigned to uniquely identify to the beacon Name Text The name of the city or town or other identification of the beacon Intensity Value Intensity of the light of the beacon 1000 candela European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Sub- Subject Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Property Characteristi Text Information about the characteristics of beacon cs Hours of Schedule The hours of operation of the beacon operations Position Point Geographical location of the beacon Marine lights Position Point Geographical location of the beacon Visibility Distance The visibility range of the beacon range Characteristi Text Information about the characteristics of the beacon cs Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Special navigation Stations associated with special navigation system systems (DECCA, LORAN, etc.), Type Text Type of service available (master signal, slave signal, colour); Designator Text The code assigned to uniquely identify to the special navigation system Name Text The textual name assigned to the special navigation system Frequency Value Frequency (channel number, basic pulse rate, recurrence rate, as applicable) of the special navigation system Hours of Schedule The hours of operation of the special navigation operations system Position Point Geographical location of the special navigation 100m essential surveyed / system calculated Operating Text Name of the operating authority of the facility authority Facility coverage Text Description of special navigation system faciity coverage European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 6. Obstacle data Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Obstacle All fixed (whether temporary or permanent) and mobile obstacles or parts thereof, Obstacle identifier Text Unique identifier of obstacle Operator / Owner Text Name and Contact information of obstacle operator or owner Geometry type Code An indication whether the obstacle is a point, line or list polygon. Horizontal position Point Horizontal position of obstacle Line Polygon See Note 1) Horizontal extent Distanc Hoizontal extent of the obstacle e Elevation Elevatio Elevation of the highest point of the obstacle. n See Note 2) Height Height Height of the obstacle above ground Type Text Type of obstacle Date and time stamp Date Date and time the obstacle was created European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Res. Chart Res. Operations Text Feature operations of mobile obstacles Effectivity Text Effectivity of temporary types of obstacles Lighting Type Text Type of lighting Colour Text Colour of the obstacle lighting Marking Text Type of marking of obstacle Material Text Predominant surface material of the obstacle Note 1) Obstacles in Area 1 50 m routine surveyed 1 sec as plotted Obstacles in Area 2 (including 2a, 2b, 2c, 2d, take-off flight path 5m essential surveyed 1/10 sec 1/10 sec area and obstacle limitation surfaces) Obstacles in Area 3 0.5 m essential surveyed 1/10 sec 1/10 sec Obstacles in Area 4 2.5 m essential surveyed Note 2) Obstacles in Area 1 30 m routine surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 3 m (10 ft) Obstacles in Area 2 (including 2a, 2b, 2c, 2d, take-off flight path 3m essential surveyed 1 m or 1 ft 1 m or 1 ft area and obstacle limitation surfaces) Obstacles in Area 3 0.5 m essential surveyed 0.1 m or 1m or 1 ft 0.1 ft 0.01 m Obstacles in Area 4 1m essential surveyed 0.1 m 7. Geographic data European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Chart Res. Res. Buildings Buildings (of operational significance) and other salient/prominent (aerodrome) features Name Text Name of the building Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the building Built up areas Areas covered by cities, towns and villages Name Text Name of the build-up area Geometry Point/ Geographical location of the build-up area Polygon Railroads All railroads having landmark value Name Text Name of the railroad Geometry Line Geographical location of the railroads Highways and All highways and roads having landmark value Roads Name Text Name of highways and roads Geometry Line Geographical location of highways and roads Landmarks Natural and cultural landmarks, such as bridges, prominent transmission lines, permanent cable car installations, wind turbines, mine structures, forts, ruins, levees, pipelines, rocks, bluffs, European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Chart Res. Res. cliffs, sand dunes, isolated lighthouses and lightships, when considered to be of importance for visual air navigation. Characteristics Text Description of the landmark Geometry Line Geographical location of the railroads Political boundaries International political boundaries Geometry Line Geographical location of international political boundaries Hydrography All water features comprising shore lines, lakes, rivers and streams (including those non- perennial in nature), salt lakes, glaciers and ice caps Name Text Name of the water feature Geometry Line/ Geographical location of water feature Polygon Wooded areas Wooded areas Geometry Polygon Geographical location of wooded area European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Chart Res. Res. Service roads Part of aerodrome surface used by service vehicles Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the service roads featbase Text Identification of the feature type affected Idbase Text Name of the underlying taxiway, parking stand area or apron Construction area Part of aerodrome area under construction Geometry Polygon Geographical location of the construction area Aircraft movement Areas unsuitable for aircraft movement unsuitable area Geometry Polygon Depicted movement area permanently unsuitable for aircraft, clearly identified as such Survey control point A monumented survey control point idnumber Text Special unique identifier permanently assigned to a feature instance by the data provider Location Point Geographical location of the survey control point Elevation Elevation Elevation of survey control point ASRN node A vertex in a graph defining the Aerodrome Surface Routing Network idnetwrk Text Logical name comprised of a delimited list of names for one or more features associated with this ASRN feature idthr Text Name of feature instance idnumber Text Special unique identifier permanently assigned to a feature instance by a data provider termref Text Terminal building associated with the feature instance nodetype Text Type of node catstop Text Low visibility operation category of holding position Position Point Geographical location of the ASRN node European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Subject Property Sub-Property Type Description Note Accuracy Integrity Orig Type Pub. Chart Res. Res. ASRN edge A connection between teo nodes in a graph defining the Aerodrome Surface Routing Network idnetwrk Text Logical name comprised of a delimited list of names for one or more features associated with this ASRN feature direc Text Directionality of corresponding feature instance, which can be one-way or two-way node1ref Text The idnumber of the ASRN Node corresponding to the start point of the edge geometry node2ref Text The idnumber of the ASRN Node corresponding to the end point of the edge geometry edgetype Text Type of edge edgederv Text Derivation method of edge geometry Geometry Line Geographical location of the ASRN edge European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Data types referred to in column 4 ‘Type’ Type Description Data elements (1) (2) (3) Point A pair of coordinates (latitude and longitude) referenced to Latitude the mathematical reference ellipsoid which define the Longitude position of the point on the surface of the Earth. Horizontal reference system Units of measurement Horizontal accuracy achieved Line Sequence of Points defining a linear object Sequence of Points Polygon Sequence of Points forming the boundary of the polygon. The Closed sequence of Points first and last Point are identical. Height The vertical distance of a level, point or an object considered Numerical value as a point, measured from a specific datum. Vertical reference system Units of measurement Vertical accuracy achieved Altitude The vertical distance of a level, a point or an object considered Numerical value as a point, measured from mean sea level. Vertical reference system Units of measurement Vertical accuracy achieved Elevation The vertical distance of a point or a level, on or affixed to the Numerical value surface of the earth, measured from mean sea level. Vertical reference system Units of measurement Vertical accuracy Distance An angular value Numerical Value Units of Measurement Accuracy achieved European Aviation Safety Agency Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-02 Angle / Bearing An angular value Numerical Value Units of Measurement Accuracy achieved Value Any measured, declared or derived value not listed above. Numerical Value Units of Measurement Accuracy achieved Date A calendar date referencing a particular day or month Text Schedule A repetitive time period, composed of one or more intervals Text or special dates (e.g. holidays) occurring cyclically Code list A set of predefined Text strings or values Text Text Free text String of characters without constraints - END -
Allikas: Lennuamet dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel