Saatja: <=?windows-1257?Q?Kristel_T=E4nover?=>
Saadetud: 12.05.2023 14:30
Adressaat: <"MKM info">
Teema: FW: [Request for visit] Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communication -
Government Technology Agency of Singapore
Manused: image001.jpg; image002.png; image003.png; image004.png; image005.png
From: Karen KEE (GOVTECH) <
[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, May 10, 2023 5:18 AM
To: Anu Vask <
[email protected]>; Indrek Õnnik <
[email protected]>
Cc: Kristel Tänover <
[email protected]>; Dominic CHAN (GOVTECH)
<
[email protected]>
Subject: [Request for visit] Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communication - Government
Technology Agency of Singapore
Message Classification: Restricted
Dear Anu and Indrek,
Hope you have been well. By way of introduction, I am from the Government Technology
Agency of Singapore and would like to kindly request for a meeting with the Ministry of Economic Affairs
and Communications on 15 or 16 June.
We would like to kindly request for a visit to MEAC’s Digital Identity team to understand your approach
to policy making as well as managing of trust services. The delegation will be led by the Assistant Chief
Executive for Products, Mr Dominic Chan and joined by colleagues from the Smart Nation and Digital
Government Office in charge of policy and planning. The delegation could share Singapore’s plans as
part of the meeting, if required.
GovTech has the mandate to develop technology for the Singapore Government including digital
services for citizens and businesses of strategic importance. This includes Singapore’s National Digital
Identity. We regularly review our Digital Identity plans and hope to learn from leading countries such as
Estonia your implementation plans and lessons learnt from eID.
If agreeable, we hope to visit on Thur 15 June or Fri 16 Jun. Understand that the request is coming at
short notice and appreciate if you could accommodate the request please. The delegation is planning to
attend the Identity Week event at Amsterdam on 13/14 June.
We look forward to your favorable reply and happy to answer any questions you may have. A
concurrent request has been sent to the Information System Authority.
Thank you.
Regards
Karen Kee
Deputy Director, International & Community Development Lead
Government Technology Agency
M: (+65) 8522 6005
This Email is filed in GovTech DRMS
[3S-id=a3b63c55-8f6d-4eb1-94c6-8fa717c47a2a:a0a98837]
This Email is filed in GovTech DRMS
[3S-id=1eb7dbbb-c213-4f3a-8c3e-9666ec968a19:a0a98837]
From: Anu Vask <
[email protected]>
Sent: 10 May, 2022 2:49 AM
To: Diana LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Priit Turk <
[email protected]>; Helmuth Martin
Reisner <
[email protected]>; Kristel Alver <
[email protected]>; Laura-Liisa Laving <Laura-
[email protected]>; Kristel Tänover <
[email protected]>; Tiina Tarkus <
[email protected]>;
Indrek Õnnik <
[email protected]>
Cc: Pei Ying LIM (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Jenny JH FOO (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Kai Ling LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Chi Hsia FOO (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Paul LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Daniel LOOI (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Evelyn GOH (IMDA) <
[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Asia Tech x Singapore 2022
Dear Diana
Thank you so much for all the assistance you are providing to our delegation.
Our Minister will be travelling with his Adviser Mr Helmuth Martin Reisner and Mr Indrek Õnnik, Global
Affairs Director at the CIO’s Office in the Ministry. Mr Õnnik will be staying in a different hotel not far
from Minister+1 Hotel- we are trying to find one. We would appreciate your recommendations.
The Minister’s flights’ information below:
1 . AY 1032 29MAY Tallinn TLL-Helsingi HEL 2210 2245
2 . AY 131 30MAY Helsingi HEL-Singapur SIN 0015 1820
3 . AY 132 02JUN Singapur SIN-Helsingi HEL 2150 #0615 (03JUN)
4 . AY 1011 03JUN Helsingi HEL-Tallinn TLL 0730 0800
We kindly ask your help in setting up additional meetings for 1 and 2 June in addition to Ministers’
bilateral meeting.
- Cyber Security Agency
- GOVTECH
o Discussion about developing ID and interoperability opportunities.
o AI
- National AI Office
IMDA
- Visit to Smartcity showroom CityScape (smartnation.gov.sg);
- Visit to Port of Singapore Authority Innovation Centre (PIC)
- Visit to Sustainable Singapore https://www.terra.sg/ssg
We would be also interested in discussing about the VICA - https://www.tech.gov.sg/products-and-
services/vica/
1. Technical co-operation in the future with #Bürokratt open-source solutions
2. Knowledge exchange between technical and business teams
3. Knowledge with working 3rd party chatapp companies like whatsapp/telegram etc – risks, usage
% etc
1. What kind of technology will be used in VICA?
2. Do you plan to use federated learning? If not, how do you solve nation open knowledge and
restricted knowledge by agencies/ministries?
3. Did we understand correctly - the software stack is proprietary and not open-source?
4. How have you solved authentication and support with 3rd party platforms like
telegram/whatsapp?
5. How is the training done – supervised learning by VICA-s clients?
6. What did you learn from “Ask Jamie” – pros and cons + what you will do now differently.
Our Minister is open to media interviews (International and local) and we would be grateful for your
help in arranging interviews with journalists during his stay in Singapore.
Kind regards
Anu
From: Diana LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, May 4, 2022 9:15 PM
To: Anu Vask <
[email protected]>; Priit Turk <
[email protected]>; Helmuth Martin Reisner
<
[email protected]>; Kristel Alver <
[email protected]>; Laura-Liisa Laving <Laura-
[email protected]>; Kristel Tänover <
[email protected]>; Tiina Tarkus <
[email protected]>;
Indrek Õnnik <
[email protected]>
Cc: Pei Ying LIM (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Jenny JH FOO (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Kai Ling LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Chi Hsia FOO (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Paul LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Daniel LOOI (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Evelyn GOH (IMDA) <
[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Asia Tech x Singapore 2022
Message Classification: Restricted
Dear Anu,
As spoken, please do let us have Minister’s thoughts on whom he would like to meet, and any areas of
interest he has. We can then make recommendations, and subject to your approval, we can help you to
arrange those meetings, working closely with your colleagues at the Embassy.
Please also do let us have an approved photograph of Minister so that we can include it in our
conference materials.
On the flights, we had discussed the various options, so please let us know what you decide with your
colleagues.
I have included the updated programme in this email. I understand that Minister Sutt is meeting
Minister Makishima on Friday, and I’m very pleased to note that she will be speaking virtually on the
same panel as him!
And again, please do let us know if we can be helpful in any way to make Minister Sutt’s visit a success.
Best,
Diana
From: Anu Vask <
[email protected]>
Sent: Wednesday, 4 May 2022 16:41
To: Diana LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Priit Turk <
[email protected]>; Helmuth Martin
Reisner <
[email protected]>; Kristel Alver <
[email protected]>; Laura-Liisa Laving <Laura-
[email protected]>; Kristel Tänover <
[email protected]>; Tiina Tarkus <
[email protected]>;
Indrek Õnnik <
[email protected]>
Cc: Pei Ying LIM (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Jenny JH FOO (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Kai Ling LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Chi Hsia FOO (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Paul LEE (IMDA) <
[email protected]>; Daniel LOOI (IMDA)
<
[email protected]>; Evelyn GOH (IMDA) <
[email protected]>
Subject: RE: Asia Tech x Singapore 2022
Dear Diana
I hope you are well.
Thank you so much for your e-mail to our Ambassador. Nice to e-meet you. We are very happy for all
the assistance your team can provide to our Minister’s visit. I am sure it will be a great visit with good
discussions.
I will get back to you with more information before the end of this week. I apologise for the delay.
We are very grateful for your kind offer to cover Minister+ 1 flights and accommodation+ transfers. Can
you please let me know how we proceed with flights. We kindly ask you to cover their business class
flights as the flight time is quite tiring and long. Should we book the flights ourselves and then send you
an invoice or is there another procedure for this arrangement?
Thank you so much in advance.
We were also thinking about setting up some additional meetings for our Minister. I really appreciate
your help with this. I can send you more information about it by the end of the week.
I am looking forward to working with you.
Kind regards
Anu
Anu Vask
Counsellor
EU and International Cooperation Department
Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Communications
+372 56676371
www.mkm.ee | Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn
Priit Turk
Ambassador of Estonia to Singapore and ASEAN
+65 9729 8905
260 Orchard Rd, Singapore 238855
@EstoniainSG