Registrite ja Infosüsteemide Keskus · 26. oktoober 2021
Sisu (failidest)
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)5636653 - 14/09/2021
Proposal Evaluation Form
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Evaluation
Justice Programme (JUST)
Summary Report -
JUST
Call: JUST-2021-JCOO
Type of action: JUST-PJG
Proposal number: 101046340
Proposal acronym: CRIS-TCN
Duration (months): 24
Proposal title: Adaptation and development of the national criminal record according to the needs of ECRIS TCN system
Activity: JUST-JCOO-AG-2021
Grant
N. Proposer name Country Total Cost % %
Requested
1 REGISTRITE JA INFOSUSTEEMIDE KESKUS EE 650,560 100.00% 585,504 100.00%
Total: 650,560 585,504
Abstract:
Estonia has started preparations to implement the changes required by the ECRIS-TCN Regulation (EU 2019/816) to the national information
systems. This central system aims to improve the exchange of criminal records information regarding convicted non-EU-citizens and stateless
persons through the existing European Criminal Records Information System (ECRIS).The new system will make it faster and easier for law
enforcement authorities to spot third country nationals previously convicted in the EU, by a simple search in ECRIS. This will help improve police
and judicial and cooperation to better fight crime and terrorism across the EU, making Europe a safer place for all of its citizens. Improving ECRIS
with regard to third-country nationals is part of the European Agenda on Security. ECRIS-TCN is also a part of the new approach set out by the
European Commission towards data management for borders and security whereby all centralised EU information systems for security, border and
migration management should become interoperable in full respect of fundamental rights.The main objective of the project is to implement the
needed adaptations of the national criminal records systems for the linking and exchange of alphanumeric data and fingerprints with the ECRIS-
TCN central system. It should also be possible to add facial images if the law of the Member State of conviction allows for the collection and
storage of facial images of convicted persons.The time for the launch of the new central information system is planned for 1 January 2023.
Evaluation Summary Report
Evaluation Result
Total score: 84.50 (Threshold: 70)
Form information
Criterion 1 - Relevance
Score: 37.00 (Threshold: 25/40.00 , Weight: -)
The following aspects have been taken into account:
• extent to which the proposal matches the priorities and objectives of the call (0-10 points)
• clearly defined needs and robust needs assessment (0-10 points)
• clearly defined target group, with gender perspective being appropriately taken into account (0-5 points)
• contribution to the EU strategic and legislative context (0-5 points)
• European/trans-national dimension; impact/interest for a number of countries (EU or eligible non-EU countries) and possibility
to use the results in other countries (potential for transfer of good practices) (0-4 points)
• potential to develop mutual trust/cross-border cooperation (0-3 points)
• building synergies and avoiding duplication with projects (0-3 points).
1. The project is 100% relevant to priority 4 of the call for proposals "Support to Member States for their connection to the ECRIS-TCN
system".
2. While the applicant clearly presents relevant shortcomings of the existing process and the respective needs, the needs assessment is
missing data and references to appropriate sources. Nevertheless, there is a clear definition of the target state, described by a set of general
and specific objectives, in line with the defined themes and priorities and the associated regulation.
3. The target groups are identified by the applicant and a general explanation is presented how they benefit from the action. However, the link
between the target groups and the project's needs are not as clearly defined. Similarly, the gender perspective is rather generally covered and
incorporated in the proposal.
4. What is more, the project will clearly contribute to the consistent and coherent implementation of European Union law concerning ECRIS-
TCN as it is the result of regulation 2019/816, and furthermore supports Interoperability [2019/818].
5. As for the project's European dimension, it is underlined that the implementation of the project will have an impact across all the EU
Member States that participate in ECRIS-TCN or other Interoperable Systems. It will greatly simplify the exchange of conviction and security
information across the EU, with positive effects on judicial, law enforcement and other authorities.
6. Against that backdrop, the project has a very high potential to foster mutual trust and promote cross-border cooperation.
7. Last but not least, the proposal describes clearly synergies with existing the ECRIS system and avoids duplication. In this context the
applicant provide practical examples for synergies such as the aim to incorporate the new ECRIS TCN next to ECRIS.
Criterion 2 - Quality
Score: 31.00 (Threshold: 0/40.00 , Weight: -)
101046340/CRIS-TCN-14/09/2021-17:47:02 1/3
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)5636653 - 14/09/2021
The following aspects have been taken into account:
• clarity and consistency of project (0-5 points)
• methodology for implementing the project is robust, clear, feasible and well chosen for the objectives of the project with gender
perspective being appropriately taken into account; feasibility of the project within the proposed time frame; there are logical
links between the identified problems, needs and solutions proposed (logical frame concept) (0-5 points)
• consortium and project teams have sufficient capacity to implement the proposed project (0-5 points)
• organisation of work, timetable, allocation of resources and distribution of tasks between partners is appropriate for the
activities planned (0-5 points)
• risks are identified appropriately & risk management, monitoring and evaluation are well thought (0-5 points)
• ethical issues are addressed (0-5 points)
• financial feasibility (sufficient/appropriate budget for proper implementation) (0-5 points)
• cost-effectiveness (best value for money) (0-5 points).
1. Whereas the project's description is rather succinct, it is of good quality. All elements of the Application Form are coherently linked with
each other.
2. With a view to the project methodology, it is acknowledged that no references to a specific IT methodology. Furthermore, the approach
presented lacks clarity, in particular in terms of achieving project objectives. Nevertheless, the split of the project into three distinctive work
packages (PM, analyses and development) seems to be appropriately addressing the project's needs. In addition, a very clear decision-
making mechanism is described. Moreover, and as alphanumeric data is concerned, the schedule of the project is fully in line with the legal
deadline and eu-LISA's timeline concerning implementation of the ECRIS-TCN central system. This is not the case for the fingerprint data
though.
3. The consortium is composed by partners that have the needed expertise in the domain and experience collaborating with each other.
In particular, the main partner responsible for the development of the project, has extensive experience in the specific domain as they are
managing the current Criminal Records Database.
4. As for the organisation of work, the distribution of resources and profiles between work packages is reasonable. All tasks are separately
presented in the project's timetable and their logic is coherent. Furthermore, detailed deliverables and milestones are presented, which it is a
good indication of a rigorously planned project. However, there are some unclarities. It is not clear how the EFI will be involved in the project,
as no resources are allocated on their side. As example activity 3.5.1, implies an interaction with ABIS system. Furthermore ABIS participant
is not mentioned as participant on any task on any role. In addition, the Ministry of Interior is a partner but is is not involved on any task,
especially on WP1. e.g task 1.6 it should be included as reviewer.
5. While risks and and proposed mitigation measures are described, including probability and impact of the risks, there are some gaps in
information. For example, although the prerequisites delay risk has been identified, it is not clear what the prerequisites are and why they are
applicable only to WP1, without clearly describing the impact on WP2 and WP3. Furthermore, since this is an integration project with ECRIS
TCN, the applicant does not make it entirely evident if the prerequisite risks include external risks. The risk management process is not clearly
described in this regard.
6. Concerning ethics, the applicant outlines a rather generic statement about protection of rights. However, the horizontal actions and policies
of the Estonian government overall address ethical issues. Finally, data protection is not sufficiently addressed.
7. The project's budget reflects all three work packages, all project's activities and deliverables. The overall amount requested is appropriate
in relation to the type and scale of envisaged activities.
8. Taking into account tat the budget reflect all three work packages and that the calculation of direct personnel costs is coherent throughout
all work packages, it is concluded that the project is cost-efficient.
Criterion 3 - Impact
Score: 16.50 (Threshold: 0/20.00 , Weight: -)
The following aspects have been taken into account:
• ambition and expected long-term impact of results on target groups/general public (0-5 points)
• appropriate dissemination strategy for ensuring sustainability and long-term impact (0-5 points)
• potential for a positive multiplier effect (0-5 points)
• sustainability of results after EU funding ends (0-5 points)
1. On the one hand, the applicant does not establish a very clear account of the outcomes of the project regarding their short, medium and
long-term impact per target group. Furthermore, credible quantitative or qualitative indicators, measurable to determine the results of the
project are rather lacking. Yet, there is a description of the improvement on the management of the Member States' border and security data.
On the other hand, and on a more general and overarching level, the expected results of the project, i.e. changes to national IT systems and
integration of those systems with the central ECRIS-TCN module, will clearly have an impact on the development project managed by eu-LISA
and the future operation of the ECRIS-TCN system as such. Thereby, the project project will produce a long-term and sustainable impact on
the concerned Estonian national authorities, the ECRIS community within Europe and concerned TCNs.
2. As for the dissemination strategy, the applicant formulates a strategy, which is mainly targeting the relevant communities by using the
appropriate channels of communication per target group. Key messages have been formulated but quantitative or qualitative indicators are
missing. Gender inclusive language is not sufficiently addressed. What is more, the activities are not presented in the planning. However, the
visibility of EU funding, is ensured by making the appropriate references and the inclusion of logos.
3. The proposal is very likely to have a positive multiplier effect. Indeed, the applicant directly refers to the interoperability with relevant
information systems in the field of security, border management and migration management.
4. Strong guaranties of the sustainability of the project after funding ends are provided. The Estonian Government supports the project and the
inclusion of the project on the Ministry’s action plan. The project will be incorporated in the existing ECRIS project.
Scope of the proposal
Status: Yes
Comments (in case the proposal is out of scope)
Not provided
Ethics and EU values
101046340/CRIS-TCN-14/09/2021-17:47:02 2/3
Associated with document Ref. Ares(2021)5636653 - 14/09/2021
Status: Yes
The project will be entirely implemented by Estonian national authorities.
For applicants which work directly with children, do they have an adequate child protection policy in place (see Keeping Children
Safe Child Safeguarding Standards )?
Not applicable
Not provided
Project budget
General comments on the project budget:
No budget irregularities were found. In addition, there are no discrepancies between part A and B of the proposal.
Overall comments
A good quality proposal, however, some elements are either missing or described in a general fashion. As positive should be mentioned that
the project will be implemented directly by a partner that has extensive experience in the domain. Yet, interactions and dependencies to
external partners are not properly captured.
101046340/CRIS-TCN-14/09/2021-17:47:02 3/3
Digitally sealed by the European Commission
Date: 2021.09.14 17:50:49 CEST
This electronic receipt is a digitally signed version of the document submitted by your
organisation. Both the content of the document and a set of metadata have been digitally
sealed.
This digital signature mechanism, using a public-private key pair mechanism, uniquely
binds this eReceipt to the modules of the Funding & Tenders Portal of the European
Commission, to the transaction for which it was generated and ensures its full integrity.
Therefore a complete digitally signed trail of the transaction is available both for your
organisation and for the issuer of the eReceipt.
Any attempt to modify the content will lead to a break of the integrity of the electronic
signature, which can be verified at any time by clicking on the eReceipt validation
symbol.
More info about eReceipts can be found in the FAQ page of the Funding & Tenders
Portal.
(https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/support/faq)
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
DECLARATION OF HONOUR FOR BENEFICIARIES (DoH)
I, the undersigned:
for natural persons: in my own name
or
for legal persons1: representing the following entity:
REGISTRITE JA INFOSUSTEEMIDE KESKUS
Lubja 4
TALLINN 19081
Estonia
VAT number EE100523377
hereby certify
that (subject to the additional declarations below):
1 — The information provided for action 101046340 — CRIS-TCN is correct and complete.
2 — The information concerning the legal status in the Participant Register for me/my organisation
is correct and complete.
3 — I/my organisation commit to comply2 with the eligibility criteria and all other conditions set
out in the call for proposals — for the entire duration of the action.
4 — I/my organisation:
– are committed to participate in the action
– have stable and sufficient sources of funding to maintain the activity throughout the
checking action and to provide any counterpart funding necessary
– have or will have the necessary resources needed to implement the action
– acknowledge to be fully responsible for my affiliated entities which participate in the
action
– for research actions: are committed to comply with the highest standards of ethical
principles and research integrity and confirm that the work is free of plagiarism
– for actions involving EU-classified information: acknowledge that any sensitive
1 This includes ‘entities without legal personality’ under Article 197(2) of Regulation (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046 of the
European Parliament and of the Council of 18 July 2018 on the financial rules applicable to the general budget of the
Union, amending Regulations (EU) No 1296/2013, (EU) No 1301/2013, (EU) No 1303/2013, (EU) No 1304/2013,
(EU) No 1309/2013, (EU) No 1316/2013, (EU) No 223/2014, (EU) No 283/2014, and Decision No 541/2014/EU and
repealing Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 (‘EU Financial Regulation’) (OJ L 193, 30.7.2018, p. 1).
2 ‘Commit to comply’ means complying now and for the duration of the grant.
1
information or material that qualifies as EU-classified information under Commission
Decision 2015/4443 must be handled in accordance with specific rules and follow the
instructions given by the EU
– for coordinators of multi-beneficiary actions: are committed to act as the coordinator for
this action.
5 — For applicants from non-EU countries: I/my organisation
– undertake to comply with the obligations under the agreement and to:
– respect general principles (including fundamental rights, values and ethical
principles, environmental and labour standards, rules on classified information,
intellectual property rights, visibility of funding and protection of personal data)
– for the submission of financial certificates under the agreement: use qualified external
auditors which are independent and comply with comparable standards as those set
out in EU Directive 2006/43/EC
– for controls under the agreement: allow for checks, reviews, audits and investigations
(including on-the-spot checks, visits and inspections) by the granting authority, the
European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF), the European Prosecutor’s Office (EPPO) and
the European Court of Auditors (ECA) (and any persons mandated by them)
– and confirm that:
– we can be subject to the jurisdiction of the Belgian courts.
6 — I/my organisation:
– are NOT subject to an administrative sanction (i.e. exclusion or financial penalty
decision)4
I/my organisation (or persons with unlimited liability for debts):
– are NOT in one of the following exclusion situations5:
– bankrupt, being wound up, having the affairs administered by the courts, entered
into an arrangement with creditors, suspended business activities or subject to any
other similar proceedings or procedures
– in breach of social security or tax obligations
I/my organisation (or persons having powers of representation, decision-making or control,
beneficial owners or persons who are essential for the award/implementation of the action):
3 See Commission Decision 2015/544/EU, Euratom of 13 March 2015 on the security rules for protecting EU classified
information (OJ L 72, 17.3.2015, p. 53).
4 See Article 136 EU Financial Regulation.
5 See Articles 136 and 141 EU Financial Regulation.
2
– are NOT in one of the following exclusion situations6:
– guilty of grave professional misconduct7
– committed fraud, corruption, links to a criminal organisation, money laundering,
terrorism-related crimes (including terrorism financing), child labour or human
trafficking
– shown significant deficiencies in complying with main obligations under an EU
procurement contract, grant agreement, prize, expert contract, or similar
– guilty of irregularities within the meaning of Article 1(2) of Regulation
No 2988/95
– created under a different jurisdiction with the intent to circumvent fiscal, social
or other legal obligations in the country of origin (including creation of another
entity with this purpose).
7 — I/my organisation are NOT subject to a conflict of interest in connection with this grant and
will notify — without delay — any situation which could give rise to a conflict of interests.
8 — I/my organisation have NOT and will NOT, neither directly nor indirectly, grant, seek, obtain
or accept any advantage in connection with this grant that would constitute an illegal practice
or involve corruption.
9 — I/my organisation have not received any other EU grant for this action and will give notice
of any future EU grants related to this action AND of any EU operating grant(s)8 given to my
organisation.
10 — I/my organisation are aware that false declarations may lead to rejection, suspension,
termination or reduction of the grant and to administrative sanctions (i.e. financial penalties
and/or exclusion from all future EU procurement contracts, grants, prizes and expert contracts).
and acknowledge
that:
1 — The grant will be signed and managed electronically, through the Funding & Tenders Portal
Electronic Exchange System (accessible via your Funding & Tenders Portal account9).
6 See Articles 136 and 141 EU Financial Regulation.
7 Professional misconduct includes: violation of ethical standards of the profession, wrongful conduct with impact on
professional credibility, false declarations/misrepresentation of information, participation in a cartel or other agreement
distorting competition, violation of IPR, attempting to influence decision-making processes or obtain confidential
information from public authorities to gain an advantage.
8 See Article 180 EU Financial Regulation.
9 Available at https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/myarea/projects.
3
2 — Access and use of the electronic exchange system is subject to the Funding & Tenders Portal
Terms & Conditions10.
3 — Personal data submitted or otherwise collected by the EU will be subject to the Funding &
Tenders Portal privacy statements11.
SIGNATURE
For the applicant:
[--TGSMark#signature-917887721_75_210--]
10 Available at https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/docs/2021-2027/common/ftp/tc_en.pdf.
11 Available at https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/support/legalnotice.
4
Digitally sealed by the European Commission
Date: 2021.10.07 12:15:06 CEST
This electronic receipt is a digitally signed version of the document submitted by your
organisation. Both the content of the document and a set of metadata have been digitally
sealed.
This digital signature mechanism, using a public-private key pair mechanism, uniquely
binds this eReceipt to the modules of the Funding & Tenders Portal of the European
Commission, to the transaction for which it was generated and ensures its full integrity.
Therefore a complete digitally signed trail of the transaction is available both for your
organisation and for the issuer of the eReceipt.
Any attempt to modify the content will lead to a break of the integrity of the electronic
signature, which can be verified at any time by clicking on the eReceipt validation
symbol.
More info about eReceipts can be found in the FAQ page of the Funding & Tenders
Portal.
(https://ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/portal/screen/support/faq)
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
Ref. Ares(2021)5670534 - 16/09/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Directorate-General for Justice and Consumers
JUST.4 – Programme and Financial management
JANEC LEPPIK
REGISTRITE JA INFOSUSTEEMIDE
KESKUS
Lubja 4
19081 TALLINN
ESTONIA
Subject: Justice Programme (JUST)
Call: JUST-2021-JCOO
Project: 101046340 — CRIS-TCN
GAP invitation letter
Dear Madam/Sir,
I am writing in connection with your proposal for the above-mentioned call.
Having completed the evaluation, we are pleased to inform you that your proposal has passed this
phase and that we would now like to start grant preparation.
Please find enclosed the evaluation summary report (ESR) for your proposal.
Invitation to grant preparation
Grant preparation will be based on the following:
1. Project: 101046340 — CRIS-TCN
2. Topic: JUST-2021-JCOO — Call for proposals for action grants to promote judicial cooperation in civil and
criminal matters
3. Type of action: JUST Project Grants
4. Project officer: Angeelika ROODEN
Programme and Financial management
Please always use the Funding & Tenders Portal messaging function (via your Portal account). Do NOT contact
us via other means (email, letter, etc.) — unless explicitly asked to do so.
5. Maximum grant amount:
Requested EU contribution (according to proposal): 0.00 EUR
Maximum grant amount (proposed amount, after evaluation): 585 504.00 EUR
Please note that the proposed amount may still be lowered during grant preparation.
1
EUROPEAN COMMISSION, B-1049 Brussels, BELGIUM
6. Project duration: 24 months
7. Grant preparation:
Preparation of grant data & annexes: 2 weeks after receiving this letter
The annexes (description of the action, estimated budget, etc.) must be based on the proposal you submitted
and the clarifications provided (if any). You may normally NOT make changes to the project/project budget/
consortium composition (except if required by us). Please immediately inform the project officer if you need to
make a change (e.g. bankruptcy, etc.).
Please be aware that your proposal may still need to undergo an ethics review or security scrutiny (and the
results will then have to be implemented by you).
Once we have checked the information you have encoded, you will have 2 weeks to submit your final version
— to bring it in line with our comments.
Declaration of honour (DoH): 6 weeks after receiving this letter
Please note that each applicant should also submit a signed and scanned DoH for each one of their linked
third parties.
Signature: within 3 months after receiving this letter (planned date)
Please note that repeated failure to respect deadlines during grant preparation may lead to the rejection of your
proposal (or a consortium member). Lack of cooperation will be taken to mean that you are no longer interested.
8. Funding & Tenders Portal
Grant preparation (including signature) will be done exclusively through the Funding & Tenders Portal electronic
exchange system (login via your Portal account). Do NOT contact us via other means (email, letter, etc.) — unless
explicitly asked to do so.
Please be aware that linked third parties (if allowed) must be registered and validated as legal entities in the Portal
Participant Register. Register them immediately, if not already done.
Please note that some of your legal and financial data in the Participant Register is read-only and can be updated
only by a LEAR (via the Portal My Organisation(s) page). You will therefore be contacted soon to appoint a LEAR
(unless you already have one).
9. Other
Not applicable
For more information on grant preparation, see the Online Manual. You can refer to this document also for
programmes other than H2020 since the procedures are very similar.
Please note that this letter does NOT constitute a formal commitment for funding. The final
decision on your project will only be taken at a later stage, since it depends on the finalisation of
grant preparation and further checks which we still need to make (for instance, financial capacity,
non-exclusion, etc.).
For calls with a limited number of proposals to be funded: If a call can fund only a limited number of
proposals, grant preparation may be moreover be stopped if other proposals move up in the ranking
after a successful evaluation review and re-evaluation procedure.
2
EUROPEAN COMMISSION, B-1049 Brussels, BELGIUM
I would be grateful if you could inform the other members of your consortium (if any) of this letter.
For any questions, please contact us via your Funding & Tenders Portal account.
Yours faithfully,
Richard SONNENSCHEIN
Director
Enclosure: Evaluation summary report (ESR)
3
EUROPEAN COMMISSION, B-1049 Brussels, BELGIUM