2023 Warsaw Cyber Command, 12-13 April, 2023 - War Studies University, Warsaw, Poland

HYBRID – IN PERSON & DIGITAL INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE https://cutt.ly/cDxr71r 2022 WARSAW CYBER SUMMIT ACADEMIC CENTER FOR CYBERSECURITY POLICY WAR STUDIES UNIVERSITY MILITARY CYBERACTIVITY WAR STUDIES UNIVERSITY, WARSAW – REMBERTÓW 14th June, 2022 LIBRARY HALL – venue THE HONORARY PATRONAGE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF POLAND ANDRZEJ DUDA Conference Host’s Media Patronage Chairman of the Scientific Committee Assoc. Prof. Katarzyna Chałubińska-Jentkiewicz, PhD, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland Members of the Committee Prof. Boštjan Brezovnik, PhD, Institute for Local Self-Government Maribor, Slovenia Assoc. Prof. Małgorzata Czuryk, PhD, University of Warmia and Mazury in Olsztyn, Poland Assoc. Prof. Oksana Еvsyukova, PhD, University of Educational Management, Ukraine Prof. István Hoffman, PhD, Eötvös Loránd University (Budapest), Hungary Prof. Mirosław Karpiuk, PhD, University of Warmia and Mazury in Olsztyn, Poland Prof. Miroslav Kelemen, PhD, Technical University of Kosice, Slovakia Assoc. Prof. Jarosław Kostrubiec, PhD, Maria Curie-Skłodowska University, Poland Prof. Marco Lombardi, PhD, Catholic University of Sacred Heart, Italy Assoc. Prof. Agnieszka Łukasik-Turecka, PhD, The John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin, Poland Assoc. Prof. Jan Maciejewski, PhD, University of Wroclaw, Poland Assoc. Prof. Piotr Milik, PhD, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland Prof. Uroš Pinterič, PhD, Alexander Dubček University in Trenčin, Slovakia Assoc. Prof. Francesco Pira, PhD, University of Messina, Italy Assoc. Prof. Beata Piskorska, PhD, The John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin, Poland Assoc. Prof. Lucas J. Ruiz, PhD, University of Granada, Spain Assoc. Prof. Alida Maria Silletti, PhD, University of Bari Aldo Moro, Italy Assoc. Prof. Simone Tosoni, PhD, Catholic University of Sacred Heart, Italy Assoc. Prof. Barbara Wiśniewska-Paź, PhD, University of Wroclaw, Poland Chairman of the Organizational Committee LTC ret. Zbigniew Nowak, PhD, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland Members of the Committee Assoc. Prof. Urszula Soler, PhD, The John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin, Poland Assoc. Prof. Piotr Milik, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland Anna Makuch, PhD, University of Economics and Human Sciences in Warsaw, Poland Filip Radoniewicz, PhD, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland Paweł Pelc, PhD Student, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland Paulina Krawczyk, PhD Student, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland Sławomir Stalmach, War Studies University in Warsaw, Poland  14th June, 2022 07:30 – 08:50 O p e n O n l i n e R e g i s t r a t i o n –MS TEAMS– https://cutt.ly/cDxr71r ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 09:00 – 09:30 Opening remarks Ministry of National Defence of the Republic of Poland representatives Republic of Poland Ministry of National Defence / Deputy Minister – Secretary of State – Mr. Michał WIŚNIEWSKI -------------------------------------------------------------- Republic of Poland War Studies University / Rector – Commandant – BG Robert KOSOWSKI, Ph.D. -------------------------------------------------------------- Republic of Poland EXATEL Poland / Management Board Vice President – Mr. Rafał MAGRYŚ -------------------------------------------------------------- Republic of Poland Security and Defence Council Poczta Polska S.A. / Management Board President – Mr. Tomasz ZDZIKOT ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9:30 – 10:00 Keynote Address Republic of Poland Commander, Cyber Command – Brigadier General Karol MOLENDA Cybersecurity in the Republic of Poland. Military aspects. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  I PANEL 10:00 – 10:50 National Cybersecurity Strategies Experts panel – NATO member states, MoD’s representatives Discussion – national cyber doctrines, strategies, policies. MODERATOR Japan – NTT (Nippon Telegraph and Telefone) Corporation, Chief Cybersecurity Strategist – Ms. Mihoko MATSUBARA PANELISTS 1. Hungary – Eötvös Loránd University – Faculty of Law Budapeszt / Centre for Social Sciences, Institute for Legal Studies (Budapest) – Professor István HOFFMAN 2. Australia – International Cyber Policy Centre, Australian Strategic Policy Institute – Director – Mr. Fergus HANSON 3. Federal Republic of Germany – NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Center of Excellence Tallin, Estonia – Law Researcher – Mr. Sebastian CYMUTTA 4. Canada – Government of Canada, Department of National Defence, Researcher in International Relations and International Security, Senior POLAD for Active Cyber Operations with the Department of National Defence – Andrew Stephen CAMPION, Ph.D. 5. Ukraine – Taras Schevchenko National University of Kyiv / Military Institute, Military Law Department – Oleg GUSHCHYN, Ph.D. 6. France - GEODE Research and training center, Researcher – Alix DESFORGES, Ph.D. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10:50 – 11:00 N e t w o r k i n g B r e a k -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  II PANEL 11:00 – 11:55 Military cyber operations. Operational and legal aspects. Experts panel – representatives of the NATO, UE, national entities Discussion – national and international regulations on cyber operations in military domain and environment ROUND TABLE DISCUSSION EXPERTS 1. North Macedonia – Military Academy „General Mihaela Apostolski” Skopje / Associate Professor of Law – Brigadier General Metodi HADJI – JANEV, Ph.D. 2. United Kingdom – Army Headquaters – Operational Law at British Army – Head – Brigadier General Keith EBLE 3. United States – United States Cyber Command – Staff Judge Advocate – Colonel Peter R. HAYDEN 4. Canada – NATO Communications and Information Agency, Chief Legal Adviser, Director Legal Office – Ms. Sujin CHAN-ALLEN 5. Netherlands – Associate Professor Cyber Operations NLDA Researcher LACMO/ACIL UvA – Col Peter B.M.J. PIJPERS, Ph.D. 6. Hungary – Ministry of Defence – National Military Security Service, Cyber Defence Center, Head – Col. Karoly KASSAI, Ph.D. 7. Japan – Ministry of Defense – Principal Deputy Director, operational policy division, Hudson Institute – Japan Chair Fellow – Mr. Taro HAYASHI ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11:55 – 12:00 N e t w o r k i n g B r e a k -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  III PANEL 12:00 – 13:00 Information Warfare Experts panel. Discussion on the strategic – political level; „fake news”, „deep fake”, special services exploratory activities – cyber intelligence & counter – intelligence, governmental coordination & supervision of the special services’ cyber legal activities. Cybercrimes – penal code, jurisdiction. ROUND TABLE DISCUSSION EXPERTS 1. United States – Stanford University & Stanford University’s Center for International Security and Cooperation (CISAC) – Professor Sean KANUCK 2. Israel – Tel Aviv University – School of Electrical Engineering, The Iby and Aladar Fleischman Faculty of Engineering, Cyber Research Center – Professor Yuval SHAVITT 3. Georgia / Estonia – Baltic Defence College, Estonia, Tartu / Defence and Cyber Studies, Ambassador – Mr. Shota GVINERIA 4. Republic of Poland – Pedagogical University of Cracow – Institute of Security and Civic Studies – Institute of Security Science – Adjunct, Lawyer, Senior Lecturer – Piotr ŁUBIŃSKI, Ph.D. 5. Nigeria – Federal Ministry of Justice, Prosecution Unit, Deputy Director – Cybercrime, Vice-Chair of the Ad Hoc Committee to Elaborate a Comprehensive International Convention on Countering the Use of Information and Communications Technologies for Criminal Purposes – Mr. Terumun George – Maria TYENDEZWA 6. United States – Research Professor at Brussels School of Governance, VUB, (previously RAND Corporation and Country Director for Russia at the U.S. Department of Defense – Olesya TKACHEVA, Ph.D. 7. Republic of Poland – Independent cybersecurity researcher and consultant, former cyberwarfare advisor at the International Committee of the Red Cross in Geneva – Łukasz OLEJNIK, Ph.D. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 13:00 – 14:00 N e t w o r k i n g B r e a k -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------  IV PANEL 14:00 – 14:55 Cooperation between public, private, military and the academic sectors – cyber & new technologies Experts panel – representatives of public, private, military and academic sectors Discussion – cooperation between sectors, sector’s needs, requirements & future challenges for cybersecurity and new technologies MODERATOR United States / Italy – Cybersecurity Consultant – World Bank's Digital Development team, the International Telecommunications Union (ITU), and the Global Forum for Cyber Expertise (GFCE) – Ms. Francesca SPIDALIERI EXPERTS 1. Brazil – CySource – COE Brazil – Cyber Workforce Transformation and Cyber Defense, Israel – Mr. Helio SANT’ANA 2. USA – Florida Center for Cybersecurity (South Florida State University System institution & US CYBERCOM partner) – Staff Director – Mr. Ron SANDERS, Ph.D. 3. Hungary – Institute of Cybersecurity, National University of Public Service – Head – Csaba KRASZNAY, Ph.D. 4. Republic of Poland – University of Gdańsk, International Centre for Theory of Quantum Technologies – Professor Marcin PAWŁOWSKI – and/or – Anubhav CHATURVEDI, Ph.D. 5. Portugal – Ministry of Defence, Directorate-General for National Defense Resources – Lt. Col. Luis Salomão CARVALHO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 14:55 – 15:00 N e t w o r k i n g B r e a k ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 15:00 – 15:30 Honorary Guest vice admiral (ret.) US Navy John Michael McConnell Director of the National Security Agency (1992 – 1996) United States Director of National Intelligence (2007 – 2009) Florida Center for Cybersecurity  V PANEL 15:30 – 16:45 New fields – Artificial Intelligence & Cosmic domain Experts panel – lawyers / academics / military experts Discussion – AI in military operations, role of AI for the national policies, AI & cyberthreats Discussion – NATO policy on cosmic operational domain, cosmic policy in national regulations, act, doctrines MODERATOR United States – Adjunct Management Scientist at the RAND Corporation, Professor – Pardee RAND Graduate School, Distinguished Visiting Professor – U.S. Naval Academy – Professor Martin LIBICKI EXPERTS 1. Republic of Poland – Jagiellonian University, Faculty of Law and Administration, Associate Professor at the Chair of Public International Law – Professor Marcin MARCINKO Rules of Engagement and Military Algorithms of Autonomous Weapon System 2. Republic of Poland – Digital Justice Center, University of Wrocław – Kaja KOWALCZEWSKA, Ph.D. Meaningful human control - a new AI-related norm in statu nascendi? 3. United Kingdom – Associate Professor of International Relations Co-Director, Centre for Doctoral Training in Cyber Security Oxford University – Professor Lucas KELLO Space security – new players and new technologies 4. Republic of Poland – War Studies University – Faculty of Law – Professor Małgorzata POLKOWSKA Space situation awareness (Freedom to maneuver in space) 5. Hungary – Hungarian Academy of Sciences Centre of Excellence – Centre for Social Sciences, Institute for Legal Studies – Research Fellow – Kitti MEZEI, Ph.D. The legal challenges of AI-enabled cyberthreats 6. Republic of Poland – Maria Curie – Sklodowska University (Lublin), Associate Professor and Vice-Dean of the Faculty of Law and Administration – Professor Jaroslaw KOSTRUBIEC Artificial intelligence and the individual's right to personal data protection 7. Republic of Poland – Inseqr Poland Mr. Kornel KOWIESKI Artificial intelligence and its role in fighting disinformation  16:45 – 17:15 Keynote Speech Member of the Advisory Board on EDTs at NATO Chair of the CYBERSEC Programme Committee The Kosciuszko Institute Executive Board Member at DIGITALEUROPE – Ms. Izabela ALBRYCHT Importance of Artificial Intelligence for NATO -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 17:15 – 17:30 Closing remarks Republic of Poland War Studies University / Rector – Commandant – BG Robert KOSOWSKI, Ph.D. -------------------------------------------------------------- 14th June, 2022 https://cutt.ly/cDxr71r ACADEMIC CENTER FOR CYBERSECURITY POLICY WAR STUDIES UNIVERSITY MILITARY CYBERACTIVITY WAR STUDIES UNIVERSITY, WARSAW – REMBERTÓW ONLINE MICROSOFT TEAMS PLATFORM https://cutt.ly/Ul4PLWT 2021 WARSAW CYBER SUMMIT ACADEMIC CENTER FOR CYBERSECURITY POLICY – LEGAL PANEL – MILITARY CYBERACTIVITY MILITARY ACTIVITY IN CYBERSPACE WAR STUDIES UNIVERSITY, WARSAW – REMBERTÓW 12th – 13th May, 2021 HONORARY PATRONAGE OF THE MINISTER OF NATIONAL DEFENCE OF THE REPUBLIC OF POLAND 1  DAY 1st – 12th May, 2021 7.30 – 8.45 O p e n R e g i s t r a t i o n ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 8.45 – 9.00 Opening remarks The Ministry of National Defence of the Republic of Poland representatives Republic of Poland – Military Counterintelligence Service / Head – BG Maciej MATERKA ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Republic of Poland – National Cyber Security Center / Director – BG Karol MOLENDA - Republic of Poland – War Studies University / Rector – Commandant – BG Robert KOSOWSKI, PhD ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9.00 – 9.30 Keynote Address Evolution of cyber military operations NATO HQ, Brussels – Office of Legal Affairs / Legal Adviser and Director – John SWORDS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2  I PANEL 9.40 – 11.00 Military cyber security: a challenge for the governments Expert panel – NATO HQ & NATO Member States, MoDs representatives National cyber doctrines, strategies, policies. Role of MOD. Cyber threats, challenges, governmental and private sector actions & cooperation MODERATOR NATO HQ, Brussels – Cyber Defence Section / Emerging Security Challenges Division / Deputy Head – Chelsey SLACK PANELISTS 1. USA – US Military Academy West Point / US Army Cyber Institute / Associate Professor and Academy Professor – Col. Mark VISGER 2. Hungary – Institute of Cybersecurity / National University of Public Service / Head – Csaba KRASZNAY, PhD / Ministry of Defence – National Military Security Service / Cyber Defence Center, Head – Col. Karoly KASSAI, PhD 3. Republic of Poland – Cyberspace Defence Forces Command Forming Group / Head – Col. Przemysław PRZYBYLAK 4. Slovakia – Ministry of Defence of the Slovak Republic / Military Intelligence / Cyber Defence Center of the Slovak Republic, Director – Col. Miroslav ČAČÍK 5. Czech Republic – TBD – Armed Forces of the Czech Republic / Cyber Forces Command ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11.10 – 11.40 N e t w o r k i n g B r e a k ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11.40 – 12.10 Keynote Speech Defensive and Offensive Cyberspace Operations Estonia – NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence / Director – Col. Jaak TARIEN ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3  II PANEL 12.20 – 13.20 Legal framework of military cyber operations Expert panel – representatives of the US, NATO, POL and UE entities Legal discussion panel, national and international regulations on cyber operations in military domain and environment MODERATOR USA – United States Cyber Command / Staff Judge Advocate – Col. George R. SMAWLEY PANELISTS 1. Republic of Poland / Norway – Joint Warfare Center, Stavanger / Legal Office – CDR Navy (ret.) Wiesław GOŹDZIEWICZ „Sovereign Cyber Effects Provided Voluntarily by Allies (SCEPVA) Mechanism from the Perspective of Operational Law” 2. Greece – National and Kapodistrian University of Athens / Assistant Professor of International Law School of Law – Dr. George D. KYRIAKOPOULOS „Environmental implications of military cyber operations: Challenges for International Law” 3. Republic of Poland – Cyber Security Training Centre of Excellence Warsaw, Poland / Deputy Director – Col. Jerzy SYPEK, PhD 4. Republic of Poland – Polish Naval Academy Gdynia / Maritime Cybersecurity Center / Director – Professor Jerzy KOSIŃSKI 5. Republic of Poland – Academic Center for Cybersecurity Policy, War Studies University – LtCol. Zbigniew NOWAK, PhD ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 13.30 – 14.00 Networking Break ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4  III PANEL 14.00 – 15:00 Information Warfare Expert panel – lawyers & representatives of governments / MODs Discussion panel on the strategic – political level; „fake news”, „deep fake”, special services exploratory activities – cyber intelligence & counter – intelligence, governmental coordination and supervision of the special services’ cyber legal activities MODERATOR Georgia / Estonia – Baltic Defence College, Estonia, Tartu / Defence and Cyber Studies / Ambassador – Shota GVINERIA PANELISTS 1. USA – US Department of State – Office of the Legal Adviser – Political – Military Affairs / Attorney – Adviser – Marguerite C. WALTER 2. Republic of Poland – War Studies University / Academic Center for Cybersecurity Policy / Director – Professor Katarzyna CHAŁUBIŃSKA – JENTKIEWICZ 3. Republic of Poland – The John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin – Professor Urszula SOLER 4. Republic of Poland – the University of Wroclaw / Institute of Sociology / Department of Sociology of Education – Professor Barbara WIŚNIEWSKA – PAŹ 5. Republic of Poland – EU – East Stratcom Task Force / European External Action Service / Strategic Communications and Information Analysis – Martyna BILDZIUKIEWICZ, PhD 6. Ukraine – Taras Schevchenko National University of Kyiv / Military Institute / Military Law Department – Oleg GUSHCHYN, PhD 7. Israel – Israel Defense Forces / Chief Signal Officer & J6/C4I & Cyber Defense Directorate Chief of Staff – BG Yariv NIR ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5  DAY 2nd – 13th May, 2021 IV PANEL 10.00 – 11.00 Sovereignty in cyberspace Expert panel – lawyers / academics / military experts Legal discussion panel, four individual speeches, Q &A MODERATOR North Macedonia – Military Academy „General Mihailo Apostolski” Skopje / Associate Professor of Law – BG Metodi HADJI – JANEV, PhD PANELISTS 1. United Kingdom – Chatham House – London / The Royal Institute of International Affairs / International Law Programme / Senior Research Fellow – Harriet MOYNIHAN 2. USA – US Army HQ Pentagon / Office of The Judge Advocate General / National Security Law Division / International Law Branch / Chief – Maj Gretchen DAVENPORT 3. Republic of Poland – Cardinal Stefan Wyszynski University in Warsaw / Faculty of Law and Administration / Department of International and European Law – Łukasz KUŁAGA, PhD 4. Republic of Poland – Jagiellonian University in Krakow / Faculty of Law and Administration / International Law – Przemysław ROGUSKI, PhD ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11.10 – 11.40 N e t w o r k i n g B r e a k ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6  V PANEL 11.40 – 12.50 Cooperation between the public sector, private sector and the academic world in the field military activity in cyberspace Experts panel – discussion panel from public, private and academic sectors Cooperation between sectors, sector’s needs, requirements & future challenges OPEN TABLE Republic of Poland – Pedagogical University of Krakow / National Security Institute – Piotr ŁUBIŃSKI, PhD – Coordination – EXPERTS 1. Hungary – Eötvös Loránd University – Faculty of Law Budapeszt / Department of Administrative Law / Department of International Public Law / Senior Research Fellow – Professor István HOFFMAN 2. Italy – Universita Cattolica del Sacro Cuore / Department of Sociology Milan / Head – Professor Marco LOMBARDI 3. USA – United States Cyber Command / Office of the Staff Judge Advocate – LtCol. Joshua J. SMITH 4. Italy – Leonardo Company / VP International Product Marketing and Strategic Campaigns Coordination – Luigi LUPOLI 5. Israel – Embassy of Israel, Warsaw / Head of Trade & Economic Mission to Poland, Counselor – Ann Sarah MADI ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 13.00 – 13.30 N e t w o r k i n g B r e a k ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7  VI PANEL 13.30 – 14.30 Security and privacy in military cyberoperations Expert panel – lawyers / academics / military experts Legal panel, „balance” between security and privacy in the military operations in cyberspace; boundaries and rules MODERATOR 1. USA – US Army HQ Pentagon / Office of The Judge Advocate General / National Security Law Division / Chief – Col. Gail CURLEY PANELISTS 1. Republic of Poland – Lazarski University, Warsaw / Faculty of Law and Administration / International and European Public Law Branch / Head – Professor Justyna ZAJDEL – CAŁKOWSKA “IA impact on cybercrime – legal aspects” 2. Republic of Poland – University of Lodz / Faculty of Law and Administration – Joanna KULESZA, PhD “Prioritizing privacy and security in a multistakeholder environment" 3. Republic of Poland – War Studies University / Institute of Law – Monika NOWIKOWSKA, PhD „Security vs. Privacy – legal aspects” ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 14.45 – 15.00 Summary and closing remarks Republic of Poland – National Cyber Security Center / Director – BG Karol MOLENDA - Republic of Poland – War Studies University / Rector – Commandant – BG Robert KOSOWSKI, PhD ONLINE–MICROSOFT TEAMS PLATFORM https://cutt.ly/Ul4PLWT 8