From: Taivo Kivimäe
To: Jens Schröder-Fürstenberg
Cc: Olavi Heinlo; Leo Käärmann; Sander Linikoja;
[email protected]; Signe Paevere
Subject: Vs: IHO Resolution 2/2007; Invitation to product specification implementation survey
Date: Tuesday, January 9, 2018 3:02:30 PM
Attachments: S-122_Marine Protected Area_EST_Dec_2017.docx
S-123_Radio Services_EST_Dec_2017.docx
Mr Jens Schröder-Fürstenberg
NIPWG Chairman
Please find attatched Estonian surveys.
Yours sincerely,
Taivo Kivimäe
Head of Hydrography and Aids to Navigation Division
Maritime Administration
Valge tn 4
11413 Tallinn ESTONIA
Tel +372 6205 600, Fax +372 6205 606, GSM +372 5010 406
E-mail:
[email protected]
Saatja: Jens Schröder-Fürstenberg [mailto:
[email protected]]
Saatmisaeg: reede, 1. detsember 2017 8:03
Adressaat: …
Koopia: Edward Hosken <
[email protected]>; Abri KAMPFER <
[email protected]>; Yves
GUILLAM <
[email protected]>; Tom Loeper <
[email protected]>
Teema: IHO Resolution 2/2007; Invitation to product specification implementation survey
Dear IHO contacts,
Based on IHO resolution 2/2007, NIPWG is pleased to invite you to participate the survey on the S-
122 (Marine Protected Area) and S-123 (Radio Services) implementation.
The survey seeks feedback from all potential parties involved in the production and distribution
chain including software developer and end users.
The attached white paper and the invitation provide background information and specific survey
details. Each survey might require no more than 5-10 minutes time.
Your feedback is important to us and NIPWG appreciates it if you could spend few minutes of your
time to complete the survey.
Deadline for responses is 31 January 2018.
Thanks and best regards
Jens Schröder-Fürstenberg
(NIPWG Chairman)
Jens Schröder-Fürstenberg
Sachgebietsleiter/ Head of Section
Nautische Redaktion/ Nautical Editorial Office
Tel +49-381-4563-764
Fax +49-381-4563-769
[email protected]
Neptunallee 5 | 18057 Rostock | Germany
Das Bundesamt für Seeschifffahrt und Hydrographie ist eine Bundesoberbehörde im
Geschäftsbereich des Bundesministeriums für Verkehr und digitale Infrastruktur (BMVI)
1. What is your stakeholder Group? Software developer Data Producer Service Provider End user 2. What is your role in the stakeholder Group? HO (hydrographic product/service delivery) Other government agency Navigation System Manufacturer (ECDIS) Navigation System Manufacturer (ECS) Navigation System Manufacturer (PPU) Production Tool Developer Service Provider Developer (SDK) Developer (Kernel) Navigator Ecologist GIS user Coast Guard MPA management authority Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 3. Do you plan to produce or use S-122 datasets? Yes Yes, under conditions No If yes, under conditions, please describe (max 50 characters) 4. I f Yes, what benefit do you expect from S-122 compared with existing mechanisms? Ease of access to data/information Interoperability with other data/Information Neutral More frequent/up to date information Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 5. If Yes, how confident are you that you understand how to implement S-122? We have fully read and understand the details of the product specification We have a reasonable understanding, and are confident we can implement, but have not yet studied the product specification in detail We understand the concept, but lack confidence in full understanding We haven’t yet studied the product specification Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 6. If Yes, what is the main driver for implementation? Internal data Management Standardised data transfer between organisations Delivery of data/services to end users 7. If Yes, do you expect implementation issues? Inconsistencies with ENC content Insufficient access to information needed Insufficient availability of information needed Lack of understanding of how to implement Lack of production capability (e.g. application Software) Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 8. If Yes, when do you plan to start the implementation? Within a 3 year time frame Within a 5 year time frame Not specified yet Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 9. If No, what are the issues preventing you from implementation? No customer request to provide this information Lack of available data Not responsible for handling this type of information Lack of maturity of S-100 environment Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 10. Do you foresee any disadvantages, risks and issues for your organization from a technical and/or from a commercial or resources perspective. DONE
1 . What is your stakeholder Group? Software developer Data Producer Service Provider End user 2. What is your role in the stakeholder Group? HO (hydrographic product/service delivery) Other government agency Navigation System Manufacturer (ECDIS) Navigation System Manufacturer (ECS) Navigation System Manufacturer (PPU) Production Tool Developer Service Provider Developer (SDK) Developer (Kernel) Navigator Ecologist GIS user Coast Guard Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 3. Do you plan to produce or use S-123 datasets? Yes Yes, under conditions No If yes, under conditions, please describe (max 50 characters) 4. f Yes, what benefit do you expect from S-123 compared with existing mechanisms? Ease of access to data/information Interoperability with other data/Information Neutral More frequent/up to date information Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 5. If Yes, how confident are you that you understand how to implement S-123? We have fully read and understand the details of the product specification We have a reasonable understanding, and are confident we can implement, but have not yet studied the product specification in detail We understand the concept, but lack confidence in full understanding We haven’t yet studied the product specification Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 6. If Yes, what is the main driver for implementation? Internal data Management Standardised data transfer between organisations Delivery of data/services to end users 7. If Yes, do you expect implementation issues? Inconsistencies with ENC content Insufficient access to information needed Insufficient availability of information needed Lack of understanding of how to implement Lack of production capability (e.g. application Software) Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 8. If Yes, when do you plan to start the implementation? Within a 3 year time frame Within a 5 year time frame Not specified yet Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 9. If No, what are the issues preventing you from implementation? No customer request to provide this information Lack of available data Not responsible for handling this type of information Lack of maturity of S-100 environment Other (please specify) (max 50 characters) 10. Do you foresee any disadvantages, risks and issues for your organization from a technical and/or from a commercial or resources perspective. DONE